Question The Big Fight With Big Mam

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
The time draws nigh, ladies and gentlemen. We got a taste of it with Brook's brief showdown, but now we're at the point where everyone wants a piece of the emperor.

A personal prediction I made elsewhere involves BM revealing that her information network has even pinpointed that Luffy's straw hat is by far his most valued possession. When he proves invulnerable to her fear-based soul-ripping powers, she will instead decide to stuff Napoleon's soul into Luffy's beloved hat, forcing the two to fight it out for her amusement. Or BM's power's will go wild during what will undoubtedly be the most monstrous tantrum ever, and the straw hat will come to life and fight on Luffy's side against Napoleon. I guess I just want to see a fighting hat at this point; Oda can't just leave that shotgun on the rack.

Speaking of guns, is Capone really just planning on shooting up BM? Even if he stole the sooper special guns/bullets Pudding spoiled to Reiju, there's no way Capone should be able to take down BM, right? Castle Man or not, I've just not seen anything this guy can do that suggests he's capable of killing BM. I'm sure Oda's got something wonderful planned, but eh.

How do you guys think/want the big fight will go down?
 

Aizen

MH Senpai
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2016
Messages
1,469
Reaction score
4,067
Age
32
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I think Big Mom will fight Luffy briefly, but I don't see her going down in this battle. I feel like if Capone's plan were to go perfectly, that would be de-hyping Big Mom a bit. They are in her territory and yet she allows Capone to be the security at the wedding and assassinate her? That would be pretty pathetic, on top of her allowing her Poneglyph to get stolen a second time apparently. I hope she actually puts in some work, and Luffy succeeds in allowing the Vinsmokes to escape but does not bring her operation down. My preference is that there are sacrifices, but OP does not really do this that often so I am not holding my breath on that.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I don't think Capone plans on shooting Big Mom.

Whatever his plan is, it involves Ceasar in some capacity, maybe even hinges on his cooperation. Why go through the trouble of forcing him to join and keep him hidden in plain(ish) sight. I think the fact that we saw the final moments of the cakes creation this past chapter is also important.

Going by Jinbe's description of Capone's methodology, I think they'd try and strike against her first. Whatever his plan is, I don't think it's going to work initially, until, that is, Big Mom goes to open the Tamatebako Box, which will, somehow, put the plan back on track or make it more effective than they initially planned.

Before or during all of this, I think Sanji is going to kiss Pudding, probably surprising her and making every member of the Big Mom Pirates pause, giving The Crew precious time to fix whatever went wrong.

Match Ups will probably be:

Carrot versus Galette
Brook versus Amande
Pedro versus Tamago
Nami versus Mont-d'Or (or vice versa with Chopper)
Chopper versus Opera (or vice versa with Nami)
Jinbe versus Smoothie
Reiju versus Pudding (if no face turn and she isn't Katakuri)
Sanji versus Ichiji, Niji, and Judge or versus Katakuri if Pudding isn't Katakuri
Luffy, Capone, Ceasar, and a bunch of others versus Big Mom
 

plex

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
149
Reaction score
77
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Sanji versus Ichiji, Niji, and Judge or versus Katakuri if Pudding isn't Katakuri
I don't think there'll be a huge fight between Sanji and his brothers/father. After all, he said he wants to save them even if they don't deserve it. Since Big Mom is planning to annihilate all of them I'd say they'll team up and fight together.
 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
Why would Sanji be fighting his brothers? Doesn't make any sense since the real enemy here is Big Mom. Like Jinbei said, they have a common enemy they must defeat, kill each other later.

