Discussion Power/Abilities thread

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
Escanor was told by the kingdom they had to kill Izraf and stop the vampires because they literally killed the holy Knights of Edienberg and took over the land. You cannot call Escanor a murderer for stopping and evil conquestest. By that logic Meliodas is a murderer for killing two of the 10 Comamndments in the past. Also, Rhitta=preferred method for physical attacks. He uses that instead of punching mainly. It doesn't matter how good he is with his magic, Escanor still uses two methods of attack. Even while fighting Estarossa he slashed at his chest then blew him up. Dawn Escanor can still destroy Edienberg while holding Rhitta, he did exactly that and wasn't even serious. The reason he didn't release castle killing magic on Estarossa was because he's not a murderer and wouldn't kill others in his vicinity. And even if it was a one on one, Escanor still would've sensed the combined presence of the other 4 commandments, fighting Estarossa has nothing to do with a singular presence since they were all grouped in. Rhitta may be able to surpress his magic, but it's useless when he get's serious, not to mention he didn't even need Rhitta during the first part because in the end he ended up moving the fight away and he wasn't serious at first. He could've dropped Rhitta and just punched Estarossa for a while if he didn't have full counter.
Yes meliodas is a muderer, he even slain goddess back then. Doesnt matter you kill people for the good for the others but murder is murder unless you kill someone accidentaly while defending yourself. That is a different story. If he drops rhitta , it would be very very hard for him to control the heat without rhitta and its useless to battle if liones gonna get destroyed anyways. Thats why he wielded rhitta even in the air even though after taking serious damage. I have been repeating it for the 3rd time already. Yes even you can say that he didnt release his power like he did in edinburgh cause he cared for his comrades. If he really wanted challenge estarossa like he did to izraf, he would have asked estarossa to deliver his strongest blow to test his might. Boom!!! Back to the point, he didnt have any intention to challenge estarossa. He was there to teach him a lesson that his pride is greater than esta's, avenge the captain and to claim back liones. He got serious when esta used full counter and was taken back. That part when he hit him with cruel sun he was already serious. Nobody destroys an entire lake for the purpose of entertainment. As a knight he had sworn to protect liones from danger and he is fullfilling that responsibility. If he repeat the mistake like he did in edinburgh, he knows merlin is there.....
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Yes meliodas is a muderer, he even slain goddess back then. Doesnt matter you kill people for the good for the others but murder is murder unless you kill someone accidentaly while defending yourself. That is a different story. If he drops rhitta , it would be very very hard for him to control the heat without rhitta and its useless to battle if liones gonna get destroyed anyways. Thats why he wielded rhitta even in the air even though after taking serious damage. I have been repeating it for the 3rd time already. Yes even you can say that he didnt release his power like he did in edinburgh cause he cared for his comrades. If he really wanted challenge estarossa like he did to izraf, he would have asked estarossa to deliver his strongest blow to test his might. Boom!!! Back to the point, he didnt have any intention to challenge estarossa. He was there to teach him a lesson that his pride is greater than esta's, avenge the captain and to claim back liones. He got serious when esta used full counter and was taken back. That part when he hit him with cruel sun he was already serious. Nobody destroys an entire lake for the purpose of entertainment. As a knight he had sworn to protect liones from danger and he is fullfilling that responsibility. If he repeat the mistake like he did in edinburgh, he knows merlin is there.....
Escanor didn't care about avenging meliodas. He was there for a fun fight, he said it himself. And Escanor doesn't just radiate lethal heat 24/7, it happens when he exerts himself, which he wasn't doing in the first part. Also, killing to protect lives isn't murder. If it was, then Meliodas murdered two of the 10 Commandments. Would you call soldiers murderers? And Escanor didn't have to ask Estarossa to release his strongest attack because he knew he got serious. Point of the matter is you're making Escanor sound like he has too much of a dependence on Rhitta when he doesn't. He only needs Rhitta when he gets serious because he cannot control his serious power. If Escanor lost Rhitta during the fight it wouldn't matter because in part 1 he wasn't serious and in part 2 Rhitta became useless. He didn't let go of Rhitta because that's how he fights physically, he prefers it to unarmed combat. He wasn't even thinking about his comarades during the fight, if he was, then Estarossa wouldn't have had to point out the fact that Escanor was about to kill them. Heck even during the fight with Drole and Glox, Rhitta was in some random rock ravine far away from Escanor. The only reason he called Rhitta was to use charge and fire.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
What're you talking about ? Didn't Merlin gain immortality by using Infinity to stop her body from aging ?

