Discussion Mael vs Meliodas | SPOILERS OUT !!!!!!!

Who will win ?

  • Meliodas

    Votes: 15 24.2%
  • Mael

    Votes: 12 19.4%
  • Someone will interrupt

    Votes: 23 37.1%
  • The battle will end in a tie

    Votes: 12 19.4%

  • Total voters
    62
  • Poll closed .

Bøjan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
817
Reaction score
1,111
Gender
Male
Country
Macedonia
You're right, but TarXan claims that the Demon has 20+ elite Warriors that means including the Six Black Knights. And She only included 4 Goddes AA, so I also included the Divine Lance Corporal which is equivalent to Six Black Knights ...
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Isn't it unfair if Six Black Knights is included, while the Divine Lance Corporal is forgotten ??
The demons have way more elites and also the Divine Lance Corporal are fodders..
Btw is TarXaN a female? Lol
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I get what you're saying, but there's a problem. AM Mel is MUCH stronger than the Commandments, going by your logic Mael at some point is MUCH stronger than AM Mel. That would mean that he would've been able to literally oneshot them all at once....doesn't make much sense to me :hmm
You’re literally missing the point

Despite Mel’s immense strength, when he defected, the Demon clan still held their own

His existence wasn’t as crucial as Mael’s

Mael death literally flipped the entire power balance
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
It doesn’t make any sense because he’s not that strong.

The fact that Tarmiel/Sariel are able to overpower and restrain him together, even while he’s amped with 3C’s already proves that. He had to guilt tripe Tarmiel into letting him go. He was completely cornered.

He was weaker than them to begin with, and became marginally stronger than either with his amps.

He wasn’t able to casually kill them until he absorbed 4C’s, and one of his casual blasts oneshot Tarmiel.

If he was even Ludo level(100K) without amps just the 28K from Galan’s 1 single commandment would make him almost 130K. Let alone 3C’s.
This makes 0 sense

That’s like me lowballing Meliodas because he got injured by a slap from Elizabeth

Sarmiel and Tarmiel used all of their might to restrain Mael

Also Mael shoving in the Commandments into his body isn’t the same as Meliodas absorbing them the correct way and assimilating them into raw power
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Mael with the Commandments shouldn’t be comparable with when he has the sun grace
 

Bøjan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
817
Reaction score
1,111
Gender
Male
Country
Macedonia
Mael with the Commandments shouldn’t be comparable with when he has the sun grace
I go with Estarossa base = Mael base without Sun. Which means lower than 60k ( because 60k was with demon mark), so 45-50 probably. They should be more or less the same, 4c Mael is probably 11:59 Mael with Sun or something. Going by Mael's peak being on AM Meliodas' level.
 

LaserBeam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2017
Messages
1,791
Reaction score
1,984
Age
40
Country
Greece
You’re literally missing the point

Despite Mel’s immense strength, when he defected, the Demon clan still held their own

His existence wasn’t as crucial as Mael’s

Mael death literally flipped the entire power balance
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


This makes 0 sense

That’s like me lowballing Meliodas because he got injured by a slap from Elizabeth

Sarmiel and Tarmiel used all of their might to restrain Mael

Also Mael shoving in the Commandments into his body isn’t the same as Meliodas absorbing them the correct way and assimilating them into raw power
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Mael with the Commandments shouldn’t be comparable with when he has the sun grace

Escanor defeated meliodas with the one and escanor basic power lvl is 15 he is weaker than hawk who is at 30 mael on the other hand his base power must be at least 30 -40k i would say that perhaps mael and meliodas never had a real 1 vs 1 fight because if the inferior version escanor was capable of beating meliodas with just one move well mael with the grace i bet he would had done the same but a lot of time pre peak.

I would say that mael with the grace was stronger than meliodas the guy lost by escanor .

My explanation of why the demons sides didn't crumbled away after losing his best card while the goddess did was because the demons had More overrall players with greater power than the goddesses.

The demon side had the 10 commandments + 2 masters and the goddess had the 4 archangels but from the 10 commandments if we exclude the ones meliodas killed and the guy that was replaced by mael as estarossa and he is probably that dude friend of gallant that was turned into indura but was locked away.

