Games Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - END GAME

[wizzard]

But that's not the point.
He says "he didn't himself", so, he's obviously referring to the stage after people started the "niichan is inactive, he's Mafia" witch hunt. What you say might be an answer to what to do to avoid being suspected on Day 1, but it doesn't give an answer to how to defend yourself once you are suspected already.

Once you get a suspect status it's hard to get rid of it... niichan proved it. Not getting suspected is the best defense imo.

Also I believe Hardy was referring to niichan making minimal effort to convince anyone in anything.

 

[Hardy]

But that's not the point.
He says "he didn't himself", so, he's obviously referring to the stage after people started the "niichan is inactive, he's Mafia" witch hunt. What you say might be an answer to what to do to avoid being suspected on Day 1, but it doesn't give an answer to how to defend yourself once you are suspected already.

No, I'm talking about the moment when he could had saved himself with his vote / convincing someone else to vote for gary.

Also I believe Hardy was referring to niichan making minimal effort to convince anyone in anything.

You've started to understand me a lot after this game

 

[wizzard]

No, I'm talking about the moment when he could had saved himself with his vote / convincing someone else to vote for gary.



You've started to understand me a lot after this game

I've always been able to understand others (to a certain level)
to be precise I understand when someone thinks like me (That's why I never understand why someone wouldn't like me )

 

[Hakuteiken]

No, I'm talking about the moment when he could had saved himself with his vote / convincing someone else to vote for gary.

You start your sentence with "No", then copy exactly what I said. You weren't talking about the time when he was inactive and had no votes on him. You were talking about the time when he came back and had like 6 votes on his head. And he is supposed to convince someone else to vote for Gary. Cool. How, if I may ask?
Or looking beyond how, why? He had no idea what Gary's role was. Why should he try to get people to hang some other guy just to save his own head? This is a team game. Maybe Gary had a role which was as much valuable to the town, or more. How was he even supposed to make that judgment, with zero information?

Show me how he could actually convince people, then. Or rather, wasn't it already over when he came back? There was no way I'd be voting for Gary, so, did he even have a chance to survive with my vote going to you from the beginning?

 

[Hardy]

You start your sentence with "No", then copy exactly what I said.

You never said that

Well, he could had tried instead of bitching, what could he lose?. As I said in day 2, there were clearly 3 guys (+ kat who ended up changing her vote) in the thread besides him that could change their votes and didn't want him dead. If I wanted to stay alive (and didn't suspect Gary) I would have potentially 5 votes to help me. He could had lynched anyone in order to save himself. But of course, he surely didn't suspect nobody. Cool.

 

[Hakuteiken]

I did. Doesn't matter if you didn't comprehend that part, though.

We were in the thread for the entire phase almost, yet we had no idea what to do. He was MIA for most part and naturally, he didn't have a clear suspect.
And I just asked how he could have been more convincing with his words. He revealed his role and that was about what he could do. If anything, if he tried to survive the way you later did yourself, I'd probably have locked my vote on him, since I find such drama, tryhard stuff and demagogy inherently annoying. I'm surprised you can still find a saving grace for Town in that fail bandwagon by putting the blame on the victim himself. Those who started and pushed the bandwagon and those who didn't bother stopping it are at fault, before his lack of defense might be mentioned.
Anyways, enough is enough, I guess.

 

[Hardy]

If anything, if he tried to survive the way you later did yourself, I'd probably have locked my vote on him, since I find such drama, tryhard stuff and demagogy inherently annoying

Yet you helped me and voted against the guy I wanted.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Yet you helped me and voted against the guy I wanted.

Because it wasn't Day 1. We had a clue about what Josef's rule was (Bomb), and how weird he was playing it (refusing to be tested). So, we actually had a chance to express why not to vote for you. We had nothing of that sort on Day 1.
If niichan was in your shoes and did not fight back once he got votes on his head, then yeah, I'd agree, but the cases aren't one bit similar.

 

[Hardy]

...ok enough is enough

 

[MidoBan]

 

[Farfalla]

I like it fast though

You're 16 D: ! That's just wrong ç.ç

 

[Kat]

You're 16 D: ! That's just wrong ç.ç

well these days its just normal but who knows I might have been joking

 

[Hardy]

We know you weren't

 

[Kat]

We know you weren't

Only I know if I was or no doesnt matter if its true or not it was a silly joke

 

[digitaldude]

well these days its just normal but who knows I might have been joking

It's been normal for like 40-50 years. Anyway I think the actual game disucssion has pretty much ended, you know what to do mido!