Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[jagman1x3]

World Trigger had two oneshots, right? I mean technically part 1 & 2 but still two total. Though I think it was called Trigger Keeper and was back in 2009 pre-Rilienthal.

You're actually still right regardless of it being two parts, there was the Trigger Keeper oneshot and the Elite Agent Jin one.

 

[savethecat]

"It could be complete shit and flop" could be applied to any upcoming film, tv show, book, video game, ect. Doesn't mean people can't be excited for it

 

[Tamil]

you think an ecchi manga can outsell 1 of the 3 current pillars OP, Hq, MHA?

Okay maybe not Yuragi or even Yaiba but definitely TPN.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Also his three oneshots were Iron Curtain, Goblin Night, and Iron Knight. Makes you think.

What is this, some kind of anti-communist propaganda?
But seriously, what were they about?

 

[xAsum0x]

Why do some people have this attitude of "heheheh I'm gonna laugh so hard when this manga gets canceled and these guys get disappointed and upset hehe"?

 

[Mammo]

Nobody is saying it's the next big thing and if they are saying it they know it has a chance of being trash and getting canceled just like the other series you pointed out. Nothing wrong with hoping for the opposite lol, especially as a fan of battle shonen like myself, I just want more adventurous stuff to read on Fridays along with One Piece. Not rocket science.

"It could be complete shit and flop" could be applied to any upcoming film, tv show, book, video game, ect. Doesn't mean people can't be excited for it

you say you know the possibility of it not meeting your expectations and you're excited but cautious but do you? are you really?

this entire thread have been "Golem Hearts this "and "Golem Hearts that" for a month now so I'm wondering

hmmmmm

Why do some people have this attitude of "heheheh I'm gonna laugh so hard when this manga gets canceled and these guys get disappointed and upset hehe"?

we are all sad miserable people and we want other people to be sad and miserable like us because there is comfort in company

also you get to tell people I told you so and look smart/obnoxious

 

[xAsum0x]

you say you know the possibility of it not meeting your expectations and you're excited but cautious but do you? are you really?

this entire thread have been "Golem Hearts this "and "Golem Hearts that" for a month now so I'm wondering

hmmmmm



we are all sad miserable people and we want other people to be sad and miserable like us because there is comfort in company

also you get to tell people I told you so and look smart/obnoxious

Yeah for a month it's been "I really like this one shot and it just got a series, I hope it does well". What's the difference with this series and you rooting for other mangakas with One shots you liked to get series (mangaka of Fulldrive etc).

Yes I'm fully aware it can be bad and get canceled lol, and if it does then oh well sucks

 

[TyVip]

you think an ecchi manga can outsell 1 of the 3 current pillars OP, Hq, MHA?

MHA has what 20 mil in circulation now?

20,000,000 million copies in circulation * 400 yen = 8000000000 yen convert to USD = 70,101,040 million

so one jackpot lottery ticket should do it. ez boi.

 

[savethecat]

you say you know the possibility of it not meeting your expectations and you're excited but cautious but do you? are you really?

this entire thread have been "Golem Hearts this "and "Golem Hearts that" for a month now so I'm wondering

hmmmmm



we are all sad miserable people and we want other people to be sad and miserable like us because there is comfort in company

also you get to tell people I told you so and look smart/obnoxious

Most of the ppl looking forward to it are looking forward to it because they enjoyed the One Shot a lot.
Yes, there are examples of One Shots being good, but the series being terrible. That's the possibility with anything. A movie can be really good, but the sequel can suck. A video game could have a great demo. But the full game can be terrible.
There are also example of one shots being awesome and the series being awesome too.

Usually when ppl enjoy something, and find out that thing they enjoyed is getting more content, they look forward to the future of it.
Golem Hearts may be trash. And may get cancelled. But there's nothing wrong with liking the one shot, and being excited for the series based on that. Hoping that it'll be just as good or better

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

And more importantly director/staff.

TPN/KnY/YnY potentially becoming pillars is really exciting tbh.

I think only TPN can become a pillar.
Kimetsu no Yaiba I'm still not sure if it will become a pillar.
Already Yuragi-sou can become Jump's best ecchi series, surpassing even To Love-Ru in sales.
But Yuragi becoming a pillar is almost impossible.

 

[Mammo]

Yeah for a month it's been "I really like this one shot and it just got a series, I hope it does well". What's the difference with this series and you rooting for other mangakas with One shots you liked to get series (mangaka of Fulldrive etc).

my posts about authors are no where near as active/frequent/prominent as talks about GH have been
other than Ono can you remember others oneshots rookies I've shilled?

