Games Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - END GAME

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

A freeman with a night role, that's pretty unique.

Haku doesnt have a night role

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

So, since Haku is the only one online... Why did you decide to stay out of that mess, if you believed in Niichan?

 

[Hardy]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

My long ass post had less relevance to everyone's mind that I expected

It still wasn't me that said that Gary was a doc '-'


Now I believe we do have a poisoner in this game... Evil just posted something about it in the discussion thread, and if we didn't have one, he could have waited until the game was over.

...but you called me dumbass

Out of game things shouldn't be relevant here. If anything, Evil was just being helpful and told us how the poisoner works, that doesn't mean there's one.

I believe it's still a possibility though.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

A freeman with a night role, that's pretty unique.

Without saying yes or no to freeman argument.. I already said I don't have a night role

 

[Josef]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

What? no.

But he said he got blocked and, funny thing, a kill didn't happen at night.



A freeman with a night role, that's pretty unique.

So you suspect Leo? Or you just do not trust him ...

Haku said no night role, btw.^^

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

I finished reading the wall \o/ And I agree with Hardy... although in one hand it's suspicious that people just joined a bandwagon, we also saw that happening multiple times and I think that many of those times the ones bandwagoning were all townies. On the other hand, sitting on their arses and w8ing for someone they believed to be a precious player/role to die, that's even more suspicious to me...

Indeed it's pretty suspicious to just not contribute in the last part of the phase when a big bandwagoning is happening. It's a fair point definitely. That's prime mafia behavior as they obviously would believe niichan is a BP (although there would be a small chance from their perspective of niichan lying and being 3rd party). As such it would be in their best interest to just let him die and remain in the shadows when the bandwagon is already "complete".

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Why would Leo pick Greg just cause he claimed to be the hider? That doesn't confirm that he's a townie, it would still be a gamble.

 

[Hardy]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Hmm, I didn't even mention you, so why you acting like I blame you? So defensive.

It was pretty easy to see with niichan really, that's all I'm saying. Just going into his post history he had no posts after he came into the mafia thread. An easy counter-example would be xi0. A member of the forum everyone knows is on very often and posts a lot. If such a guy avoids the thread it's highly suspicious.

Voicing my opinion on a matter isn't defensive.

I never post in the same forums as niichan so I didn't notice anything, so I don't see why it is something necessary for the rest.

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Is it possible to chose not to use your ability at night? I thought it wasn't.

Sure it is just don't send a PM... The host can't wait longer than the phase lasts rofl. If for example the slut doesn't send a PM within 12 hours the ability would "not be used".

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Indeed it's pretty suspicious to just not contribute in the last part of the phase when a big bandwagoning is happening. It's a fair point definitely. That's prime mafia behavior as they obviously would believe niichan is a BP (although there would be a small chance from their perspective of niichan lying and being 3rd party). As such it would be in their best interest to just let him die and remain in the shadows when the bandwagon is already "complete".

And Haku even stated he didn't want "to join the mess".

 

[Hardy]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

So you suspect Leo? Or you just do not trust him ...

Haku said no night role, btw.^^

I suspect him...

Jesus Josef, it's all in the long ass post, I clearly said Leo is the one I suspect the most >_>

Without saying yes or no to freeman argument.. I already said I don't have a night role

Yeah, I'm kinda dumb.

And Haku even stated he didn't want "to join the mess".

And as I said before, Leo said ¨I'm free of guilt¨.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Sure it is just don't send a PM... The host can't wait longer than the phase lasts rofl. If for example the slut doesn't send a PM within 12 hours the ability would "not be used".

Hardy said that alrdy '-' I think you should consider my "finish reading before posting", the one you thanked '-'

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

So, since Haku is the only one online... Why did you decide to stay out of that mess, if you believed in Niichan?

I didn't particularly believe in his "I'm Bulletproof" argument, that could well have been a desperation attempt, trying to bet hopes on the fact that the real Bulletproof wasn't online at that very point. I didn't believe in him, since he didn't/couldn't really get into the game that much.
However, I also didn't buy into "One liner random vote without any reason, inactive guy, Mafia" argument. He's much better than that. That doesn't mean I had 100% trust in him, so much that I'd randomly try to kill xi0 in his place.

**
What I meant to say overall, we played the first day badly. Enough said about it. Again, I'm saying "we", since we remained in a deadlock with all random Hardy votes and some vague arguments about xi0 activity.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

And as I said before, Leo said ¨I'm free of guilt¨.

Yeah, and he would fit the case of a mafia being blocked and coming out of the closet before the hoe does, but saying he had a pro townie ability.

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Why would Leo pick Greg just cause he claimed to be the hider? That doesn't confirm that he's a townie, it would still be a gamble.

Because he made it easy for the detectives to target the same person at night to confirm their sanities....

 

[Hardy]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

It would be really dumb for a mafia to say ¨I was blocked yesterday¨ though, lol.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

It would be really dumb for a mafia to say ¨I was blocked yesterday¨ though, lol.

Can't Poisoner or Mafia Detective get blocked? In that case, that wouldn't be dumb, since it wouldn't be a lie.

 

[Nuno]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

And Haku even stated he didn't want "to join the mess".

Haku always plays like this however. He plays his own way and votes for his own suspects.

We can't forget that both instances are convenient for the mafia. Making the bandwagon is convenient for them, and "not preventing it" is convenient for them. Both the ones that made the bandwagon and the ones that didn't prevent it are equally suspicious.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

I didn't particularly believe in his "I'm Bulletproof" argument, that could well have been a desperation attempt, trying to bet hopes on the fact that the real Bulletproof wasn't online at that very point. I didn't believe in him, since he didn't/couldn't really get into the game that much.
However, I also didn't buy into "One liner random vote without any reason, inactive guy, Mafia" argument. He's much better than that. That doesn't mean I had 100% trust in him, so much that I'd randomly try to kill xi0 in his place.

**
What I meant to say overall, we played the first day badly. Enough said about it. Again, I'm saying "we", since we remained in a deadlock with all random Hardy votes and some vague arguments about xi0 activity.

btw you voted for hardy right? I dont recall you saying reasons or I dont remember them .... can you repeat in short sentence?

 

[Josef]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Xadyu and nanaDmari ... these two ... I do not know, but they are uncontributive to the max ... at one point in this day I thought of lynching Tommy boy ... DOES HE EVEN READ THE DAMN THREAD?

Nana has not been active since the beginning of day one ... hmmm.

Throwing them out there as suspects ...