Arjuna claimed to be Hider iirc.
Yeah and next phase you'd be all like "Gry was a real Traitor man, cmon it was obvious" while taking James' result as confirmation when I was naive
A stupid and risky plan, but not the worst one you had.
Yeah, I feel you. At the same time, you basically alrdy heavily implied I'm on your list... Why did I get a different treatment from the other ones?
That's also odd. I'm a traitor as well, I got a single name in my list. Something Greg said made me think he's legit in his traitor claim and well, and the way James conducted the whole theory and the fact he said first he only has one name makes me believe in him as well. Kato might have been a fourth person with a single name in the list. I know for sure some other people aren't traitors (like Demon, being unfamiliar with how Greg wrote about being one. meaning he didn't get the same thing, or he'd know). So we have at least one case, which makes Hardy's case look less odd. On the other hand, we only got a single traitor with more than 1 name in his list, which is you.
That's false.
You also can't be recruited by masons or third parties, you're pretty much mafia in that case. The only difference is that you can't win as townie and will also lose if you don't join a mafia party. So you're not only capable of joining them and changing their numbers, but you also won't count on ours for the victory condition. It's hard to see an experienced host making a distorted affirmation like that o.o
Not to that part you didn't. But I guess it's inconvenient answering everything
Gets more complicated for you.
No, next phase I'll be like "Gry was a mafia, gj everyone, let's piss on his grave".Yeah and next phase you'd be all like "Gry was a real Traitor man, cmon it was obvious" while taking James' result as confirmation when I was naive
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Uhm actually I can't find the post with my reply, maybe it got lost from multiposting sorry. Meant that you are taking yourself being in his traitor list as a fact.Not to that part you didn't. But I guess it's inconvenient answering everything
Because you pushed for it the most. I'd actually be hoping on you not being mafia so I'm naive, to explain why you were so eager for a potential Traitor to say more. Or maybe you didn't expect to hear your name on it, but I'm hoping it's the former.
My guess is it's related to the person's role, as well as simple lying. Now that it's a trend everyone would claim to have only 1 name on it, much easier. I could've done that too, but I didn't. I questioned half or all of us being Traitors ever since early day 1, mainly because I couldn't believe I'd get a fun secondary role like that in addition to a new role I never had. It's a lot easier for everyone now to blend in with having only 1 person, so it'll be impossible telling who's legit even if everyone claims theirs. Is how I see this game go from now, I won't participate in that mess.
If I'm a real traitor though. I am still counting on me being naive, and until I know for sure I can only play along with town and try lynching mafias. Ideally I'd have wanted one of my 3 people to die so I know, but...
Nice retort. But I already said about it at the start of day phase. He'd share if it was based on his BK results, or if he had a random hunch. Him dying as Traitor more likely means I was on his list, and I was confused why he only would mention me there. But it's most likely he had me as his "contact".
Just to make sure, but I wasn't on that list, right?^^;
Ok, just so we're all clear on the new claims xD
No.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
What a mess.
Yep.Btw what is the name on your list?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Yeah, that was also my thought as well, that basically ALL townies are traitors, most ofc naive but none of the Mafias CAN be a traitor so if they claim they aren't traitors and we end up lynching them then being a traitor is actually a way to hide yourself. And so far we have far more 1 name traitors than 3 name traitors or no traitors so I wouldn't wonder if this was what Panda made go all "huehuehue" when creating that game and giving every townie a 2nd traitor role.No.
Actually so far Hardy is the only person who claimed not to be a Traitor. If everyone is a Traitor then the only people who'd claim not to be one would be mafias--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
From your point of view either Gry or me (or both) is a bastard or baby bastard so you know Panda didn't go full troll (just very troll).
Right. Didn't think it could actually get worse than the Umineko mayhem. I've also been thinking, that putting a Santa into this game would be very good too because we start with N0. Effectively buffing him by needing to survive 1 day less.
Tbf to Panda, I would never put it past him to go full troll. xD
I pushed you to reveal your list - in spite of its content - or at least the numbers. Giving my name alone was rly unecessary, and it contradicts you saying you didn't want to say anything or that giving away mafia kills the game. And nah, I'm fine with it, since I was the one to ask you to do it anyway. As I said, it's just an odd chain of actions if you ask me.
It would have been useless if you had, tbh. You alrdy implied at the beginning of this whole conversation you didn't have a single name, even before James shared his list. You seemed to also miss the fact that Greg claimed the same, since you only listed James and Kato (this one as an opinion). So you didn't know about this trend back then, and wouldn't match you first comments on the matter.
Yeah, Gry, but you tried to feed us more than once with the idea you could still play with us in spite of your alignment...
If you're considering your death before a recruitment to be a condition to win as town, you'd have to be naive... you can't be sane.
if that were the case we would have somebody come out with a present after two nights. Plus some presents would be there to make finding Santa easier yet nobody came out so far.
Vandred
