Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[nonowa]

The BnHA chapter being ranked was the big climax of the arc. Damn.

 

[Scruffy8642]

Also guess we can expect one of FD/GH to get the axe in this next round. Shudan's already had the "Veteran flop 4 volume treatment", so even that won't survive another.

 

[Nemesis]

Goodbye Golem Hearts

Also, really nice to see Saiki, WNL, Neverland and Kimetsu in the top.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Screw Jump audience for not enjoying Golem Hearts. Adventure and battle shounen are dead. It turned it up to eleven after the timeskip. Save us, Kishimito.....

 

[Aipom626]

Also guess we can expect one of FD/GH to get the axe in this next round.

Cross Account is definitely gone, and I'd say Spring Weapon is safe. If I had to pick one of the 2, I'd choose Full Drive to go. I'm not a fan of the artwork, characters, or story. I'm not really loving Golem Hearts either so far, but I'm more willing to give it a bit more time. Honestly, I'd rather see Shudan survive at both of their expenses, but I highly doubt that'll happen

 

[TyVip]

Telling yall for the 2nd time,

Post-Apocalypse manga will be the future of Jump, at least for the next 3 years.

 

[Avok]

Damn son! Golem Hearts deserves better.

 

[savethecat]

I said this before, but I feel like MHA ranking in the middle has more so to do with the editor probably putting it there for his own reasons(maybe to give newer series on the rise, like TPN, Kimetsu No Yaiba, and Dr.Stone more promo). I don’t feel like it’s not a definitive sign that ppl hate the arc or the popularity is declining.

Like Yonkou’s vid and Oda says. The ToC isnt necessarily a ranking system

 

[Doughboy]

RIP Golem Hearts, Jump hates fun and good characters. I'm just in disbelief.

 

[SharkBait]

Screw Jump audience for not enjoying Golem Hearts. Adventure and battle shounen are dead. It turned it up to eleven after the timeskip. Save us, Kishimito.....

BLack Clover has already saved us.

 

[Scruffy8642]

BLack Clover has already saved us.

B-but Golem Hearts has cute boys too! One even has bags under his eyes!

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

CPs: Hinomaru Zumo (Big Announcement)

Please be the anime announcement.
Many people have been expecting this for years.
Golem Hearts started very badly.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

Remember the last time HZ had a big annoucement it was something about 2nd arc, ending, etc..? If it gets an anime then good for the fans, but it's kinda weird how it wasn't announced at Jump Festa.

My esport manga will finally become a thing .

Prepare for FrankerZ and Kappas I guess

 

[Mammo]

Wow, I know I was hating on GH but I didn't expect it to rank dead last

If HZ is getting an anime why wouldn't they announce it in Jump Festa?

Komi went from writing a repetitive going nowhere romcom which I hate to writing esport manga which I also hate

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Issue 6
Cover/Lead Poster Color: One Piece
CPs: Hinomaru Zumo (Big Announcement), Kimetsu no Yaiba, E no Genten (Naoshi Komi oneshot, ESports)
Extra Pages: Golem Hearts

I want a space battle manga (Something similar to the Mass Effect game) or a gag manga nonsense like Sexy Commando Gaiden.
And also an eSports manga.

Now, Jump give me the space battle manga.
Not a oneshot, but a series.

 

[xAsum0x]

thats a good point that I never thought of. Why would they annouce an anime for it 1 week after Jump Festa when they couldve announced it then? I wanna see the sumo matches animated tho.

Battle shonen continuing to catch L's these past couple of years. Kids are getting better taste /s

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 20, 2017, Original Post Date: Dec 20, 2017 ---

Now, Jump give me the space battle manga.
Not a oneshot, but a series.

Alas, I know of one man for the job.....or at least I thought I knew him

 

[Doughboy]

Not gonna lie I'm shook but guess it's deserved for falling for the hype. GH was simply an entertaining series that was hitting all the right strokes. Nice MC and heroine, side characters like Carles was chill too. Good premise and world. Lol @ me agreeing with the EiC from that Viz interview, dude has degraded the mag by giving fans of safe series trauma by placing them in the lower end because of JUMP SUPER PUSH!!! for Stone and Neverland while series like Spring Weapon nobody knows why it's around. He's a joke, get rid of him.

 

[SharkBait]

I wouldnt want a manga that took cues from Mass Effect, Mass Effect always had some pretty terribly m/m ships that made me always play FemShep just to get with my favorite guy (Kaidan, cause Williams was garbage).

ST&RS was already the best space manga ever.

 

[Luca11]

Esports Manga! I'm curious to see how that's gonna go down.
Can anyone read the raw Hinomaru spoil me re. what's happening? Haven't been up to date.

I also think the rankings also depend on whether or not the contents of the chapters. Kimetsu tends to not rank high when there's little action in the chapter in the issue with the ranking (not the one that is supposedly being ranked).

 

[Mammo]

Battle shonen continuing to catch L's these past couple of years. Kids are getting better taste /s

kids they killed Shudan and are keeping SW#1 alive so I wouldn't say their taste got better

Alas, I know of one man for the job.....or at least I thought I knew him

I'll pretend you mean Hisao Tamaki and not who you actually meant