How exactly this fight will transpire, I'm absolutely clues; there's more than 1 ways to skin a cat dilemma here in my opinion. I'm just certain Luffy will grab the spotlight and defeat her whether or not she's weakened.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I don't think there'll be a huge fight between Sanji and his brothers/father. After all, he said he wants to save them even if they don't deserve it. Since Big Mom is planning to annihilate all of them I'd say they'll team up and fight together.
I don't see Judge and the Brothers going along willingly with Sanji despite him wanting to save their life. And since they are planning to interrupt the wedding, we don't even know if the Vinsmoke will be made aware of Big Mom's plot to kill them. It'll just seem like Sanji and his crew wrecked the wedding and their plans to take over the North Blue.
 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
I don't see Judge and the Brothers going along willingly with Sanji despite him wanting to save their life. And since they are planning to interrupt the wedding, we don't even know if the Vinsmoke will be made aware of Big Mom's plot to kill them. It'll just seem like Sanji and his crew wrecked the wedding and their plans to take over the North Blue.
Sanji and Reiju will likely inform them. Judge is a pragmatist and he's not stupid. If he catches wind about their plans, he'll likely believe it. More so if informed by Reiju. Even Yonji brought up the possibility to Judge and they shrugged it off which implies they can see the possibility of Big Mom's underhandedness and more so if there's evidence. All it takes at this point is travelling to the mirror world to inform them. At this point, it's in their best interest to side with the alliance if they want to survive with their empire intact. Not allying with Big Mom wouldn't be the end of their ambitions; pretty sure Judge said they could pull it off already on their own, but Big Mom as an ally just makes it a much more secure endeavour which implies it's more of a perk than an absolute necessity.
 

Brandish μ

Taking notes
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Global Moderator
Joined
Oct 24, 2015
Messages
10,247
Reaction score
33,682
Gender
Male
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
From a pure stylistic standpoint I'd say Capone will use guns. Well it's just as feasible as any other way tbh - since beating BM in some other fashion seems unlikely. Maybe he has some magic bullet made of sea stone.

A big player in the fight will be the Tamatebako Box. Depending on it's power, it'll either serve as the distraction to commence the hit, or do significant damage for Luffy/Capone/someone to defeat BM.

I'd like to hear Capone's plan before committing here, and the adjustments he'll make with Luffy joining + the Tamatebako. He might have the power to change the schedule of the wedding if they need to (for instance if the Tamatebako was meant to be opened after the Vinsmokes are dead, then maybe Capone can move it forward).

My gut feeling is that BM will be killed by Capone, after the Tamatebako + Luffy do most of the damage. Sanji has to get a good fight here, with 'Vinsmoke genes' powerup. I'd guess he'll get a go at Starch, and fight alongside Ichiji (and maybe the other siblings). Don't know what happens with Smoothie, her legs look good for kicking maybe Jinbe can fight her with fishman karate.
 

Core D. Roy

MH Senpai
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 10, 2006
Messages
7,363
Reaction score
9,272
Age
37
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
I would love it if the Tamatebako bomb was a dud. Or fakes us out for a chapter and then explodes whenever the SHs need their mythical luck to come through in order to escape with at least Reiju/the minks.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Judge is a pragmatist and he's not stupid.
I really want to believe this. Everything we've seen of him so far is leading the reader to believe he's the nazi equivalent of a star high school quarterback always chasing the dragon of glory. Same with BM, we're being led to believe that she's too incompetently insane to effectively run her empire, with most of her losses being conspired by her own offspring and subordinates. And we're being led to believe that Capone is the only incredibly competent actor here, with Jinbei's hype story about how he's infamous for boss killing.

I feel like all of this will be twisted around by the end, and Capone is going to get it the worst. If Kidd got off-paneled and stuffed into a cage so Kaidou could drunkenly belittle him, then Capone should get off just about as bad. Oh! Maybe BM will make him into a new homie if one of her three main ones gets taken out (which seemed to be foreshadowed by Brook injuring Prometheus).
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Now I'm also imagining BM being utterly immune to conventional weapons like blades or bullets. I want a scene of her stopping bullets by turning them into homies as they get close.
 

