Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

M3J

MH Senpai
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
48,828
Reaction score
17,292
Gender
Male
Country
Akatsuki
what percent of power did Edo Tensei Serena have? Seems like it could have been under half, but we know that Serena was nowhere close to his potential, if Gildarts is telling the truth.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
Natsu has the ability to eat every attack that Jackal threw at him.
This isn't a matter of Natsu's eating Jackal's attacks, it's a matter of them affecting him if they land, and those explosions were landing some serious damage, a town based explosion would have seriously affected Natsu.
Even Wendy and Lucy admitted that those explosions were too much for Natsu to handle, that already shows that if the town exploded, everyone there would have died.
Jackal didn't let Natsu beat on him
Considering the fact that Jackal spent a good portion of the fight trying to talk to Natsu instead of actually engaging him in actual combat, it's pretty obvious that Jackal was pretty much taking it lightly.

but that would have only meant it would have taken Natsu longer to get back up.
Getting back up...from unconsciousness? Dude Natsu was completely knocked out from those explosions, Jackal was effectively the winner
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
This isn't a matter of Natsu's eating Jackal's attacks, it's a matter of them affecting him if they land, and those explosions were landing some serious damage, a town based explosion would have seriously affected Natsu.
Even Wendy and Lucy admitted that those explosions were too much for Natsu to handle, that already shows that if the town exploded, everyone there would have died.

Considering the fact that Jackal spent a good portion of the fight trying to talk to Natsu instead of actually engaging him in actual combat, it's pretty obvious that Jackal was pretty much taking it lightly.


Getting back up...from unconsciousness? Dude Natsu was completely knocked out from those explosions, Jackal was effectively the winner
First of all, there are 2 different types of explosions here. The first is the type of explosions that Jackal throws at his targets. These ones can be tanked the same way any other nuke can be tanked. The second is the explosion that comes when Jackal touches you. He gives you curse markings, and turns your body itself into a bomb. Natsu has never received any damage from an explosion that Jackal threw at Natsu, and Natsu has never received any damage from the explosions of Jackal's etherious form punches. The only time Natsu gets damage by Jackal is when he touches him, and doesn't eat the explosions. Which means the only chance Jackal has of dealing any damage to Natsu is reliant on Natsu touching him, and forgetting to eat. When Wendy says that those explosions are too much for Natsu to handle, she is referring to the last one that Natsu forgot to eat. The only reason Natsu was even damaged by this explosion afterwards was because he forgot to eat it.

Natsu only "lost to Jackal" the first time around because he didn't know about Jackal's power, and hadn't figure out how to eat it. In a rematch, Natsu has the option to simply not touch Jackal. If Natsu uses an LFD roar on Jackal, he could do the same amount of damage to Jackal as LFD Firing Hammer did. If that isn't enough, he can pick up a slab or rock and smash Jackal over the head repeatedly like he did against Franmalth. Or he can use the LFD Secret art that he used against Tempesta. Natsu has options to handling Jackal. Even if he does brawl with Jackal, he can avoid taking damage if he simply remembers to eat the explosions from the places where he gets cursed. On the other hand, Jackal's entire approach to victory is reliant on Natsu touching him, and then forgetting to eat the curse markings. Jackal can't dodge Natsu's attacks very efficiently. He can't block the incoming force of any of Natsu's attacks. The long distance explosions he throws at Natsu do no damage, and can be eaten. The explosions from the punches in his Etherious form were all blocked. Jackal simply can't keep up with Natsu when it comes to actual combat prowess.

Lastly, Natsu didn't even go all out against Jackal. Natsu later went on to use an LFD roar against Franmalth, an LFD secret art against Tempesta, another LFD Firing Hammer against Mard Geer, and then enter Dragon Force where he used another Dragon Slaying Secret art.
 
Last edited:

Woodenstool

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
897
Reaction score
408
Country
United States
Actually that's unknown. Both could have the same power. Are you really going to say that Gildarts back then was stronger than Irene now when Gildarts himself said Serena might've been able to truly fight and possibly win at full power—back then? And Irene has shown to be greatly above Gildarts and Serena. She actually pushed Acnologia back and dodged the small nuke he dropped while Gildarts got blitzed without any Magic being used—same for Serena.

