Games MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE ENDGAME!!

[Hakuteiken]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

I don't have a night role to play, Nuno.

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!

Well that cuts out quite a few options, but still rather vague. Haku I find you a little suspicious, just enough to keep an eye on. For starters you are very active in the discussions. This could be either because you are indeed a townie, and interested in finding the culprits, or you're a rather untraditional Mafia who blends in really well by acting very innocent. Being active in itself is nothing to go on, but I find it a little curious that you're so open to discuss others, but very vague and short respondent about yourself. Although giving even the slight specifics more than you do might reveal your role too much?

 

[Evil3ye]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Haku, what can you say about your role? And don't give me the "I consider you a strong competitor" or whatever "hint" you gave earlier to Gary. Do you e.g. have a night role, aye/nay?

I must say your vote of day 1 was the most suspicious one. You used a "random number generator" and later did not bother to reconsider it. Using a random number generater is very comfortable approach for a mafia, because they must not justify their decision, as it's "random".

And why are you jumping on Haku now?

 

[Farfalla]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Haku, I'm sorry if you said that already T.T But what you think that happened during the night phase? I know that people mentioned a lot of cases and that you're not that used to the game, but what would be your best guesses?

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

I must say your vote of day 1 was the most suspicious one. You used a "random number generator" and later did not bother to reconsider it. Using a random number generater is very comfortable approach for a mafia, because they must not justify their decision, as it's "random".

And why are you jumping on Haku now?

I'm not jumping on Haku. I'm just trying to learn something about his role since Gary's question gave me nothing. I don't find him suspicious enough to vote kill to put it that way.

While what you say is true, I had to give a vote early yesterday, like I said. I didn't trust my condition to be ideal when coming home from clubbing last night, and I would never, ever, wake up early enough to cast another vote. If you don't trust my "excuse" I can always provide you with proof (ticket to the concert I went to) of my absent behavior.

If I were indeed Mafia, I could have always changed vote to Frosty once I came home and read the posts about it, as I would know that he was a "safe kill". But it's a moot point as voting and not voting for Frosy both could provide arguments for and not being Mafia.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Farfalla you bitch!!! You are outta here!

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!

Well that cuts out quite a few options, but still rather vague. Haku I find you a little suspicious, just enough to keep an eye on. For starters you are very active in the discussions. This could be either because you are indeed a townie, and interested in finding the culprits, or you're a rather untraditional Mafia who blends in really well by acting very innocent. Being active in itself is nothing to go on, but I find it a little curious that you're so open to discuss others, but very vague and short respondent about yourself. Although giving even the slight specifics more than you do might reveal your role too much?

Well, not to defend myself, but being active isn't my strategy. I'm just trying to enjoy the game, since it's my first time playing a game of this kind
Hm, let's see. Do you want to hear out further hints?

---------- Post added at 02:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:27 PM ----------

Haku, I'm sorry if you said that already T.T But what you think that happened during the night phase? I know that people mentioned a lot of cases and that you're not that used to the game, but what would be your best guesses?

To be honest, I couldn't come up with something new. It seems to me it was either a regular doctor trying to protect one of the more active players around that could be targeted, or as Evil suggested, a poisoner's job.

---------- Post added at 02:30 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:29 PM ----------

And this is what I was theorizing at that point.

I guess you are right. Too early for this much of a detail.
I asked it bearing something else in my mind. If the target was someone who they thought to be playing a useful pro role, say, what would be their reasoning in poisoning to keep that person alive for one more day phase? I'm guessing the target was supposedly the doctor, who, unlike a detective, won't be providing anything at daytime.

 

[Evil3ye]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

I'm not jumping on Haku. I'm just trying to learn something about his role since Gary's question gave me nothing. I don't find him suspicious enough to vote kill to put it that way.

While what you say is true, I had to give a vote early yesterday, like I said. I didn't trust my condition to be ideal when coming home from clubbing last night, and I would never, ever, wake up early enough to cast another vote. If you don't trust my "excuse" I can always provide you with proof (ticket to the concert I went to) of my absent behavior.

If I were indeed Mafia, I could have always changed vote to Frosty once I came home and read the posts about it, as I would know that he was a "safe kill". But it's a moot point as voting and not voting for Frosy both could provide arguments for and not being Mafia.

So you basically suspect him, because he voted for Frosty, following niichan's lead? Then why are you ignoring xi0 and Imperium, who voted right after? You just mentioned if you were mafia, you would vote for Frosty, however you donot consider those two, why is that?

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!

Guys, is it normal for someone being targeted by the Mafia e.g. Bulletproof, to not be able to perform any action in the following day? Unless I am mistaken, Sickly Townie is the only scenario where this happens. But well, it does not explain why no one died...

 

[Evil3ye]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!

Guys, is it normal for someone being targeted by the Mafia e.g. Bulletproof, to not be able to perform any action in the following day? Unless I am mistaken, Sickly Townie is the only scenario where this happens.

You mean being unable to vote on the following day? No, we never used it like that. xi0's disabled vote is due to the Sickly Townie targetting him, not him being bulletproof and being attacked by the mafia.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Farfalla you bitch!!! You are outta here!

No spamming here!

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Well, not to defend myself, but being active isn't my strategy. I'm just trying to enjoy the game, since it's my first time playing a game of this kind
Hm, let's see. Do you want to hear out further hints?

Fair enough. I was in the same situation last time I played. The first day I didn't post like crazy, but I posted a lot more on the second day as I wanted to enjoy the game and got a certain feel of it. Too bad I died during the second night, lol.

You can always say what you are comfortable with saying. Not having a night action does narrow it down a lot.

So you basically suspect him, because he voted for Frosty, following niichan's lead? Then why are you ignoring xi0 and Imperium, who voted right after? You just mentioned if you were mafia, you would vote for Frosty, however you donot consider those two, why is that?

