Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2013-2014] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 3

[Kaizou 10]

Beelzebub rankings reached the arc in USA? Even so, I didn't see anything that good in the arc that could take it out of the bottom.

I believe it is a beginning of USA arc.

I agree with you. The USA arc isn't really that much interesting.

 

[SharkBait]

How are both writers giving it their all?

Kubo has made great improvements in writing since the break and extending back farther, since Fullbring arc. I guess reception isnt meeting expectations reflecting storytelling quality.

Furuichi mini arc and America arc are comedy genius and some of Beelzebub's best and most memorable moments. A disconnect seems to exist again here with quality and reception.

 

[Kaizou 10]

Furuichi mini arc and America arc are comedy genius and some of Beelzebub's best and most memorable moments.

Is it? I don't see it anywhere.

 

[Xadyu]

Kubo has made great improvements in writing since the break and extending back farther, since Fullbring arc. I guess reception isnt meeting expectations reflecting storytelling quality.

Furuichi mini arc and America arc are comedy genius and some of Beelzebub's best and most memorable moments. A disconnect seems to exist again here with quality and reception.

I don't really see any change in quality in Bleach, with perhaps exception on the latter half of Fullbring alright.

And I don't see that at all.. Furuichi Mini Arc was funny, yes. But genius and featuring best and most memorable moments? You're overreacting, the America Arc has nothing special to offer so far, nor is it as funny as Beelzebub's most mediocre moments..

 

[Newkerzy]

Nisekoi ranking was bad, but who cares! Nisekoi in Full Color and Two Chapters?!
Besides, Haikyuu! and an oneshot by Koisome Momiji duo, really... the best issue of the year. XD

Too bad it was fake. But Nisekoi having two chapters would have been interesting. If it was true and became a regular thing once in a while, then I will bow to Naoshi's greatness. So far, the only mangaka I know who can pull off something like that would be Mashima. I still think he's inhuman to be able to bust out 6 chapters two weeks in a row. Having Naoshi do double chapters would clearly send a message to WSM, despite the major genre difference. It would've made the industry's competition more interesting.

 

[Zeromcd]

Alright, mistakes again >.>

757 ：p2-user: 1130194 p2-client-ip: 110.133.200.101：2013/12/16(月) 20:33:03.90 ID:i0287C5kP
んじゃ言うよ

正確には恋染の人の読み切りとは別にニセコイ作者の読み切りが一本
という意味でフルカラー1本(ニセコイ)＋読み切りの二本立て
フルカラーはニセコイ本編のみだと思う

Issue #06/07 Info
Lead CP: One Piece
Center Colour: Haikyuu!!
Full Colour: Nisekoi
Oneshot by Komi Naoshi (Nisekoi) and Koisome Momiji duo

So there will only be one chapter of Nisekoi which will be in full colour, and two separate oneshots. This should be it this time!

 

[k-dom]

Too bad it was fake. But Nisekoi having two chapters would have been interesting. If it was true and became a regular thing once in a while, then I will bow to Naoshi's greatness. So far, the only mangaka I know who can pull off something like that would be Mashima. I still think he's inhuman to be able to bust out 6 chapters two weeks in a row. Having Naoshi do double chapters would clearly send a message to WSM, despite the major genre difference. It would've made the industry's competition more interesting.

There are regularly double chapters in shonen magazine, and not only Fairy Tail

 

[Newkerzy]

Oh yeah, I remember. *facepalm*.

Another Naoshi one-shot? is he trying to serialize one series in Jump and one in another??

 

[Pietro]

Can be that Nisekoi is near to an end the fact that will have a fullcolor chapter and two OS?

 

[Leoat12]

Too bad it was fake. But Nisekoi having two chapters would have been interesting. If it was true and became a regular thing once in a while, then I will bow to Naoshi's greatness. So far, the only mangaka I know who can pull off something like that would be Mashima. I still think he's inhuman to be able to bust out 6 chapters two weeks in a row. Having Naoshi do double chapters would clearly send a message to WSM, despite the major genre difference. It would've made the industry's competition more interesting.

Mashima has a good drawing and he's fast apparently. I respect him despite of I don't like Fairy Tail.
But when there is double chapters like that it is not made in a one week, probably it is prepared beforehand, but of course, the mangaka have to increase his speed each week.

