Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2011] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 1

[Ogichi]

Woah! O__o This does not look like the same series at all! What happened to the cutesy little girl?!?!

Well, if that happens I don't have any complaints about it. Furthermore, it would be like bleach's oneshot.

 

[Sayaendo]

Woah! O__o This does not look like the same series at all! What happened to the cutesy little girl?!?!

But that's how she appears in the one-shot too originally. Hell, she's a "rumored ghost which attacks people". I think it's a given that she'll appear as her true self than as her possessed doll thing in the cover page of the first chapter.

Personally I would love it if the doll just went away altogether, though. The series would be far better for it.

 

[Schabrak]

But I need my Kon fix since he hasn't appeared in Bleach for a year or was it years? Only seeing her as a spirit would be to much HnG for my liking.

 

[SSJWill4]

New series always get cover when it started.

Except for short gag manga.

 

[Zangetsu01]

Issue #39 TOC, Thanks to Ohana @ 2ch

398 ：ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E ：2011/08/31(水) 16:17:39.97 ID:8s2frSO
夏終わるねー。


ジャンプ表紙 クロガネ
巻頭 クロガネ
ワンピ
トリコ
鏡のくにＣ
ナルト
べるぜ
スターズ
銀玉
こち亀Ｃ
スケット
めだか
いぬまる
ハンター
くろ子Ｃ
ブリーチ
ぬらり
りぼん
まじこ
エニグマ
Jスカウトキャラバンお知らせ


40号スケット巻頭
クロガネ C
めだか C
いぬまるC

 

[Savi]

#39
Kurogane (New series, Lead color, Cover)
One Piece
Toriko
Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa (Color)
Naruto
Beelzebub
Stars
Gintama
Kochikame (Color)
Sket Dance
Medaka Box
Inumarudashi
Hunter X Hunter
Kuroko no Basket (Color)
Bleach
Mago
Reborn
Magico
Enigma

Bakuman (Absent)

#40
Sket Dance (Lead Color, Cover)
Kurogane, Medaka Box, Inumarudashi (Color)

 

[Josl]

Well Stars and Harisugawa will probably at least survive the first couple of weeks after the first ranking. Both got color pages which imply good rankings in the early phase. Therefore Enigma and Magico are in big trouble. Both need new series to die for them to survive.

 

[Darjaille]

...

Bleach is getting higher and higher.. XDD Still bottom 5. Looking forward to it's comeback in ToCs

ST&RS's rating is now official right? Glad it is quite high.

Toriko beat Naruto again, eh? And Sket is low after last week.

OK.

 

[k-dom]

So I guess St&rs and Kagami are really well received considering they are in their last chapters before ranking. But Enigma and Magico remind us that a good start is not always sufficient.

 

[Westlo]

Nice by Medaka, color page next week should be the results of the 2nd character poll. Hopefully Kumagawa rightfully crushes his opposition.

 

[Zeltrax]

Glad to see Beelzebub on top. The manga really deserves that.
If I'm not wrong, there this 8 weeks gap thingy so I won't worry too much about Bleach..but then maybe there wasn't any need to worry in the first place.
Stars also seem to be in a safe position, hope that it'll stay that well.
Engima is at the bottom again But I think it'll climb back up again.

 

[Divinenega]

ENIGMA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Seriously what the heck readers? This is getting ridiculous. If I;m not mistaken 8 weeks ago was a color page so that should have at least boosted it a bit out of the bottom five but now it;s dead last. I seriously hope this is just a slump otherwise I;m gonna have to pray a few new series crash and burn hard.

Well there;s still the possibility that Magico will go before it. Even if Magico is ranked a bit higher it did fall into the bottom five much sooner than Enigma did and probably won;t see any boost in sales like Enigma sort of has...

At least there;s a Medaka color page to look forward to and I hope it;s the second popularity poll. Guess it would still be too soon for a confirmation on the anime adaption if it really is coming in Spring.

 

[Nayrael]

Pure Rankings of WSJ #39:

01. One Piece (c629)
02. Toriko (c147)
03. Naruto (c545)
04. Beelzebub (c114)
05. Stars (c01)
06. Gintama (c359)
07. Sket Dance (c191)
08. Medaka Box (c104)
09. Inumarudashi (c137)
10. Bleach (c454)
11. Mago (c160)
12. Reborn (c342)
13. Magico (c17)
14. Enigma (c39)

8 chapter till ranked: Kurogane
1 chapter till ranked: Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa

Kochikame - not considered ranked
Hunter X Hunter - not considered ranked
Kuroko no Basket (c123) - Color Page thus not ranked in this issue
Bakuman (c138) - not ranked due to this week's chapter being absent

 

[Shinjipl]

Pure Rankings of WSJ #39:

But isn't this the rank for One Piece 629 since this week's chapter is 637 ? The same with Naruto and Reborn. For Naruto, it's the rank for 545,because this week's chapter is 553, and for Reborn it's the rank for 343, since this week we have 351. The others are ok.

 

[Nayrael]

But isn't this the rank for One Piece 629 since this week's chapter is 637 ? The same with Naruto and Reborn. For Naruto, it's the rank for 545,because this week's chapter is 553, and for Reborn it's the rank for 343, since this week we have 351. The others are ok.

Ups, you are right. Not sure how I made the mistake

 

[7sun]

Thats a good place for Stars, I'm happy, hope it will be survive!!
Enigma is so low again... hope it survive too, but at the moment I have a bad feeling
Sket Dance jump last week was very great, but I don't think it will happen again so often.
And I Hope the first ranking from Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa will be not as good as the
ranking from stars

 

[Jaiden82]

Fifth place for ST&RS for it's first ranking, not bad. I wonder where Harisugawa will rank when it's officially ranked next week. Bleach is still in the bottom five but it looks like it's steadily moving up.

 

[StrangerAtaru]

Pretty good week: Bleach going up sadly was expected...but it's still bottom five so the readers still have some sense. Admittedly though I do like the readers do actually want change: outside OP/Naruto, most of the top is pretty good, even the high early rank for St&rs.

 

[KiMiTo]

@Nayrael - For Bleach is c455. I think your mistake comes from that that you don't include the chapters from the new issue. It's 8 chapters behind including the new ones from this issue.

 

[Nayrael]

@Nayrael - For Bleach is c455. I think your mistake comes from that that you don't include the chapters from the new issue. It's 8 chapters behind including the new ones from this issue.

My mistake was the fact that I copy-pastes some of the numbers from my last ranking table instead of increasing them by 1. Happens when the first thing you do when you wake up is to make the table ^_^;
The Bleach chapter ranked should be c454.