The point is Ladylola's theory is out the window at this point, gaining abilities through fanboying just sounds off in my opinion

Estarossa's ability to use FC must be due to it being Hereditery, for all we know Mel might not even be the original user

Doesn't he have FC because of his moral code ? He's not killing unless necessary but it was confirmed he had a change of heart compared to 3000 years ago, powers are a reflection of one's identity/morals

So in my opinion it would make sense for Mel to gain FC after switching sides, Estarossa prob had it first
Merlin gained immortality through infinity. However she gained infinity through her desire to stop time. Merlin is living proof that if you desire a certain power, you can get it. Her theory isn't out the window. It just happens that both your theory and her's are correct. She said that you gain power from desire. This is true as Merlin desired to stop time so she gained immortality. You said that powers were genetic, that is also true as the giants are proof. So no one disproved anyone and this is me speaking as an outside source
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
Escanor didn't care about avenging meliodas. He was there for a fun fight, he said it himself. And Escanor doesn't just radiate lethal heat 24/7, it happens when he exerts himself, which he wasn't doing in the first part. Also, killing to protect lives isn't murder. If it was, then Meliodas murdered two of the 10 Commandments. Would you call soldiers murderers? And Escanor didn't have to ask Estarossa to release his strongest attack because he knew he got serious. Point of the matter is you're making Escanor sound like he has too much of a dependence on Rhitta when he doesn't. He only needs Rhitta when he gets serious because he cannot control his serious power. If Escanor lost Rhitta during the fight it wouldn't matter because in part 1 he wasn't serious and in part 2 Rhitta became useless. He didn't let go of Rhitta because that's how he fights physically, he prefers it to unarmed combat. He wasn't even thinking about his comarades during the fight, if he was, then Estarossa wouldn't have had to point out the fact that Escanor was about to kill them. Heck even during the fight with Drole and Glox, Rhitta was in some random rock ravine far away from Escanor. The only reason he called Rhitta was to use charge and fire.
His charge and fire is nothing compare to cruel sun. Do you think he loves getting blackout by merlin and gowther. He knows well what will happened if he doesnt control himself. Its obvious the main reason he was there to claim back liones. Since he had the opportunity to battle esta why not??? He hit 2 birds with a stone. If he was so interested to battle esta, why wait for a month??? He can always find them in his peak and burn their demon ass off. He never let go of rhitta because he was clearly supressing his heat and he said it he couldnt do it anymore since he was getting closer to peak..... he never let go of rhitta in part 2 either. Even the godesses slain the demon children who belongs to evil clan but they are still considered as murderers arent they???? Its basically murder. If you go against a law to kill someone then its considered murderer. You may even be a soldier but killing is killing, defending is defending.....
 

Eternita

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2016
Messages
1,164
Reaction score
2,258
Country
United Kingdom
Merlin gained immortality through infinity. However she gained infinity through her desire to stop time. Merlin is living proof that if you desire a certain power, you can get it. Her theory isn't out the window. It just happens that both your theory and her's are correct. She said that you gain power from desire. This is true as Merlin desired to stop time so she gained immortality. You said that powers were genetic, that is also true as the giants are proof. So no one disproved anyone and this is me speaking as an outside source
she gained infinity through her desire to stop time..
im sure u dont mean her innate power right? she didnt gain her magic power because she wanted to stop time, we dont know how she got it.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
she gained infinity through her desire to stop time..
im sure u dont mean her innate power right? she didnt gain her magic power because she wanted to stop time, we dont know how she got it.
Infinity is Merlin's innate power. The databook confirmed all innate powers when it came out as those were the only powers listed. Infinity was listed before it even debuted in the manga, and the wiki has it as her innate power aswell
 
Last edited by a moderator:

