Who would win?

kronoman4

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
41
Reaction score
8
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Luffy vs Zoro
Zoro vs sanji
Luffy vs sanji
And Luffy vs Zoro vs Sanji all at once.

I know i never thought about this up until someone asked me this, so i wanna see what everyone else thinks.

With all of the information that we have gathered up until this point who do you think would win these matches and why?
 

MaiSiaoSiao

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2010
Messages
214
Reaction score
17
Gender
Male
Country
Singapore
Wrong section.Should be posted in davy back fight section if im not wrong

On Topic.I thinks that sanji luffy would win no matter what.He has haki.And its a great advantage for him.Unless both zoro and sanji has haki too but hasn't shown it idk.
 

Zeltrax

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 30, 2009
Messages
3,138
Reaction score
1,583
Gender
Male
Country
Singapore
Luffy can defeat both Sanji and Zoro together.
Stated before somewhere but I don't have the source.
If you remember enies lobby, the power "level" of Lucci + Blueno is a good indicator of that.
Use it to compare against Jyabura + Kaku.
 

Dekker

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2008
Messages
423
Reaction score
103
Age
40
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Luffy can take on both at once probably. Though we don't know. Maybe Zoro or Sanji developed haki but we don't know yet. But we dont know how strong they are right now anyway. No good fight was seen yet. We need to wait a bit more to make educated guesses.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I agree with MaiSiaoSiao that this thread should probably be under "One Piece Playground: Davy Back Fight".

That said, I don't know if a battle between Luffy, Zori, and Sanji would be so clear cut. Tactically, Sanji would have the upper hand since I think he can outsmart both Luffy and Zori. But if the battles drag on, in a battle between Luffy vs Sanji, Luffy would be able to take more crushing damage (from Sanji's legs) before losing the ability to fight and therefore would beat Sanji with a good margin. On the other hand, Luffy has no resistance to slashing attacks and would not be able to sustain the same amount of damage vs. Zori and in a long battle would probably lose to him. We also saw at Thriller Bark that Zori also has the capacity to bear an immense amount of damage comparable to Luffy which is why I think he would be able to manage a long battle with Luffy and survive. Also, having seen minor skirmishes between Zori and Sanji often makes me think that a battle between them would be long and dragged out, at least until one of them is able to land a critical hit against the other. Sanji has always kept his distance from Zori's swords or parried them with his feet (against the blunt edge).

Anyways all of this was assuming their skills before the two year time skip. Post time skip would probably have other differences based on what they have learned that we don't know of yet :tem.
 

White Rose

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Jun 12, 2011
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Gender
Hidden
Country
Iceland
Luffy vs Zoro I think that would be Luffy, or may be a tie one
Zoro vs sanji Erhm, it's a bit difficult to think, Zoro still a bit, cooler
Luffy vs sanji Definitely Luffy
And Luffy vs Zoro vs Sanji all at once. Sanji would be the first one to lose, and ...a fight between Luffy and Zoro, what gonna happen next is already said above
 

Wisshard

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2010
Messages
130
Reaction score
38
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Up to W7/EL, I always viewed Luffy and Zoro as close to equal as equal goes (i.e. a fight between them would have a similar conclusion to Dorry's and Broggy's frequent clashes) with Sanji a small, but somewhat noticeable, distance behind them. I inferred thus given the, in my opinion, sense of equality Oda has portrayed between Luffy and Zoro ever since Zoro joined Luffy's merry-band of pirates.

With the introduction of Gear Second however, I felt that Luffy pulled away from Zoro. I'd say that they were still roughly equal in "base", but that in Gear Second, Luffy was a step above Zoro since Luffy paid a price that Zoro did not: he literally sacrificed years of his life, pushing his body to his absolute limits and then some, in order to achieve that level of combat prowess.

After the time skip Luffy's Gear Second seems different though; he no longer seems to extract a very heavy toll for using it, and it now seems to be more of a fundamental part of his fighting style, rather than a triumph card (i.e. I now view Luffy's Gear Second (and likewise, Sanji's Diable Jambe) similarly to Zoro swords). In addition, the way Luffy and Zoro simultaneously shut down Decken and Jones, respectively, gave me the wibe that the gap between G2 Luffy and Zoro is no longer as evident as it was (imo) before the time skip.

That being said, any fight between two of the Monster Trio would be a very tough and intense fight, but I think the end result is given in such a competition: Luffy defeats Zoro and Sani, and Zoro beats Sanji.
Zoro may wield swords, which some would argue is a superior fighting style to Rubber Kung Fu or Fire Leg Karate and that is perfectly true in our world. But One Piece is a different verse, and a fictional shounen verse at that, and I think past chapters (i.e. swordless Kaku vs. Zoro, Luffy vs. Zoro in whiskey peak) have proven that weapon styles doesn't have any significant advantage against hand-to-hand styles.

Regarding the free for all scenario, I actually think Sanji has the biggest shot at winning, if they are in character. Sanji is a more calculating and tactical combatant than the reckless Luffy and Zoro, and I think Sanji is more like to play it safe in the beginning while taking advantage of any opening to damage either of his opponent. In the end though, the winner could be either one of them, and would be decided by circumstantial luck (i.e. the third party intervenes at exactly the right moment).

EDIT: One a side note, I firmly believe that Zoro and Sanji has learned the CoA and CoO forms of Haki during the time skip, considering that it took an alleged Haki-genius like Luffy one and a half year of hardcore training from the Dark King to learn it, and I can't really see Zoro or Sanji, the two most powerful combatants of the future Pirate King's crew, growing into top tiers without it - nor can I imagine Luffy spending the next 2-4 years training Zoro and Sanji in Haki.
 
Last edited:

Jorge D. Dragon

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 13, 2010
Messages
4,484
Reaction score
987
Age
38
Gender
Male
Country
Mariejoa
Luffy wins against both Sanji and Zoro at once. I believe he actually could do this even before the timeskip, but now the gap between them got bigger and Luffy got Haki, so I believe that he will win against both of them and then can even go fight someone at Chopper's level.

Zoro will defeat Sanji. He is just stronger enough to have a victory. I wouldn't say that it would be easy, but still he wins.
 
Top