Which one is the best ?

[Obxist]

Okay fellas i need ur help... i got two pages contain the same content... but i am trying some new moves so theres a difference between two pages... i am taking the RAWs from Tista c02

Here it is the first page :

Spoiler

and here it is the second page (the new move):

Spoiler

Please choose which one is the best and also dont forget the +/- of each page.. thank you ^^

p/s : its half cleaned.. not entirely cleaned... and forget about the top panel ;p

 

[hatsuharupeace]

I think the second one looks better, the clean is a lot more... crisper, like more detail in it. Nice clean btw.

 

[icarium2]

The second one is better because there is less detail loss and it isn't as blurry.

 

[blitzx]

yeah,the second one is better...

 

[Vato Loco!]

The second one is better. Not as blurry, less detail loss, grays aren't totally destroyed. Still, both of em are pretty bad.

 

[Obxist]

o: Vato-Chan....

how do u think to make that kind of thing became more beautiful or is it RAW's problem ?

RAW :

Spoiler

 

[Vato Loco!]

Nah the raw's fine. It's about the same quality that comes from most public scans of seinen magazine raws. It really does just come down to practice. I mean, for all the people using neatimage right now, I know of one person who has a great grasp on it. And he isn't even releasing. The same goes for all techniques.

 

[ddadain]

Don't denoise at all = better

 

[henrikoez]

I like the second picture. It looks better. The gray part is good, not blurred.