Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2014] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 5

[Heiji]

Bottom 5:
Soul Catcher(S)
???
???
???
Stealth Symphony
iShoujo

#27:
CP: World Trigger (Big News?!)

-----

The provider isn't sure about the big news for WT...

Soul Catcher(S)
Gintama or Kochi Kame
Gintama or Kochi Kame
Stealth Symphony
iShoujo

 

[Eru13]

Probably a cd drama or novel...

I never thought about a novel, but I think that's probably it, I mean, something similar happened when Soma's novel was announced

 

[Stark700]

Soul Catcher(S)
Gintama or Kochi Kame
Gintama or Kochi Kame
Stealth Symphony
iShoujo

Omgz no Bleach, must be fake.

 

[Virys]

Omgz no Bleach, must be fake.

Lol

Issue #26
Cover & Lead CP: Hinomaru Zumou (New series)
CP: Isobe Isobee Monogatari, Illegal Rare, Bleach

 

[duenneud]

So excited about big news and CP of WT!!

SS or iShoujo will be ended in #27?

 

[vampire killer]

world trigger not in the bottom 5... strange.

 

[calimike]

I bet on CD Drama.

 

[Stark700]

Lol

Issue #26
Cover & Lead CP: Hinomaru Zumou (New series)
CP: Isobe Isobee Monogatari, Illegal Rare, Bleach

Then we must all talk about how Bleach would be in the bottom five if it didn't have a color page or how the color page is wasted on Bleach. Rofl.

Nice that Isobe is getting a color though.
Last colors for it were issue 48 in 2013, double issue 4/5, then 16. I guess it's getting one around every 10 chapters or so.

world trigger not in the bottom 5... strange.

Things got interesting in it though.

 

[taqzer]

world trigger not in the bottom 5... strange.

How so? World Trigger generally isn't in the bottom 5. Though for the most part it is directly above it. Out of the manga that usually make up the bottom 7 or so series World Trigger is the only one that occasionally rises to really high placements, even if its ranks for the past 3 or 4 issues have been near the bottom.

uhhh that Ishoujo rank.... well its still with the second couple maybe ranks increase next week with the 3rd couple's arc starting up. If it's last again next week I think that's the end for it. Still no other cancellations? Cant be certain but I doubt anything else will end right now if nothing ends with issue 27 (completely baseless assumption #dontkillme), unless their is a manga starting up after Hunter x Hunters return issue that is.

 

[vinceled]

WT reminds me the results of the character popularity poll still haven't been released for it lol...

 

[TXC]

That insider sure leaked legit info (not).

 

[WyldViolet]

Bottom 5:
Soul Catcher(S)
Gintama / Kochikame
Kochikame / Gintama
Stealth Symphony
iShoujo

#27:
CP: World Trigger (Big News?!)

-----

The provider isn't sure about the big news for WT...

Shit... iShoujo even below Stealth Symphony? Guess I really do have to relinquish hope for it.
At least Illegal Rare seems to be out of the bottom 5.
And big new for World Trigger? It's a bit too soon for an anime, I'm guessing it will just be a novelization or drama cd.

 

[taqzer]

That insider sure leaked legit info (not).

I'm guessing you're referring to the info Zeromcd posted a while back if so its a little early to be calling the insider out as fake.

６月のハンタとの入れ替えoutは
４月中には決まってるはずだが聞いて無い
でも多分みんなの予想通りステルスかiショウジョ

Literally says that something should be cancelled soon. Zeromcd speculated that with Ishoujo starting a new arc this issue that if something were to end this week it would logically be Stealth Symphony. Never said anything was bound to end this issue or that something couldn't end next issue either. Instead of calling the info out as being fake because of the one thing in the entire post the informer was uncertain about, you should be happy about SS still being in the running to not end. Ishoujo is at this point just as likely to end as Stealth Symphony. The post was made at the beginning of this month and the dude literally says that no decision has been made regarding Ishoujo/SS as of yet, meaning that they might have decided to not end anything at all. That doesn't mean his fake, seeing as he noted that Jump were looking at ending one of the two and at no point did he state that either would end or that Jump would end anything for definite, at all.