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
His charge and fire is nothing compare to cruel sun. Do you think he loves getting blackout by merlin and gowther. He knows well what will happened if he doesnt control himself. Its obvious the main reason he was there to claim back liones. Since he had the opportunity to battle esta why not??? He hit 2 birds with a stone. If he was so interested to battle esta, why wait for a month??? He can always find them in his peak and burn their demon ass off. He never let go of rhitta because he was clearly supressing his heat and he said it he couldnt do it anymore since he was getting closer to peak..... he never let go of rhitta in part 2 either. Even the godesses slain the demon children who belongs to evil clan but they are still considered as murderers arent they???? Its basically murder. If you go against a law to kill someone then its considered murderer. You may even be a soldier but killing is killing, defending is defending.....
Escanor doesn't need Rhitta when he's not serious though. Even when the sins went to the beach Escanor spent a full day without Rhitta and everything went well. And Escanor really wasn't in the mood to save the kingdom. He fought Estarossa because he said it was fun, and would've melted Gilthunder had the bad guy himself not told him that. How can Escanor be considered saving the kingdom when he would've melted holy Knights for fun. Sure he was gonna save Liones, but that wasn't his main objective at the moment. And there is a huge difference between murder and killing. The goddesses killed innocents=murder. Escanor killed people that were murdering others=justified killing. He never let go of Rhitta because he likes using Rhitta to fight. Rhitta did not need to repress any sunlight because he wasn't serious. When he's serious Rhitta doesn't even matter, he can still blow up castles with little to no effort. Rhitta doesn't even do a good job half the time. Charge and Fire isn't that good by Escanor standards, Rhitta cannot contain serious Escanor magic. Even if Escanor dropped it, it wouldn't matter because Escanor only releases deadly amounts of light when he's trying. He wasn't trying with Estarossa at first, he said it himself.

Also, there's a contradiction with your claims. You claim that Escanor held onto Rhitta to surpress his magic, but then moments later Escanor whips out a cruel sun that could've killed innocents. If Escanor was using Rhitta to protect others from himself, then why did he bust out a technique that would've killed others, and most importantly he didn't even care to notice or look around.
 

Escanorzoldyck

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2016
Messages
556
Reaction score
419
Country
Holy Britannian Empire
Escanor doesn't need Rhitta when he's not serious though. Even when the sins went to the beach Escanor spent a full day without Rhitta and everything went well. And Escanor really wasn't in the mood to save the kingdom. He fought Estarossa because he said it was fun, and would've melted Gilthunder had the bad guy himself not told him that. How can Escanor be considered saving the kingdom when he would've melted holy Knights for fun. Sure he was gonna save Liones, but that wasn't his main objective at the moment. And there is a huge difference between murder and killing. The goddesses killed innocents=murder. Escanor killed people that were murdering others=justified killing. He never let go of Rhitta because he likes using Rhitta to fight. Rhitta did not need to repress any sunlight because he wasn't serious. When he's serious Rhitta doesn't even matter, he can still blow up castles with little to no effort. Rhitta doesn't even do a good job half the time. Charge and Fire isn't that good by Escanor standards, Rhitta cannot contain serious Escanor magic. Even if Escanor dropped it, it wouldn't matter because Escanor only releases deadly amounts of light when he's trying. He wasn't trying with Estarossa at first, he said it himself.

Also, there's a contradiction with your claims. You claim that Escanor held onto Rhitta to surpress his magic, but then moments later Escanor whips out a cruel sun that could've killed innocents. If Escanor was using Rhitta to protect others from himself, then why did he bust out a technique that would've killed others, and most importantly he didn't even care to notice or look around.
I'm pretty sure everyone from the sins are murderers except maybe mel (but dosent mean he dont kill he just dont kill innocents)
Diane when enraged, she was about to kill everyone (including Elizabeth her "friend")
King and ban pretty much dosent care for every one except their friends and were about to kill guila when she was unconscious
Merlin can kill people if she wants
Gowther is emotionless so....
And do you think escanor the one who's above all would care if someone died by standing next to him?? (except if that someone is a comrade/friend) and dont forget he was burning izraf for about 2-3 hours for no reason he couldve just killed him with one attack
He used rhitta even when he was far from others so he wast using it to not hurt his friends it is just his favorite weapon and he doesn't seem to be a h2h fighter like mel or ban
And imo rhitta is there to absorb the wasted energy and store it
And he fought estarossa bcz
1 he is a threat
2 to have fun bcz why not?
And if he didnt fight him the tc could've killed him at night and since no one could stand to the tc they could've killed merlin
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I'm pretty sure everyone from the sins are murderers except maybe mel (but dosent mean he dont kill he just dont kill innocents)
Diane when enraged, she was about to kill everyone (including Elizabeth her "friend")
King and ban pretty much dosent care for every one except their friends and were about to kill guila when she was unconscious
Merlin can kill people if she wants
Gowther is emotionless so....
And do you think escanor the one who's above all would care if someone died by standing next to him?? (except if that someone is a comrade/friend) and dont forget he was burning izraf for about 2-3 hours for no reason he couldve just killed him with one attack
He used rhitta even when he was far from others so he wast using it to not hurt his friends it is just his favorite weapon and he doesn't seem to be a h2h fighter like mel or ban
And imo rhitta is there to absorb the wasted energy and store it
And he fought estarossa bcz
1 he is a threat
2 to have fun bcz why not?
And if he didnt fight him the tc could've killed him at night and since no one could stand to the tc they could've killed merlin
Majority of the sins have murderous potential, but I wouldn't label their modern selves as murderers. They seem to care for innocent lives to some degree, but they are pretty liberal when it comes to villains. Also I don't think day Escanor's fight with Izraf lasted for 2-3 hours. I'm pretty sure he ran away for the night part, transformed at dawn then simply destroyed him.
 