Eigengrau

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Apr 9, 2015
Messages
3,024
Reaction score
3,040
Gender
Hidden
Country
The Wall
I feel like all of this will be twisted around by the end, and Capone is going to get it the worst. If Kidd got off-paneled and stuffed into a cage so Kaidou could drunkenly belittle him, then Capone should get off just about as bad.
To be fair, Kidd is just a raging, violent enthusiast who simply doesn't give a fuck about anything or anyone. Capone, on the other hand, is a cunning man who actually plans things out. In that aspect, we could even say that they're kinda opposites.

Not saying that Bege can't get his ass kicked when the situation will inevitably go wrong because of X factor(s), but look at it this way: Kidd is so reckless that he somehow lost an arm during the timeskip, and even with an alliance he ended up in a cell just to be mocked, but Capone? He actually made it into a Yonko's special ranks despite having ulterior motives of his own.

Hell, maybe Big Mom planned for all of Bege's rivals to show up at the wedding and gun down Bege and his crew for all we know, but as I see it Bege has more chances of success/escaping due to his personality and how he does things...

Then again you could just throw this argument out of the window by just mentioning Luffy and how everything always works out for him no matter what he does :invalid
 

M3J

MH Senpai
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
48,833
Reaction score
17,298
Gender
Male
Country
Akatsuki
I can see Luffy and the others losing. I mean, it took multiple people to beat Doflamingo, I can't see even Bege, Luffy, Sanji, Jinbei, and the Vinsmokes standing a chance, not easily anyway, especially against the other commanders. Hell, even Luffy couldn't beat Cracker, an underling, by himself. I can see the group retreating, and I hope they do. Though, I don't mind the entire group beating Big Mom, just that Luffy by himself has no right to do it at this point in the story.
 

Hannibal Psyche

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
8,180
Reaction score
9,256
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
I really want to believe this. Everything we've seen of him so far is leading the reader to believe he's the nazi equivalent of a star high school quarterback always chasing the dragon of glory. Same with BM, we're being led to believe that she's too incompetently insane to effectively run her empire, with most of her losses being conspired by her own offspring and subordinates. And we're being led to believe that Capone is the only incredibly competent actor here, with Jinbei's hype story about how he's infamous for boss killing.

I feel like all of this will be twisted around by the end, and Capone is going to get it the worst. If Kidd got off-paneled and stuffed into a cage so Kaidou could drunkenly belittle him, then Capone should get off just about as bad. Oh! Maybe BM will make him into a new homie if one of her three main ones gets taken out (which seemed to be foreshadowed by Brook injuring Prometheus).
I don't really think it's a case of one being stupid; as it were, I'd compare it to a chess match by 2 masters where one just happens to lose due to poor judgement and in the scheme of things, circumstance. Circumstance plays a huge role in the outcome of many things; circumstance can be that 1/100 opportunity for an event to go in the most unlikely direction. This seems to be that point in this arc as it has been in every other.

Let's remember how every other arc has been in the story; it's been a matter of these circumstantial periods that have facilitated in the outcomes we've all come to be acquainted with being the demise and defeats of all the antagonists (as well as having the best situational outcomes based on limitation).

Judge thinks that Big Mom would at best try to kill Sanji in order to manipulate Germa; that in itself shows he's aware that Big Mom is very likely having a card of hers to play.
He's not as naive as being made out:
  • For one, they pointed out they're dealing with Pirates.
  • They even recognise that they need to make sure Pudding is kidnapped in order to coerce Big Mom.
  • And they believe that in the event Sanji is taken hostage to coerce them, he has no value to them which offers them no leverage or need to compromise.
If they were naive, they wouldn't have such a solid plan. Their plan only falls short because they're not aware that Big Mom aims to kill them. Judge and co. aren't as incompetent as made out.

