Discussion Mael vs Meliodas | SPOILERS OUT !!!!!!!

Who will win ?

  • Meliodas

    Votes: 15 24.2%
  • Mael

    Votes: 12 19.4%
  • Someone will interrupt

    Votes: 23 37.1%
  • The battle will end in a tie

    Votes: 12 19.4%

  • Total voters
    62
  • Poll closed .

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
As long as one of them isn't dead, they can fight again. Losing the battle but not the war.

Meliodas's betrayal has a different effect since he became part of Stigma's force, it also reduced the Demon Clan's power.
They can, but credibility and the initial impact is lost. It changes the perception of the clans, despite not directly affecting them physically.

That’s not how it works though

Mael was the champion of his clan for like 6 hours & within that time frame he was the strongest

The Demon Clan had strength in numbers, they had more high class warriors, which is why when Meliodas left, they still had a fighting chance

Cusack + Chandler alone are strong enough to make up for 9 Commandment slots

The Demon Clan as a whole was simply vastly superior while the Goddess clan relied heavily on Mael and 3 Arc Angels

It’s no different than the power gap between the Commandments and the sins within the 2nd arc

The sins relied heavily on Escanor to bridge the gap
It is, though. We know close to nothing about the Goddess Clan, so claiming they only had the Archangels would be improper. If the Demon Clan were really vastly superior, then they could wipe the goddesses rather easily at night, early morning, or late evening. Unlike the Commandments against Escanor, the demons had means to render Mael powerless. That said, the goddesses probably had someone who would do the opposite.

Nah, from what we've seen, the demons only stood a chance because the Archangels were fucking around. That was the reason most were surprised when it was revealed that Sariel and Tarmiel were supposedly on the upper 80,000s.
Either way, a loss on Mael's side would be catastrophic for the goddesses, and a loss on Meliodas' side would damage his reputation immensely. Nothing suggests either happened at any point.
 

Chibi Moon

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
118
Reaction score
340
Country
United Kingdom
Bruh

Galan cursed himself out of fear

Melascula freaked out when Galan was getting fodderized

Estarossa literally turned into a little girl

Monspeet, Zeldris, Fraudrin & Derieri were in complete awe when they witnessed Escanor’s power

Glox and Drole got completely bodied just by Escanor’s night Form

How were the Demons not afraid of Mael if the Commandments themselves were shook as fuck everytime Escanor popped up ?



No

Mael was stronger then Meliodas that is a fact
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I agree about those demons (the 10TC) being scared but they were unlucky - they caught Escanor during the 6 hour window - (I don't know about 6 hours...but for the sake of debate I'll stick to 6) If one of them caught him at night and recognised him word would quickly spread that all they had to do was wait until the sun went down and then they can make their move. It seems that only Ludo has caught on to that, I don't think Galan and Melascula realised if they went and hid for a few hours then they can get him later. No-one has that chance with Meliodas.

The problem is we don't know what the base for Mael is. If it is already quite high without sunshine that would be great - and because he is an AA it is very possible that he would be, but sunshine creates such a strong contrast in its current user that there is a possibility that he's unbeatable during those '6 hours' and well less than 60k for the remaining time of the day which is a problem. That is why I agree with you when you say Mael is super strong but I disagree when you say Mael was stronger than Mel because apart from those 6 hours we just don't know we should wait before declaring facts like that.

Mael was the strongest AA at certain times at the day I cannot remember the exact words Ludo used but he went something like "At a certain point of the late morning he surpassed my strength etc"
 
Last edited:

Shutensatsu

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2017
Messages
862
Reaction score
2,395
Age
35
Country
United States
He was stronger than him for sure for 1 minute.

A max of 1 hour from 11-12.

He was not always above 142K anytime the sun was up from dawn till dusk lol.

Even if his goddess base was 60K, with the same boosting values as Escanor he’d be 110K at dawn(weaker than Mel), and 174K Late Morning.

He’d still have to waiting until Late Morning to beat Assault Meliodas even with a 60K base, and base Mael is probably even weaker than that. We have no idea how much his demon mark was contributing to his strength stat.

They can, but credibility and the initial impact is lost. It changes the perception of the clans, despite not directly affecting them physically.


It is, though. We know close to nothing about the Goddess Clan, so claiming they only had the Archangels would be improper. If the Demon Clan were really vastly superior, then they could wipe the goddesses rather easily at night, early morning, or late evening. Unlike the Commandments against Escanor, the demons had means to render Mael powerless. That said, the goddesses probably had someone who would do the opposite.

