Rebecca won her block with skill or luck or both?

Deleted member 182576

初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Well, then let's say she would have to carry her head in both of her palms as it would be split in two halves. She was fast enough to notice of Hakuba's movements, however, even though she moved to avoid it, Hakuba was still fast enough to lay a hit on her. If she had not had the helmet, she would have been done for.
well let's say Cavendish didn't carry his sword. What would happen then? It was allowed to bring armor so she did. If you'd go in that ring and they tell you that you can take swords and shields with you, would you take them with you or not? Rebecca did the right thing and it wasn't luck. Doflamingo said that because he's evil and evil people in mangas do say such nonesense things.
 

amizou

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
234
Reaction score
129
Gender
Male
Country
Tunisia
She saw through Cavendish's attack and dodged it. Definitely not luck, especially since she's undefeated in the arena. By the way, Barto also won because he saw through Elizabello's attack and blocked it with a barrier, while it took out everyone else, including Elizabello himself. So both he and Rebecca won in very similar ways. And Cavendish and Elizabello lost in similar ways. So the most we can say for sure is that if Cavendish didn't go to sleep, it would've been a longer fight. If you want to call that luck, I guess you can go ahead. Sabo didn't call it luck, though. I think he'd know (Doflamingo wasn't there and was doing the "I'm-a-villain-and-talking-down-to-the-good-guys" bit that villains do).
It has nothing to do with Barto who was not lucky and who wasn't the only one to notice the King's attack, and the difference that he has a devil fruit that helped him to defend himself also we saw him beat the crap of a higher up in the marines, and when he was fighting he was winning with ease and not doing much effort, same thing applies to Blackbeard first Captain and a bit less Luffy because he was fighting a former 500 000 000 wanted pirate, but Rebecca, she was having a very hard time with some fodders, Oda needs her for the advance of the story or maybe he needs Cavendish to help in the SOP operation so he made him loose, whatever everyone says Rebecca is just too weak, remember the guy who always bullied her and get smashed by Luffy with less than a punch.

Even if we cannot compare the strength in one piece but there is a limit to that, I can accept people discussing who is stronger between Luffy and Law or Luffy and DD but to go and say Rebecca is stronger than Cavendish and deserves her win is just not acceptable.
 

Spam286

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2009
Messages
174
Reaction score
56
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
In order to win but produce no harm you must be truly above your enemy, we saw her parrying with Suleiman and avoiding his attacks but even with her ally(s) she couldn't take any of the bigshots and you may say that she got not enough time to do so but in the same panels she was fighting Suleiman, Bellamy took someone we knew the name of (Tank Lepanto). She was struggling already thus she is not strong enough to defeat those opponents with that style.
There are many fallacies in that statement. First, that the same number of panels = the same time frame. It doesn't. Second, that Suleiman and Tank Lepanto are comparable in strength when there's zero evidence for it and third that those two confrontations are somehow equivalent when the situation and characters in question are completely different.

So you want to say that Cavendish become this popular and with a bounty of 250 000 000 with a technique that have a time attack of few seconds then go to sleep, and he never fought someone strong enough to not fall against him for few seconds because if what you assume is true the Cavendish should be acptured a long time ago.

Even so lets say that you are right, its still luck that she won, because simply Cavendish slept, as I said she is not the strongest one in her block but she still won so she was lucky, its as simple as that. I'm not saying she is weak but she is not the strongest one in her block and all the circumstances that happened in the block D played in her favor.
You're still saying Rebecca wasn't capable of winning her block without substantiating it with evidence. (I'll go ahead and say in advance that I don't find Rebecca's scuffle with Luffy compelling enough evidence to prove she's weaker than Cavendish, so you'll have to find something else.)

It has nothing to do with Barto who was not lucky and who wasn't the only one to notice the King's attack, and the difference that he has a devil fruit that helped him to defend himself also we saw him beat the crap of a higher up in the marines, and when he was fighting he was winning with ease and not doing much effort, same thing applies to Blackbeard first Captain and a bit less Luffy because he was fighting a former 500 000 000 wanted pirate, but Rebecca, she was having a very hard time with some fodders, Oda needs her for the advance of the story or maybe he needs Cavendish to help in the SOP operation so he made him loose, whatever everyone says Rebecca is just too weak, remember the guy who always bullied her and get smashed by Luffy with less than a punch.

Even if we cannot compare the strength in one piece but there is a limit to that, I can accept people discussing who is stronger between Luffy and Law or Luffy and DD but to go and say Rebecca is stronger than Cavendish and deserves her win is just not acceptable.
So wait, a thing that happened to a character's advantage (the King Punch wiping block B except Barto who was able to block) is not comparable to a thing that happened to a character's advantage (Hakuba wiping block D except for Rebecca who was able to dodge)? One is luck while the other is pure skill? You're still determining this based on things that didn't happen, i.e. Barto winning block B without the aid of the King Punch and Rebecca losing block D without Hakuba. You're making assumptions and using them to justify your arguments.

