Having a naive detective isn't a really crazy theory though.
He said he was the whore?
Because it's 50/50...meaning I'd kill myself or another Townie before I got another Mafia. Mafia looks pretty screwed atm, but if I got too antsy I could fuck the game up royally still.
Not really, but his role is either Prostitute or Hider according to the clues he gave.
I still see it differently. I wouldn't have gone for him as Mafia. It's a waste. And I have no idea were this percentage is coming from, after all first he has to have the right target, doesn't he.
Yes, I see your point. Maybe he is a lying Mafia. But this claim alone is not enough for me yet to be sure that is the case.Sure it is and I guess it's more believable since it isn't Doctor...but it's pretty convenient, no?
If I was Mafia, I'd definitely consider not killing me on the first Night and it's just like Nuno to taunt me with this max disrespect. "Oh, he'll just kill himself anyway, lel". "Oh look, Bodyguard...perfect explanation for Gary making it through the first night, let's just kill ____ instead and keep this card in our pockets".
...pls
I think it is pretty clear that you are lying. First you have no result at all. Claming you have been blocked by a Prostitute, which probably doesn't even exist. Josef might have dropped hints about it, but we don't know it for sure. And I have a reason to doubt he is one, why - because I instantly got my result when I asked niichan about xi0's alighment. It was when just when the night started and Josef was off.
3 detectives, 1 bodyguard, 1 hoe, 1 badass cowboy.
Actually.. I missed that bit..
You think there's a naive and a sane detective in this game?
Well, I'll wait for him to come and confirm then
His "I pay visits at night
" is rather obvious. Almost too obvious I found it for a day 1 info reveal. If you considered the smiley it was 100% obvious, which is why I didn't believe him fully, but no one else seems to claim the whore.
Or Gary shooting one of you.Yeah, well, the only answer is either a lynching or waiting for the next night results..
Of course, but as far as I know the insane doc is one of the most important targets for the mafia just because he can actually kill one of them. Just like that.
Well... i receive my result in the same time as well... but nii-chan send me a pm today talking about i was blocked and asked me if i want to stop the game. I told him to make the call, for me there isnt any problem because my result first day could be a lot of things.
You have a point here. He might have been unsure about if it fitted with the other hints he dropped. To be frank I was expecting him to come out as Spy, he went for the Detective though, trying to get gnut lynched (not going after me for claiming sane - instead probably assuming or he is insane, or wanting to make us think that to get gnut lynched).
I think Josef is more likely to be a Hider and the smiley was just to get the Mafia to target him - which is probably why we don't have a dead body this night.His "I pay visits at night
So what was it now Mido, first you got the result, and then niiachn was taking it back saying you were blocked? Really?
Well , like i said, you guys can kill me o.o. Maybe its better for the gameI think Josef is more likely to be a Hider and the smiley was just to get the Mafia to target him - which is probably why we don't have a dead body this night.
So what was it now Mido, first you got the result, and then niiachn was taking it back saying you were blocked? Really?