No, my slight suspicion has more to do with how he had been very active and willing to discuss others (including Frosty of course), but vague and short respondent about himself. He does seem more willing now however, which takes some of it away.

You could always question people that jump on bandwagons, especially the vote when it becomes a true bandwagon. The reason I asked Haku was because he was active in the thread.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

No spamming here!

WTF!? you are just trolling now.

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE!

You mean being unable to vote on the following day? No, we never used it like that. xi0's disabled vote is due to the Sickly Townie targetting him, not him being bulletproof and being attacked by the mafia.

So then we know a Sickly one targeted Gary. Which means someone was either saved (seems a little unlikely to me when the Doc wouldn't know his sanity, but it could be a gamble he/she took) or poisoned? I'm going to lean towards a Mafia Poisoner too, mainly because a Doc seems more random.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

WTF!? you are just trolling now.

Ok, I'm sorry.


Haku was kinda bugging me a bit as well... I think he was also playing safe... Ok, he's a newbie, so he asked some things around, but he kept following Gary a bit. People that follow others around makes me feel uneasy xD but I do that sometimes when I agree with someone... I just don't think he represented a big threat to no one, he posted a lot, but mainly agreed with people and followed them. He didn't actually add something from his own initiative. But maybe I'm just being paranoid about active people, since they give us more material to wonder about. And haven said that, I really hope that a lot of people get hostkilled today, LOL. I should be studying, but I'm here, fighting against my wifi, 'cause I joined the game. Those absent bastards annoys me too damn much @.@

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Fair enough. I was in the same situation last time I played. The first day I didn't post like crazy, but I posted a lot more on the second day as I wanted to enjoy the game and got a certain feel of it. Too bad I died during the second night, lol.

You can always say what you are comfortable with saying. Not having a night action does narrow it down a lot.

I guess it does. Not many to tell about. It's one of those one-sided abilities. For instance, I'm not someone like a Traitor or a Third Party, who depends on both sides. That should be narrowing it down a bit more.

No, my slight suspicion has more to do with how he had been very active and willing to discuss others (including Frosty of course), but vague and short respondent about himself. He does seem more willing now however, which takes some of it away.

You could always question people that jump on bandwagons, especially the vote when it becomes a true bandwagon. The reason I asked Haku was because he was active in the thread.

It was partially because people started by saying things like "Hey X, you were doing that in Role Y in Game N, so, you are a suspect". Since I never played it before, there wasn't much to talk about it me for day one.
It should change by time, I suppose.

 

[Evil3ye]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

No, my slight suspicion has more to do with how he had been very active and willing to discuss others (including Frosty of course), but vague and short respondent about himself. He does seem more willing now however, which takes some of it away.

You could always question people that jump on bandwagons, especially the vote when it becomes a true bandwagon. The reason I asked Haku was because he was active in the thread.

That's a funny thing to say, especially for you, who as against him (who did say he gave hints away about himself), did not reveal anything about your role. As for the bandwagon. From my experience a bandwagon is usually initiated by either a competent mafia, who was carefully watching over inconsistancies of townie's behaviour he could point out, or by a townie who is following the wrong lead while having strong arguments. I agree, one or two mafia could pick up the latter to start it rolling, so I partly understand why you are questioning him.

However, most mafia members usually vote for someone rather random, inconspicuous by saying some vague arguments. In this clichee for one you fit very well with your randomized vote, but also Xadyu, who voted for jorped, because of DN characters, Mazino, who said niichan is always suspicious and M3j, ...ok, I don't recall the reason why he was voting for xi0, but his vote fits very well there too.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

So, what about you, Farfalla? How are you enjoying your role so far? Any clues you could give without completely revealing your identity?

 

[Farfalla]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

So far I'll be either voting for Xadyu or Faust.

Xadyu 'cause I'm not satisfied with the answers he gave us yesterday... he just dodged everything, said conflicting things, and, in my opinion, tried to resort to our emtions using "" emotes (I don't recall if it was exaclyt this one, but something like that) and trying to look like a poor thing "I dunno what else to say mimimi".

Faust 'cause he said a lot of non sense here today, imo xD He basically suspect the ones that voted for him, as if some of them didn't have reason to do it. And then there's the Nuno thing, first saying he was connected to Frosty, and later saying it's just a hunch. I'll save it for later, and try to really study right now, but I'll prolly go for one of those if something big doesn't show up.

---------- Post added at 07:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:59 PM ----------

So, what about you, Farfalla? How are you enjoying your role so far? Any clues you could give without completely revealing your identity?

Well, it's the second time I'm playing with this role, but it's been a long while since I last played with it. People usually call it dull, useless or boring, but I wanna see if I can do a better job with it this time, since last time I was indeed useless '-' I think that's enough hints o/ (at least to oldschool players, maybe)

 

[Nuno]

Re: MAFIA GAME 22 DEATH NOTE! DAY 2!

Evil, like I said I did not have the time to cast an analytic vote later on... And I didn't trust myself to cast a vote while drunk. At the point I randomized there were two bandwagons, Mej and Faust. Mej I honestly thought was more nooby than suspicious, and I didn't find Faust worthy enough of vote kill either, which would make contributing to their bandwagons rather cruel. Which left me with taking someone on a gut feeling (which I didn't have at the time), or random. I do agree that it's a convenient excuse for Mafia members to use, but it is what it is. Most first days are rather random anyway. I won't randomize again, needless to say.

I will gladly tell you something about my role. But because of the nature of it I cannot reveal too much. No one asked for it, hence why I didn't say anything on my own. What I can say is that I'm 1) townie, 2) have no action and 3) I have a boring role. That should narrow it down a lot.