How can he be vigilante temporarily and know it? James couldn't give out any gifts until night 1. The only other option is Spirit being an Assassin of red, but lakhan already died. Not to mention that the hosts wouldn't allow an assassin roleplaying a vigilante since that's hostkill material.
That and mafia pirate are the only ways a mafia would get vigilante, assuming there's no special system in the game allowing that(and we only have genkidamas). And even with that it's still impossible since Spirit used it day 1 with no time to use pirate or get a gift. The santa gift doesn't let the recipient know what his role temporarily changes to so he wouldn't even know that he can daykill.
But that's irrelevant, ofc he's trolling. Not sure we can even believe Spirit being their target the last night, but that depends on what pompom did.
A.ulq - Mason/Lover(Confirmed) - Will die next night after Daws is killed.
Demonspeed - Mason(Confirmed)
desin24 - Apprentice
Emperor Spriggan - Jesus
Erinyes - Bulletproof
GrySun - Spy
Holt - Doctor
Lady pompom - Prostitute
WithYouInSpirit - Daytime vigilante(Confirmed)
xi0 - nothing
Not counting SonOfDaws since he's Mafia Detective.
So yes, he's the only one that hasn't claimed. Also, in that list are a minimum of 3 mafias. My money's on desin, xi0 and maybe pompom.
If Gary is Mafia I think he is probably Orange as well. I hoped pompom would reveal that she blocked Brandish. Brandish has without a doubt been killed by a Orange, and it would mean that Orgz died because of the recruitment.
There is Son who is acting as if he didn't know who they chose to target. The Escort must be Orange, and if they didn't kill Son it's because of this blocking role. Son revealed Tina and Gry's role yesterday. Son also asked you to spy on him to confirm his target. If they know what your action will be and have an Escort, they don' have to worry about killingyou since you are not going to spy on them. So, they killed the one they thought was Doc, Brandish while you were busy spying the Mafia, who got blocked.
I thought so at first, but now I really don't belive he is, judging from how he played all game. If he's really orange mafia mason then I will be shocked and congratulate him on the great win.
I thought so at first, but now I really don't belive he is, judging from how he played all game. If he's really orange mafia mason then I will be shocked and congratulate him on the great win.
Why did Orgz target Desin. And why would Daws lie then about desin? Or Daws actually tried to kill instead? Why didn't the other red perform the kill instead?
We were hesitating between Gary, desin, Erin and pompom but chose desin in the end because of his penalty votes mainly. pompom was the least favorite because Prostitute is a very important role right now.
Why did Orgz target Desin. And why would Daws lie then about desin? Or Daws actually tried to kill instead? Why didn't the other red perform the kill instead?
Yeah. I trust him, but shouldn't let that be too subjective. So the list is
A.ulq - Mason/Lover(Confirmed) - Will die next night after Daws is killed.
Demonspeed - Mason
desin24 - Apprentice
Emperor Spriggan - Jesus
Erinyes - Bulletproof
GrySun - Spy
Holt - Doctor
Lady pompom - Prostitute
WithYouInSpirit - Daytime vigilante(Confirmed)
xi0 - nothing
If you think closely, red mafia wasn't able to kill anyone this night,while Orgz died because of his recruitment and one from the red was killed by an orange. I know you're suspecting me, but xi0 looks the mosty iffy for me.
GKing son seems plausible by now (he was a confirmed mafia and survived until now). I'm still reluctant about xi0, but...
If Gary is Mafia I think he is probably Orange as well. I hoped pompom would reveal that she blocked Brandish. Brandish has without a doubt been killed by a Orange, and it would mean that Orgz died because of the recruitment.
There is Son who is acting as if he didn't know who they chose to target. The Escort must be Orange, and if they didn't kill Son it's because of this blocking role. Son revealed Tina and Gry's role yesterday. Son also asked you to spy on him to confirm his target. If they know what your action will be and have an Escort, they don' have to worry about killingyou since you are not going to spy on them. So, they killed the one they thought was Doc, Brandish while you were busy spying the Mafia, who got blocked.
Oh that's interesting. But why desin ?
So was considering voting for xio, but now Im wondering. So if Orga died by recruiting, it means Desin is definitely mafia.
Have no idea who to vote for now, need to leave soon, and day will end in the middle of the night in my time zone, will likely go for either xio or desin.
We were hesitating between Gary, desin, Erin and pompom but chose desin in the end because of his penalty votes mainly. pompom was the least favorite because Prostitute is a very important role right now.
Say, should the last mason/s come out now that the recruiter is dead? ulq dies tonight regardless, and if you die next night there will be no known mason left to confirm/deny any future mason claims? Or is it just you and ulq who are left?
Same decision for me really. desin can just say tomorrow that he was blocked so letting him live another day to prove his apprentice claim is very likely pointless, but then there's xi0 who didn't claim anything.
We were hesitating between Gary, desin, Erin and pompom but chose desin in the end because of his penalty votes mainly. pompom was the least favorite because Prostitute is a very important role right now.
Yeah. I trust him, but shouldn't let that be too subjective. So the list is
A.ulq - Mason/Lover(Confirmed) - Will die next night after Daws is killed.
Demonspeed - Mason
desin24 - Apprentice
Emperor Spriggan - Jesus
Erinyes - Bulletproof
GrySun - Spy
Holt - Doctor
Lady pompom - Prostitute
WithYouInSpirit - Daytime vigilante(Confirmed)
xi0 - nothing
Say, should the last mason/s come out now that the recruiter is dead? ulq dies tonight regardless, and if you die next night there will be no known mason left to confirm/deny any future mason claims? Or is it just you and ulq who are left?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Same decision for me really. desin can just say tomorrow that he was blocked so letting him live another day to prove his apprentice claim is very likely pointless, but then there's xi0 who didn't claim anything.
It depends. Son was not explicit with their night actions. If Orgz died because of the recruitment, desin is definitely Mafia, but if Orgz has been targeted by Red, things change.
But if desin if Mafia, is he the Red one? If he is Orange, is he the Escort? If we don't kill the Red one we will have two deaths next night, Mafia could kill each others but still. If desin is Orange it's better if he is the Escort. Because if he is not things will become even more complicated.