Misc Attempt With denoise or without denoise?

[toptea]

Which one do you guys prefer?

Example 1

Raw copy: http://i.imgur.com/poKMc.jpg
without denoise: http://i.imgur.com/05qKX.png
with denoise: http://i.imgur.com/z2W3K.png

Example 2

Raw copy: http://i.imgur.com/4ufRp.jpg
without denoise: http://i.imgur.com/ZmmBj.png
with denoise: http://i.imgur.com/0TWOg.png

Also, any other advice on how to improve them further would be greatly appreciated!

 

[Sensei 12]

but...
these are raws from the volume...
they don't need any kind of denoising, but only levelling


you need to denoise raws from magazines, not from volumes ^^


anyway... your works without the denoise are very good ^^

 

[progste]

i'm not sure these are tankobon raws, anyway I agree with sensei, without denoise is better XD

 

[Sensei 12]

i'm not sure these are tankobon raws, anyway I agree with sensei, without denoise is better XD

te lo posso assicurare, sono raw da volume

 

[progste]

ah, ok XD
è che per essere scannerizzate dal volume sono abbastanza scarse