Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[G_I_A]

Route End looks like something Shueisha can finally build Jump Plus around.

I felt a "Sharkabait" on this comment. But I agree... Definitely a "Route End".

 

[Mammo]

Route End is written by Kaini Nakagawa, he's rookie and his artstyle is pretty amateurish

http://rookie.shonenjump.com/users/1609047349018087143

 

[savethecat]

Route End is written by Kaini Nakagawa, he's rookie and his artstyle is pretty amateurish

http://rookie.shonenjump.com/users/1609047349018087143

Wouldn't say it's amateurish at all. Reminds me a lot of American comic strip art similar to Peanuts and Calvin and Hobbes

 

[Halloween]

Chitoge also confirmed in love with with Raku in chapter 49/50/51. So 46 is a good spot.

As for harem ending

Spoiler

Too bad it's missing

Spoiler: Renge-sama

Can you guys try to sell me on this series, because the excessive fanservice makes me want to cringe.

 

[Mammo]

Wouldn't say it's amateurish at all. Reminds me a lot of American comic strip art similar to Peanuts and Calvin and Hobbes

you're right, I'm an idiot

I found his pixiv which have normally drawn manga and his artstyle is fine

http://www.pixiv.net/member.php?id=15125818

 

[Nakura]

Can you guys try to sell me on this series, because the excessive fanservice makes me want to cringe.

It's just a really fun read, and the MC is actually likable. The amount of best girls also helps.

 

[Halloween]

It's just a really fun read, and the MC is actually likable. The amount of best girls also helps.

Fun how? Is it the fanservice that makes it fun, or something else?

 

[TyVip]

Can you guys try to sell me on this series, because the excessive fanservice makes me want to cringe.

It's (and i'm not kidding)
One Punch Man with fanservice.
Bakuman with fanservice.
Shokugeki no Soma with more fanservice.

and i'm 90% sure in the future there will be
Haikyuu with fanservice.
KnB with fanservice.
Dance-bu with fanservice.
Sports manga in general with fan service.

"Insert a talent here" plus fan service.

If you don't like fan service, you won't like it. Since there are a lots.

Here's a badass image spoiler from chapter 15.

Spoiler

 

[Tanzo]

It's (and i'm not kidding)
One Punch Man with fanservice
Bakuman with fanservice
Shokugeki no Soma with more fanservice

and i'm 90% sure in the future there will be
Haikyuu with fanservice
KnB with fanservice
Sports manga in general with fan service.

"Insert a talent here" plus fan service.

If you don't like fan service, you won't like it. Since there are a lots.

Here's a badass image spoiler from chapter 15.

Spoiler

Some people I've heard enjoy it even if they don't like the fanservice.

For me, the characters, development, and comedy are the best parts. Even if there isn't too much of a "serious" plot (it is mostly SoL) it still is one of my favorite weekly reads now.
Though I'll admit the series didn't really pick up for me until the last chapter of Vol 1/Vol 2.
They partially colored that scene in this week's colored chapter :O

 

[Doughboy]

Can you guys try to sell me on this series, because the excessive fanservice makes me want to cringe.

It's just a fun read like everyone else says. It's a lot of fanservice but the actual characters/story/development is cool and enjoyable. The best part of it that differentiates from regular harems is that the girls rarely attack the MC when he grabs their asses, titis, or both.

 

[Leoat12]

So many things to catch up with...

1) The cover for The Promised Neverland could be better. It reminds me the guys who escaped from prison here in Brazil, took a selfie and posted on Facebook. They were recaptured soon after. XD

2) I liked the cute girl for them first new seris of Jump+. Gonna read. hahaha

 

[Kadir0]

So many things to catch up with...

1) The cover for The Promised Neverland could be better. It reminds me the guys who escaped from prison here in Brazil, took a selfie and posted on Facebook. They were recaptured soon after. XD

Lmao! I guess the artist jinxed it.

 

[Halloween]

It's (and i'm not kidding)
One Punch Man with fanservice.
Bakuman with fanservice.
Shokugeki no Soma with more fanservice.

and i'm 90% sure in the future there will be
Haikyuu with fanservice.
KnB with fanservice.
Dance-bu with fanservice.
Sports manga in general with fan service.