Also, what constitutes 'having a very hard time' and 'fodders' in this scenario? Rebecca was still in and still untouched when Hakuba appeared. The only actual fodder we saw her fighting were the ones she despatched with consummate ease. Unless you're implying that the named characters in block D are also 'fodders' in which case I would ask: 'fodder for whom?' and 'how can you substantiate that with evidence?'

As for Spartan, again you're substantiating an argument with assumptions, in this case that the reason she was bullied was because she was too weak to defeat Spartan. We don't know the nature of the bullying that took place, so there's nothing to back up your claims except your own beliefs.
 

Beatrice

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2013
Messages
1,657
Reaction score
1,425
Age
35
Gender
Hidden
Country
Germany
Yeah, let's everyone remember Spartan when it comes to Rebecca being "Weak", cause it's not like Dressrosa hates her guts and Spartan being a Sexist (and Muscle Brained) and even tried to "bully" Luffy right?Not to forget it's OoC for Rebecca to hurt anyone.
And "Get's smashed by Luffy in less than a punch", sorry but what?IT'S LUFFY.What he does means nothing considering his power.

Goddammit, everywhere I go People pull out this Spartan crap cause apparently they think bullying automatically equates to beating the crap out of someone.
She's just the "Root of all Evil" for people on Dressrosa, and in this case Spartan was also a guy who believed a Gladiator has to be a like 4m tall muscle mountain of a man.


we saw her parrying with Suleiman and avoiding his attacks but even with her ally(s) she couldn't take any of the bigshots and you may say that she got not enough time to do so but in the same panels she was fighting Suleiman, Bellamy took someone we knew the name of (Tank Lepanto). She was struggling already thus she is not strong enough to defeat those opponents with that style.
You people have a twisted definition of "Struggling", apparently "Struggling" now equates to:
"Dodging EVERY single one of the opponents attacks".
Yeah, Suleiman didn't get a single hit in.That's not struggling especially when her fighting style is based upon an Martial Art which is all about finding the right moment and position to counter.


And for the billionth time, calling her weak is a freaking insult to everyone who practices Aikido, it's all defense with 0 offense but pure counter with the purpose to not hurt anyone.

But yeah, I suppose for most people only busting things equates to strong.That's purely simple minded.
 
Last edited:

BetaRuler

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2009
Messages
382
Reaction score
89
Gender
Hidden
Country
United Kingdom
I can't believe this thread is really so necessary! As if the discussion in the prediction thread wasn't enough already.

Here's a ton of lucky things happening.

Rebecca and Cavendish getting thrown in D block instead of any of the other blocks.
Cavendish having such a condition in the first place.
Cavendish falling asleep in the middle of a fight
Hakuba falling asleep in the middle of a fight causing him to loose!
it's also luck a natural earthquake didn't rip a whole in the ground and just kill everyone. You know natural disasters and all that.
 

Deleted member 182576

初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Here's a ton of lucky things happening.

Rebecca and Cavendish getting thrown in D block instead of any of the other blocks.
Cavendish having such a condition in the first place.
Cavendish falling asleep in the middle of a fight
Hakuba falling asleep in the middle of a fight causing him to loose!
it's also luck a natural earthquake didn't rip a whole in the ground and just kill everyone. You know natural disasters and all that.
Yeah, Rebecca won cause Cavedish fell asleep and everything was pure luck. (Y) It was also pure luck that Luffy won his Block because I mean like an earthquake could've happen and everybody getting smashed. Really? lol
 

BetaRuler

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2009
Messages
382
Reaction score
89
Gender
Hidden
Country
United Kingdom
You can see I'm being sarcastic can't you? Really, lol, I feel there is very little to discuss here, only opinions to express about a moot point.

Going by the logic people are trying to pursue that Rebecca is lucky, Cavendish can also be considered lucky he has such a condition and that he could change to Hakuba so fast, you'd think half the fighters nearby could leave a fatal wound before he even touched the ground when falling asleep. Luck that no one like Luffy, Jesus or Bartolomeo got into D block or any other certain fighters we saw in the previous rounds or Sabo, who might have possessed a skill to take Hakuba down.
Or who is a better judge between Doffy and Sabo? Doflamingo who is biased against members of the previous royal family anyway vs Sabo who was watching what happened with a neutral and objective pov?
 

Syphin

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2009
Messages
658
Reaction score
884
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
I do find it amusing how [some] people make the arguments so personal and resort to insulting jabs when countering =/.

We are not enemies here, lets keeps the discussion within friendly levels please.
 