Honestly, your brain functions must be permanently on low-power if you're making connections like this and acting as if they're facts,
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

That's a one-liner.
--- Double Post Merged, ---

Gildarts is by no means August level. The most he has shown was using a finisher that knocked out a Historia that was not even remotely at full-power. I really don't get why people are hyping him up this much.

August casually nuked Natsu and co. and Natsu wasn't even able to negate the whole attack—even though he could eat it.
Gildarts casually busted a mountain, something that August nuke wasn't even the size of. Gildarts has casual mountain busting punches and flash speed feats. Combine those two and August and Irene get blitz. And Irene dodged an attack that could be seen from a mile away. She didn't move to another position instantly like Gildarts did. Gildarts said he fought the black dragon while Irene 'fought' Acnologia. All she did was teleport him after pushing him back two feet. Natsu and the dragon slayers moved him in Dragon form a lot more bud.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
The only reason Natsu was even damaged by this explosion afterwards was because he forgot to eat it.
That doesn't change anything tbh, Natsu already figured out the trick to eat it when he came to fight Jackal the second time
The only reason that Natsu didn't eat the explosions, is that he was too occupied beating up Jackal's Etherious form and he didn't have time to react to the Curse Markings. Also do you honestly think he would have eaten the explosions on his legs? His hands are one thing, but he wouldn't be able to eat the explosions on his legs, and we know he kicked Jackal in his Etherious form.
Natsu didn't forget to eat anything, he simply couldn't since he was occupied with beating Jackal, and at the end of the day, those explosions were still powerful enough to knock him out
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
That doesn't change anything tbh, Natsu already figured out the trick to eat it when he came to fight Jackal the second time
The only reason that Natsu didn't eat the explosions, is that he was too occupied beating up Jackal's Etherious form and he didn't have time to react to the Curse Markings. Also do you honestly think he would have eaten the explosions on his legs? His hands are one thing, but he wouldn't be able to eat the explosions on his legs, and we know he kicked Jackal in his Etherious form.
Natsu didn't forget to eat anything, he simply couldn't since he was occupied with beating Jackal, and at the end of the day, those explosions were still powerful enough to knock him out
Natsu had already beaten Jackal at that point, so no he wasn't occupied. Also, it takes quite a while for Jackal's curse markings to kick in. Also, even if he ate the explosions from the hands he would have cut down the damage by two-thirds. Also, this series of explosions didn't knock him out. The first series did, but Natsu touched Jackal way more times.

But let's assume that Natsu simply didn't have the reaction time to eat it. That still doesn't change the fact that Natsu has a whole arsenal of attacks that doesn't require him to touch Jackal, that would do just as much damage to Jackal as LFD Iron Hammer did or more. In a rematch between the two, Natsu wouldn't even have to touch Jackal.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
he can pick up a slab or rock and smash Jackal over the head repeatedly like he did against Franmalth.
Yeah because Jackal won't just make the rock explode immediately it touches him:-_- Kinda reaching there now man
If Natsu uses an LFD roar on Jackal, he could do the same amount of damage to Jackal as LFD Firing Hammer did.
Fully powered Jackal? No, it won't take him out, why are you downplaying Jackal's durability like this?The fact that Natsu had to resort to using LFD as a finishing move and not outright use it in the middle of the fight like he did with Mard Geer already shows that Jackal has amazing durability, plus he can easily just blow away the roar, he uses explosions to defend and guard against magic
In a rematch, Natsu has the option to simply not touch Jackal.
Yes, and have all his long range attacks negated, yes? Jackal would easily defend against long range attacks
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Yeah because Jackal won't just make the rock explode immediately it touches him:-_- Kinda reaching there now man
No, he won't, because he doesn't even make Natsu explode after immediately touching him. Plus, Natsu can always lift another rock.

