Okay, I got it. I guess there is no point in hiding the name now. This would be too conservative and revealing it could expand a few things.
Already said that in the previous page. Not guilty.
The information is not completely lost though. He will surely share it with the recruiter at night. Also, the remaining detectives, as far as they trust him to be sincere, can investigate him and clarify their own sanity. I don't get how investigating the same person would do any good, as one would get an innocent and the other a guilty result.
Then have another clue: I'm not the bomb.
They already have one information about last night, if they look at imp they will know what exactly their sanity
If it wasn't himself asking for that, I was planning to hold it back, but I wanted to see how he would react to this new information.
Hm, if we consider this is the truth (which somehow I believe it to be the case), quite a generous information this is.
I feel sort of suspicious with how lawlett acted. It seemed uncharacteristic of him. I think it could be easy to be doubtful of jorped too, but there isn't much to go off of there. Haku seems to have thrown a wrench into everything and I sort of agree with your assessment of niichan. It was a smart play, but it doesn't mean he's Mafia or Townie. Though it makes it more likely he's Townie because that would be a risky, risky play if he was a Townie. As a Mafia he would only know who ISN'T Mafia, and picking out a single Mentor out of 22 would be pretty improbable.
Yeah but if the Recruiter was a Mafia Mason he wouldn't try to recruit a Mafia...
Assuming I am telling the truth and am a townie so all the remaining detectives have to do is investigate me and check out their sanity. Haku is either naive or a normal detective. The most important person now though is the insane detective who would be able to investigate without difficulty peoples allegiances (if they stay alive long enough).
How? I don't understand. The only information we now have is Imperium being innocent. We do not know about Haku's sanity, and only the other detective can say who he or she investigated if the result was guilty or innocent. We also do not know who the other detective investigated, but the chances are high, that the result was guilty, thus him being insane.
The thing is, we don't know if you indeed are a townie or not, unless we kill you. And the whole thing is based on a previously made assumption that Haku indeed was a detective. And if that is the case then why would somebody investigate YOU then, instead of HIM to test his sanity? It doesn't make any sense, as we know there are at least two different types of detectives and the result is likely to be the opposite. Thus we'd have two people having wasted their moves on you and still not knowing whether theryare sane, nor whether you are guilty or not.
So, what would you be your reason? Why do you think I implied I had a night role to Gary and said the opposite to you?
He's right about it being a convenient excuse to say two different things, but I don't think you're that dumb...nor are you intentionally trying to confuse. So I think you're probably a Townie.
Hmmm, yea, investigating him would prove more for definite. But the point is that him revealing it is not exactly useless.
I said before, I have a nightime townie role.
Like I said, inconsistencies. It could be a noob mistake, who knows at this point. You were challenged with your role rather early the first time.
I know. Hence why it's so easy to do what he's doing, if it's fake. However I seem to be rather alone in my suspicions. So far the only ones I want to vote kill are Haku and Xad, but Xad hasn't even showed up yet and it might be a useless vote.
Possible. Or I could even be a regular Townie with no great role trying to shield the real Townie Detective. It doesn't help rule out much of a thing, I'd say.
Yeah, it certainly is true, it's a weird choice for sure. Other than the recruiter completely being sure of him being a townie, I don't see a reason to go after him. But on the other hand, it is very risky for a mafia member to claim being a mason. It can be a good move to lure out the real mason and the recruiter, but the mafia cannot know how many masons there were to begin with, and if they don't vote him out pretty quickly. We started with a game of 22 players and had at least two killing parties. Nobody says the masons started with one person only. Especially since we had games in which they were three from day 1.