Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Mammo]

so basically you didn't like because it was faithful to the manga & they didn't turn it into a yaoi bait series

 

[G_I_A]

so basically you didn't like because it was faithful to the manga & they didn't turn it into a yaoi bait series

Exactly. Even so, to make a 12-13 episode series with bones animation... Why not make a blast with production IG or Madhouse? Like what they did with one punch man?

To me it was a stupid idea to go for Bones...

About the anime... I'm not mindblown so far.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

Exactly. Even so, to make a 12-13 episode series with bones animation... Why not make a blast with production IG or Madhouse? Like what they did with one punch man?

To me it was a stupid idea to go for Bones...

About the anime... I'm not mindblown so far.

You need to think do want Stupid fillers or a well adapted anime that doesn't catch up to manga and ends in a original ending?
13 episodes is good for bones, They can barely handle 26 look at Captain Earth and look how bad that was.

Madhouse and Production I.G. are busy with other projects, Bones was the only one available and I won't judge the anime by the first episode lets watch and see.

 

[Xzone]

Also Madhouse is a hit and miss, they had series with a ok animation(Or work in there genious) and Toei tier animation and adaptation(they called MADhouse and BADhouse for a reason), people tend to forget The destruction they make to Neuro or the first arc of HxH because Chimera Ant or Death Note.
And People act like they only will make 12 episodes and they aren't new to knew that they will announce the second cour in a few week in the fall season.
Respect the episode itself, good adaptation and a slow pace because the most emotional moment come in the second half of the first manga chapter, they will adapt the first 18 issues.
And stop talking about anime in the manga news...

I was hoping itd be as good as BLast of Tempest for Bones and at least Owari no Serafu adaptation visual quality.

The only visual quality of Owari was the OP and the Studio Pablo work, the anime itself was a mess....

 

[Nayrael]

You need to think do want Stupid fillers or a well adapted anime that doesn't catch up to manga and ends in a original ending?
13 episodes is good for bones, They can barely handle 26 look at Captain Earth and look how bad that was.

Madhouse and Production I.G. are busy with other projects, Bones was the only one available and I won't judge the anime by the first episode lets watch and see.

Captain Earth is really not one of those shows to base anything on ^_^;
In any case, Bones was chosen because it IS one of better studios and because Bones LOVES Superhero shows (thus Bones likely fought with all they had to get the right to adapt it). Though knowing WSJ, they would not have minded giving the series to Toei or Pierrot either.

 

[Stark700]

How in the world is Ghost Tits successful?

what is wrong with you?

1. this series has a name... show a little bit respect and use it

Again.

 

[TyVip]

Can someone explain to me the power of anime boost ( My Hero Academia) in this case ? And all recent Jump anime too if that's okay ( Haikyuu, Shokugeki, Assassination Classroom, World Trigger)

Happy for the series but:

If i'm an anime only Japanese fan and it's my first time seeing the anime, I would have wait for more episodes , rather than rushing to the store and purchase the manga . I haven't seen the My Hero Academia anime but I did on the series I've mentioned.

 

[Mammo]

think of the anime as a commercial for the manga & you will see that manga works the same as any other product

you see an advertisement for something then you go buy it if you like it, simple as that

e.g: when you go to buy shampoo, you don't need to try it first or when you listen to a song on the radio & buy the album if you like it

btw, you example is invalid, if you buy manga then you're not an "anime only fan"

 

[Bigivelfhq]

Can someone explain to me the power of anime boost ( My Hero Academia) in this case ? And all recent Jump anime too if that's okay ( Haikyuu, Shokugeki, Assassination Classroom, World Trigger)

Happy for the series but:

If i'm an anime only Japanese fan and it's my first time seeing the anime, I would have wait for more episodes , rather than rushing to the store and purchase the manga . I haven't seen the My Hero Academia anime but I did on the series I've mentioned.

A lot of people don't buy a series as soon as it starts being released in manga. They wait for the series to get popular and to get recognition(if the series just dies before that, they didn't expend any money and effort), basically they wait for the anime to get out. Than they watch the first episodes, and if they like it, they then start buying, and this time they have a good number of volumes already released.

There is also people that are hearing of the series for the first time, and when they watch they like it, find out that the series has a manga, and that the manga is way in front of the anime, and so go buy it. The manga is cheap and a different experience.