Escanorzoldyck

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2016
Messages
556
Reaction score
419
Country
Holy Britannian Empire
Majority of the sins have murderous potential, but I wouldn't label their modern selves as murderers. They seem to care for innocent lives to some degree, but they are pretty liberal when it comes to villains. Also I don't think day Escanor's fight with Izraf lasted for 2-3 hours. I'm pretty sure he ran away for the night part, transformed at dawn then simply destroyed him.
That dont seem like dawn escanor to me he looks more like 11:30 escanor
I might be wrong
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
That dont seem like dawn escanor to me he looks more like 11:30 escanor
I might be wrong
It was probably just an inconsistency with Nakaba's art. If it wasn't, then that means Escanor fought Izraf for like 5 hours because he started from immediate dawn.
 

Escanorzoldyck

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2016
Messages
556
Reaction score
419
Country
Holy Britannian Empire
It was probably just an inconsistency with Nakaba's art. If it wasn't, then that means Escanor fought Izraf for like 5 hours because he started from immediate dawn.
He didnt really fight him
They were just starring at each other (a starring contest ?) but yeah it might be just an inconsistency
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
He didnt really fight him
They were just starring at each other (a starring contest ?) but yeah it might be just an inconsistency
Probably. I just re read the chapter and Escanor's height changes a lot. At one point he and the vampire king are the same height and then Escanor is seen staring down at him at another.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Probably. I just re read the chapter and Escanor's height changes a lot. At one point he and the vampire king are the same height and then Escanor is seen staring down at him at another panel that happend a moment after.
 

smokeesid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2009
Messages
687
Reaction score
220
Gender
Male
Country
India
Merlin gained immortality through infinity. However she gained infinity through her desire to stop time. Merlin is living proof that if you desire a certain power, you can get it. Her theory isn't out the window. It just happens that both your theory and her's are correct. She said that you gain power from desire. This is true as Merlin desired to stop time so she gained immortality. You said that powers were genetic, that is also true as the giants are proof. So no one disproved anyone and this is me speaking as an outside source
Grayroad said that stopping time is impossible. Merlin was talking about it so casually that it was so simple and it was stupid that once she worried about the lack of time. No rational person would consider it like that unless he already has a magic power like infinity up in his sleeve

If I had that magic power then I would also consider it stupid to worry about such thing when all I have to do is accumulate magic, learn time stopping spell and cast it.

So due to the way she was saying all that I would say infinity was available to her even before she got the desire to stop time.
 
Last edited:

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Grayroad said that stopping time is impossible. Merlin was talking about it so casually that it was so simple and it was stupid that once she worried about the lack of time. No rational person would consider it like that unless he already has a magic power like infinity up in his sleeve

If I had that magic power then I would also consider it stupid to worry about such thing when all I have to do is accumulate magic, learn time stopping spell and cast it.

So due to the way she was saying all that I would say infinity was available to her even before she got the desire to stop time.
Merlin implies that infinity was gained from her desire to stop time. She's so nonchalant about it because Merlin is the stereotypical calm and collected researcher, and because she is probably very old. She is credited as being the creator of Balor's eye and is stated to have known Meliodas the longest out of all the sins. There isn't any spell to infinity, she just puts it on something and it stops progressing through time. Also we probably shouldn't talk about Merlin's powers here, the post will probably get deleted.
 

smokeesid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2009
Messages
687
Reaction score
220
Gender
Male
Country
India
Merlin implies that infinity was gained from her desire to stop time
I am saying that she doesn't imply that.