Also, this idea that because Kid got off-panelled equates into SHs failuire doesn't have any correlation or bearing with the outcome of this arc or shouldn't if we look at the Manga progress in terms of consistency. This idea is not contextual.
  • For one, Kid is not the protagonist, Luffy is, and this easily the most undermined fundamental fact especially in a Shounen Manga.
  • Have any of the Supernova defeated a single Shichibukai?
  • How many of them have been tutored by the strongest individuals in the OPverse?
  • Have any of the Supernova slipped into Impel Down and escaped which was unbelieveably pulled off by even Shiki despite being a rival of Whitebeard & Roger?
  • Have any of the Supernova gone into the a war akin to the 'War of the Best' and pulled off an upset? Not only just putting up a great performance, but also accomplishing his goal? Unfortunately, Ace decided by his own will to take on the worst opponent possible and died by his own failure to assess the situation properly.
  • Have any of the Supernova come close to accomplishing anything near what the SHs have?
By this logic, Luffy should absolutely have never escaped Impel Down since Shiki (an Emperor in his own right) was the last person to do that. Fairness of strength and accomplishment was never once portrayed equal between the Supernova at any point during introduction. Luffy was always just that step ahead.
Even if there were 2 Laws in the fight against Joker, the outcome wouldn't have changed - Law's best attacks were rendered powerless. What Law brought to the table was strategy; Luffy brought power.
The case is the same here; Bege has planned for a year or 2 and has brought strategy and Luffy has brought power. I'd suspect Caesar's role would implement a way to weaken Big Mom too, but nonetheless, Luffy's power will once again be reflected. Even the overrated Cracker is reduced to nothing; all it took was one direct attack to defeat him; no truly powerful character should be down from 1 attack.

Another thing is that Kid's defeat, the circumstances around it are unknown. We see Apoo is allied with Kaido, but when exactly did this occur? We don't know for sure and for all we know, he may have already been allied with Kaido before then. Even Hawkins another part of the alliance was unseen in the prison. How do we know they all didn't gang up against Kid as opposed to their apparent alliance taking on Kaido? We really cannot use Kid's imprisonment as basis for the SH's chances of taking out Big Mom.

Everything Luffy has done and achieved has always been against the odds.
  1. The question now is, why is this any different?
  2. And when has there ever been an arc where Luffy didn't have everything in place for an upset? Allies whether common goal or somewhat similar goal?
  3. Presence of convenient abilities to assist that have plot-changing roles?
I think eventually, we're all going to have to come to terms with an implies truth. The Supernova in themselves are irrelevant. They're just devices meant to aid in Luffy's goals inadvertently.
I'm not sure how aware people are, but Luffy is actually a child of prophecy as cliche as that is, so this is not just to do with looking at situations from a rational point of you per se like this is reality, but from the perspective that this is divine guidance which both Whitebeard and Otohime (via JoyBoy's) words have confirmed and plot-power as attributed to all Shounen protagonists naturally.
 
Last edited:

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
734
Reaction score
703
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
I can see Luffy and the others losing. I mean, it took multiple people to beat Doflamingo, I can't see even Bege, Luffy, Sanji, Jinbei, and the Vinsmokes standing a chance, not easily anyway, especially against the other commanders. Hell, even Luffy couldn't beat Cracker, an underling, by himself. I can see the group retreating, and I hope they do. Though, I don't mind the entire group beating Big Mom, just that Luffy by himself has no right to do it at this point in the story.
I feel the same way as you in regard of Luffy's strenght, but you forgot that "Zeff" is pretty much the key of this arc, and by saying this I mean "every single person loved by every single crew member".
They make the biggest mess ever, then they run away like it's all OK... then what?
Soon they'll find out that their actions led to the painful death of their loved ones.

Big Mom is going down one way or another, IMHO at this point it's a fact.
That said, I can't see Luffy beating BM by fighting her alone, even if her three "sons by soul" will be taken on by someone else.

Also, I just love the idea of Luffy's hat fighting BM's hat.
 

M3J

MH Senpai
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Mar 2, 2009
Messages
48,833
Reaction score
17,298
Gender
Male
Country
Akatsuki
I can't see her going down this arc, there's no need to. For all we know, the good guys either find a way to get the soldiers out of Zeff's way, or Zeff and his crew beat up the bad guys. There can also be ways for Big Mom not to go after the loved ones yet, like a challenge or something.
 