So there will only be one chapter of Nisekoi which will be in full colour, and two separate oneshots. This should be it this time!

It's not surprise me.
Who would have thought that Komi Naoshi will make a oneshot with a series running. Now we can say that he is inhuman. XD
Komi Naoshi one shots are used to be very good. Looking forward for this.

---------- Post added at 11:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:30 AM ----------

Oh yeah, I remember. *facepalm*.

Another Naoshi one-shot? is he trying to serialize one series in Jump and one in another??

I don't think so, maybe it is an one shot that he was saving. He made various one shots before. Since that Nisekoi anime will debut soon, I think it's the way to promote it and the mangaka.

Can be that Nisekoi is near to an end the fact that will have a fullcolor chapter and two OS?

There is no way to finish Nisekoi in two chapters, even more when the anime will debut

 

[Eru13]

Issue #06/07 Info
Oneshot by Komi Naoshi (Nisekoi) and Koisome Momiji duo

You know, rather than the duo, I think it's only by Miura Tadahiro, he's published two oneshots on his own this year, so I don't really think they're back as a duo

Btw, people in 2ch are taking this as the real TOC, I can't but feel it's fake but I'll post it so that everyone can decide whether to believe it or not by themselves

835 ：名無しさんの次レスにご期待下さい：2013/12/16(月) 21:56:31.89 IDVQdnxo+0
しかしまあ、なんでわかめはドベしか発表しないんだ？
別に全部言うのもドベだけ言うのも変わらんだろー

年末だけは情報入るので……

暗殺
ソーマ
ワンピ
黒子
ナルト
ソーマ番外編C
トリガー
トリコ　　　　　　
磯部C　
アイアン
ハイキュー
斉木
ソウル
ニセコイ
銀魂
ハチ
鰤
こち亀
べるぜ
焼野原

Issue #4-5 (Unconfirmed, might be fake)
Ansatsu Kyoushitsu (Lead CP, Cover)
Shokugeki no Soma
One Piece
Kuroko no Basket
Naruto
Shokugeki no Soma Bangaihen (Center Color)
World Trigger
Toriko
Isobe (Center Color)
Iron Knight
Haikyuu
Saiki Kusuo no PSInan
Soul Catcher(S)
Nisekoi
Gintama
Hachi
Bleach
Kochikame
Beelzebub
Koi no Cupid Yakenohara Jin

What feels weird is Soma having a chapter and the bangaihen (it can actually be true which is why I posted this)

 

[Kaizou 10]

Btw, people in 2ch are taking this as the real TOC, I can't but feel it's fake but I'll post it so that everyone can decide whether to believe it or not by themselves

Issue #4-5 (Unconfirmed, might be fake)
Ansatsu Kyoushitsu (Lead CP, Cover)
Shokugeki no Soma
One Piece
Kuroko no Basket
Naruto
Shokugeki no Soma Bangaihen (Center Color)
World Trigger
Toriko
Isobe (Center Color)
Iron Knight
Haikyuu
Saiki Kusuo no PSInan
Soul Catcher(S)
Nisekoi
Gintama
Hachi
Bleach
Kochikame
Beelzebub
Koi no Cupid Yakenohara Jin

What feels weird is Soma having a chapter and the bangaihen (it can actually be true which is why I posted this)

Is it? When I look at the 2ch, people aren't saying that is real. Plus, if it is real, then it should be massive comments on 2ch, but it is too little comments. So, I think it is a fake. I know next issue is releasing early, but it is still early for getting full ToC.

And it is not weird for Souma having a normal chapter and bangaihen together since Kuroko and Beelzebub also released two in one issues. So, it is possible for Souma as well.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

That was just confirmed to be fake a page back...

 

[Eru13]

Is it? When I look at the 2ch, people aren't saying that is real. Plus, if it is real, then it should be massive comments on 2ch, but it is too little comments. So, I think it is a fake. I know next issue is releasing early, but it is still early for getting full ToC.

And it is not weird for Souma having a normal chapter and bangaihen together since Kuroko and Beelzebub also released two in one issues. So, it is possible for Souma as well.