M3J

MH Senpai
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
48,833
Reaction score
17,298
Gender
Male
Country
Akatsuki
Doesn't matter what Sabo says, what we see is that Rebecca had the skill to see the attack AND move in time. That's manga fact, she saw the attack and was quick enough to move. I forgot and cannot be assed to check if she used haki, but it doesn't change the fact that she still reacted. Had she not moved, she would have likely been hit right in the head and been out, when instead her helmet took the brunt of the damage and kept her conscious.


Luck played a part too, when Cavendish went back to sleep.
 

Impossibility

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
4,545
Reaction score
1,195
Gender
Male
Country
Bahamas
It's a bit of both. She was lucky that the most dangerous opponent decided to take a nap immediately after wiping everyone else out, but it took some level of skill for her to be the only one to survive his attack.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
...I keep asking people to stop claiming the 'fact' that Rebecca would have lost against Cavendish if not for Hakuba as a basis for the argument that she was lucky to win. It is not a fact because it did not happen and we will never know what would have happened because what happened happened instead. Using something that didn't happen as an argument in a debate about what did happen is dumb.
Aren't you convoluting the facts here? Saying she won because of plot is basically saying it happened because the story went that way regardless of her skill. This is just a roundabout way of saying she got lucky without actually admitting it. What I see as "dumb" is people actually thinking that plot armor is an actual skill that can be attributed to a character just so they don't have to say that circumstances played a large part in the progression of the story.
 

Spam286

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2009
Messages
174
Reaction score
56
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Aren't you convoluting the facts here? Saying she won because of plot is basically saying it happened because the story went that way regardless of her skill. This is just a roundabout way of saying she got lucky without actually admitting it. What I see as "dumb" is people actually thinking that plot armor is an actual skill that can be attributed to a character just so they don't have to say that circumstances played a large part in the progression of the story.
You have misread my argument. I'm saying that I don't think it's reasonable to assume Cavendish would have beaten Rebecca if not for Hakuba and so using that as an argument to conclude that Rebecca's win was lucky doesn't work. You might disagree with that, but I'm bored of people taking it as given when it didn't happen so we can't know.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
You have misread my argument. I'm saying that I don't think it's reasonable to assume Cavendish would have beaten Rebecca if not for Hakuba and so using that as an argument to conclude that Rebecca's win was lucky doesn't work. You might disagree with that, but I'm bored of people taking it as given when it didn't happen so we can't know.
Don't get me wrong :^_^ With all due respect, you're argument is irrelevant to the actual question that is in the topic of the thread. It doesn't matter if Rebecca would've won or lost based on something that didn't happen (Cavendish not staying asleep). The question is if her win was based on luck or skill or both.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with being of the opinion of either or both but its kinda insulting to a person's intelligence when someone says their opinion is backed by manga as fact while another's isn't simply by saying the testimony of Character X is canon and the testimony of Character Y doesn't count. This is just bias based on subjective reasoning.

IF: there's no way to say that she could have lost if Cavendish didn't stay asleep,
THEN (by the same logic): there's no way to say that she could have won if Cavendish woke up.

so what you said here:

...I'm saying that I don't think it's reasonable to assume Cavendish would have beaten Rebecca if not for Hakuba...
doesn't really hold up as an argument either if by the same breath you say:

It is not a fact because it did not happen and we will never know what would have happened because what happened happened instead.
Saying that just because something that was possible didn't happen, and therefore discussing that possibility is dumb is just a way to shut down debate without having to seriously consider that possibility even simply for the sake of discussion.
 

Spam286

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2009
Messages
174
Reaction score
56
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Don't get me wrong :^_^ With all due respect, you're argument is irrelevant to the actual question that is in the topic of the thread. It doesn't matter if Rebecca would've won or lost based on something that didn't happen (Cavendish not staying asleep). The question is if her win was based on luck or skill or both.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with being of the opinion of either or both but its kinda insulting to a person's intelligence when someone says their opinion is backed by manga as fact while another's isn't simply by saying the testimony of Character X is canon and the testimony of Character Y doesn't count. This is just bias based on subjective reasoning.

IF: there's no way to say that she could have lost if Cavendish didn't stay asleep,
THEN (by the same logic): there's no way to say that she could have won if Cavendish woke up.

so what you said here:



doesn't really hold up as an argument either if by the same breath you say:



Saying that just because something that was possible didn't happen, and therefore discussing that possibility is dumb is just a way to shut down debate without having to seriously consider that possibility even simply for the sake of discussion.
I'm not trying to shut down discussion, just pointing out that it isn't a fact that Rebecca would have lost. If people actually wanted to debate it they would maybe suggest why they think she would have, but they haven't been doing that. New people are just arriving to throw in the exact same argument based on the exact same presupposition. Hence why I'm getting bored of it.

