Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
From the Yakuma 18? Yagdo Rigora is the same as Ikusutsanagi

Um, because Tenrou enemies haven't shown any sign of growth other than Ultear? There's no indication that BlueNote was stronger than he was 8 years ago.
And all the current characters are stronger than their Tenrou selves? It isn't such a hard thing to grasp
From the Yakuma 18? Yagdo Rigora is the same as Ikusutsanagi

Um, because Tenrou enemies haven't shown any sign of growth other than Ultear? There's no indication that BlueNote was stronger than he was 8 years ago.
And all the current characters are stronger than their Tenrou selves? It isn't such a hard thing to grasp
She only used a Yagdo Rigora spell, it's not like she actually summoned the god himself.

What a flawed argument. Romeo's stronger than his Tenrou self. Does that mean he can oneshot Bluenote too?
 

Static

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Mar 18, 2016
Messages
5,918
Reaction score
10,237
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
Because like your argument against Laxus vs Wahl, he pulls victories out of his ass? Base Natsu couldn't do much against Lessio in the guild hall then he magically one shots Neinhart? If you want to use the asspull argument against Red Lightning then you have to carry it all the way mang, no half hearted arguments
Natsu two-shotted an ENHANCED Neinhart, not a restricted one. Irene made Neinhart MORE POWERFUL Simple as that, that alone proves Natsu is Spriggan tier.
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
Because like your argument against Laxus vs Wahl, he pulls victories out of his ass? Base Natsu couldn't do much against Lessio in the guild hall then he magically one shots Neinhart? If you want to use the asspull argument against Red Lightning then you have to carry it all the way mang, no half hearted arguments
He couldnt do much against Lessio because he was holding back tremendously. If he had gone FDKM from the beginning who knows how things would have turned out.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
I seriously don't remember Minerva SUMMONING Yagdo Rigora. She has only used spells.

Correct me if I'm wrong, my memory is a bit hazy.
The god literally appears next to her.
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
The god literally appears next to her.
That's just a visual effect, it's not representative of what's actually going on. It's like when Natsu uses a spell and Igneel shows up in the background. Does that mean he summons Igneel?
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
What a flawed argument. Romeo's stronger than his Tenrou self. Does that mean he can oneshot Bluenote too?
WTF LMAO Romeo wasn't in Tenrou...are you seriously going to use this argument?
I meant all the characters that were on the island itself, hence the use of Tenrou enemies, a.k.a Grimoire Heart, which, surprise suprise, BlueNote was in!
Try again
He couldnt do much against Lessio because he was holding back tremendously. If he had gone FDKM from the beginning who knows how things would have turned out.
Um, that doesn't change anything, I'm using Base Natsu as the template here because he was in base in the Guild Hall, and also when he fought Neinhart.
Also, there seems to be a grave misunderstanding here, I'm not discussing whether Natsu is S12 level or not, because quite frankly I don't care, I'm just telling you that his feats aren't as impressive as you guys want to make them sound.
Natsu two-shotted an ENHANCED Neinhart, not a restricted one. Irene made Neinhart MORE POWERFUL Simple as that, that alone proves Natsu is Spriggan tier.
Did I ever say he wasn't S12 tier?
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
WTF LMAO Romeo wasn't in Tenrou...are you seriously going to use this argument?
I meant all the characters that were on the island itself, hence the use of Tenrou enemies, a.k.a Grimoire Heart, which, surprise suprise, BlueNote was in!
Try again

Um, that doesn't change anything, I'm using Base Natsu as the template here because he was in base in the Guild Hall, and also when he fought Neinhart.
Also, there seems to be a grave misunderstanding here, I'm not discussing whether Natsu is S12 level or not, because quite frankly I don't care, I'm just telling you that his feats aren't as impressive as you guys want to make them sound.

Did I ever say he wasn't S12 tier?
Who cares if Romeo was on Tenrou or not? What does that even matter? When people refer to Tenrou they aren't talking about the island itself, they're referring to the time period.

Are you telling me that had Romeo actually physically been on Tenrou at the time, you would consider him to be able to oneshot Bluenote now? Sorry man but your logic is completely flawed.

