Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[WyldViolet]

1. Neverland
2. Yuragi
3. Kimetsu
4. Spring Weapon
5. Ore Golazo
6. Love Rush
7. Amaglam
8. Demon's Plan
9. THE NEW BLEACH

Didn't read Takuan & Batsu or Boruto.

 

[xAsum0x]

I caught with Kimetsu no Yaiba btw. Not sure what the hype is all about from you guys. The art is preeeetttyyy bad, Tanjirou is pretty basic and uninteresting and so are his companions. Also the comedy is horrendous. The most recent arc was really good though.

As for rankings really its just The Promised Neverland then everything else.

 

[TyVip]

1) Yuragi
2) Neverland
3) Spring Weapon
4) Kimetsu (mainly because I haven't caught up)
5) Love Rush/Ole Golazo (enjoyed enough to read from beginning-end)

6) the rest which I've dropped after 3 chapters, or didn't enjoy

Before Love Rush, I had a 4/4 perfect record of predicting survive series. Love Rush made it a 4/5

 

[Nakura]

1. Kimetsu no Yaiba
2. The Promised Neverland
3. Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san
4. Spring Weapon No. 1
5. Love Rush
6. Ole Golazo
7. Amalgam of Distortion
8. Red Sprite
9. Demon's Plan

Didn't read Takuan.

 

[shoyoboyo]

I see no acklowedgement dude... Just bash.

So you did ignore them, got it. Should have said so from the first place.

 

[G_I_A]

1. The Promised Neverland
2. Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san
3. Ole Golazo
4. Kimetsu no Yaiba

====================== (everything from here on is unbearable)
5. Love Rush
6. Spring Weapon No. 1
7. Amalgam of Distortion
8. Red Sprite
9. Demon's Plan

 

[HIGAN0]

That reminds me, all the new 2016 series besides Spring Weapon have either found their place in the magazine or been cancelled by now. I'm curious how people would rank them, I think my ranking would be

1) Kimetsu
2) Neverland
3) Yuragi
4) Love Rush
5) Demon's Plan
6) Spring Weapon
7) Takuan and Batsu
8) Amalgam
9) Ole Golazo
10) Red Sprite

It's hard to compare Bort with the rest due to it being a naruto sequel, monthly, and it just adapting the movie so far but I guess it'd maybe be 5th or 6th if I had to put it somewhere.

1-Neverland
2-Yaiba
3-Yuragi
4-Spring Weapon No.1
5-Ole Golazo
6-Takuan and Batsu
7-Love Rush
8- Amalgam
9-Demon's Plan
10-Red Sprite

 

[Kave]

Kimetsu
Neverland
Takuan & Batsu
Ole Golazo
Yuragi
Spring Weapon
Boruto
Demon's Plan
Love Rush
Amalgam
Red Sprite

 

[jagman1x3]

Neverland
Takuan
Amalgam
Kimetsu
Spring Weapon
Demon's Plan
Red Sprite
Yuragi
Love Rush
Ole Golazo

Haven't actually read all of them so just based off either what I saw while flipping through to get to the stuff I actually like or if I managed to make my way through one or more chapters before wanting to gouge my eyes out.

 

[Kadir0]

The Promised Neverland
The Promised Neverland
The Promised Neverland
The Promised Neverland

Everything else, i don't remember reading them.

 

[DyanSon]

KnY that's all

 

[Leoat12]

Pleasure isn't the only thing that brings pleasure, For some pain brings it.

It is called masochism and it is something pretty serious.
I only read what I like, manga is for entertainment mainly, discussion is in second place.

By the way, this rant is only possible because of piracy. You wouldn't spend your money in something just to continuously criticize it and don't enjoy it.

 

[jagman1x3]

It is called masochism and it is something pretty serious.
I only read what I like, manga is for entertainment mainly, discussion is in second place.
By the way, this rant is only possible because of piracy. You wouldn't spend your money in something just to continuously criticize it and don't enjoy it.

I buy like three different magazines for literally one series each, the rest of the series I either don't care about or actively dislike.

 

[Leoat12]

I buy like three different magazines for literally one series each, the rest of the series I either don't care about or actively dislike.

You are a rich guy, man... You should switch to volumes.
Also, you buy the magazines to read what you want and that's about it, not to read what you want and to vociferate on the internet about the other things.
I know you don't like 僕が僕であるために from Gangan because you said you were not interested, but you didn't say it was trash and should be cancelled. Honestly, I respect you for keeping your composure. It lacks here...

 

[Avok]

Ole Golazo and then everything else.

 

[Leoat12]

The Promised Neverland and Love Rush were the only ones I read completely or is currently reading, so that's the one I put in my ranking. TPN is obviously the first although I'm going after a cheap way to buy Love Rush instead. hahaha
I have a collection of unfairly cancelled romances in Magico and Koisome Momiji, Love Rush is one more to add. xD

 

[Koi Kage]

Japanese comic ranking March 13-19
8. Haikyu!! (25)
17. Shokugeki no Soma (23)
24. World Trigger (18)
32. One Piece (84)
39.Black Clover (10)


Full list v
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-03-22/japanese-comic-ranking-march-13-19/.113769

 

[WyldViolet]

The Promised Neverland and Love Rush were the only ones I read completely or is currently reading, so that's the one I put in my ranking. TPN is obviously the first although I'm going after a cheap way to buy Love Rush instead. hahaha
I have a collection of unfairly cancelled romances in Magico and Koisome Momiji, Love Rush is one more to add. xD

I miss Magico. The epitome of comfy.
Hoping to see him return in the next few rounds.

 

[Tamil]

Not the biggest Promised Neverland fan, seems like a circle jerk atm. I'll wait for the anime. Definitely KnY is #1 for me. It's nothing out of this world but is promising.

I caught with Kimetsu no Yaiba btw. Not sure what the hype is all about from you guys. The art is preeeetttyyy bad, Tanjirou is pretty basic and uninteresting and so are his companions. Also the comedy is horrendous. The most recent arc was really good though.

As for rankings really its just The Promised Neverland then everything else.

Art is improving. Tanjirou isn't uninteresting as he had some decent development & great backstory. What?! Zenitsu is great, he had a good spotlight during the spider arc. I do agree that Inosuke is pretty uninteresting and annoying at times. He could use more development. It would be funny to see him animated. I want to hear his muffled voice underneath that huge mask of his.

Factoring we're only like 54 chapters in, it's doing very well. Most of KnY's hype comes from it's potential (which could be a hit or miss) & the recent spider arc. The main cast is good too, it's just that Inosuke is slacking.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

What series do you want me to out my curse on? Everyone new series I enjoy is a failure, and those I hate are successful.