Which Straw Hat has the saddest backstory?

[weird_pirate]

i think tat brooke has the worst to know and see ur crew ppl die while playin a song then b lonely for 50 years, man
robin has it tough and all that but brooke damn
luffy seems to have the less big dramatic thing and ussop, zolo meh its kinda up there

 

[El-Thor]

i think tat brooke has the worst to know and see ur crew ppl die while playin a song then b lonely for 50 years, man
robin has it tough and all that but brooke damn
luffy seems to have the less big dramatic thing and ussop, zolo meh its kinda up there

But remember that Brooke can't feel nothing cuz he's all bones ! YOHOHOHO !

Now that Ace is dead, I think Luffy is up there with Nami/Sanji. Still not Robin/Chopper level though

 

[Jammin]

I think Robin has the saddest backstory.

Grew up alone as a mistreated orphan(more or less), then her entire island is destroyed along with everyone she knew, then spent most of her younger years running from the marines with a massive bounty on her head. Until Luffy came along her life sucked almost entirely.

 

[Kaiser Will]

Moderator Notice:
Moved. ~ Regarding this read One Piece Revamp Info/Guide Thread please. Remember character related stuff, be it DF or haki discussions should be made in the TOK Forum from now on.~ Kaiser Will

 

[Niirouge]

In order from the most 'heart-wrenching' to the least

1. Franky

His story eliminated two of the emotions I would give anything so as not to feel or experience in my lifetime: regret and guilt. I found his past the most painful to watch and empathise with and when he finally forgave himself after hearing Iceberg's words, I never felt more relieved while watching/reading One Piece

2. Chopper

Gosh, knowing that you caused your most important person's death must be tough... Added to that pain is discrimination and plain outright rejection from everyone... If I didn't relate to Franky's story more, I'd give Chopper the first place...

3. Robin & Nami

They both suffered for a long time and had to deceive everyone around them just to survive. Both women know the pain of loneliness and the fragility of having trust in someone else... They're up here because they seem the most 'breakable' if the situation arises.

4. Zoro, Sanji & Usopp

These three tie for me
Zoro and Usopp having lost someone dear to them while Sanji has to live with (a little) shame at accusing and suspecting his boss... Lol, these three are pretty straight-forward so I don't have much to say

As for Brook and Luffy, I'm still on the fence for where they rank...
Well, they clearly beat 4th place though...