. She's so nonchalant about it because Merlin is the stereotypical calm and collected researcher,
Calmness is not related to seriousness or insouciance. A calm person has the capacity to say something seriously as well as lightly
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,829
Reaction score
61,582
Gender
Male
Country
France
Grayroad said that stopping time is impossible. Merlin was talking about it so casually that it was so simple and it was stupid that once she worried about the lack of time. No rational person would consider it like that unless he already has a magic power like infinity up in his sleeve

If I had that magic power then I would also consider it stupid to worry about such thing when all I have to do is accumulate magic, learn time stopping spell and cast it.

So due to the way she was saying all that I would say infinity was available to her even before she got the desire to stop time.
She didn't say it's impossible. She said it requires immense Magic Power. Merlin had enough power to create a spell able to stop her time then, she developed Infinity thanks to her desire to continue her researches long enough. Infinity supports her time stop spell forever.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
Escanor doesn't need Rhitta when he's not serious though. Even when the sins went to the beach Escanor spent a full day without Rhitta and everything went well. And Escanor really wasn't in the mood to save the kingdom. He fought Estarossa because he said it was fun, and would've melted Gilthunder had the bad guy himself not told him that. How can Escanor be considered saving the kingdom when he would've melted holy Knights for fun. Sure he was gonna save Liones, but that wasn't his main objective at the moment. And there is a huge difference between murder and killing. The goddesses killed innocents=murder. Escanor killed people that were murdering others=justified killing. He never let go of Rhitta because he likes using Rhitta to fight. Rhitta did not need to repress any sunlight because he wasn't serious. When he's serious Rhitta doesn't even matter, he can still blow up castles with little to no effort. Rhitta doesn't even do a good job half the time. Charge and Fire isn't that good by Escanor standards, Rhitta cannot contain serious Escanor magic. Even if Escanor dropped it, it wouldn't matter because Escanor only releases deadly amounts of light when he's trying. He wasn't trying with Estarossa at first, he said it himself.

Also, there's a contradiction with your claims. You claim that Escanor held onto Rhitta to surpress his magic, but then moments later Escanor whips out a cruel sun that could've killed innocents. If Escanor was using Rhitta to protect others from himself, then why did he bust out a technique that would've killed others, and most importantly he didn't even care to notice or look around.
The problem is time and he is surrounded by water when he was with his friends. Besides merlin is there to handle things if he get out of control. U dont expect him to take rhitta and swim with it dont you???? Cruel sun is a more specific attack. With my very own eyes i saw only estarossa was damage by it. Others were suffering from its heat. Thats why he turned around and asked ban about the lake to take it somewhere else. I just said it by myself that he uses cruel to get himself to another level instead of rhitta. Did cruel sun wiped out ban and the others??? Where is my contradiction???
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The problem is time and he is surrounded by water when he was with his friends. Besides merlin is there to handle things if he get out of control. U dont expect him to take rhitta and swim with it dont you???? Cruel sun is a more specific attack. With my very own eyes i saw only estarossa was damage by it. Others were suffering from its heat. Thats why he turned around and asked ban about the lake to take it somewhere else. I just said it by myself that he uses cruel to get himself to another level instead of rhitta. Did cruel sun wiped out ban and the others??? Where is my contradiction???
The contradiction is that you say Escanor cared about his comrades though the entirety of the fight, but the fact of the matter is Escanor would've killed them had Estarossa not said anything. And the water wasn't going to save anyone, it completely evaporated around when Escanor was at the beach, but when he was normal everything was good. If Escanor is that much of a crazy powerhouse, then he wouldn't have gone to the beach with the rest of the sins in the first place. Rhitta isn't the much of a necessity to Escanor because it's just too weak for him. It cannot nerf his powers when he gets serious and it's not needed when he isn't serious because he can control his powers if he's calm, it's when he starts trying that he would need it. Also keep in mind Escanor was fine before he even was given Rhitta. He went around saving others from monsters and the only problem was that they were scared of him.
 

smokeesid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2009
Messages
687
Reaction score
220
Gender
Male
Country
India
She didn't say it's impossible. She said it requires immense Magic Power. Merlin had enough power to create a spell able to stop her time then, she developed Infinity thanks to her desire to continue her researches long enough. Infinity supports her time stop spell forever.
There is nothing that supports your assertion. Escanor developed his magic at a very early age without any conscious effort. He is the only example that is given in the manga. It shows that conscious effort is unrelated to developing magic power. If that hadn't been the case then every living human would have desired for something and gained magic power. It would be pretty easy. You would just have to desire strongly and your wish would be granted.

What Grayroad said means that it is practically impossible to sustain that magic for a considerable period of time. That is what I was saying.
 
Top