Did I ever say you thought Natsu wasn't Spriggan tier?
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Hit hundreds of fodder, so now Neinhart will summon fodders as meatshields? Let's use Occam's Razor here please, assuming doesn't go too far in things like this.
No. Hundreds of people. The AoE doesn't change.
FDK roar should do just as much damage as demolition fist.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Anyone in the current timeline can replicate this feat, it isn't as impressive as you make it sound

He took out one, which had no effect on GMG Erza and Kagura, again, not impressive

Igneel's power=/= Natsu's power. Not his own feats

Because he has Fire Resistance? That's like giving credit to Gray for resisting Invel's insta freeze
Given how hard of a time Erza had Historia like Azuma, I highly doubt it. Wendy hasn't done anything that suggests she could oneshot Bluenote, much less do it whilst carrying Chelia in one arm.

Ikusatsunagi's feats dwarfed Yagdo Rigora's.

I do give Gray credit for resisting insta freeze, difference being Natsu negated August's attack to the point where it allowed Lucy and Happy (presumably Mest as well) to survive it.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
Am I supposed to assume that had Romeo actually physically been on Tenrou at the time, you would consider him to be able to oneshot Bluenote?
Jesus man, you're really splitting hairs with this argument, my original point was that BlueNote wasn't stronger than his Tenrou self, and everyone else was stronger than their Tenrou selves, so anyone from the current time period could take him on..period.
You then bring up Romeo who has no bearing in this conversation as if to prove something, then discard him in your next statement...okay, I'll ask you a question now, proof of why Romeo is stronger than his Tenrou counterpart? Burden of proof is on you now
 

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
Jesus man, you're really splitting hairs with this argument, my original point was that BlueNote wasn't stronger than his Tenrou self, and everyone else was stronger than their Tenrou selves, so anyone from the current time period could take him on..period.
You then bring up Romeo who has no bearing in this conversation as if to prove something, then discard him in your next statement...okay, I'll ask you a question now, proof of why Romeo is stronger than his Tenrou counterpart? Burden of proof is on you now
Yes I'm well aware that that was your original point. Im saying that your logic makes no sense.

Of course Romeo has a bearing in this conversation. If you truly believe that ANYONE who's improved from their Tenrou selves can take on Bluenote, why would that not apply to Romeo?

Well logically we can assume that Romeo's improved a little bit. It doesn't have to be much, it doesn't even have to be that noticeable, but as long as he's improved even the tiniest bit then your argument applies to him as well.
 

Hermit

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
6,560
Reaction score
24,727
Age
31
Country
Mozambique
The AoE doesn't change.
AOE=/=Damage
Natsu used the FDK roar on the Black Carpet who even Lisanna fought, we haven't seen him use it on any opponent worthy of significance so you can't just assume it has the same damage as FDK Demolition Fist
Given how hard of a time Erza had Historia like Azuma, I highly doubt it.
Because she wasn't at full health? Plus she was being ganged up on, in a one on one she completely destroys Azuma
Wendy hasn't done anything that suggests she could oneshot Bluenote
Uh, her DF attacks? She was able to toss around the largest member of the Nine Demon Gates in Tartaros and destroy him plus FACE, so BlueNote really couldn't stand all those attacks
much less do it whilst carrying Chelia in one arm.
Okay, how is this relevant to the argument? Semantics much?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
we can assume
Assumptions have no bearing in this argument, come talk to me when you have proof from the manga that Romeo is stronger than he was in Tenrou
Bye
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
It can only be disabled once the victim dies. And if you're still not convinced, then why didn't Juvia use her water body to escape it?

Exactly what is Natsu's body heat going to do about Transport? Natsu would be teleported to another dimension even before he enters FDKM.

Weakness can't be countered in a solo fight. If necessary Wall will create bots who use Dispell Magic.

Neinhart isn't stronger than his historias, that's nonsense. His own combat feats are not even more impressive than Base Wendy's.

Bloodman will use Tenchi Kaimei and Natsu won't even be able to use a spell. This isn't even debatable.

Natsu ain't going to destroy Sandworld. Show me a spell of Natsu which has an AoE as high as Magnolia.

Still not convinced. Natsu isn't going to beat a single Spriggan.