You have 7 commandments against 3 of the archangels each archangel is as strong as 2 commandments or bit stronger so this means the 3 archangels sariel , tarmiel and ruoduciel were equal as 6 commandments in terms of power maybe a bit stronger but the demon side also had the 2 masters who zeldris hyped that those 2 alone would fill the voice of have 8 of them missing which means that cusack and chandler should be as strong as 3 -4 commandments each and perhaps 1 master can fight equally with 2 archangels.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I go with Estarossa base = Mael base without Sun. Which means lower than 60k ( because 60k was with demon mark), so 45-50 probably. They should be more or less the same, 4c Mael is probably 11:59 Mael with Sun or something. Going by Mael's peak being on AM Meliodas' level.
This literally makes no sense

Why would the SD give her strongest Grace to her weakest warrior ?

The last sentence is so disrespectful, Escanor literally turned Mel into a bitch at his peak and you think Mael is 142k at noon ?

Lol ok
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Escanor defeated meliodas with the one and escanor basic power lvl is 15 he is weaker than hawk who is at 30 mael on the other hand his base power must be at least 30 -40k i would say that perhaps mael and meliodas never had a real 1 vs 1 fight because if the inferior version escanor was capable of beating meliodas with just one move well mael with the grace i bet he would had done the same but a lot of time pre peak.

I would say that mael with the grace was stronger than meliodas the guy lost by escanor .

My explanation of why the demons sides didn't crumbled away after losing his best card while the goddess did was because the demons had More overrall players with greater power than the goddesses.

The demon side had the 10 commandments + 2 masters and the goddess had the 4 archangels but from the 10 commandments if we exclude the ones meliodas killed and the guy that was replaced by mael as estarossa and he is probably that dude friend of gallant that was turned into indura but was locked away.

You have 7 commandments against 3 of the archangels each archangel is as strong as 2 commandments or bit stronger so this means the 3 archangels sariel , tarmiel and ruoduciel were equal as 6 commandments in terms of power maybe a bit stronger but the demon side also had the 2 masters who zeldris hyped that those 2 alone would fill the voice of have 8 of them missing which means that cusack and chandler should be as strong as 3 -4 commandments each and perhaps 1 master can fight equally with 2 archangels.
Meliodas

9 Commandments

Zeldris

Masters

6 Black Knights

Fraudrin, Boruja and other elite demons

Vs

4 Arc Angels

Mael bridged that gap by himself

His base is most likely AA level or higher

Like Mael is confirmed stronger than Estarossa
 

Charon913155

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2018
Messages
204
Reaction score
97
Age
36
Country
Germany
This literally makes no sense

Why would the SD give her strongest Grace to her weakest warrior ?

The last sentence is so disrespectful, Escanor literally turned Mel into a bitch at his peak and you think Mael is 142k at noon ?

Lol ok
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


Meliodas

9 Commandments

Zeldris

Masters

6 Black Knights

Fraudrin, Boruja and other elite demons

Vs

4 Arc Angels

Mael bridged that gap by himself

His base is most likely AA level or higher

Like Mael is confirmed stronger than Estarossa
The SD gave Mael the grace because she pitied him, since he was so weak.

Mael most prominent character trait is his insatiable hunger for power as a result of his own lack of power. Mael was always being bullied for his lack of power until he got the grace. Then everyone started praising him, which is why he now hunts down the commandments to reclaim that feeling of supremacy.

I'm not saying he is necessarily fodder goddess level but Mael being AA level on his own wouldn't make sense for this character.
 

Surge44

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2018
Messages
190
Reaction score
444
Age
34
Country
United States
I go with Estarossa base = Mael base without Sun. Which means lower than 60k ( because 60k was with demon mark), so 45-50 probably. They should be more or less the same, 4c Mael is probably 11:59 Mael with Sun or something. Going by Mael's peak being on AM Meliodas' level.
I think base Mael is above and beyond base esta. just off the fact that his primary power (Goddess) was being suppressed and once he woke up he just stomped. Sort of like Eliz unlocking her goddess powers and becoming a whole lot stronger.


The SD gave Mael the grace because she pitied him, since he was so weak.

Mael most prominent character trait is his insatiable hunger for power as a result of his own lack of power. Mael was always being bullied for his lack of power until he got the grace. Then everyone started praising him, which is why he now hunts down the commandments to reclaim that feeling of supremacy.

