I really want to believe this. Everything we've seen of him so far is leading the reader to believe he's the nazi equivalent of a star high school quarterback always chasing the dragon of glory. Same with BM, we're being led to believe that she's too incompetently insane to effectively run her empire, with most of her losses being conspired by her own offspring and subordinates. And we're being led to believe that Capone is the only incredibly competent actor here, with Jinbei's hype story about how he's infamous for boss killing.
I feel like all of this will be twisted around by the end, and Capone is going to get it the worst. If Kidd got off-paneled and stuffed into a cage so Kaidou could drunkenly belittle him, then Capone should get off just about as bad. Oh! Maybe BM will make him into a new homie if one of her three main ones gets taken out (which seemed to be foreshadowed by Brook injuring Prometheus).
I don't really think it's a case of one being stupid; as it were, I'd compare it to a chess match by 2 masters where one just happens to lose due to poor judgement and in the scheme of things, circumstance. Circumstance plays a huge role in the outcome of many things; circumstance can be that 1/100 opportunity for an event to go in the most unlikely direction. This seems to be that point in this arc as it has been in every other.
Let's remember how every other arc has been in the story; it's been a matter of these circumstantial periods that have facilitated in the outcomes we've all come to be acquainted with being the demise and defeats of all the antagonists (as well as having the best situational outcomes based on limitation).
Judge thinks that Big Mom would at best try to kill Sanji in order to manipulate Germa; that in itself shows he's aware that Big Mom is very likely having a card of hers to play.
He's not as naive as being made out:
- For one, they pointed out they're dealing with Pirates.
- They even recognise that they need to make sure Pudding is kidnapped in order to coerce Big Mom.
- And they believe that in the event Sanji is taken hostage to coerce them, he has no value to them which offers them no leverage or need to compromise.
If they were naive, they wouldn't have such a solid plan. Their plan only falls short because they're not aware that Big Mom aims to kill them. Judge and co. aren't as incompetent as made out.
Also, this idea that because Kid got off-panelled equates into SHs failuire doesn't have any correlation or bearing with the outcome of this arc or shouldn't if we look at the Manga progress in terms of consistency. This idea is not contextual.
- For one, Kid is not the protagonist, Luffy is, and this easily the most undermined fundamental fact especially in a Shounen Manga.
- Have any of the Supernova defeated a single Shichibukai?
- How many of them have been tutored by the strongest individuals in the OPverse?
- Have any of the Supernova slipped into Impel Down and escaped which was unbelieveably pulled off by even Shiki despite being a rival of Whitebeard & Roger?
- Have any of the Supernova gone into the a war akin to the 'War of the Best' and pulled off an upset? Not only just putting up a great performance, but also accomplishing his goal? Unfortunately, Ace decided by his own will to take on the worst opponent possible and died by his own failure to assess the situation properly.
- Have any of the Supernova come close to accomplishing anything near what the SHs have?
By this logic, Luffy should absolutely have never escaped Impel Down since Shiki (an Emperor in his own right) was the last person to do that. Fairness of strength and accomplishment was never once portrayed equal between the Supernova at any point during introduction. Luffy was always just that step ahead.
Even if there were 2 Laws in the fight against Joker, the outcome wouldn't have changed - Law's best attacks were rendered powerless. What Law brought to the table was strategy; Luffy brought power.
The case is the same here; Bege has planned for a year or 2 and has brought strategy and Luffy has brought power. I'd suspect Caesar's role would implement a way to weaken Big Mom too, but nonetheless, Luffy's power will once again be reflected. Even the overrated Cracker is reduced to nothing; all it took was one direct attack to defeat him; no truly powerful character should be down from 1 attack.
Another thing is that Kid's defeat, the circumstances around it are unknown. We see Apoo is allied with Kaido, but when exactly did this occur? We don't know for sure and for all we know, he may have already been allied with Kaido before then. Even Hawkins another part of the alliance was unseen in the prison. How do we know they all didn't gang up against Kid as opposed to their apparent alliance taking on Kaido? We really cannot use Kid's imprisonment as basis for the SH's chances of taking out Big Mom.
Everything Luffy has done and achieved has always been against the odds.
- The question now is, why is this any different?
- And when has there ever been an arc where Luffy didn't have everything in place for an upset? Allies whether common goal or somewhat similar goal?
- Presence of convenient abilities to assist that have plot-changing roles?
I think eventually, we're all going to have to come to terms with an implies truth. The Supernova in themselves are irrelevant. They're just devices meant to aid in Luffy's goals inadvertently.
I'm not sure how aware people are, but Luffy is actually a child of prophecy as cliche as that is, so this is not just to do with looking at situations from a rational point of you per se like this is reality, but from the perspective that this is divine guidance which both Whitebeard and Otohime (via JoyBoy's) words have confirmed and plot-power as attributed to all Shounen protagonists naturally.