 

[TXC]

Shit... iShoujo even below Stealth Symphony? Guess I really do have to relinquish hope for it.
At least Illegal Rare seems to be out of the bottom 5.
And big new for World Trigger? It's a bit too soon for an anime, I'm guessing it will just be a novelization or drama cd.

Ir got cp this week...

---------- Post added at 10:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:49 AM ----------

The info was posted 2 weeks ago, I'm pretty sure jump at the very least decides stuff more than 2 weeks in advance. Should is quite likely of a word, of course I would take it take way, look at the comments made afterwards... Everyone killed ss this week, even that French twitter used the info.

 

[SharkBait]

Bottom 5:
Soul Catcher(S)
Gintama / Kochikame
Kochikame / Gintama
Stealth Symphony
iShoujo

#27:
CP: World Trigger (Big News?!)

-----

The provider isn't sure about the big news for WT...

Is it finally happening for world trigger? Hyped beyond belief right now!

And like predicted last week Stealth Symphony is striking back hard and defying the odds by rising. At this rate it will be out of there next week.

 

[Maxy Barnard]

yes, a rise of one place over another series that's crashed massively is 'striking back hard'

Good gravy, you're just trolling at this point.

 

[SharkBait]

yes, a rise of one place over another series that's crashed massively is 'striking back hard'

Good gravy, you're just trolling at this point.

Considering that it was speculated to be ending in a week, I think any rise is a big accomplishment for it, especially with the writer saying theyre working pretty hard.

 

[taqzer]

WT reminds me the results of the character popularity poll still haven't been released for it lol...

Man if that ends up being the big news, I would feel so trolled.
I'm guessing its a drama cd or novel, an anime would get the cover, or at least I think it would.
61 chapters for World Trigger feels a little to soon for an anime as well. My moneys on it getting an anime announcement shortly after this ongoing invasion arc ends. Would probably do well as a 2 cour, unless this arc carries on for a long while still.

The info was posted 2 weeks ago, I'm pretty sure jump at the very least decides stuff more than 2 weeks in advance. Should is quite likely of a word, of course I would take it take way, look at the comments made afterwards... Everyone killed ss this week, even that French twitter used the info.

My Japanese isn't that great but he says the decision as to which other manga should be cancelled was delayed, as in it should have happened already but hasn't.
That info came out on the 3rd of May, this current issue is for May 26th, That's a decent distance away and like I said it might end with the next issue June 2'nd. I don't see how a manga not ending this week means his information was false seeing as how the new manga are only starting now.

The French twitter used Zeromcd's post regarding the bottom 5, not the post regarding the informers statements, unless their is another twitter post they made that I am unaware of? In regards to everyone killing SS, man, If that were any other new manga and it ranked in the bottom 3/2 every week and for two consecutive weeks it was dead last, everyone and I mean everyone would be saying it was dead already. Why should anyone react differently just because its Stealth Symphony? Dead last in the TOC means your days are numbered, I don't see fault in anyone stating that it would most likely end very soon specially when you consider that new manga were/are entering the mag.

 

[TXC]

Killing it this week, using that insider info is what I meant. Even I did it.
And yeah there were more than one tweet using that leak! And I can't read jp so I'm just using zero translation, yours seems different, with a totally different outcome.

 

[vinceled]

Man if that ends up being the big news, I would feel so trolled.
I'm guessing its a drama cd or novel, an anime would get the cover, or at least I think it would.
61 chapters for World Trigger feels a little to soon for an anime as well. My moneys on it getting an anime announcement shortly after this ongoing invasion arc ends. Would probably do well as a 2 cour, unless this arc carries on for a long while still.

Yeah, I don't think it's an anime, not enough material for now. Not to forget that after Haikyuu and Nisekoi, the next series in line for an anime are most likely Assassination Classroom and Soma. There is also to consider that the series is still a bit "minor" as far as WSJ goes. This could actually be novel or drama cd but the fact the results of the character popularity poll back in ch51 still haven't been announced, that's also likely (maybe not just for that though?)