You can call me biased for saying Natsu isn't Spriggan tier but you didn't show me any evidence that he is LOL.

Laxus, Jellal and Gray are proven Spriggan tier because they soloed one who wasn't holding back..



He took out restricted Spriggans, yes. So he is portrayed to be restricted Spriggan tier.



Scroll up and see my proof. Or just read the flawless post of @Takuan.



UNBIASED HE SAID.
1) Another exaggeration by Invel. Ice Lock can obviously be disabled before the victim dies. Neither Juvia nor Gray are actualy dead. Weakness bots themselves are fairly weak.
2) Even with a weakness bot present, Natsu can still brute force them. He can pick up a giant rock and smash them like he did to Franmalth, whom was immune to magic itself.
3) Neinhart literally said that this power surpasses the limits of his own magic. Neinharts winds can cut up Brandish and Natsu. Wendy's feats aren't even as impressive as Lucy's. You would have me believe that Neinhart is weaker than base Wendy when Brandish was taken aback by how strong he became?
4) Maybe back during the Tartarus arc. However, now Natsu's body heat are capable of evaporating a lake. Tenchi-Kami would get overwhelmed by an actual FDK spell.
5) Natsu doesn't have to destroy sand world. If Ajeel is standing anywhere Natsu in the radius of a city, Natsu can just blast the area around him. Though to be fair, Natsu can probably burn up a decent raidus within sand world to see the immediate area around him.

Between you and me, we both know who is more biased here. I've seen the stuff you say on discord. In any case, it is massively biased to say that Jellal is a Spriggan tier while Natsu is not. It's not like Jellal fought with any of the Historia is either. Even Simon's historia was taken out by Kagura. There's simply no way around this.

Jacob might have been holding back in the initial stages against Natsu, but Natsu definitely was holding back against Jacob. It evens out. Neinhart wasn't holding back against Natsu. His Historia's were preoccupied, but Neinhart was prepared to go after Erza - and Irene enchanted him to be capable of doing that without his Historia. I have already responded to the points Takuan made in a post above. I'll quote it here.
Lucy didn't counter transport. Lucy reversed it, but it wasn't as if Lucy stripped him of his abilities to cast it. Happy stopped transport by getting in between Jacob's hands. Unless you believe Happy is uber fast and this feat can't be replicated by any character just rushing at Jacob, this is all that it would take to stop Jacob from casting transport. This is probably why Jacob hasn't simply transported Mirajane yet. Natsu's body heat was capable of making Jacob recoil in pain, and can potentially prevent Jacob from being in position to cast transport long enough to deliver an attack. This effectively makes the victor of the battle whomever makes the first move. Obviously if Jacob wanted to, he can use stealth and assassinate Natsu. However, Jacob can do that to practically anyone. You can even use Jacob's abilities of stealth and transport to take down someone like Dimaria. To use these abilities to downplay Natsu's attack power is disingenuous.

Irene's enchantment boosted Neinhart's power beyond that of the limits of his own magic. Brandish was surprised that he was now immune to how strong he was, and wondered how strong Irene made him. Neinhart was probably stronger than any of his Historia individually, especially because his Spriggan Historia were probably a shell of what they were. I consider the total sum of all of Neinhart's historia to be equivalent to 1 Spriggan. Would Neinhart have done better against Natsu if he had some meatshields in the way? Yes, conceivably. However, attacks like FDK roar can hit hundreds of people at a time. Neinhart is getting hit.
 
Last edited:

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
Hit hundreds of fodder, so now Neinhart will summon fodders as meatshields? Let's use Occam's Razor here please, assuming doesn't go too far in things like this.
Ah yes, the ol' "It's weak because it was used on fodder" argument, yet Demolition Fist (another FDK spell) can oneshot spriggans. To say that Natsu's FDK Roar can't achieve a similar result as Demolition Fist would be saying that FDK Roar is vastly inferior to it, despite them being in the same class of spells.

You're clearly in denial here mang. Neinhart was restricted because the three Historia Spriggans he summoned AFFECTED his magical output. Since he used Historia of Corpses at its full potential, he wasn't able to use it against Natsu during their fight thus he had to use his secondary magic. So Neinhart WAS restricted and you can deny it what you want, but it's just a solid fact.

