Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Scruffy8642]

So we don’t even know if this is real haha. Either way, the fact that these two tocs are so similar (and one might be real) just proves how poorly handled it is nowadays.

I quite like Ikezawa’s works, even if he is a bit of a dick. Inb4 another changed and cancelled GFC winner.

 

[MangAniMY]

Saiki about his series ending:
https://i.imgur.com/am77wbV_d.jpg?maxwidth=640&shape=thumb&fidelity=medium

For real though, I'm really sad. But thank you for the laughs! Judgement Knights Of Thunder!

 

[tirakai]

I think I'll just wait for yonkou's TOC before believing anything.

 

[MangAniMY]

You know it's time to fire the current EiC when he puts Spring Weapon above HxH, Soma, Hinomaru, Gintama, Yuragi and Robot. Even at their worst moments or being unranked because of hiatus, they still deserve better ranks than the only <10k selling manga in the magazine.

Spring Weapon is that bad?

 

[Yaiba]

Tokyoto Tachi Jujutsu Koutou Senmon Gakkou by Akutami Gege, the 3rd manga of that list. It was published on Jump GIGA 2017 with 4 chapters.

 

[razerxs]

Oricon Ranking Feb 12 - Feb 19
90967 *819134 Hunter X Hunter
71346 *549823 Haikyuu!!
63421 *439655 BNHA
35806 *278442 Shokugeki no Soma
23917 *162482 World's End Harem
20496 *114962 Darling in the Franxx
-----------------------
11052 **83197 We Never Learn
10765 *358285 Promised Neverland 7
10609 **76622 Dr. Stone
*8175 2349137 One Piece
*7000 *539811 Promised Neverland 1
*6887 *398994 Promised Neverland 6

Are you sure its the old guy? Because on 5ch tocs, lot of people dont trust him.

All we've got to go on is the trip code.

 

[nonowa]

Yonko, you're our only hope.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

Huh... this new serialization round is definitely good looking, I'm particularly excited with the Tanaka Seiji one shot being seralized, just the other day I was wondering if we could get to see it in the magazine this year and bang, here it is. Would anyone have the raws for it?

Also surprised by the Kurogane and Mononofu guy coming back, would of thought he would move to another magazine but hey I am not complaining, for all what's worth he certainly has talent, let's hope he pulls a Horikoshi with this third series

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Hopefully Mononofu guy goes the way Horikoshi, Tabata, World Trigger author, Nisekoi author did aka at 2nd or 3rd time, the running title.

''GFC Winner 2016''

Has anyone any pic?

 

[Yaiba]

Hopefully Mononofu guy goes the way Horikoshi, Tabata, World Trigger author, Nisekoi author did aka at 2nd or 3rd time, the running title.

''GFC Winner 2016''

Has anyone any pic?

Spoiler

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Important question: who was the GFC 2017 Winner?

 

[Yaiba]

Important question: who was the GFC 2017 Winner?

Joreishi Rentarou no Yakusoku by Masaoki Shindou

Spoiler

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Ok, got titles (source: Jump World, spanish Facebook site).

-14 (05/02): Kantou Grimoarts by Haruto Ikezawa (autor of Kurogane and Mononofu)
Plot: Unknown
-15 (12/02): Tokubetsu Kokkakoumuin Kaizousha Taisakuka Tanaka Seiji by Keiji Amatsuka
Plot :An administration official gets first place in a contest of mangas and his story just published in the magazine Shonen Jump.
-16 (19/02): Tokyoto Tachi Jujutsu Koutou Senmon Gakkou by Akutami Gege
Plot: Tried to search it, didn't find it despise it having 4 chapters in GIGA. If anyone has any info....

 

[Yaiba]

Ok, got titles (source: Jump World, spanish Facebook site).

-14 (05/02): Kantou Grimoarts by Haruto Ikezawa (autor of Kurogane and Mononofu)
Plot: Unknown
-15 (12/02): Tokubetsu Kokkakoumuin Kaizousha Taisakuka Tanaka Seiji by Keiji Amatsuka
Plot :An administration official gets first place in a contest of mangas and his story just published in the magazine Shonen Jump.
-16 (19/02): Tokyoto Tachi Jujutsu Koutou Senmon Gakkou by Akutami Gege
Plot: Tried to search it, didn't find it despise it having 4 chapters in GIGA. If anyone has any info....

As I mentioned before, Tokyoto Tachi Jujutsu Koutou Senmon Gakkou was published in Jump GIGA 2017 #01 to #04 https://comicvine.gamespot.com/shonen-jump-giga-5-2017-vol-1/4000-593473/ this issue published first chapter & https://comicvine.gamespot.com/shonen-jump-giga-8-2017-vol-4/4000-611015/ this issue published fourth chapter. According to japanese title and mangaka, it's refers to this manga.

 

[De La Croissant]

Oricon Ranking Feb 12 - Feb 19
90967 *819134 Hunter X Hunter
71346 *549823 Haikyuu!!
63421 *439655 BNHA
35806 *278442 Shokugeki no Soma
23917 *162482 World's End Harem
20496 *114962 Darling in the Franxx
-----------------------
11052 **83197 We Never Learn
10765 *358285 Promised Neverland 7
10609 **76622 Dr. Stone
*8175 2349137 One Piece
*7000 *539811 Promised Neverland 1
*6887 *398994 Promised Neverland 6


All we've got to go on is the trip code.

My impression or did MHA reach the 500k faster in previous volumes?

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

As I mentioned before, Tokyoto Tachi Jujutsu Koutou Senmon Gakkou was published in Jump GIGA 2017 #01 to #04 https://comicvine.gamespot.com/shonen-jump-giga-5-2017-vol-1/4000-593473/ this issue published first chapter & https://comicvine.gamespot.com/shonen-jump-giga-8-2017-vol-4/4000-611015/ this issue published fourth chapter. According to japanese title and mangaka, it's refers to this manga.

Yeah yeah, I wanted to get some info about its plot. For the pic posted here it looks like something...strange, with exorcism and pandas

PD: I think the GFC 2016 winner has huge chances of surviving. Let's see it...in 3 months.
PD2: New 3 titles, and none of them being related to sports (well, Kantou Grimoarts could be, but doesn't look the case) makes me thing RxL is going to survive for sure.

 

[ChocoBar9]

My impression or did MHA reach the 500k faster in previous volumes?

Volume 12(17 Days)- 54,169(389,256)

Volume 13(20 Days)- 41,512(391,797)

Volume 14(17 Days)- 62,913(416,205)

Volume 15(21 Days)- 51,957(490,771)

Volume 16(18 Days)- 48,168(447,972)

Definitely your impression.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Well, title I have more hype to see how it does is Kantou Grimoarts.

Unlike most of axed titles, both Kurogane and Mononofu lasted more than 30 chapters. I hope Kantou Grimoarts becomes the ''Hero Academia'' of Ikezawa and he finally gets his Jump long running title.

Bad thing: right now Jump lineup looks pretty solid for me. I don't imagine any newcomer being able to rank over anything not called RxL. I hope I'm wrong, 2018 needs some success.

 

[SharkBait]

Hopefully Mononofu guy goes the way Horikoshi, Tabata, World Trigger author, Nisekoi author did aka at 2nd or 3rd time, the running title.

''GFC Winner 2016''

Has anyone any pic?

I miss Mononofu

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

Really wonder if Ikezawa will make another spokon or totally shift to a different genre, Kantou Grimoarts certainly doesn’t sound like a sports manga so we’ll see

Also, has Spring Weapon actually gotten good?!?!? I only know that the manga is climaxing but like has it actually gotten into some good content?