Discussion Mael and Meliodas

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Mael might've retreated because he was on the decline and could tell Mel was holding back. If night was only an hour or so away i wouldnt want to stick around.

That just means they function similarly, not that they're identical.

No they arent, we have already seen a huge difference between the two. Sunshine alters Escanor physically and mentally to an incredible degree as well as increases his PL, Sun on the other hand merely increases PL.
Logically Mael's use of it should be superior, sure, just like logically Merlin shouldnt be relevant with her supposed 4k PL, just likely logically Diane shouldnt be able to dance almost up to Dolor's level, just like logically King shouldnt have effortlessly shat on Mael a couple of chapters ago, Escanor is a Sin, and Sins are better than everyone else.
Bro Ludociel acknowledged Escanor’s transformation from a skinny whimp to a masculine power house

He didn’t question it at all

If anything Mael’s transformations should be more noticeable towards the afternoon since he’s already built

The Sun Grace alters Escanor’s personality because he has no mastery over it or it’s power
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Or maybe you should provide more evidence for your claim right here, because last time i checked Tarmiel said he and Sariel are worth 2 commandments each, not that "without Mel the commandments are nothing to them". In fact the demons would have succeeded in sealing off the goddesses and unleashing the demons on Stigma if it wasnt for Gowther and old Gowther doing their own plan, so i guess there goes your whole theory of "Mel switching sides=goddesses win", demon infighting was a bigger hindrance than Meliodas' defection lol.
What are u talking about??? Why is tarmiel and sariel in this conversation??? Your argument is just grabbing straws at this point without backing what you're saying to address my actual point. You do realize that gowther sealed both sides right??? He used his last resort magic to force goddess clan to seal the demon clan so in return their bodies will be gone hence they took millenia to just being conscious and possessing someone. So gowther qasnt contributing on both sides, so you clearly just grabbing straws at this point and does not know what you're talking about. So you kept quoting what I already explained because u can't provide any sources thanks for the reminder.
 

TarXan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
2,479
Reaction score
3,872
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It all depends on his base PL.

Assuming he's around Ludoshel or Elizabeth level he should be around 90-100k.

And we don't have the specific time they met. Was it really dawn?
It was most likely early morning

Either way Mael should be on that level, he’s either stronger than Ludociel or extremely close and surpasses him with the Sun Grace
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
The fact that a 60k character like Estarossa was seen as a fitting replacement for Mel is already enough to say that the impact of Mel switching sides had more to do with his reputation than his actual strength.
You do realize that mael was a goddess who absorbed a commandment right?? They thought it would be a good idea since it's a "commandment after all'. In fact it was also revealed even when king fought mael that commandments and his goddess nature are being opposite to each other. Clearly light and dark should not go together. You just got debunked without providing any sense of logical arguments.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It all depends on his base PL.

Assuming he's around Ludoshel or Elizabeth level he should be around 90-100k.

And we don't have the specific time they met. Was it really dawn?
Well even if it was Dawn or afternoon the grace is still active till the sun goes down and by that point it can’t be used. So going off of the fact that it’s still useable and able to generate a lot of power at worst it would early afternoon, in which case Mael would still roughly have the same power minus the one and he should still be able to overwhelm non assault Mel. Assault Mel would be a different story
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
It was most likely early morning

Either way Mael should be on that level, he’s either stronger than Ludociel or extremely close and surpasses him with the Sun Grace
Meh Mael looks slightly weaker to Ludoshel without sunshine.

Well even if it was Dawn or afternoon the grace is still active till the sun goes down and by that point it can’t be used. So going off of the fact that it’s still useable and able to generate a lot of power at worst it would early afternoon, in which case Mael would still roughly have the same power minus the one and he should still be able to overwhelm non assault Mel. Assault Mel would be a different story
Meliodas can active assault mode at any time, hence Maels retreat despite Meliodas being only in second demon mark mode.
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Haha, you sure like the word ,"debunked", don't you? Too bad you haven't done anything more than say it. And no, the fact that i said Meliodas was beaten by The One means i've read the manga. Merlin also said that Meliodas had become as he was as the leader of the 10C back at the start of his fight with Escanor. And besides, in the panel you just gave it says Mel is growing even stronger than his previous levels, why wouldnt Mael be able to beat him if he was even weaker back then?
Merlin clearly stated that meliodas took the form when he lead the commandments. So no Merlin only specifically stated that meliodas was in his leader of 10C form which does not indicate his peak. So provide some sources to your claims without them getting debunked.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
Bro Ludociel acknowledged Escanor’s transformation from a skinny whimp to a masculine power house

He didn’t question it at all

If anything Mael’s transformations should be more noticeable towards the afternoon since he’s already built