MHA has what 20 mil in circulation now?

no, I think the last time they updated in March(?) it was like 11 mil

it's probably 13 or 14 mill now

Most of the ppl looking forward to it are looking forward to it because they enjoyed the One Shot a lot.
Yes, there are examples of One Shots being good, but the series being terrible. That's the possibility with anything. A movie can be really good, but the sequel can suck. A video game could have a great demo. But the full game can be terrible.
There are also example of one shots being awesome and the series being awesome too.

Usually when ppl enjoy something, and find out that thing they enjoyed is getting more content, they look forward to the future of it.
Golem Hearts may be trash. And may get cancelled. But there's nothing wrong with liking the one shot, and being excited for the series based on that. Hoping that it'll be just as good or better

I'm not saying you shouldn't be excited or hyped, I get excited for every serialization round too

I'm saying the hype around this one have been the biggest I've recently seen although this isn't the first battle manga oneshot that people like and turned into a series

I'm not seeing what so special about the oneshot so in my eyes it's the fans the are overhyped

 

[Tanzo]

Gintama final popularity poll Top 10

Spoiler

Gintoki: 1st with 4636 votes
(Remained 1st from last poll)

His place is firm and unnomving as it should be --the perfect adornment as the protagonist of the seires!

Hijikata: 2nd with 2385 votes
(Remained 2nd from last poll)

A Vegeta like position that has a

Okita: 3rd with 1698 votes
(Remained 3rd from last poll)

Perhaps this is his favorite spot for aiming at Hijikata-san's back?!

Takasugi: 4th with 1572 votes
(Remained 4th from last poll)

His latest exploits in the main story have left quite an impression!

Kagura: 5th place with 1206 votes
(Up from 6th last poll)

Katsura: 6th place with 966 votes
(Down from 5th last poll)

Shinpachi: 7th place with 576 votes
(Up from 8th last poll)

Kamui: 8th place with 543 votes
(Down from 7th last poll)

Tsukuyo 9th with 465 votes
(Up from 12th last poll)

Tae 10th with 273 votes
(Up from 12th last poll)



Shinpachi's comment:

Waaaaait a second. I'm "seventh" this time around. It's the first time my rank has risen, y'know? Like frreal it was a brave fight on my part..
So why the hell do I feel as if everyone is saying "ah what a pity?"? Isn't this "too bad" atmopshere kinda weird?

Source: Bomber D Rufi/Sakaki

 

[Caiops]

I don't think there's space for one more battle shounen series in Jump, all the kids are voting in Black Clover or One Piece.

 

[De La Croissant]

THERE IS ALWAYS SPACE FOR MORE BATTLE SHONEN.

A-L-W-A-Y-S.

 

[OfficialHxH]

Still waiting on that Hunter x Hunter Return Announcement

 

[WyldViolet]

I don't think there's space for one more battle shounen series in Jump, all the kids are voting in Black Clover or One Piece.

There's plenty of room for competition, and it's what Jump wants and needs.

In 1998 we had JoJo, Kenshin, Hoshin Engi, Takeshi, One Piece, Hunter x Hunter, and Shaman King all running together. Plus other really popular series of other genres.

2004 we had One Piece, Hunter x Hunter, Shaman King, Naruto, Black Cat, Bleach, Buso Renkin, Reborn, D. Gray Man, and Muhyo and Roji.

The best periods of Jump are always ones with lots of battle manga competition.

Right now having just One Piece, My Hero Academia, Black Clover, and Kimetsu no Yaiba aren't really quite scratching that weekly battle competition itch.

I want Shiibashi and Utsumi to come back soon.

 

[Leoat12]

I like Shiibashi, I have NuraMago in my shelf, but I think he already had a lot of chances in the past couple of years. I think he has to pair up with someone and be responsible with only the drawings.

 

[WyldViolet]

I like Shiibashi, I have NuraMago in my shelf, but I think he already had a lot of chances in the past couple of years. I think he has to pair up with someone and be responsible with only the drawings.

Huh? His only series were NuraMago, Illegal Rare, and that Jump Giga miniseries. He's sure to have another shot.

 

[Leoat12]

Huh? His only series were NuraMago, Illegal Rare, and that Jump Giga miniseries. He's sure to have another shot.

It seemed to me much more than this, but anyway, my opinion doesn't change, he should pair up with someone.

 

[Tamil]

I think only TPN can become a pillar.
Kimetsu no Yaiba I'm still not sure if it will become a pillar.
Already Yuragi-sou can become Jump's best ecchi series, surpassing even To Love-Ru in sales.
But Yuragi becoming a pillar is almost impossible.

Yaiba can become one if the anime is a hit. It's gonna be really hard though but yea if anything TPN.