Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Dr. Stone first again?
I'm impressed.
It's a shame that Cross Account and Shoodan! Failed.
Jump should know that they had already gotten a new sport manga and a romcom in 2017, why do you want more genres like these again?

 

[TyVip]

More Golden Future Cup One Shots that Viz won't translate.

 

[Koi Kage]

Black Clover isn't ranked this week due to being absent 8 weeks ago

I looked through the chapter 8 weeks ago and there was no little side note on the chapter that stated it was absent from the magazine at that time. I'm not denying that it was absent just I couldn't find that it was.

 

[ChocoBar9]

I looked through the chapter 8 weeks ago and there was no little side note on the chapter that stated it was absent from the magazine at that time. I'm not denying that it was absent just I couldn't find that it was.

Weekly Shonen Jump #31

Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san (Cover, Lead CP)
One Piece
Kimetsu no Yaiba
Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Souma (CP)
Hunter x Hunter
My Hero Academia
The Promised Neverland (CP)
Hinomaru Zumou
Haikyu!!
Dr. Stone (CP)
Cross Account
Omoiyo Todoke ~Butsuri-teki Niwa Todokanai~ (One Shot)
Gintama
Shudan!
Spring Weapon No.01
Robot x Laserbeam
The Disastrous Life of Saiki K.
We Never Learn
Hungry Marie
Isobe Isobee Monogatari ~Ukiyo wa Tsurai yo~

Absent: Black Clover

 

[savethecat]

Shouldn't a new round be starting soon?

 

[TotalEconomist]

Also from Kaizou:

Shounen Jump Issue 41:
Golden Future Cup Entry #2: Joreishi Rentarou no Yakusoku (by Shindou Masaoki)

Shounen Jump Issue 42:
Golden Future Cup Entry #3: Raven Burai (by Kobayashi Eiken)

Shounen Jump Issue 43:
Golden Future Cup Entry #4: Chou Kasoku Ningen Leo (by Matsubara Dai)

Shounen Jump Issue 44:
Golden Future Cup Entry #5: Mahou Shounen X (by Nakama Tadaichi)

Magical Boys X? Count me in!

 

[Leoat12]

Golden Future Cup again, what a huge waste of time...

We Never Learn in 9th is not bad, I hope it stays in the middle and out of peril. Next series batch when?

 

[TotalEconomist]

Golden Future Cup again, what a huge waste of time...

We Never Learn in 9th is not bad, I hope it stays in the middle and out of peril. Next series batch when?

When the decide to behead the Hungry French Princess would be my guess.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Also from Kaizou:

Shounen Jump Issue 41:
Golden Future Cup Entry #2: Joreishi Rentarou no Yakusoku (by Shindou Masaoki)

Shounen Jump Issue 42:
Golden Future Cup Entry #3: Raven Burai (by Kobayashi Eiken)

Shounen Jump Issue 43:
Golden Future Cup Entry #4: Chou Kasoku Ningen Leo (by Matsubara Dai)

Shounen Jump Issue 44:
Golden Future Cup Entry #5: Mahou Shounen X (by Nakama Tadaichi)

I expect a rookie with a manga of the same level as Nurarihyon no Mago (best Golden Future Cup winner in my opinion).

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Another GFC winner not serialized until after the next year`s competition. You can sensor this, but this is just not acceptable for Jump. They really need to start thinking about a new EiC.

 

[razerxs]

They really need to start thinking about a new EiC.

They already got a new one this year.

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 23, 2017, Original Post Date: Aug 23, 2017 ---

Shoseki Ranking for 8/14-20

3 - One Piece 86
11 - Haikyuu 27
35 - Black Clover 12
59 - Kimetsu no Yaiba 7
133 - We Never Learn 2

Neverland backlog in the top 100
MHA backlog in the top 200

 

[Newkerzy]

Weekly Shonen Jump #31

Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san (Cover, Lead CP)
One Piece
Kimetsu no Yaiba
Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Souma (CP)
Hunter x Hunter
My Hero Academia
The Promised Neverland (CP)
Hinomaru Zumou
Haikyu!!
Dr. Stone (CP)
Cross Account
Omoiyo Todoke ~Butsuri-teki Niwa Todokanai~ (One Shot)
Gintama
Shudan!
Spring Weapon No.01
Robot x Laserbeam
The Disastrous Life of Saiki K.
We Never Learn
Hungry Marie
Isobe Isobee Monogatari ~Ukiyo wa Tsurai yo~

Absent: Black Clover

I see nothing on that link. Just a bunch of Russian.

 

[G_I_A]

Is hunter x hunter still being considered unranked, because I think it's be around longer then 8 weeks by now.

Yes it's not ranked since the dark ages.