TitaniumOxide

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2012
Messages
1,369
Reaction score
1,158
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Twist: pudding unlocks her ability and hear sanji's thoughts so to speak and then instead of frenching she tells mama to watch out. Plan bege is foiled. Plan Luffy begins. Which probably mean no plan.
 

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
734
Reaction score
703
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
So they plan to do literally "the worst thing they could think of" to the poor Big Mom, just right in her face.
I think that they will indeed enrage BM like no one before, but something with the "killing part" will go poopity poo.
And then, there will be absolutely no way to avoid the fight.

Also, have you noticed how Luffy is waaay too happy about this "unluffy-ish" plan, and how he's looking forward to his "great entrance"?

...He's gonna storm in like Leeroy Jenkins to challenge her directly, he's gonna do it, that's what will happen. -.-"
 
Last edited:

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
So, in terms of angering Big Moms:
- The Tamatebako treasure will explode on Big Mom's face during the wedding
- Luffy will ruin the party, odds are he will do something to the cake
- Big Mom won't gain control of the Germa Army
- They will damage Mother Carmel's photo
- Trying to take Big Mom's head for the lulz
 

Zehahaha

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 7, 2009
Messages
8,514
Reaction score
5,754
Gender
Male
Country
Morocco
So, in terms of angering Big Moms:
- The Tamatebako treasure will explode on Big Mom's face during the wedding
- Luffy will ruin the party, odds are he will do something to the cake
- Big Mom won't gain control of the Germa Army
- They will damage Mother Carmel's photo
- Trying to take Big Mom's head for the lulz
More like the Tamatebako will explode, they will damage the photo and launch the gas, which will make BM weak enough for her to be defeated in a straight fight

Calling it here, that mad woman will be defeated in a fight and Luffy will get a powerup (be it a new use for CoC or awakening)
 
Last edited:

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
734
Reaction score
703
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
So, in terms of angering Big Moms:
- The Tamatebako treasure will explode on Big Mom's face during the wedding
- Luffy will ruin the party, odds are he will do something to the cake
- Big Mom won't gain control of the Germa Army
- They will damage Mother Carmel's photo
- Trying to take Big Mom's head for the lulz
We have at least 5 chapters until that happens and I'm already laughing at the idea, really... she'll be even madder than the "maddest version" of Nami. :grin
 

hokageji

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
4,982
Reaction score
3,747
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Also, this idea that because Kid got off-panelled equates into SHs failuire doesn't have any correlation or bearing with the outcome of this arc or shouldn't if we look at the Manga progress in terms of consistency. This idea is not contextual.
  • For one, Kid is not the protagonist, Luffy is, and this easily the most undermined fundamental fact especially in a Shounen Manga.
  • Have any of the Supernova defeated a single Shichibukai?
  • How many of them have been tutored by the strongest individuals in the OPverse?
  • Have any of the Supernova slipped into Impel Down and escaped which was unbelieveably pulled off by even Shiki despite being a rival of Whitebeard & Roger?
  • Have any of the Supernova gone into the a war akin to the 'War of the Best' and pulled off an upset? Not only just putting up a great performance, but also accomplishing his goal? Unfortunately, Ace decided by his own will to take on the worst opponent possible and died by his own failure to assess the situation properly.
  • Have any of the Supernova come close to accomplishing anything near what the SHs have?

We don't know if they fought shichibukai, but they could have beaten a Vice Admiral at some point... about being tutored, maybe Kid was tutored by someone equally strong, like Scopper Gaban,and besides, he might be talented enough himsefl. Also, he is having a similar path as Shanks, both have red hair, both have a facial scar and both are missing an arm. Maybe Kid wants to beat Shanks for some personal goal, just like Luffy does.

Kid lost cos they were caught off guard. They werent expecting to be facing the strongest man alive.... besides, Kidd could've been betrayed by his counterpart supernovas as well...

There isnt enough to count Luffy's victory here other than the plot of course....
 
Top