Nah, from what we've seen, the demons only stood a chance because the Archangels were fucking around. That was the reason most were surprised when it was revealed that Sariel and Tarmiel were supposedly on the upper 80,000s.
Either way, a loss on Mael's side would be catastrophic for the goddesses, and a loss on Meliodas' side would damage his reputation immensely. Nothing suggests either happened at any point.
The Demons have more high class fighters as of right now.

All of the commandmnets are worthless. Tarmiel and Sariel could trap all of them in the Enlil dimension and none of them could escape. But even then they still have more battle power.

Mel - 142K.

Cusack - 90K+

Chandler - 90K+

Zeldris - Hard to peg probably stronger than Cusack and Chandler when activating his second mark.

5 Indura’s all over 100K.

That’s 9 potential fighters that have 90K or more.

Probably even 10 when you factor in this personal servant to the DK that Mel said he used to have.

The goddesses had 4.
 
Last edited:

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
They can, but credibility and the initial impact is lost. It changes the perception of the clans, despite not directly affecting them physically.


It is, though. We know close to nothing about the Goddess Clan, so claiming they only had the Archangels would be improper.
At this point it’d be an ass pull if Nakaba introduced more high ranked Angels

If the Demon Clan were really vastly superior, then they could wipe the goddesses rather easily at night, early morning, or late evening. Unlike the Commandments against Escanor, the demons had means to render Mael powerless. That said, the goddesses probably had someone who would do the opposite.
The Demons weren’t knowledgeable about the Graces specifically, Monspeet didn’t know how Sariel was deflecting his purgatory flame bird, not to mention there were various battlefields, they rarely crossed paths

Even if it was night time Mael should still be capable and still be AA level

Nah, from what we've seen, the demons only stood a chance because the Archangels were fucking around. That was the reason most were surprised when it was revealed that Sariel and Tarmiel were supposedly on the upper 80,000s.
Either way, a loss on Mael's side would be catastrophic for the goddesses, and a loss on Meliodas' side would damage his reputation immensely. Nothing suggests either happened at any point.
I agree with both statements, but there’s no way one didn’t have the upper hand
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
The Demons have more high class fighters as of right now.

All of the commandmnets are worthless. Tarmiel and Sariel could trap all of them in the Enlil dimension and none of them could escape. But even then they still have more battle power.

Mel - 142K.

Cusack - 90K+

Chandler - 90K+

Zeldris - Hard to peg probably stronger than Cusack and Chandler when activating his second mark.

5 Indura’s all over 100K.

That’s 9 potential fighters that have 90K or more.

Probably even 10 when you factor in this personal servant to the DK that Mel said he used to have.

The goddesses had 4.
You said it yourself - as of right now.
There's no way the four Archangels alone would be able to stalemate Meliodas, Zeldris, Cusack, Chandler (who are four potential Indura and can fight and even defeat Archangels without it), Derieri and Monspeet as potential Indura, four additional Indura in the Demon Realm, and so on.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I agree about those demons (the 10TC) being scared but they were unlucky - they caught Escanor during the 6 hour window - (I don't know about 6 hours...but for the sake of debate I'll stick to 6) If one of them caught him at night and recognised him word would quickly spread that all they had to do was wait until the sun went down and then they can make their move. It seems that only Ludo has caught on to that, I don't think Galan and Melascula realised if they went and hid for a few hours then they can get him later. No-one has that chance with Meliodas.

The problem is we don't know what the base for Mael is. If it is already quite high without sunshine that would be great - and because he is an AA it is very possible that he would be, but sunshine creates such a strong contrast in its current user that there is a possibility that he's unbeatable during those '6 hours' and well less than 60k for the remaining time of the day which is a problem. That is why I agree with you when you say Mael is super strong but I disagree when you say Mael was stronger than Mel because apart from those 6 hours we just don't know we should wait before declaring facts like that.

Mael was the strongest AA at certain times at the day I cannot remember the exact words Ludo used but he went something like "At a certain point of the late morning he surpassed my strength etc"
That’s what I’m saying

I’m not talking about PL numbers but as soon an SunShine kicks in Mael should be impossible to kill point blank period simply because of Sunshine’s Durability, Escanor was able to tank blows that shatter mountains early in the morning when his PL was 50k WHEN HE FOUGHT GALAN, that was BEFORE 11:00AM

If Mael’s base was 60k to 80k+ that’d mean he’d be 150k+ as soon as it hit 11:00am where in Escanor’s case he’d normally be at 114k
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
At this point it’d be an ass pull if Nakaba introduced more high ranked Angels
Chandler and Cusack were asspulls made to give Zeldris a chance in this arc. It's a poor choice, but at this point it would make no sense if the goddesses only had four angels capable of doing something.