I'm not saying he is necessarily fodder goddess level but Mael being AA level on his own wouldn't make sense for this character.
Is this confirmed or headcannon? Im under the impression after being motivated to end the war + trying to make his brother proud he became strong to the point the supreme deity bestowed Sun unto him to be there shining hope to destroy the demon clan.Becoming the Angel of Death before or after receiving it idk probably after.
 
Last edited:

Charon913155

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2018
Messages
204
Reaction score
97
Age
36
Country
Germany
I think base Mael is above and beyond base esta. just off the fact that his primary power (Goddess) was being suppressed and once he woke up he just stomped. Sort of like Eliz unlocking her goddess powers and becoming a whole lot stronger.




Is this confirmed or headcannon? Im under the impression after being motivated to end the war + trying to make his brother proud he became strong to the point the supreme deity bestowed Sun unto him to be there shining hope to destroy the demon clan.Becoming the Angel of Death before or after receiving it idk probably after.
The parts about him being bullied for being weak and being praised after optaining sunshine are definitely confirmed.
The part about the SD pitying him was told to us by Monspeet, only he said it was the DK but it doesn't seem like Gowther made up some entirely new backstory for Estarossa.
He just switched around demons and goddesses in Maels. So the SD would have been the one to pity him which fits with the rest of his backstory.
The rest, I have to admit, is just my humble analysis of Maels behavior in the current arc.
But think of this, why would Mael be this obsessed with gaining power if he was already strong on his own?

Also if Maels PL was already 60 K+ on his own he would have been at 110 K+ already in the morning, which means he could have beaten Mel all throghout the day, add to that the fact that none of the 10C, except for maybe Zeldris, can hold a candle to any of the AA, and the goddesses have the clear advantage, meaning they should have been able to crush the demons even without Mels desertion.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The SD gave Mael the grace because she pitied him, since he was so weak.

Mael most prominent character trait is his insatiable hunger for power as a result of his own lack of power. Mael was always being bullied for his lack of power until he got the grace. Then everyone started praising him, which is why he now hunts down the commandments to reclaim that feeling of supremacy.

I'm not saying he is necessarily fodder goddess level but Mael being AA level on his own wouldn't make sense for this character.
The first sentence is literally head cannon

Please post the panel where the SD pitied Mael and gave him sun ?

Sariel called him the strongest Arc Angel 2 chapters ago

This is Mael without Sun

Y’all are so weird, it’s like there’s some denial going on
 

Charon913155

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2018
Messages
204
Reaction score
97
Age
36
Country
Germany
The first sentence is literally head cannon

Please post the panel where the SD pitied Mael and gave him sun ?

Sariel called him the strongest Arc Angel 2 chapters ago

This is Mael without Sun

Y’all are so weird, it’s like there’s some denial going on
Every other detail of Estarossas back story was also part of Maels backstory. Why should this be the exception?

Mael had Sun. Unless it works differently than Sunshine, which we have no reason to believe, that already made him the strongest AA. No need to pull a ridiculously high base PL out of thin air.

But lets entertain your claim and do the maths.

Estarossas base is 60K, we take 28K away from that because of Love and we are left with 32K as Maels minimum PL.

AA level seems to begin at around 90K but since you claim he's already the strongest one on his own lets say his base is 100-110K.

First we will now add the Sun Grace to that which raises his max PL to:
150K in the morning,
224K around 11 am and
252K+ around noon.

Now these are already ridiculously high numbers but lets go ahead and look at the current situation as well.

So Mael starts out at 60K takes in a commandment and gets to 88K. He then eats another, raises his PL, presumably to 116K, and starts to overpower stigma. Shortly after he regains his original identity and by the look of it his original powers as well, returning the 78K power difference back to him and further raising his PL to 194K. Odd then that he doesn't completely destroy the SD-squad but actually gets overpowered himself until he takes in a fourth commandment and raises his PL yet again to 222K.

So in conclusion:
4C Mael: 222K
Sun Mael: 110-252+K

Are you really going with this, because this sounds absurd.
 
Last edited:

Bøjan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
817
Reaction score
1,111
Gender
Male
Country
Macedonia
This literally makes no sense

Why would the SD give her strongest Grace to her weakest warrior ?

The last sentence is so disrespectful, Escanor literally turned Mel into a bitch at his peak and you think Mael is 142k at noon ?