Fully powered Jackal? No, it won't take him out, why are you downplaying Jackal's durability like this?The fact that Natsu had to resort to using LFD as a finishing move and not outright use it in the middle of the fight like he did with Mard Geer already shows that Jackal has amazing durability, plus he can easily just blow away the roar, he uses explosions to defend and guard against magic
Natsu used LFD Iron Hammer against Jackal because that was all he needed to use against Jackal. Natsu used the exact same attack he used against Jackal that he used against Mard Geer, and then later went on to use Dragon Force and another dragon slaying secret art. That just goes to show you that LFD Firing Hammer isn't by any means an exhaustive move on Natsu's part. Something like LFD roar would easily do just as much damage as LFD Firing Hammer. LFD Firing Hammer isn't even Natsu's strongest LFD attack. Crimson Lotus Exploding Lightning Blade is.
In the Tartarus arc, Natsu can use an LFD roar, an LFD secret art, an LFD Firing Hammer, and then enter dragon force & use another secret art before he finally runs out of magic power. Jackal is ready to suicide bomb after realizing he can't win in open combat after a single LFD Firing Hammer. Jackal doesn't have amazing durability, even among the 9 demon gates. Someone like Tempesta or Torafusa is easily more durable.

Yes, and have all his long range attacks negated, yes? Jackal would easily defend against long range attacks
Huge difference between Wendy's and Lucy's attacks and Natsu's LFD roar. Besides, just think about it. Jackal is blowing up Wendy's winds with an explosion. How is adding an explosion in the middle of a ball of fire and lightning going to negate it? If anything, adding an explosion to the roar is only going to make it stronger. Jackal would literally be adding to the heat. Base Natsu's roar can completely engulf DF Rogue's roar, and DF Rogue's roar is more impressive than base Wendy's roar. Right off the bat, there's no reason to assume that what Jackal did is impressive at all.
 
Last edited:

BluePegasus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2015
Messages
1,818
Reaction score
5,128
Gender
Male
Country
Netherlands
Natsu wasn't stronger than Jackal during the Tartaros arc at all. Saying he is is just like saying he can solo Jacob.

Exactly what could Natsu have done if Wendy wasn't there to save him? What would've happened if Happy didn't save Natsu from Jackal's suicide spell? Yeah, he would've been a dead man if he didn't receive support on the way. It's just a fact, accept the truth :cookiehand
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Natsu wasn't stronger than Jackal during the Tartaros arc at all and he probably isn't now either. Saying he is is just like saying he could solo Jacob.

Exactly what could Natsu have done if Wendy wasn't there to save him? What would've happened if Happy didn't save Natsu from Jackal's suicide spell? Yeah, he would've been a dead man if he didn't receive support on the way. It's just a fact, accept the truth :cookiehand
Well, the same persons who says Natsu can't solo Jacob also says that current Natsu isn't stronger than Jackal. Pick your roll.

Had Wendy not been there, Natsu would have taken longer to get back up and then do everything that he did to Jackal later. You act like he would have died had Wendy not been there. Wendy was there to heal some of his injuries. Wendy has never shown the ability to completely heal someone, and Natsu has been knocked out before. Had Happy not flown him away, he survived it with less injuries than Happy got. Happy was engulfed by the explosion, and we can see where he was burnt.

Now it's my turn for a question: What would have happened if Natsu decided to use LFD roar against Jackal from the beggining?
 
Last edited:

sharkai

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2016
Messages
2,061
Reaction score
1,112
Age
36
Country
United States
Zeref and Acno are out of this picture cause they are 400 years old and for all we know they're still young so they can train and improve nonstop, then they're definetely gonna be above 20 year-old mages particularly when 1 year training here boosts you by A LOT.

So, now that you mention it, it's true that the spriggan 12 were trained by Zeref himself so it may be natural that they're above Ishgar's mightiest; but then August seems to have learnt everything from books and experience or this is just my feeling; I mean he was stated to have more knowledge on magic than even Zeref himself so I don't think someone can teach someone who knows more than you. Then again I think: if August being a wise elderly could become this powerful on his own, why couldn't characters like Makarov?

Also we're splitting hairs here, spriggans, other than their hax which may've well been taught by Zeref, they've got immense MP and for all we know this is within the realm of human acquisition/limits. Therefore, I don't understand how it can be that a 30 year old woman has massively more MP than Ishgar's strongest, God Serena, and ultra massively more than the second Ishgar's strongest, Hyberion (ofc he's not the second strongest but you knwo what I mean, title wise).

