Games Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - END GAME

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

so demon didnt use his ability....i had no protection....gives me shivers

Well, tata used her ability to block you but she lost at coin flip since you targeted Panda.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Have to say one of the most hilarious day phase was the one were tata almost died, I could have made a tie but I decided to wait, Lala was lurking too, then Frosty came and made Lala lock her vote on someone else .

Well Frosty was hasty and he didn't have a lot of time to play, so I thought he acted on instinct or something D:

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

because its an easy check list for mafias...just doing work for them...no?

Eh, lists also do work for Town. Overall, it's handling the information at hand. I doubt it magically changes anything, but as I said, if people agree with you and don't want lists, they shouldn't do them anymore. I won't be doing them, anyway.

 

[g01]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Wait, I see now that Panda never stole the doctor role from Demon at night 3 despite what he said... ah, god damnit, so much false information from everybody which leads to wrong conclusions...

That made me laugh you know it happend right after lawl

I even pushed him and he was trying to convince me lol

You know almost all of my decisions were useful for townies but you guys never listened me

 

[Aonori]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Wait, I see now that Panda never stole the doctor role from Demon at night 3 despite what he said... ah, god damnit, so much false information from everybody which leads to wrong conclusions...

True, we should have killed inactive tata first lol and go through the least inactive ones to lynch, Demon got so lucky on day 1 damn.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Eh, lists also do work for Town. Overall, it's handling the information at hand. I doubt it magically changes anything, but as I said, if people agree with you and don't want lists, they shouldn't do them anymore. I won't be doing them, anyway.

List help townie more, it's always helpful to just claim your role and be honest, then mafia forced to claim role and they get caught out on the lies. The things that happened in this game are pretty unique.

 

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

True, we should have killed inactive tata first lol and go through the least inactive ones to lynch, Demon got so lucky on day 1 damn.

But without James, you would have lost your Spy early .

Day 2 was the most difficult honestly, there was also a moment Haku randomly challenged tata(and he was right that her role was super important), we could not afford to let her die at role considering the roles we had, not so early at least.

 

[gnut]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Eh, lists also do work for Town. Overall, it's handling the information at hand. I doubt it magically changes anything, but as I said, if people agree with you and don't want lists, they shouldn't do them anymore. I won't be doing them, anyway.

im not demanding it...

 

[jorped]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Well, I dunno, we just played super bad overall, imo.

That seems to be always the case when i am townie.

I need to read a 101 How to be Townie book

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

List help townie more, it's always helpful to just claim your role and be honest, then mafia forced to claim role and they get caught out on the lies. The things that happened in this game are pretty unique.

Hm, not really nowadays, there are too many roles for mafia to bs. But it does help to narrow down the ones that don't understand about the roles they claimed, or how they interact with others.

 

[Aonori]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

List help townie more, it's always helpful to just claim your role and be honest, then mafia forced to claim role and they get caught out on the lies. The things that happened in this game are pretty unique.

Panda and Law were quite unique in the way they showed their "honesty"

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

That seems to be always the case when i am townie.

I need to read a 101 How to be Townie book

I don't think you were a problem. You were obsessed by Greg as I was. Being wrong is super common and athough people are claiming they knew better, that didn't avert the game result or mattered during the game xD

What we had was:
- Two people that fucked up hinting their roles (Zasz and Greg);
- A person that decided to take a gamble that was super risky (Misho);
- A person that decided to lie about the outcome of his night action (Panda);
- A doctor that decided not to protect anyone half of the game (Haku);
- Suggestions that the cowboy should duel someone that could be trolling;
- A fucking perma-absent player (Zasz).

'-'"

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

Hm, not really nowadays, there are too many roles for mafia to bs. But it does help to narrow down the ones that don't understand about the roles they claimed, or how they interact with others.

That's the majority of mafia claims though. And why didn't you go after inactive players like every game?

 

[jorped]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

But without James, you would have lost your Spy early .