And if you're really that blind to understand, I'll give you the evidence you want so badly.

undefined


Courtesy of AstonishingSpiderman from the FT subreddit.

Did you seriously said Natsu can burn through Ice Lock with his body heat? Do you even understand the capabilities of Ice Lock?

It can only be disabled once the victim dies. And if you're still not convinced, then why didn't Juvia use her water body to escape it?
NLF, unless you believe that Invel is the strongest being in the verse.

Exactly what is Natsu's body heat going to do about Transport? Natsu would be teleported to another dimension even before he enters FDKM.
His body heat isn't going to affect Transport, it's going to affect Jacob and if Mirajane's cleavage can prevent the guy from casting transport, I highly doubt that Natsu's body heat (which can be raised really quickly and can make him recoil) will fail.

Weakness can't be countered in a solo fight. If necessary Wall will create bots who use Dispell Magic.
Again with the NLF. Does this mean that Wahl is stronger than human Acnologia?

Bloodman will use Tenchi Kaimei and Natsu won't even be able to use a spell. This isn't even debatable.
So because Tartaros Natsu couldn't ignite his fire while submerged in Tenchi Kaimei, that means that current Natsu, who can passively evaporate a lake, can't as well?

Natsu ain't going to destroy Sandworld. Show me a spell of Natsu which has an AoE as high as Magnolia.
Sand World wouldn't make a difference if Natsu just blasts the immediate area with a large AoE spell.
BluePegasus, I honestly thought that after chapter 500 you'd finally admit that Natsu is spriggan tier. The guy twoshotted an amped up spriggan and amazed Brandish with his power (she even stated that he was a threat to them) yet you still vehemently believe that he isn't. Your baism is starting to reach new heights man.
 
Last edited:

Boomburst

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
945
Reaction score
1,872
Country
United States
AOE=/=Damage
Natsu used the FDK roar on the Black Carpet who even Lisanna fought, we haven't seen him use it on any opponent worthy of significance so you can't just assume it has the same damage as FDK Demolition Fist

Because she wasn't at full health? Plus she was being ganged up on, in a one on one she completely destroys Azuma

Uh, her DF attacks? She was able to toss around the largest member of the Nine Demon Gates in Tartaros and destroy him plus FACE, so BlueNote really couldn't stand all those attacks

Okay, how is this relevant to the argument? Semantics much?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Assumptions have no bearing in this argument, come talk to me when you have proof from the manga that Romeo is stronger than he was in Tenrou
Bye
What a pathetic excuse. Do you realize how ridiculous you sound? Are you telling me that if I provide proof that Romeo improved then you'll admit he can take on Bluenote?

I was about to edit my original post to include the following but I guess I'll put it here.

Romeo's Tenrou self wasn't even able to use magic. After the seven year time skip he could use magic. Therefore he's improved since his Tenrou self. Your move.
 

Axiomus

Mangahelper
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
6,526
Reaction score
11,422
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
AOE=/=Damage
Natsu used the FDK roar on the Black Carpet who even Lisanna fought, we haven't seen him use it on any opponent worthy of significance so you can't just assume it has the same damage as FDK Demolition Fist

Because she wasn't at full health? Plus she was being ganged up on, in a one on one she completely destroys Azuma

Uh, her DF attacks? She was able to toss around the largest member of the Nine Demon Gates in Tartaros and destroy him plus FACE, so BlueNote really couldn't stand all those attacks

Okay, how is this relevant to the argument? Semantics much?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Assumptions have no bearing in this argument, come talk to me when you have proof from the manga that Romeo is stronger than he was in Tenrou
Bye
Lisanna didn't take down hundreds of people in one attack. FDK roar has the AoE capable of hitting a bunch of people at once, and should be no weaker than other FDK attacks like demolition fist. Or at least the flames should. It should be like the same difference between iron fist and a regular roar. Either way, it should deal more damage than a basic punch. A basic punch was what it took to take down Neinhart.

If Erza was capable of oneshotting Bluenote with the same ease as Natsu did, it wouldn't have mattered.