Yes Glidartz says so, he says "I always wanted to see which one of us would be the last man standing, when you were at your full power" so this proves it could go eitherway, they're likely equals. As for whether Glidartz can match Ajeel or Wahl we just need to follow Glidartz, Laxus and Erza's portrayal, Glidartz > Laxus > Erza, this is a pattern that has been true from the beginning and could still apply now. Laxus > Wahl and Wahl = Ajeel so Glidartz >> Wahl/Ajeel. If you don't like portrayal let's take a look at hype: last chapter stated Glidartz is the strongest Fairy.
Think about it.
Why are only those two 400 years old and no one else. Zeref got some help. Aconologia didn't get any help. Statically speaking, someone should have appeared in so many generations to match aconologia. But that didn't happen. Same can be said about August and Serena.
As for mp. I think zeref actually had something to do with most of springgans mp.
Mp wise all springgans are above gildarts and laxus, and have at least Serena level mp. Don't think that can happen naturally.

Gildarts said he wondered who was stronger. He didn't need to meet the strongest ws, to think that. He just could have easily wondered whether he could take the strongest.
I wouldn't put too much emphasis on that statement. Gildarts might not be strongest anymore.
 

~Charging Lightning~

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
837
Reaction score
4,594
Age
29
Country
United States
Lmao, RIP Neinheart. The fanbase has come to an agreement that he's one of the weakest Spriggans.

The Tartarus arc Natsu vs Jackal debate is complicated. If neither of them have no info then Jackal wins. If they do have info on each other then Natsu wins. If we're talking about who's stronger overall then Natsu would take it. He has way better battle prowesses than Jackal overall.
Natsu wasn't stronger than Jackal during the Tartaros arc at all and he probably isn't now either. Saying he is is just like saying he could solo Jacob.

Exactly what could Natsu have done if Wendy wasn't there to save him? What would've happened if Happy didn't save Natsu from Jackal's suicide spell? Yeah, he would've been a dead man if he didn't receive support on the way. It's just a fact, accept the truth :cookiehand
And what would've happned if Porlyusica didn't save Laxus from Tempesta's posion? Yeah, he also would have been a dead man. In other words with your logic one could say that Tempesta is stronger than Laxus despite him getting one shot.

I hope your joking when you say that current Natsu is probably weaker than Jackal...
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
Wendy has never shown the ability to completely heal someone,
Uh what? She healed Natsu and his scarf completely on Tenrou Island after his fight with Zancrow, Wendy has healed completely, she healed Erza's poisoned arm against Cobra in Oracion Seis and many other examples
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I hope your joking when you say that current Natsu is probably weaker than Jackal...
He means Tartaros arc fam, current Natsu is obviously stronger but in Tartaros he was weaker, he couldn't take any of the 9 Demon Gates one on one
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
Natsu wasn't stronger than Jackal during the Tartaros arc at all. Saying he is is just like saying he can solo Jacob.

Exactly what could Natsu have done if Wendy wasn't there to save him? What would've happened if Happy didn't save Natsu from Jackal's suicide spell? Yeah, he would've been a dead man if he didn't receive support on the way. It's just a fact, accept the truth :cookiehand
If Natsu had known about Jackals curse from the beginning he never would have gotten knocked out in the first place. He would have just eaten the explosion and he would have been alright. The only reason he got knocked out was because he was taken by surprise and that he knew nothing about the bomb curse prior to that moment.

Suicide attacks shouldn't be considered when we're talking about power rankings. By that logic Gray would be at the very top with Iced Shell.
 

