Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.8

xi0 · Dec 21, 2013

digitaldude said:
Everyone contributed, some are just lazy.

Or forgot.

Plus, his penalty for not voting is you getting automatic vote for lynching the next day phase. It seems like a more sensible penalty than unbalancing the game with hostkills. But if someone is completely MIA, it shouldn't be done for more than a single phase IMO.

---------- Post added at 05:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:36 AM ----------

Almost 400 posts in a day for a game with 20 players...seems fine to me.

He only extended the day phase in the first place because there was a tie. He gave an extra three hours, I don't see what the problem is...

scav · Dec 21, 2013

a 36h extended day 1 so far never hurt anyone and have been the most balanced thing in this game, allowing everyone to set his marks on the game and not just coming and posting/voting cuz he's running out of time. And almost every host do it if i recall correctly

---------- Post added at 10:42 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:40 AM ----------

xi0 said:
Or forgot.

Plus, his penalty for not voting is you getting automatic vote for lynching the next day phase. It seems like a more sensible penalty than unbalancing the game with hostkills. But if someone is completely MIA, it shouldn't be done for more than a single phase IMO.

---------- Post added at 05:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:36 AM ----------

Almost 400 posts in a day for a game with 20 players...seems fine to me.

He only extended the day phase in the first place because there was a tie. He gave an extra three hours, I don't see what the problem is...

lol i forgot 400post is nothing for you, generally you generate 1/4 of it only by yourself :derp

what happened to you bro?

Faust · Dec 21, 2013

scav said:
just a remark. faust should've extended day 1 specially cuz he selfishly started the game at night time at both EU and NA (around 2am eu time where the majority of players are) he taken into account Philippine clock that's fine but still should've been an extended day1 so the majority of players would've been able to participate to their full content.

I noted/highlighted that I will be relying in my time zone, Philippine Time.

scav said:
this guy always in a hurry like he have a stick on fire up his ass

And you're the one who has one. 2012 Passionate Member.

xi0 · Dec 21, 2013

FaustXIII said:
You're the one who has one.

And I noted/higlighted that I will be relying in my time zone, Philippine Time.

Despite my tl;dr, it's a fair complaint. I don't know if you've hosted a game of 20+ before or not, but I think Day 1 can be longer without it harming much. Plus, I think Evil and digital have done the same and ended it earlier than said if it seems like the game is stagnate, or people locked their votes. It gives more breathing room.

Faust · Dec 21, 2013

xi0 said:
Despite my tl;dr, it's a fair complaint. I don't know if you've hosted a game of 20+ before or not, but I think Day 1 can be longer without it harming much.

I hosted 3 Games.

Game 27 with 13 Players
Game 29 with 12 Players
and
Game 31 with 14 Players

So this is my first time hosting a game with 20 Players.

And I admit it didn't crossed my mind to extend the Day Phase. I sincerely apologize if I disappointed you guys by not extending the Day Phase 1.