Lol ok
I think base Mael is above and beyond base esta. just off the fact that his primary power (Goddess) was being suppressed and once he woke up he just stomped. Sort of like Eliz unlocking her goddess powers and becoming a whole lot stronger.
Mael and Meliodas are rivals, one of the meanings of "rivals" is equals. It doesn't make sense if Nakaba said that they are equals he probably meant at their peak. Meliodas' peak is AM, and if Mael at base is strong enough to not be oneshotted by him means that he had to be 140k+. So any time of the day Mael stomps Meliodas but they are rivals (equals) i'm sorry but please explain to me how that works and makes sense...
 

Surge44

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2018
Messages
190
Reaction score
444
Age
34
Country
United States
Mael and Meliodas are rivals, one of the meanings of "rivals" is equals. It doesn't make sense if Nakaba said that they are equals he probably meant at their peak. Meliodas' peak is AM, and if Mael at base is strong enough to not be oneshotted by him means that he had to be 140k+. So any time of the day Mael stomps Meliodas but they are rivals (equals) i'm sorry but please explain to me how that works and makes sense...
We aren’t sure if Sunshine had the drastic increase in power for Mael that it does for Escanor. But even so it could be for half the day Meliodas has the advantage, whereas the other half Mael does. We can interpret that as being equals. Also did Mel have the love commandment when he was the leader and fought Mael? Because then we can see that as a boost in power for him. That’s how that would work.

If the movie doesn’t give us a clearer image then either we need to see him purged of commandments or a data book needs to be released.
 

LaserBeam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2017
Messages
1,791
Reaction score
1,984
Age
40
Country
Greece
This literally makes no sense

Why would the SD give her strongest Grace to her weakest warrior ?

The last sentence is so disrespectful, Escanor literally turned Mel into a bitch at his peak and you think Mael is 142k at noon ?

Lol ok
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---


Meliodas

9 Commandments

Zeldris

Masters

6 Black Knights

Fraudrin, Boruja and other elite demons

Vs

4 Arc Angels

Mael bridged that gap by himself

His base is most likely AA level or higher

Like Mael is confirmed stronger than Estarossa
if mael is as strong as 4 commandments and the rest of the aa = the remaning 6 well 4 aa = 10 commandments

as far as we know the nerobasta lvl of archangels are black knights lvl at best plus the goddess clan do not have guys of the lvl of the 2 masters.

In general the goddess have the quality but not the quantity (numbers) the demons have quality and quantity (many powerful individuals )
 

Isaiah Thomas

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2016
Messages
411
Reaction score
308
Age
31
Country
United States
What day should we anticipate this?
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Every other detail of Estarossas back story was also part of Maels backstory. Why should this be the exception?

Mael had Sun. Unless it works differently than Sunshine, which we have no reason to believe, that already made him the strongest AA. No need to pull a ridiculously high base PL out of thin air.

But lets entertain your claim and do the maths.

Estarossas base is 60K, we take 28K away from that because of Love and we are left with 32K as Maels minimum PL.

AA level seems to begin at around 90K but since you claim he's already the strongest one on his own lets say his base is 100-110K.

First we will now add the Sun Grace to that which raises his max PL to:
150K in the morning,
224K around 11 am and
252K+ around noon.

Now these are already ridiculously high numbers but lets go ahead and look at the current situation as well.

So Mael starts out at 60K takes in a commandment and gets to 88K. He then eats another, raises his PL, presumably to 116K, and starts to overpower stigma. Shortly after he regains his original identity and by the look of it his original powers as well, returning the 78K power difference back to him and further raising his PL to 194K. Odd then that he doesn't completely destroy the SD-squad but actually gets overpowered himself until he takes in a fourth commandment and raises his PL yet again to 222K.

So in conclusion:
4C Mael: 222K
Sun Mael: 110-252+K

Are you really going with this, because this sounds absurd.
This is literally all headcannon

From your interpretation of Mael’s supposed “ origin “ up till the calculations on the PL numbers

I’m not saying Mael is 200k or 100k at night but I wouldn’t be surprised if he was

Like everything Nakaba has given us points to Mael being ridiculous

1. He trained to become the strongest Arc Angel

Fact

2. Sariel confirmed he can control 3 Commandments because he’s the strongest AA (he didn’t even have Sunshine active)

Fact

3. His existence single handedly kept his clan together and maintained the power balance for the Angels

Fact

4. He was feared by the Demon Clan

Fact

5. Ludociel confirmed Mael would be the man to surpass him

Fact

6. Gowther confirmed he was the strongest fighter in the holy war

Fact

All I’m saying is Mael’s strongest form would’ve overpowered AM Meliodas in the Holy War and that’s a major fact

