Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Avok]

Great start for Ole Golazo!

Solid art and amazing panelling. I really hope it survives.

 

[Leoat12]

Oh, it's not like I think PN is perfect, but I trully believe it's more healthier see the good things instead of bad things - the pace, for exemple, I think is a good thing on the series. Neither fast or slow

And besides, internet it's already full of negativism

Correct me if I'm wrong guys, but my vision of this forum is a place where we can make discussions and analysis about the mangas, be it compliments or criticism. Did it become a place where the fandom just worship their favorites series? XD

 

[jagman1x3]

Correct me if I'm wrong guys, but my vision of this forum is a place where we can make discussions and analysis about the mangas, be it compliments or criticism. Did it become a place where the fandom just worship their favorites series? XD

I always assumed the point was to overanalyze tables of contents.

 

[TyVip]

That's true. I saw many people complaining about Nisekoi for 229 chapters and still read it through the end. XD
It is better and healthier when you have complaints, it shows that you are paying attention to the story and thinking while reading. There isn't a perfect manga out there and if you don't have complaints about one, no matter the size of the complaint, something is wrong.

Nope, just Double Arts salty fans, or shippers complain about it.

 

[Leoat12]

I always assumed the point was to overanalyze tables of contents.

This is the reason of this thread, I'm talking about the entire forum. XP
I'm in search for my new favorite manga that will make me worry about the TOC again after Nisekoi ended...

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 29, 2016, Original Post Date: Nov 29, 2016 ---

Nope, just Double Arts salty fans, or shippers.

I didn't understand. Can you rephrase it?

 

[TyVip]

This is the reason of this thread, I'm talking about the entire forum. XP
I'm in search for my new favorite manga that will make me worry about the TOC again after Nisekoi ended...

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 29, 2016, Original Post Date: Nov 29, 2016 ---

I didn't understand. Can you rephrase it?

I mean the only group of people I see complaining about Nisekoi for 229 chapters are Double Arts fans, or shippers.

 

[Silverblade]

Yes, let us generalize the audience and handwave any actual concerns about the series. After all, nobody could be sad and worried to see Komi Naoshi slowly die as a manga artist.

 

[tirakai]

I always saw an interesting mix of complainers for Nisekoi, half of them were in it for the main plot/literal key drama and would complain whenever it was doing comedy slice of life stuff while the other half were in it for the comedy harem side and complained whenever it went into serious mode.

 

[Varus]

I liked the main character a lot but Ole Golazo's first chapter was lacklustre for me, it felt too fast like Moue was trying to jam everything together. I know I will enjoy this manga I'm just praying Japan finds it interesting. A thing that I really loved was that the club manager was a Martian.

 

[Leoat12]

I saw me yelling "golaço!" (that's how it's written in Portuguese) in the last scene, which is a good signal. The manga seemed to me a true sports manga like Haikyuu, so I'm looking forward to the next chapter.

Haikyuu got my interest when the series quoted Brazil men volleyball coach (the best coach of volleyball history btw) and soccer is just the right opportunity to cite some Brazil legends. Pelé was mentioned, which was good. You know, Brazil is not mentioned in mangas that much, inflate your ego some times is not bad. XD

 

[savethecat]

The action panels in Golazo really has me hype for what games could possibly look like

 

[Halloween]

I usually always dislike sports series, but something about Ole Golazo stood out for me. I'm definitely anticipating more.

 

[Newkerzy]

Yes, let us generalize the audience and handwave any actual concerns about the series. After all, nobody could be sad and worried to see Komi Naoshi slowly die as a manga artist.

Pretty much. Dunno if anyone's read the epilogue with the future kids, but Komi notes in his afterword he didn't even want to do rom-com. For someone who was forced into it, it's a pretty decent manga in the end. I'm just hoping they'll give him a chance for another battle manga. It'll be far better than BC for sure.

 

[xAsum0x]

It'll be far better than BC for sure.

the sad reality. This current Black Clover arc has to be the worst arc so far. Almost convinced Tabata cant write an arc to save his life

 

[Leoat12]

Pretty much. Dunno if anyone's read the epilogue with the future kids, but Komi notes in his afterword he didn't even want to do rom-com. For someone who was forced into it, it's a pretty decent manga in the end. I'm just hoping they'll give him a chance for another battle manga. It'll be far better than BC for sure.

He never said such a thing. He said that he took the challenge of writing a genre he was not accustomed with and was able to continue until the end. That's what he said.
Double Arts was pretty much romance as well, not battle shounen.

 

[G_I_A]

Can anybody link ore golaço first chapter?

 

[Doughboy]

I didn't have much issues with Nisekoi or its ending, it wasn't like super amazing but wasn't bad at all. It was just like .... the end lol. It was a harem so it was good enough for a harem ending. It really was the shippers who complained about it the most. If I had to point a flaw it had to be the filler episode-like chapters, which I get cause it was supposed to make it seem like 3 years of high school go by but it had to be like 100 chapters or so that literally nothing to do with the main plot. Tsugumi was the best girl too

After I'm fully caught up with Neverland I'll check out Demon's Plan off the strength of y'all saying it's interesting.

 

[WyldViolet]

the sad reality. This current Black Clover arc has to be the worst arc so far. Almost convinced Tabata cant write an arc to save his life

Really? All of the arcs prior to the castle town invasion were practically unreadable.
Clover is still not anywhere close to good, but Tabata has at least found his footing.

 

[xAsum0x]

Really? All of the arcs prior to the castle town invasion were practically unreadable.
Clover is still not anywhere close to good, but Tabata has at least found his footing.

I don't see a footing after these past 3 arcs. They're basically just invasions with poorly written villians

 

[Kave]

I didn't have much issues with Nisekoi or its ending, it wasn't like super amazing but wasn't bad at all. It was just like .... the end lol. It was a harem so it was good enough for a harem ending. It really was the shippers who complained about it the most. If I had to point a flaw it had to be the filler episode-like chapters, which I get cause it was supposed to make it seem like 3 years of high school go by but it had to be like 100 chapters or so that literally nothing to do with the main plot. Tsugumi was the best girl too

After I'm fully caught up with Neverland I'll check out Demon's Plan off the strength of y'all saying it's interesting.

I enjoyed the slice of life filler-like chapters a lot more than the "main plot"