Bluenote > Ezel. Ezel is around Jackal's level at best. Ezel isn't even that large compared to some of the random monsters in this series. Of course being able to carry Chelia is relevant. Bluenote is a gravity mage. Natsu was able to lift Chelia up from Bluenote's gravity, and negate Bluenote's attempt to crush him by punching the ground with his other arm. Wendy couldn't even move. Even if she does better in Dragon Force, I very much doubt she can oneshot him - much less do it while carrying someone else.
 
Last edited:

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India
@Axiomus beat me in posting the image.Anyway Neinhart clearly says in the image that his Historia Magic will never reach this level.He is stronger than what he can naturally be(courtesy Neinhart himself).Whatever he lost his energy in creating the 3 Historias was filled by Irene and also recieved a bonus.Suppose if Neinhart's natural powerlevel is 9000 but after being enhanced it reached 11000. @BluePegasus even people who don't like Natsu accept that he is Spriggan level.And Gray and Natsu was always potrayed to be equal.So you are accepting Gray but not Natsu.How?Dislike maybe.
 

Takuan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
1,839
Reaction score
7,564
Age
33
Country
France
@Emperor Spriggan Damn dude xD
I love you man, but aren't you a bit on your nerves lately? Your posts are kinda aggressive and i'm not sure i agree with everything :/
I read only your argument with @Daniel9dsi and i'm afraid, i agree with him...
Let's just drop it here though, you both agree with the fact that Natsu is Spriggan level. That's all that matters and that's the main point everything stemmed from anyway.
 

BluePegasus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2015
Messages
1,818
Reaction score
5,128
Gender
Male
Country
Netherlands
1) Ice Lock can obviously be disabled before the victim dies. Proof? Neither Juvia nor Gray are actualy dead.
That's because Juvia saved Gray from the death with her Blood Transfusion Magic. Are you really going to keep up ignoring manga facts?

2) Weakness bots themselves are fairly weak. Even with a weakness bot present, Natsu can still brute force them. He can pick up a giant rock and smash them like he did to Franmalth, whom was immune to magic itself.
So I guess Natsu can defeat Wall without using magic? Do you actually know what you sound like now?

3) Yes, he is. Neinhart literally said that this power surpasses the limits of his own magic. Neinharts winds can cut up Brandish and Dimaria. Wendy's feats aren't even as impressive as Lucy's.
Yeah just ignore my whole argument, what a debating skills.

So according to you Neinhart's Wind Magic is > Historia of Corpses?

4) Natsu's body heat (no flames required) are capable of evaporating a lake. Tenchi-Kami would get overwhelmed by an actual FDK spell.
Dude..


5) Natsu doesn't have to destroy sand world. If Ajeel is standing anywhere Natsu in the radius of a city, Natsu can just blast the area around him.
Who says Ajeel is standing in the area where Natsu uses a spell?

@Axiomus @Shoutmon @Lexusflame @atomic_2000 @natsulucy The five of you have no right to call me biased as long as you can't refute the arguments of my statement about Natsu not being a Spriggan tier.

So just stfu.
 

Ice devil slayer

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2016
Messages
1,387
Reaction score
2,534
Age
28
Country
France
Natsu is easily spriggans level..look at how he destroyed jacob and one shotted neinhart(what a weakling..)
 

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India
That's because Juvia saved Gray from the death with her Blood Transfusion Magic. Are you really going to keep up ignoring manga facts?



So I guess Natsu can defeat Wall without using magic? Do you actually know what you sound like now?



Yeah just ignore my whole argument, what a debating skills.

So according to you Neinhart's Wind Magic is > Historia of Corpses?



Dude..




Who says Ajeel is standing in the area where Natsu uses a spell?

@Axiomus @Shoutmon @Lexusflame @atomic_2000 @natsulucy The five of you have no right to call me biased as long as you can't refute the arguments of my statement about Natsu not being a Spriggan tier.

So just stfu.
Neinhart himself says his Historia Magic will never reach this level.It is not said by Axiomus but by Neinhart himself and it is canon.Natsu defeated 2 Spriggans and you still can't accept it.When will you accept.When he oneshots Zeref?Which we know is impossible.
 
Top