~Charging Lightning~

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
837
Reaction score
4,594
Age
29
Country
United States
He means Tartaros arc fam, current Natsu is obviously stronger but in Tartaros he was weaker, he couldn't take any of the 9 Demon Gates one on one
Natsu wasn't stronger than Jackal during the Tartaros arc at all and he probably isn't now either. Saying he is is just like saying he could solo Jacob.
He said "and he probably isn't NOW either". That's what I was responding to. When I look back at his post now it seems like he edited that part out (which probably means that he was joking).
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Uh what? She healed Natsu and his scarf completely on Tenrou Island after his fight with Zancrow, Wendy has healed completely, she healed Erza's poisoned arm against Cobra in Oracion Seis and many other examples
Natsu still had injuries after healing against Jackal. He still had injuries after healing against Zancrow as well, and Wendy didn't even end up healing him. She just purified his scarf. Removing poison isn't exactly the same thing as healing all injuries. I've never seen Wendy heal someone to the point where they were without a single injury in the same way Zeref can heal himself. Even if she had and I missed it, the most important thing is that she certainly didn't do so for Natsu.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
Gildarts casually busted a mountain, something that August nuke wasn't even the size of.
But it was.

Gildarts has casual mountain busting punches and flash speed feats.
Tartaros Glidartz casually busted a mountain, doesn't mean he can bust mountains casually as in, an array of mountain busting punches.

Combine those two and August and Irene get blitz.


And Irene dodged an attack that could be seen from a mile away.
So, you're Mashima to tell us about that move mechanisms... could it be seen from a mile away, or from 1759 meters?

She didn't move to another position instantly like Gildarts did.
That was not even shown in the main Fairy Tail manga but on a spinoff, plus you're comparing PRE TENROU Glidartz to Irene...
:coolstory

Gildarts said he fought the black dragon while Irene 'fought' Acnologia.
Glidartz didn't even fight, he didn't even blink and he was ripped off. Irene did fight him though. Also, comparing pre tenrou Glidartz to Irene after the massive power inflation... :epicfacepalm

All she did was teleport him after pushing him back two feet. Natsu and the dragon slayers moved him in Dragon form a lot more bud.
That wasn't even canon

 

~Charging Lightning~

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
837
Reaction score
4,594
Age
29
Country
United States
@Emperor Spriggan: Also, I forgot to mention this , but I disagree that Natsu was weaker than Jackal and couldn't defeat any of the nine demon gates one on one. Just because he didn't defeat any of them one on one doesn't mean that he couldn't have. The outcome of a battle doesn't always determine who's stronger. There are certain factors that you have to look at.

-In the Natsu vs Jackal fight Natsu had no intel. If he did then the fight would have been over with Natsu not being nearly as damaged as he was in the manga.
-In the Natsu and Lucy vs Franmalth fight Natsu again had no intel. If he did then he wouldn't have given Franmalth a crap load of his LFD power to absorb. Instead he would've used a huge boulder to begin with. To be fair to Franmalth though, if Natsu didn't have boulders or hard objects to use on Franmalth then he would lose.
-In the Natsu vs Tempesta fight Torafusa interrupted and trapped him and Gajeel in his water. If not for the interuption, Natsu would have most likely won since we saw that he was dominating the fight once he entered LFD mode.

However, I actually like that Hiro didn't let Natsu solo any of the demon gates. It's better writing imo.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
Now it's my turn for a question: What would have happened if Natsu decided to use LFD roar against Jackal from the beggining?
Uh, he'd obviously move out of the way? That or use Explosive Helix to blow it away, or the town level explosion he used when he first encountered Natsu and Lucy in Michello's house...
Lightning is weak against fire, and Jackal's fire would blow away Natsu's due to it being more
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,423
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Uh, he'd obviously move out of the way? That or use Explosive Helix to blow it away, or the town level explosion he used when he first encountered Natsu and Lucy in Michello's house...
Lightning is weak against fire, and Jackal's fire would blow away Natsu's due to it being more
The same way he moved out of the way of Natsu's other attacks? Keep in mind that the roar I showed was from prior to Natsu receiving second origin. Natsu's roar at the Tartarus arc would have been more powerful, and was indeed shown to be much wider.

Just because an attack has large AOE, doesn't mean it's stronger. Jackal's explosions in his etherious form would have been stronger than the ones in his base form, and the ones in his etherious form were blocked by base Natsu. Natsu should have no problem overpowering Jackal's explosions with an LFD strike. If Jackal really thought he could have taken Natsu in his base form, he wouldn't have been trembling out of fear.

Also, where are you going with this "lightning is weak to fire"? LFD doesn't just have lightning. It also has fire. Moreover, by your logic, Jackal would overpower Laxus' attacks as well.
 
Top