"Insert a talent here" plus fan service.

If you don't like fan service, you won't like it. Since there are a lots.

Here's a badass image spoiler from chapter 15.

Spoiler

One Punch Man with fanservice, eh? Does Yuragi have as much action as OPM?

 

[TyVip]

One Punch Man with fanservice, eh? Does Yuragi have as much action as OPM?

FINE!!

Saitama with hair and his harem full of girls (Not Genos and friends ).

 

[Halloween]

FINE!!

Saitama with hair and his harem full of girls (Not Genos and friends ).

The action? How much action is in it, percentage wise?

 

[TyVip]

The action? How much action is in it, percentage wise?

Probably 10-15% (4-10 chapters, out of 47 currently). So not much. It's a manga that majority of the time it will take place during school. The action is definitely not an important part.

If you decide to read, in the very first chapter, the MC tells us that he can "exorcise" anything with One Punch. Then he shows it as the time when on.

The other manga reference I posted above will come true in mostly comedy chapters. If you want to know how, gotta read it.

The protagonist is also refreshing. He is not indecisive like Raku from Nisekoi or Rito from TLR (don't know if you've read it since you dislike fanservice). The girls don't yell at him for accidental groping.
The art is similar to Shokugeki no Soma because the artist for SnS was an assistant for Miura before

The casts (mostly girls) have good designs, but their some of the characters' personality are by the book standard. You have a clumsy girl, president-counsil, tsundere, etc..

To be honest, the series doesn't distinguish itself from other harem/romcom until chapter 15. I like it since the very first chapter and i'm happy that JPN readers like it too.

 

[Mammo]

guys it's a lost cause, he said he doesn't like excessive fanservice, I don't think there's anything you can say past this point sell him on it, even if he reads it he will probably drop it after reading 4 pages from chapter 1


about, jump plus new manga full list (credit to kaizou_10)
1. Aharen-san wa Hakarenai (by Mizu Asato (author of Denchi-gai no Honya-san)) = January 29th
2. Ao no Flag (by Kaito (author of Cross Manage and Buddy Strike)) = February 1st
3. Route End (by Nakagawa Kaiji) = February 11th
4. Macho Gourmet (by Narita Nariaki) = February 14th
5. Susume! Jump Heppoko Tankentai! (by Sakurai Takeshi author of Jump no Tadashii Tsukurikata!)
6. Ore wo Sukinanowa Omae Dakekayo (comicalization of the light novel; drawn by Itou Yuu)
7. Inochi wo Kaketa Kimi to, Jinsei Saigo no Yume wo Miry (by Welzard (author of Karada Sagashi; story) and Ogura Yuuya (artwork) artist of Navirinth)
8. Shuukyoku Engage (by Etou Toshiji (story) and Miwa Yoshiyuki (artwork) artist of The New Gate manga)

 

[Leoat12]

I have the same problem. I'm just considering reading Yuragi-sou because I like Miura Tadahiro art, but I'm more and more afraid that it will be a waste of time. No matter how fun a manga is, if it has ecchi in every page, I don't enjoy it.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Yuragi is just a fun romcom with ecchi thrown in (that normally adds to the comedy and forces a bit of a laugh). I haven't read many Romances, but to me it's essentially Nisekoi with Ecchi, and a much better male lead. The Ecchi doesn't make or break the series, its just there. There's not much story, but character interactions, developement and comedy are well done. Read the first volume and you'll probably see everything the series has to offer,

 

[shoyoboyo]

BANBA THE MAN once again showing how great he is. Seems like he's gonna make soccer great again (with Trump backing him up lol). Speaking of which, @Mammo you keep mentioning how similar or straight up the same Ole Golazo is to Slam Dunk. What are the similarities? Unfortunately i haven't read slam dunk yet so I can't figure these things out for myself

about demons plan, this chapter is definitely one of the better ones, although it's still not "good" yet, still maybe a 5-6/10. Wonder if it'll last long enough to maybe pick up pace and get better, or it'll just be axed like it's first ranking seems to suggest. honestly wouldn't really miss it that much, would definitely prefer ole surviving over it. Eustass is a cool dude though, as someone said earlier, he should have been the main character. i like his design, especially his hair.