Escanor didn’t it effortlessly and he’s fodder at night

Even if Mael was 45k base (which makes no fucking sense because all the demons would just attack a night) by early morning he’d be 100k+ because Escanor hit 50k facing Galan early in the morning

Regardless on how you spin it, Mael was the strongest
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Mael and Meliodas are rivals, one of the meanings of "rivals" is equals. It doesn't make sense if Nakaba said that they are equals he probably meant at their peak. Meliodas' peak is AM, and if Mael at base is strong enough to not be oneshotted by him means that he had to be 140k+. So any time of the day Mael stomps Meliodas but they are rivals (equals) i'm sorry but please explain to me how that works and makes sense...
You’re just nitpicking the incorrect definition to fit your head canon

It makes perfect sense

Mel has access to 142k levels of power 24/7 with literally 0 consequences, meaning he could unleash his full power whenever he wanted on any opponent

Mael on the other hand became the strongest only when the sun was out

If Mael was the only thing keeping the power balance for his clan, the Demons would’ve killed him when it was night or just using True Night whenever he was on the battlefield

Mael has to be strong enough to keep Meliodas from slaughtering everyone during the day as well as be strong enough to avoid getting Sunshine’s weakness exploited
 

Charon913155

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2018
Messages
204
Reaction score
97
Age
36
Country
Germany
This is literally all headcannon

From your interpretation of Mael’s supposed “ origin “ up till the calculations on the PL numbers
Of course this is all headcannon, it's yours after all. I'm just showing you that your headcannon makes no sense when we use the Numbers gives in the manga on it.

I’m not saying Mael is 200k or 100k at night but I wouldn’t be surprised if he was
You are saying he is already the strongest AA without the Sun, so yeah you are saying that.

Like everything Nakaba has given us points to Mael being ridiculous
Not this ridiculous. After all, Mel was still enough to keep the goddess clan at bay.

1. He trained to become the strongest Arc Angel

Fact
Since when?

2. Sariel confirmed he can control 3 Commandments because he’s the strongest AA (he didn’t even have Sunshine active)

Fact
Well he was at some point. He had Sun after all.

3. His existence single handedly kept his clan together and maintained the power balance for the Angels

Fact
He had the Sun grace.

4. He was feared by the Demon Clan

Fact
He had the Sun grace.

5. Ludociel confirmed Mael would be the man to surpass him

Fact
He also said he himself was still the strongest until noon.

6. Gowther confirmed he was the strongest fighter in the holy war

Fact
He had the Sun grace.

All I’m saying is Mael’s strongest form would’ve overpowered AM Meliodas in the Holy War and that’s a major fact

Escanor didn’t it effortlessly and he’s fodder at night
Sure, around noon, I'm not arguing with that.

(which makes no fucking sense because all the demons would just attack a night)
Same goes for the goddess clan during the day.

Even if Mael was 45k base (which makes no fucking sense because all the demons would just attack a night) by early morning he’d be 100k+ because Escanor hit 50k facing Galan early in the morning

Regardless on how you spin it, Mael was the strongest
That checks out far better with whats been established in the Manga, then your claim that he's the strongest AA regardless of time.
 

Zeldris-sama

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
May 8, 2018
Messages
127
Reaction score
93
Age
30
Country
Indonesia
OK, we make a summary:
Members of the Demon and Goddes Clan that we know (best)

DEMON:
Demon King
Meliodas
Zeldris
10 Commands (Indura)
2 masters
Six Black Knights

GODDESS:
Supreme Goddess
Elizabeth
4 ArchAngel
Divine Lance Corporal


That is a member who can make the balance between the two clans =
#DK is clearly the equivalent of SG
#Meliodas = Mael they should be balanced, but some say Mael is stronger, Okay Mael is stronger but only when "The One" becomes more than "The One" they are balanced.
# We consider Zeldris balanced with Elizabeth
# 10 Commandments (including Meliodas) with 4 AA (Including Mael)
# 2 Masters >>> This is still confusing and makes it unbalanced, why does the Demon have a very strong Masters ?? It is possible that Nakaba will show the Masters from the Goddes Clan, it should be there sometime.
#Six Black Knights is balanced with Divine Lance Corporal.

That according to my conclusion ...
 
Top