Well, there's mixed opinions, some people (like the guy who always posts the averages in TOC positions) just went and believed it and most of the people who don't have as their argument that Soma won't have 2 chs this week
As I said, I wouldn't find it weird in either case, I just really feel that 50 pages in one week is a bit too unreal even for Saeki Shun which is why I'm more inclined to say there's only a bangaihen this week (how many pages were the Kuroko/Beelzebub's bangaihens when that happened?)

 

[Kaizou 10]

Well, there's mixed opinions, some people (like the guy who always posts the averages in TOC positions) just went and believed it and most of the people who don't have as their argument that Soma won't have 2 chs this week

When the person (who uploads the averages) uploads new data, then people are normally replying to that new data. But, this time, people basically ignore that which is unusual. So, I think it is most likely that ToC is fake.

As I said, I wouldn't find it weird in either case, I just really feel that 50 pages in one week is a bit too unreal even for Saeki Shun which is why I'm more inclined to say there's only a bangaihen this week (how many pages were the Kuroko/Beelzebub's bangaihens when that happened?)

I forgot about Beelzebub's length, but Kuroko's length is same as regular chapter (19 pages). But, I don't think the editors tell the author to do 50 pages within one week; I think it is more like the editor tell them beforehand, so the author can do the special chapter whenever they have free time after the regular serialization. Plus, based on Komi has to do the one shot and full color chapter by Issue 6/7 as well. Even though there is one extra week to work on, it is still lots of work for two weeks. So, I think Komi was working during his free time. So, I don't think Saeki was forced to do the two chapters within one week.

 

[Eru13]

When the person (who uploads the averages) uploads new data, then people are normally replying to that new data. But, this time, people basically ignore that which is unusual. So, I think it is most likely that ToC is fake. (1)

I forgot about Beelzebub's length, but Kuroko's length is same as regular chapter (19 pages). But, I don't think the editors tell the author to do 50 pages within one week; I think it is more like the editor tell them beforehand, so the author can do the special chapter whenever they have free time after the regular serialization. Plus, based on Komi has to do the one shot and full color chapter by Issue 6/7 as well. Even though there is one extra week to work on, it is still lots of work for two weeks. So, I think Komi was working during his free time. So, I don't think Saeki was forced to do the two chapters within one week. (2)

1) As I said at first, it might be real, if Soma actually has 2 chs the real TOC can either be this or something really similar imo (I mean, with the bottom 8 already confirmed there's not much left to see really)
2) That makes a lot of sense, mostly thinking that it's a story that doesn't have much to do with the main story and from a period of time in-story that's already in the past, in Nisekoi's case, well, Nisekoi has pretty much been a series of oneshots lately so I guess Komi could do it without a problem

 

[Kaizou 10]

2) That makes a lot of sense, mostly thinking that it's a story that doesn't have much to do with the main story and from a period of time in-story that's already in the past, in Nisekoi's case, well, Nisekoi has pretty much been a series of oneshots lately so I guess Komi could do it without a problem

But, as you said, it is possible that there going to be just one special chapter, but I think there is a possibility for two as well.

 

[Eru13]

But, as you said, it is possible that there going to be just one special chapter, but I think there is a possibility for two as well.

That's why I hate when the announcements aren't clear enough... ¬¬

 

[Greco]

Cover of the new Weekly Shonen JUMP's crossover video-game: J-Stars Victory VS! for PS3.

 

[SharkBait]

Cover of the new Weekly Shonen JUMP's crossover video-game: J-Stars Victory VS! for PS3.

Partial song list too
One Piece: We Are
Naruto: GO!!!
Dragon Ball: Cha-La Head-Cha-La
Yu Yu Hakusho: Hohoemi no Bakudan (Smile Bomb)
Toriko: Gatsu Gatsu
Bleach: Asterisk
Hunter x Hunter: departure!
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: ~Jojo~ Sono Chi no Sadame
Ruroni Kenshin: Sobakasu
Beelzebub: Dadada
Gintama: Pray
Medaka Box: Happy Crazy Box
Kochikame: Katsuhishika Rhapsody
Jigoku Sensei Nube: Bari Bari Saikyou
Katekyo Hitman REBORN!: LISTEN TO THE STEREO!