The Demons weren’t knowledgeable about the Graces specifically, Monspeet didn’t know how Sariel was deflecting his purgatory flame bird, not to mention there were various battlefields, they rarely crossed paths

Even if it was night time Mael should still be capable and still be AA level
But the fact that Meliodas fought Mael implies he at least had an idea of his power. Monspeet seemingly never fought Sariel before.

Mael without a Grace would be easy prey for the highest demons, to say the least.

I agree with both statements, but there’s no way one didn’t have the upper hand
Depends on the hour.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
He was stronger than him for sure for 1 minute.

A max of 1 hour from 11-12.

He was not always above 142K anytime the sun was up from dawn till dusk lol.

Even if his goddess base was 60K, with the same boosting values as Escanor he’d be 110K at dawn(weaker than Mel), and 174K Late Morning.

He’d still have to waiting until Late Morning to beat Assault Meliodas even with a 60K base, and base Mael is probably even weaker than that. We have no idea how much his demon mark was contributing to his strength stat.

The Demons have more high class fighters as of right now.

All of the commandmnets are worthless. Tarmiel and Sariel could trap all of them in the Enlil dimension and none of them could escape. But even then they still have more battle power.

Mel - 142K.

Cusack - 90K+

Chandler - 90K+

Zeldris - Hard to peg probably stronger than Cusack and Chandler when activating his second mark.

5 Indura’s all over 100K.

That’s 9 potential fighters that have 90K or more.

Probably even 10 when you factor in this personal servant to the DK that Mel said he used to have.

The goddesses had 4.
That’s why I keep high balling the fuck out of Mael because the Demon Clan is fucking ridiculous in terms of their strength to number ratio

They’d comepletly destroy the Goddess

Mael had to be as strong as I think he is or this shit would make no sense
 

Dio-wilo13

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
202
Reaction score
266
Age
29
Country
Switzerland
Rivals, yes, even tho, he has zero chance to get Elizabeth.

Equals? Nope, Meliodas is stronger than him most of the time and he takes the lead at noon.
It doesn’t matter, I’m talking about a « summarize of his power ». And plus power isn’t everything. They’re equal, if they weren’t, there wouldn’t have a balance of power. They’re in the same league. It’s smarter to talk about league rather that power levels
 

sobreno

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
5,379
Reaction score
3,058
Country
Djibouti
It doesn’t matter, I’m talking about a « summarize of his power ». And plus power isn’t everything. They’re equal, if they weren’t, there wouldn’t have a balance of power. They’re in the same league. It’s smarter to talk about league rather that power levels
But nowhere it is stated that they were equals, we know that Mael is stronger than Meliodas at noon and he is stronger than him the rest of the time.

Of course, that is Meliodas without his Indura or whatever true form he has.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Chandler and Cusack were asspulls made to give Zeldris a chance in this arc. It's a poor choice, but at this point it would make no sense if the goddesses only had four angels capable of doing something.


But the fact that Meliodas fought Mael implies he at least had an idea of his power. Monspeet seemingly never fought Sariel before.

Mael without a Grace would be easy prey for the highest demons, to say the least.


Depends on the hour.
Even if so, Sunshine gives Mael immense durability not to mention his Goddess clan healing powers

It’d be impossible to kill him

The only way to lowball Mael for arguments sake would be to make him fodder at base/night and have 0 access to Goddess healing/Ark

That’s the only way

Even if Nakaba goes that route it wouldn’t make sense

Why did the Goddesses rely on Mael so much if Meliodas could’ve just killed him at anytime before noon ?

Why didn’t the SD give Sun to Ludociel or somebody with a high base ?

It all depends

Maybe Sunshine users have to be super weak and useless in order to inherit the power

It’s either Mael was useless at night exactly like Escanor or he was an Arc Angel level warrior at based who held the fate of his entire Clan when the sun came up
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Meliodas should not be equal to Mael in power

That is not how the power balance works
 

Dio-wilo13

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
202
Reaction score
266
Age
29
Country
Switzerland
But nowhere it is stated that they were equals, we know that Mael is stronger than Meliodas at noon and he is stronger than him the rest of the time.

Of course, that is Meliodas without his Indura or whatever true form he has.
It doesn’t have to be stated. Both clans were equal, it’s safe to say that the strongest warriors were in the same league. But in fact, it doesn’t really matter. Luduciel is said to be stronger than Mael most of the time even if Mael has a higher peak. Talking about pure power is not the right thing in a manga like NNT
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Even if so, Sunshine gives Mael immense durability not to mention his Goddess clan healing powers
I know, but we saw how effortlessly Meliodas was overcoming that durability with a single punch. Mael would recover faster, but it's not like he doesn't feel pain - Meliodas could kill him at the same power level as Escanor.

