Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Leoat12]

It may be good, but good is not enough in the magazine current state: many successes and pratically no space for new series. It should be extraordinary to make success and by the conversations, none of them had unanimity regarding quality. Honestly, I don't think that any of them will last more than one year, that's why I'm waiting to start reading. If I didn't read new series before, now I read even less. Less stress and disappointment.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Black clover could be a hit,I think you're understimating it.
There are many elements that can make it a good manga

I really love Tabata's art. His style just works for me. But for me, save for Obata's Art, all four series are better than anything in the last two serial rounds.

 

[xAsum0x]

Im rooting for UBS though I should calm my hype down before I get disappointed

 

[RafaFedKilla]

It may be good, but good is not enough in the magazine current state: many successes and pratically no space for new series. It should be extraordinary to make success and by the conversations, none of them had unanimity regarding quality. Honestly, I don't think that any of them will last more than one year, that's why I'm waiting to start reading. If I didn't read new series before, now I read even less. Less stress and disappointment.

I used to think that way too, but I love watching mangaka grow. Even though we only got 16 chapters of Yoakemono, I'm glad we got at least that. And I definitely see series surviving from this batch.

 

[De La Croissant]

Black clover could be a hit,I think you're understimating it.
There are many elements that can make it a good manga

The elements of the story are great, but (for now) the way they are being used is quite limited, because Tabata doesn't take advantage of any of them (after the first chapter, we had a six-month time skip, and the tournament didn't last more than a blink). It's like Gakkyuu Houtei, if not for the drawings (OTabata's art is wonderful), I think my expectations would be even lower.

 

[Leoat12]

I'm almost sure nobody posted the preview here, so here it is.

 

[Pietro]

I've read the 4th chapter and it seems like it's becoming original BC

 

[susanoo13]

Did anyone read Kagamigami chapter 5 and can share an opinion?

 

[vinceled]

Did anyone read Kagamigami chapter 5 and can share an opinion?

In two words:

Battle Heavy. And I gotta say the characters are ridiculously likeable. I found Mako kinda annoying in ch1 a bit less in ch2 but I find her awesome now.

 

[Asclepius]

better quality cover of Jump Next Vol. 01/2015

 

[Eru13]

664 名無しさんの次レスにご期待下さい＠転載は禁止 sage 2015/03/10(火) 12:17:40.32 ID:53yuGRaT0
17号 新章突入センターＣ
16の順は下から６番に落ちてましたけど

Apparently, Hinomaru is 6th from bottom to top this week and will have center color next week

 

[KageTrigger]

My favorite thing about Cyborg Roggy so far, is Roggy himself. I would literally keep reading the manga just for him, he reminds me a lot of Deadpool from Marvel Comics. The story so far doesn't interest me yet, but Roggy is an entertaining character. I also liked UBS second chapter, and going by the raws of Kagamigami and Black Clover so far I'm still enjoying all 4 series. This round of new series is really good, well to me at least.

 

[trexanh]

Issue 15
One Piece (Cover, Lead Color)
Assassination Classroom - 1st place
Haikyuu - 2nd place
Ultra Battle Satellite (Center Color)
Hinomaru Zumou - 3rd place
Shokugeki no Soma - 4th place
Cyborg Roggy
Boku no Hero Academia (Center Color)
Kagamigami
Gintama -5th place
Isobe Isobee Monogatari (Center Color)
Toriko -6th place
Black Clover
PSI Kusuo Saiki -7th place
Nisekoi -8th place
World Trigger - 9th place
Kochikame -10th place
Bleach -11th place
Takujou no Ageha -12 place
Gakkyuu Hotei -13 place

Excuse me, Is this the ranking of series in WSJ in the last issue? Sr for my poor english

 

[Zeromcd]

267 ：39 ◆7zq1d2q4b2Is ＠転載は禁止：2015/03/10(火) 19:12:06.10 ID:Hwz2t4G40
１６
ドベ
炉義ｲ
法律
w鳥
交番
age
(磯)

上から
案札
排気
鳥
広垢

１７
三周年　排気表紙&巻頭　Ｃカラー相撲　読み切り

Issue #16 Top 4
Assassination Classroom (Lead CP, Cover)
Haikyuu
Toriko
Hero Academia

Issue #16 Bottom 6
Hinomaru Zumo
Rogii
Gakkyu Houtei
World Trigger
Kochikame
Ageha
(Isobe)

Issue #17 Info:
Lead CP/Cover: Haikyuu
CP: Hinomaru Zumo, Oneshot

 

[Leoat12]

One more week without Nisekoi in the bottom. Great.
Toriko has been volatile these days.... The rest was expected, except for Rogii, which I didn't expect to see in the bottom so fast.
World Trigger is suffering in last couple of weeks... If it continues like that, its future will become uncertain.

 

[johannes22a]

There are 4 more series to be ranked in this Toc (Bleach, Gintama, Nisekoi, Soma). Very short one.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

I don't understand why they aren't enjoying World Trigger....

 

[KageTrigger]

Now I am truly worried about World Trigger. I wonder which chapter was ranked, 88 or 89. The Rank Wars arc is really good imo, I really hope it goes up by next week.

 

[Leoat12]

I don't understand why they aren't enjoying World Trigger....

I read until chapter 90 and it really lacks something... I wouldn't consider it interesting enough to vote to it.

 

[SharkBait]

Thsnkfully gakkyu hotei is not dead last.