Note that the manga boost doesn't happen just in the first week, but it keeps up for a long period of time. This shows that there are a ton of people with different purchase times. You have the people that buy things really fast, people that wait for the middle of the anime, and people that wait for it to end, and people that buy after a good time of the anime ending.

 

[SharkBait]

Didnt Assassination Classroom even have one?

 

[chrisbj]

Didnt Assassination Classroom even have one?

It got a small boost with the anime, the bigger boost came from the live action movie, it's getting a second big boost now thanks to the live action sequel

 

[Xzone]

Seeing Shoseki 5 volume of WT still ranking(1,2,12,13,14), I assume that the last and small bost because the anime final but that a surprise.
Here the first day sales of SHieshia series(Not prove anything about the final sales):
1-OP
2-Assclass
3-Boku no hero academia
4-Nisekoi
5-Yu gi oh Arc-V
6-Kinikuman
8-PSI
9-Twintail exorcist
10-Dragon ball Super
11-Dance bu
12-Zumou
13-Samon-kun
14- Karada sagashi
24-Seven Garden
25-Wonder Rabit Girl
26-BnH smash(that spin of)
42- U&i
48-Emperor to isho
72-DJ
199-Contrast 88
201-Buddy Strike
390- Shakunetsu no Takkyuu Musume

 

[Caiops]

Seeing Shoseki 5 volume of WT still ranking(1,2,12,13,14), I assume that the last and small bost because the anime final but that a surprise.
Here the first day sales of SHieshia series(Not prove anything about the final sales):
1-OP
2-Assclass
3-Boku no hero academia
4-Nisekoi
5-Yu gi oh Arc-V
6-Kinikuman
8-PSI
9-Twintail exorcist
10-Dragon ball Super
11-Dance bu
12-Zumou
13-Samon-kun
14- Karada sagashi
24-Seven Garden
25-Wonder Rabit Girl
26-BnH smash(that spin of)
42- U&i
48-Emperor to isho
72-DJ
199-Contrast 88
201-Buddy Strike
390- Shakunetsu no Takkyuu Musume

It seems Bnha didn't get a boost yet. We will see, OPM took 4 or 5 weeks to get a boost.

 

[Lehran]

It seems Bnha didn't get a boost yet. We will see, OPM took 4 or 5 weeks to get a boost.

No, it's already getting a boost. He included only the Shonen Jump volumes that were released this week in that list.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 6, 2016, Original Post Date: Apr 6, 2016 ---

These are the positions for the older BnHA volumes in the April 4th daily ranking:

31. Boku no Hero Academia #1
34. Boku no Hero Academia #2
40. Boku no Hero Academia #7
44. Boku no Hero Academia #3
52. Boku no Hero Academia #4
56. Boku no Hero Academia #5
57. Boku no Hero Academia #6

 

[BlackTriggerX]

Seeing Shoseki 5 volume of WT still ranking(1,2,12,13,14), I assume that the last and small bost because the anime final but that a surprise.

Those chapters were really good i don't think it had something to do with the anime the manga is much better

 

[Koen]

Shouldn't the title have 2016

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Damn, Contrast 88 is dead too....

 

[jagman1x3]

Seeing Shoseki 5 volume of WT still ranking(1,2,12,13,14), I assume that the last and small bost because the anime final but that a surprise.
Here the first day sales of SHieshia series(Not prove anything about the final sales):
1-OP
2-Assclass
3-Boku no hero academia
4-Nisekoi
5-Yu gi oh Arc-V
6-Kinikuman
8-PSI
9-Twintail exorcist
10-Dragon ball Super
11-Dance bu
12-Zumou
13-Samon-kun
14- Karada sagashi
24-Seven Garden
25-Wonder Rabit Girl
26-BnH smash(that spin of)
42- U&i
48-Emperor to isho
72-DJ
199-Contrast 88
201-Buddy Strike
390- Shakunetsu no Takkyuu Musume

I wonder if someone is really regretting greenlighting that Shakunetsu anime right about now.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

Shouldn't the title have 2016

Nice to see someone using the image I made as a sig

 

[Asclepius]

Nice to see someone using the image I made as a sig

It's a forum glitch after the migration of database.
Members that haven't rehosted or reuploaded their signs to MH will show images of the ones that did it.
I see my sign on him, but not on you, for example.