Discussion Caribou's Logia Power

[Channy]

So i cant think of many logias left in the series And I'm really curious as to what Caribous power is. I'm just gonna name some off that i haven't seen yet correct me if I'm wrong please

• Mud
• Wind
• Cement
• Acid
• Water
• Liquidized metal like from Terminator 2
• Snow (Fox666)
• Goo (kkck)

That's all i can think of lets see how many we can think before Chapter 603 and see if any of us were right

 

[kkck]

I find it a tad strange that the cannon ball which he absorb did not actually seem to go all the way through but rather it seemed to have been absorbed. Don't things go a bit more clearly through other logias? Perhaps I am reading too much into that. he could still be a goo paramecia though lol.

 

[Mashiro_Luna]

I would think he was some kind of earth Logia but he's way to lightly colored for mud so I would think cement too since that kind of goes along with burying people but that doesn't seem powerful enough for a logia. He may also not be a logia but some kind of parmencia.

 

[Fox666]

there are some flakes falling, I would include snow too if there wasn't Aokiji fruit out there already... =/

I find it a tad strange that the cannon ball which he absorb did not actually seem to go all the way through but rather it seemed to have been absorbed. Don't things go a bit more clearly through other logias? Perhaps I am reading too much into that. he could still be a goo paramecia though lol.

Hmm, but a paramecia can't do that anyway.

The difference there is that the ball did not go through him. I can see Caribou pulling that same cannonball at the Strawhats later

 

[kkck]

At least IMO a logia is defined by two things:
1.- Being able to transform his body into an element and by extension acquire intangibility.
2.- Being able to generate unlimited amounts of his element and being able to control external sources of the element.

That said, the properties of what a fruit user transform into can also have an effect. For example, BB's fruit is a logia but due to how darkness works (absorbing and whatnot) he just can't let things go through him. He is basically a weird logia. In that sense, why can't we have the opposite, a weird paramecia? Paramecia fruits can create effects which would seem logia-ish, take for example mr 3 and magellan. Both of them can create unlimited amounts of their wax or poison and control it like logias would with their elements but in turn they can't transform their bodies into wax or poison. In this scenario it is possible that there is a paramecia which makes the user essentially intangible while unable to generate more of their element, alter his body mass or other usual logia attributes.

Most likely Caribou is a logia user but I do think it is conceptually possible to be an intangible paramecia.

 

[Channy]

I find it a tad strange that the cannon ball which he absorb did not actually seem to go all the way through but rather it seemed to have been absorbed. Don't things go a bit more clearly through other logias? Perhaps I am reading too much into that. he could still be a goo paramecia though lol.

Goo you mean like Ivan Ooze from Mighty Morphing Power Rangers the Movie.

Thats what Goo reminded me of

there are some flakes falling, I would include snow too if there wasn't Aokiji fruit out there already... =/

And i think it could actually be snow because remember there is fire and magma so could be snow and ice

 

[-Ken-]

Right. Snow fruit is still an option. Logia fruit seems to strictly gave only their elements, not something's that close to it.

On topic, I think that it's mud.

 

[Baron Vorg]

i think the abillity of paramecia have many kind.. So, it can be the power of Caribou is paramecia..
I hesitant that Caribou's power is logia.. I found 2 fact that different from annother common logia (except yami2 no mi)..
1. The bullet from fake Sogeking, it's not perforated in caribou body and make a hole to his body, we know that if logia user is attacked by bullet, the bullet is perforate the body of logia user and make a hole in body altough it's a few moment..
2. Caribou's body is absorb the bullet, not perforate.. It's different from another logia's as we know...

Imo, he's a paramecia that have an ability to make his body became something such as Joz diamond that can change his body became diamond...

 

[kkck]

Goo you mean like Ivan Ooze from Mighty Morphing Power Rangers the Movie.

Thats what Goo reminded me of



And i think it could actually be snow because remember there is fire and magma so could be snow and ice

By goo I meant a generic and sticky liquid, nothing in particular really.

 

[Channy]

http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/45418858/3

Yeah but if ya look at this page from the latest OP chapter Caribou acknowledges that his DF is a logia

 

[Baron Vorg]

he's say "so what if i am".. He didn't say he's logia or not actually.. It can be only a snarl..

 

[zerocooldx]

I would replace cement with rock. Since rock is far more of a natural occurrence than cement. And Caribou seems to be a mud Logia.

 

[Baron Vorg]

but the colour is white..

 

[kkck]

^Thats because the image we saw is in black and white. It could be any color really...

 

[Baron Vorg]

but crocodile's sand colour is not white or black.. Oda using tone..

 

[Poneglyph420]

http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/45418858/3

Looking at this image of Caribou using his DF shows a great deal more shading and tone....

http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/45418858/2

Then in the above image over the fake Sanji's head is says "do ro do ro ro"
(Doro means dirt in Japanese)

When I put the two together I guess he's a Dirt/ Mud Man.

 

[Baron Vorg]

it use a tone because the picture showed very near, so tone used for make a dark efect...

It can be mud, but i'am not sure it logia..

 

[Poneglyph420]

it use a tone because the picture showed very near, so tone used for make a dark efect...

It can be mud, but i'am not sure it logia..

However there is also shading on the middle image of page 3..
Where Caribou is choking out fake Sanji and being proclaimed a Logia..

I don't see how him being Logia is still under debate.. A cannon ball flew through him. He might be a psycho but he's not out of his mind.. So him admitting to being Logia pretty much confirms it.. no?

 

[Baron Vorg]

his body just absorb the canon ball.. The canon ball not trough him..
And he don't say he's a logia, it just according to fake SHP.. He just say "so what if i'am".. He say "if".. So i think he just threating fake SHP.. It can be not..

 

[Dice]

However there is also shading on the middle image of page 3..
Where Caribou is choking out fake Sanji and being proclaimed a Logia..

I don't see how him being Logia is still under debate.. A cannon ball flew through him. He might be a psycho but he's not out of his mind.. So him admitting to being Logia pretty much confirms it.. no?

Seeing the dialogue and the image I thought that he might not be a logia at all. We know that there are paramecia that turn your body in to something else. Take Luffy for example. Furthermore there are fruits that can be turned on and off. An example for that would be Jozu (and Mr. 1? or is he always a metal man?).
So I think that Caribou is a mudman who got his powers through a paramecia.