Don't get me wrong

With all due respect, you're argument is irrelevant to the actual question that is in the topic of the thread. It doesn't matter if Rebecca would've won or lost based on something that didn't happen (Cavendish not staying asleep). The question is if her win was based on luck or skill or both.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with being of the opinion of either or both but its kinda insulting to a person's intelligence when someone says their opinion is backed by manga as fact while another's isn't simply by saying the testimony of Character X is canon and the testimony of Character Y doesn't count. This is just bias based on subjective reasoning.
IF: there's no way to say that she could have lost if Cavendish didn't stay asleep,
THEN (by the same logic): there's no way to say that she could have won if Cavendish woke up.
so what you said here:
doesn't really hold up as an argument either if by the same breath you say:
Saying that just because something that was possible didn't happen, and therefore discussing that possibility is dumb is just a way to shut down debate without having to seriously consider that possibility even simply for the sake of discussion.