The only way to lowball Mael for arguments sake would be to make him fodder at base/night and have 0 access to Goddess healing/Ark
Not necessarily. If he were 60,000 at base, he'd be at about 120,000 in the morning. Meliodas would defeat him until about 10:30 or 11:00.

Why did the Goddesses rely on Mael so much if Meliodas could’ve just killed him at anytime before noon ?
He couldn't. I never said that. I'm saying they were stalemated at sometime between 10 and 11.
 

Dio-wilo13

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
202
Reaction score
266
Age
29
Country
Switzerland
Even if so, Sunshine gives Mael immense durability not to mention his Goddess clan healing powers

It’d be impossible to kill him

The only way to lowball Mael for arguments sake would be to make him fodder at base/night and have 0 access to Goddess healing/Ark

That’s the only way

Even if Nakaba goes that route it wouldn’t make sense

Why did the Goddesses rely on Mael so much if Meliodas could’ve just killed him at anytime before noon ?

Why didn’t the SD give Sun to Ludociel or somebody with a high base ?

It all depends

Maybe Sunshine users have to be super weak and useless in order to inherit the power

It’s either Mael was useless at night exactly like Escanor or he was an Arc Angel level warrior at based who held the fate of his entire Clan when the sun came up
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Meliodas should not be equal to Mael in power

That is not how the power balance works
It would be awesome if Sunshine chooses his host
 

Chibi Moon

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
118
Reaction score
340
Country
United Kingdom
That’s what I’m saying

I’m not talking about PL numbers but as soon an SunShine kicks in Mael should be impossible to kill point blank period simply because of Sunshine’s Durability, Escanor was able to tank blows that shatter mountains early in the morning when his PL was 50k WHEN HE FOUGHT GALAN, that was BEFORE 11:00AM

If Mael’s base was 60k to 80k+ that’d mean he’d be 150k+ as soon as it hit 11:00am where in Escanor’s case he’d normally be at 114k
"I'm not talking about PL numbers" Starts to talk about PL numbers. Dude calm down.
Galand has a PL of 27k who cares if he got beat lol. The commandment give Mael a power boost so it is unlikely he started at 60k. If Mel goes AM it gives him 142k. So in theory Mael doesn't start with a base of 60k they could have similar PL at 11am. Where have you got this 6 hour unbeatable window?
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
"I'm not talking about PL numbers" Starts to talk about PL numbers. Dude calm down.
Galand has a PL of 27k who cares if he got beat lol. The commandment give Mael a power boost so it is unlikely he started at 60k. If Mel goes AM it gives him 142k. So in theory Mael doesn't start with a base of 60k they could have similar PL at 11am. Where have you got this 6 hour unbeatable window?
Because of the durability and instantaneous healing

That’s what I meant

Even if his PL isn’t high enough to match blows with Meliodas, he’s impossible to kill
 
Last edited:

Dio-wilo13

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
202
Reaction score
266
Age
29
Country
Switzerland
"I'm not talking about PL numbers" Starts to talk about PL numbers. Dude calm down.
Galand has a PL of 27k who cares if he got beat lol. The commandment give Mael a power boost so it is unlikely he started at 60k. If Mel goes AM it gives him 142k. So in theory Mael doesn't start with a base of 60k they could have similar PL at 11am. Where have you got this 6 hour unbeatable window?
Mael should be at 53K since « Estarossa’s » physical strenght is so. Even without Sunshine, the Love only gave him POD not his strenght
 

Chibi Moon

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
May 17, 2018
Messages
118
Reaction score
340
Country
United Kingdom
Because of the durability and instantaneous healing

That’s what I meant

Even if his PL isn’t high enough to match blows with Meliodas, he’s impossible to kill
Mel is durable. You talk about instantaneous healing like it isn't affected by a person becoming tired or worn down. Everything becomes more harder to do when you're tired - even breathing becomes laborious. Mel has the ability to run him down. Dude they are quite likely equal.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I know, but we saw how effortlessly Meliodas was overcoming that durability with a single punch. Mael would recover faster, but it's not like he doesn't feel pain - Meliodas could kill him at the same power level as Escanor.


Not necessarily. If he were 60,000 at base, he'd be at about 120,000 in the morning. Meliodas would defeat him until about 10:30 or 11:00.


He couldn't. I never said that. I'm saying they were stalemated at sometime between 10 and 11.
That’s IF his base is 60k

With the new spoiler summary he could be 80k+ base

Plus shouldn’t Mael be more versatile with sunshine ? Maybe he has a higher skill set + moveset oppose to Escanor
 
Top