- Joined
- May 2, 2009
- Messages
- 181
- Reaction score
- 0
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
I'm sure that everyone who reads Gintama will scream out for MOAR.
So sad that Gintama is so badly underrated...

and I don't think it's going to end soon with the way things are now...

I know they're inconsistant. >_> This is EXACTLY what I told them when I went ahead and gave them the okay to use my translations. I'm gonna give it a week or two, and if they still haven't said anything I may act on my own behalf then.Only thing is, I really don't think Bomber should be doing this thing with Binktopia being the only one allowed to use his TLs. They're pretty well known for doing a good job, but then being inconsistant. Like how they haven't released anything for Gintama in 3 weeks and all...
The answer to this is simple. The long arcs are usually closer to normal Shounen, and therefore get attention quicker than the slice of life type stories. Longer arcs usually get done, while little chapters get skipped. (Oddly in Japan, they don't seem to like the longer arcs, and prefer the short gag stories, but to each his or her own.) I don't blame them (scantlators) though, since Gintama was rumored to have won an unofficial award for being the wordiest Jump manga. Throw in Sorachi's penchant for using pop culture references, and anyone who isn't stupid or crazy (I'm both personally.) Would stay far far away from Gintama translations.@Bomber D Rufi
Have you read the whole series including the not scanlated chapter? Could you eventually say what the gaps are - (longer) single arcs or several small episodes that were uninteresting to scanlate? There are small and big gaps, makes me wonder why Manga Editors skipped those chapters in particular *scratches head*
Eh I like Gintama as a whole. Whether its the long actiony arcs or the shorter gag ones, I think they work really well in tandem with each other. If Gintama were all gags, it would lose its magic rather quickly. At the same time, if it were all action, it would be no better than Bleach or Naruto. Gintama's an awesome manga because it balances both really well.So, they pretty much skipped on stuff I would like >.>
<--- is no friend of long arcs either.
Hmm, I saw now that Mangafox has ch168-171 but I haven't read a bunch of the chapters in the middle, so I can't confirm whether that's the supposed chapters or whether they're wrong numbered. Anyone?
And yes, Gintama is text heavy but I don't expect anyone to speed-work on the missing chapters or to release super high quality cleans. But I think with a one month focus on this series, a Manga Editor could easily fill some of the short arcs in.Yet the gasps are there since years and sadly a reason for many to not start the series at all. I'm also a little afraid that, looking at the English official release, they'll never closed ._.
Most gaps are 1-4 chapters long, only three are longer:
3x 3 chapter
3x 4 chapter
1x 1, 2, 8, 12 and 20 chapter
If at least the short ones could be closed within this year, that would already be awesome. They're the ones who gives this cruel 'patchwork' impression to potential readers.
Ha, yeah right... no one would be so insane to try and translate chapters of Gintama not even Bomber D. Ruffy could do...
It's gonna be me, isn't it........
... but I just can't remove it because it serves an important purpose >.<
[/eni]
Me too. I just said that I'm generally someone who likes shorter arcs. But that really goes for every manga I readEh I like Gintama as a whole.

My general problem is that I prefer buying the Japanese tanks of my favorite manga. But I have to use the Edited Mangas to understand them. Translations alone are confusing to read parallel to the book ^^I have no interest in filling the gap mainly because I want to support the English version. (So I do buy the Viz tanks, even though I translate the later ones.) Gintama's a series that's well worth buying. (The other reason is that I have no time to go back and do the older lessons...)