Dr. Stone first again?
I'm impressed.
It's a shame that Cross Account and Shoodan! Failed.
Jump should know that they had already gotten a new sport manga and a romcom in 2017, why do you want more genres like these again?

Probably they are trying sports manga because of the coming olympics that will be in Japan.

Shouldn't a new round be starting soon?

Probably after the golden future cup

Golden Future Cup again, what a huge waste of time...

We Never Learn in 9th is not bad, I hope it stays in the middle and out of peril. Next series batch when?

You say waste of time... I think it's a gold opportunity to annoy you guys even more... Since you seem to hate series made by them. Remember that we currently have 2 GFC winners being serialized (even though one of them will be canceled).

And come on Leo, it's time for you to recognize Dr. Stone and Black Clover.

 

[Leoat12]

You say waste of time... I think it's a gold opportunity to annoy you guys even more... Since you seem to hate series made by them. Remember that we currently have 2 GFC winners being serialized (even though one of them will be canceled).

And come on Leo, it's time for you to recognize Dr. Stone and Black Clover.

We would like to see good oneshots, believe me, but they are just bad and when any of them are good they change the entire story and mess things up like Hungry Joker. But they are not serialized with the series they won GFC, Hungry Joker was painfully terrible and Beelzebub got some success, but it is not that great either.

I don't know what you are talking about. Who?

 

[UnspokenCoconut]

Re-read Hungry Joker and I think its awful. Why the MC need to keep shouting unnecessary things out of nowhere again?

Speaking of GFC, I do hope they are at least decent enough to read. Still can't forget how horrible all those 2015 entries.

 

[Mammo]

Also from Kaizou:

Shounen Jump Issue 40:
Golden Future Cup Entry #1 Jekyll no Tsukaima (by Ishikawa Kouki)

already competed in the GFC before and lost to Devilyman
this was his oneshot

Shounen Jump Issue 41:
Golden Future Cup Entry #2: Joreishi Rentarou no Yakusoku (by Shindou Masaoki)

this is the 17 y/o mangaka that wrote SKY CLAW, which most people here liked

http://bato.to/comic/_/comics/sky-claw-r20983

Shounen Jump Issue 42:
Golden Future Cup Entry #3: Raven Burai (by Kobayashi Eiken)

this guy wrote that one mma manga in Next, it wasn't anything special and the art was amateurish

Shounen Jump Issue 43:
Golden Future Cup Entry #4: Chou Kasoku Ningen Leo (by Matsubara Dai)

this guy wrote a Sherlock Holemes manga in Giga last year which I really didn't care about

Shounen Jump Issue 44:
Golden Future Cup Entry #5: Mahou Shounen X (by Nakama Tadaichi)

this one is the guy that wrote Alien Sage oneshot, it was an cliched Space/Scifi manga a la Galaxy Gang, his art is very very nice tho

 

[SkerllyFC]

So Shonen Jump these days has less luck for success with mangas in other genres than shonen action mangas. I really wanted the magazine to be more diverse with other genres, like Shonen Sunday and Shonen Magazine, but it seems that it´s not working much. Do we really need more action shonens in the magazine?

 

[ChocoBar9]

So Shonen Jump these days has less luck for success with mangas in other genres than shonen action mangas. I really wanted the magazine to be more diverse with other genres, like Shonen Sunday and Shonen Magazine, but it seems that it´s not working much. Do we really need more action shonens in the magazine?

He says this in spite of the fact of the success of Neverland, Dr. Stone and Robot all three of which don't fall into the category of shounen action manga,

 

[HIGAN0]

194680 2191794 Ｏ
*83274 *594792 ハ
*21296 *149552 ブ

194680 2191794 ONE PIECE #86
*83274 *594792 Haikyuu!! #27
*21296 *149552 Black Clover #12

 

[G_I_A]

We would like to see good oneshots, believe me, but they are just bad and when any of them are good they change the entire story and mess things up like Hungry Joker. But they are not serialized with the series they won GFC, Hungry Joker was painfully terrible and Beelzebub got some success, but it is not that great either.

I don't know what you are talking about. Who?

Black Clover?

He says this in spite of the fact of the success of Neverland, Dr. Stone and Robot all three of which don't fall into the category of shounen action manga,

He does not know what his talking about (as always). Despite having the following successes:

Shonen Sunday - Detective Conan, Magi (which is ending) and Gin no Saji (that is almost always on hiatus).
Shonen Magazine - Seven Deadly Sins, Hajime no Ippo and Fire Force.

NONE of this magazines have new, different, revolutionary or even relevant series with different genres. In fact JUMP is "innovating" WAY more than any other (relevant?) shounen magazine nowadays

I'm not even gonna start about the "luck" part of his argument since almost none of this series sells more than the high or even medium selling jump series.