It's not the same... There are cases of people who over rely on their fruits to think they are awesome (as is the case with some logia) but that's not pica's or cracker's situation. Pica in this situation is simply outclassed. He isn't particularly weak in any one regard. He has high physical strength, decent haki, a strong fruit... Cracker in turn is a fucking monster. It's true that he is a bit of a glass cannon BUT in turn he is an excellent swordsman, he is extremely fast, uses his fruit at a high level and has powerful haki. Compared to doflamingo:
1.- Luffy was able to hold his own in gear 2/3 against doflamingo for a few moments. Against cracker he was immediately outclassed when using his gears 2/3.
2.- Cracker is perfectly capable of
lunging at gear 4 luffy. Doflamingo could take gear 4 hits but luffy could even blitz doflamingo. With or without the cracker soldiers luffy simply couldn't speedblitz or overpower cracker.
It's entirely possible that awakenings work like that. The other possibility is that its a first come first serve thing. But.. that has nothing to do with pica. Pica isn't using an awakening, his ability is to simply control earth he fuses with. And we know katakuri's and doflamingo's ability works on that.
But... luffy by all appearances took out page one with gear 3. And as far as we know gear 4 hits substantially harder than gear 3. It's entirely possible that ulti and page one have the capacity to recover quickly from this though, as we saw with the impel down zoan users.