My issue is that people are talking as if they know things that they can't possibly know because they didn't happen.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
My issue is that people are talking as if they know things that they can't possibly know because they didn't happen.
I agree with that and it goes both ways. But I think you're still not addressing the main issue here. It doesn't matter if she "would have" won or not or how it "could have" happened. The actual fact is that she DID win and the question is if she won because of skill, luck, or both. Saying that she won and it doesn't matter if she could have won or lost if X or Y did or didn't happen is irrelevant. Instead, based on what actually DID happen, would you say it was purely skill? purely luck? or both? That is what really matters. :)
 

Spam286

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2009
Messages
174
Reaction score
56
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
I agree with that and it goes both ways. But I think you're still not addressing the main issue here. It doesn't matter if she "would have" won or not or how it "could have" happened. The actual fact is that she DID win and the question is if she won because of skill, luck, or both. Saying that she won and it doesn't matter if she could have won or lost if X or Y did or didn't happen is irrelevant. Instead, based on what actually DID happen, would you say it was purely skill? purely luck? or both? That is what really matters. :)
Skill. She dodged Hakuba and was the only one that did. Sabo said it wasn't luck, Doflamingo said it was, but Sabo's comment is backed up by the panels where we see Rebecca notice Hakuba and move. Doflamingo's comment isn't backed up by anything. (It could also be argued that Doflamingo has a reason to downplay Rebecca in that scene because he's in the middle of gloating to her granddad, but even if that wasn't the case Sabo's account matches what we actually see far more than Doflamingo's.)

The whole rest of the argument comes in when people say that it was lucky that Hakuba showed up in the first place because otherwise Rebecca didn't stand a chance. That's what I've been arguing against.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Skill. She dodged Hakuba and was the only one that did. Sabo said it wasn't luck
This much I agree with.

...Doflamingo said it was [luck]... Doflamingo's comment isn't backed up by anything. (It could also be argued that Doflamingo has a reason to downplay Rebecca in that scene because he's in the middle of gloating to her granddad, but even if that wasn't the case Sabo's account matches what we actually see far more than Doflamingo's.)
This I take issue with. The whole "Rebecca won because Cavendish was still asleep" IS a possible reason for why Doflamingo attributed her win to luck. Saying he was just trying to gloat is as baseless as saying there is no way to know because of what didn't happen because its also an assumption. The panels also show Rebecca looking at Cavendish sleeping like a baby after she managed to get back up on her feet which lead to her flashback where she tries to make sense of what happened. A person would have to selectively ignore and downplay the actual events shown in the manga to claim this didn't happen.

The whole rest of the argument comes in when people say that it was lucky that Hakuba showed up in the first place because otherwise Rebecca didn't stand a chance. That's what I've been arguing against.
What I've seen most people (who say Rebecca won partly due to luck) claim is that Rebecca was lucky Hacuba/Cavendish stayed asleep after knocking everybody to the ground... not that Hacuba showed up in the first place.

Saying that she survived because of skill and won because of luck (I think) is fairly accurate and consistent with both what "Sabo" said and Doflamingo said.
 

Syphin

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2009
Messages
658
Reaction score
884
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
But surviving in the Block battles = winning. Rebecca's skill allowed her to survive which in turn caused her to win as she survived. Trying to separate skill and luck doesn't really make sense in this situation because it was her skill along with some luck that helped her to win. Rebecca's Block battle works like the other battles in One Piece where skill and luck are intricately linked together.

Rebecca was fortunate the circumstances turned out the way they did, but she didn't merely win just because of luck, it is equally connected to her skill as well.

Rebecca is "lucky" that Cavendish/Hakuba is so "unlucky" and Cavendish/Hakuba is "unlucky" that Rebecca is so "lucky".
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
But surviving in the Block battles = winning. Rebecca's skill allowed her to survive which in turn caused her to win as she survived. Trying to separate skill and luck doesn't really make sense in this situation because it was her skill along with some luck that helped her to win. Rebecca's Block battle works like the other battles in One Piece where skill and luck are intricately linked together.
The two bolded statements you made contradict each other because in one you say she won purely out of skill while in the other you say she won because of both skill and luck. Herein lies the problem... you can't have it both ways (skill alone AND skill & luck). If you admit that luck played a part in her winning then your 1st bolded statement is not accurate.
 

Syphin

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2009
Messages
658
Reaction score
884
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Yeah sorry about that, should have spent some more time checking for inconsistencies. I am not arguing that Rebecca won in the way she did solely through skill because that clearly is against what Oda has conveyed. 'Luck'/fortunate circumstances played a part in her victory, especially in the way it was achieved, along with her skill and speed.

Adjusted the statement I made to reflect my view point more accurately:

Rebecca's skill allowed her to survive which in turn along with fortunate circumstances ending the battle there caused her to win as she survived
 
Last edited:
Top