Day 2 was the most difficult honestly, there was also a moment Haku randomly challenged tata(and he was right that her role was super important), we could not afford to let her die at role considering the roles we had, not so early at least.

I didn't even know the role she claimed. What surprised me the most is that no one cared to know the time-limit on her and it had to be me questioning it several times, when i didn't even knew the role.

The fact that she wasn't much active didn't help either, because that way we couldn't pressure her to reveal it.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

That's the majority of mafia claims though. And why didn't you go after inactive players like every game?

I was too busy with misleads, as I have been whining about continuously '-'

 

[Aonori]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

I don't see it as trolling, just a really poor decision. See it from his point of view, you guys were screwed, he got blocked and had no results... so he lied framing the person he trusted the less. Had you been mafia it would had been an awesome move... but you weren't.

To people complaining about balance or saying the duels screwed the townies (when the people that got killed by them were mostly ganged by duels, it wasn't completely random)... number wise I sticked to the rules, mafia had a strongman which is pretty useless having an assassin, and they even had an unskilled mafia. The other 3 roles weren't that crazy either, to the point that Demon didn't even use his ability once.

I set a lot of ¨regular townie¨ roles expecting you guys to kill them all (cause that's apparently the meta here, let's lynch the most useless first)... and I wasn't that off. A bit more self-criticism for the horrible play most of you displayed would be appreciated, apparently the town can't win unless it has a ton of roles '-'

It's also fun how everyone knew everything yet you wouldn't kill a single mafia if it wasn't for Frosty. Gratz o/

Hardy just to confirm a thing, as a paranoid detective, would I saw a mafia boss as innocent or guilty

 

[Demonspeed]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

I don't think you were a problem. You were obsessed by Greg as I was. Being wrong is super common and athough people are claiming they knew better, that didn't avert the game result or mattered during the game xD

What we had was:
- Two people that fucked up hinting their roles (Zasz and Greg);
- A person that decided to take a gamble that was super risky (Misho);
- A person that decided to lie about the outcome of his night action (Panda);
- A doctor that decided not to protect anyone half of the game (Haku);
- Suggestions that the cowboy should duel someone that could be trolling;
- A fucking perma-absent player (Zasz).

'-'"

His screw up when lawl was going to investigate him somewhat helped us.

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

night 1 I was scared
night 2 I got blocked
night 3 I suddenly realised that it was ridiculous that Demon revealed himself to be the doctor. I was thinking already that we forcing each othet to reveal too much, even greg was reluctant to reveal hoe status. But this was only during the night phase, couldn't discuss. I figured next day if Demon wasn't killed he would be suspicious. This night I'd probs loot haku as I thought he was a little too quiet. Would have shared thoughts about Demon as well with more proof. Ah well thought ai had more time... sorry :g

Wait, I see now that Panda never stole the doctor role from Demon at night 3 despite what he said... ah, god damnit, so much false information from everybody which leads to wrong conclusions...

thats my explanation, already posted it

still my bad - I had a long term goal in mind, which was framing Demon I suppose, but I waited a phase too long that revealing you're the doc doesn't make sense etc., as well as pointing out that not killing the doctor when you know it doesn't make sense either. Well maybe it does in case it was planned, but I didn't see that.

I did want the hider ability to perhaps survive a little longer, but it turns out that wasn't necessary. Sorry Im this bad at the game lmao

Keep in mind that I was under suspension all the time, mostly because I simply didn't use my ability on day 1.

 

[digitaldude]

One last thought before I go to bed, it's funny how mentors consistently get found out early in the game and die.

 

[Copy Panda]

Re: Mafia Game 46 - Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry - NIGHT 4

That made me laugh you know it happend right after lawl

I even pushed him and he was trying to convince me lol

You know almost all of my decisions were useful for townies but you guys never listened me

you played your role well, through you passive aggression I didnt ae the mafia in you lmao