The Sun Grace alters Escanor’s personality because he has no mastery over it or it’s power
And yet when we saw Mael confront Mel with Sunshine he looks exactly the same as he does right now without it.
Ok I already explained WHAT the quote means and you simply ignored and tried to twist what it says. Clearly they felt it was a dream and as soon as they knew about his betrayal. So this proves your comprehension is low and could not understand the meaning behind why would u think they were happy when he left? Because NOW THEY HAVE THE HOPE TO WIN IN THE WAR. the fact that these war demon clan vs all clans debunks that claim
You explained what you think it meant, nothing more. And there still isnt anything here that suggests the demons were winning.
What are u talking about??? Why is tarmiel and sariel in this conversation??? Your argument is just grabbing straws at this point without backing what you're saying to address my actual point. You do realize that gowther sealed both sides right??? He used his last resort magic to force goddess clan to seal the demon clan so in return their bodies will be gone hence they took millenia to just being conscious and possessing someone. So gowther qasnt contributing on both sides, so you clearly just grabbing straws at this point and does not know what you're talking about. So you kept quoting what I already explained because u can't provide any sources thanks for the reminder.
What are YOU talking about? You're the one who brought up the AA. As for the stuff with Gowther, you clearly didnt read my post properly, what was it you said about low comprehension? :teehee
You do realize that mael was a goddess who absorbed a commandment right?? They thought it would be a good idea since it's a "commandment after all'. In fact it was also revealed even when king fought mael that commandments and his goddess nature are being opposite to each other. Clearly light and dark should not go together. You just got debunked without providing any sense of logical arguments.
You do realize that has absolutely nothing to do with my actual point?
Merlin clearly stated that meliodas took the form when he lead the commandments. So no Merlin only specifically stated that meliodas was in his leader of 10C form which does not indicate his peak. So provide some sources to your claims without them getting debunked.
And what claims are those? That The One beat Mel's ass? Its in the manga. How about you provide a source that shows that Mel can last even a second against The One.
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
And yet when we saw Mael confront Mel with Sunshine he looks exactly the same as he does right now without it.


You explained what you think it meant, nothing more. And there still isnt anything here that suggests the demons were winning.
What are YOU talking about? You're the one who brought up the AA. As for the stuff with Gowther, you clearly didnt read my post properly, what was it you said about low comprehension? :teehee

You do realize that has absolutely nothing to do with my actual point?

And what claims are those? That The One beat Mel's ass? Its in the manga. How about you provide a source that shows that Mel can last even a second against The One.
Actually that does suggest demons were winning the whole time. Why did u think she specifically stated a win is like an impossible for them? So this impacts meliodas oen absent than mael the fact that goddess clan as you you logically trying to prove that mael is stronger but yet needs all clans by still isnt winning while meliodas was in the DC and in the battlefield. Clearly you cant process a thought in a debate

I never even mentioned the grace at all I mentioned Mael himself and archangels in the war not their fucking grace. You cant even read what I said way earlier.

Ok so what's your point?? That's why you can't even provide sources to prove your points cuz u know it's all headcanon thus far.
You EVEN implied earlier that meliodas is at his peak when I DEBUBKED that and said Merlin was only talking about meliodas in his form being the leader he was. It never stated meliodas at that fight was equal to when he led the commandments. So let me post a scan for you so you can clearly see. So this clearly FACTUALLY prove he wasnt at his old self when he led the commandments and proves Merlin was only talking about the form not meliodas power comparison to his old self as she even implied he was regressing to meliodas of old.

 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Meliodas can active assault mode at any time, hence Maels retreat despite Meliodas being only in second demon mark mode.
The point is though Mael should’ve easily killed him before that. Instead the two looked roughly equal. That still doesn’t add up
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
The point is though Mael should’ve easily killed him before that. Instead the two looked roughly equal. That still doesn’t add up
I mean.. they barely fought and we all know how big Nakaba's dick is for Meliodas.

So what happened isn't a complete surprise.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I mean.. they barely fought and we all know how big Nakaba's dick is for Meliodas.

So what happened isn't a complete surprise.
But look at what happened between Mel and Escanor when Escanor was more than 50K away. He was taken down with like two moves and that was a non serious Mel
 

lindananahayashida

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 5, 2018
Messages
1,110
Reaction score
1,737
Age
27
Country
Bangladesh
What if,

Sunshine max = 114k (any user)
(Exclude = T O)

Since,
Graces = equals (Should be)

If, Sunshine = base+114k

Then logically,
SS>> other grace,

But,
manga says,
Mael = strongest AA
=/= SS strongest grace

So,
Escanor = + 114k & abilities

while,
Mael = +14/20k & abilities


So,
Mael = 2nd M mel (w or w/o SS roughly)
While, TO mael> AM & AM >Mael
 
Last edited:

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
Actually that does suggest demons were winning the whole time. Why did u think she specifically stated a win is like an impossible for them? So this impacts meliodas oen absent than mael the fact that goddess clan as you you logically trying to prove that mael is stronger but yet needs all clans by still isnt winning while meliodas was in the DC and in the battlefield. Clearly you cant process a thought in a debate
Because the war has being going on for years with no end in sight? Just because they saw no way to win the war, doesnt mean they were losing it, if the goddesses actually thought they were losing they wouldve used the coffin like when Mael switched over
I never even mentioned the grace at all I mentioned Mael himself and archangels in the war not their fucking grace. You cant even read what I said way earlier.
Who said anything about graces? Certainly not me. You're all over the place lol.
Ok so what's your point?? That's why you can't even provide sources to prove your points cuz u know it's all headcanon thus far.
That Meliodas leaving and killing 2 commandments on his way out didnt mean an automatic win for the goddesses. Also that the impact Mel switching sides had on the war had more to do with reputation than power.
You EVEN implied earlier that meliodas is at his peak when I DEBUBKED that and said Merlin was only talking about meliodas in his form being the leader he was. It never stated meliodas at that fight was equal to when he led the commandments. So let me post a scan for you so you can clearly see. So this clearly FACTUALLY prove he wasnt at his old self when he led the commandments and proves Merlin was only talking about the form not meliodas power comparison to his old self as she even implied he was regressing to meliodas of old.

And why wouldnt i when the chapter i read said exactly that?
Is your translation official?
Now would you kindly provide the source that suggests that the Meliodas that had, and i quote, "just a little more" to regress, would somehow stand a chance against The One, a guy who oneshot him before.
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Because the war has being going on for years with no end in sight? Just because they saw no way to win the war, doesnt mean they were losing it, if the goddesses actually thought they were losing they wouldve used the coffin like when Mael switched over
Who said anything about graces? Certainly not me. You're all over the place lol.
That Meliodas leaving and killing 2 commandments on his way out didnt mean an automatic win for the goddesses. Also that the impact Mel switching sides had on the war had more to do with reputation than power.
And why wouldnt i when the chapter i read said exactly that? [/SPOILER] Is your translation official?
Now would you kindly provide the source that suggests that the Meliodas that had, and i quote, "just a little more" to regress, would somehow stand a chance against The One, a guy who oneshot him before.
Yeah the first one clearly does not address but you're going off with a tangent of "what ifs". So that argument of they could've used the coffin seal but you do realize everyone kept fighting despite all of that. The REASON why they were winning was all because of meliodas no1 from DC aside from DK or meliodas could oppose AAs. Omg "who was talking about grace, certainly not me" so if you look at my early premise I talked about mael and AAs not their grace equivalence to Commandments.

Him leaving THE CLAN had the impact on the goddess winninf. The fact that I brought up jelamets statement moots your argument here as she talks about their win. So you would have to prove me wrong using other sources that she isnt talking about their win when meliodas left.
Ok prove USING FACTUAL EVIDENCES that meliodas leaving was more on reputation. If you cant provide this is my win for your lack of evidence.

Ok since u said "little more step" was implying a little increase provide that claim, prove escanors PL or gap is 100k higher than 142k. If you're in this debate with me provide your assumptions with factual evidences. When Merlin states this when it meant to stop him at that level of strength. So this does not indicate the power gap being ab overrated as you're exaggerating. Also if you're talking about him one shotting meliodas when he needed tp use divine sword so you clearly didnt address my points. Also translation from crunchyroll
 

BurlapJack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2018
Messages
2,045
Reaction score
3,997
Gender
Male
Country
United States
What if mael's sunshine is more of a platau than a pyramid spike like escanor's usage? Like marl still rises in power but doesn't as high near noon (his pl with sunshine is greater than 114k escanor, but not by a ridiculous margin like ya'll like to think). YOU KNOW WHAT LEMME DRAW A CHART AND SHOW YOU ALL WHAT I MEAN
 

Tristan

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
2,725
Reaction score
2,376
Country
Germany
Now would you kindly provide the source that suggests that the Meliodas that had, and i quote, "just a little more" to regress, would somehow stand a chance against The One, a guy who oneshot him before.
You're just interpreting quotes so that they support your biased position in discussion. The fact says that between Escanor the One (11:59:00), and Escanor of 11:57 is much LESS than that ["a little more"] you keep quoting, but the power level between those two versions is FREAKING HUUUGE! Don't try to distort facts, Meliodas wasn't at his TOP + he was merely T-O-Y-I-N-G on the top of that!
That "little more" would have been more than enough to make the One jiggle around the Perfect Cube with a simple punch one more time.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Mael with Sunshine MUST have been waaaay stronger than Escanor. I don't understand why you keep discussing over such things!
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
You're just interpreting quotes so that they support your biased position in discussion. The fact says that between Escanor the One (11:59:00), and Escanor of 11:57 is much LESS than that ["a little more"] you keep quoting, but the power level between those two versions is FREAKING HUUUGE! Don't try to distort facts, Meliodas wasn't at his TOP + he was merely T-O-Y-I-N-G on the top of that!
That "little more" would have been more than enough to make the One jiggle around the Perfect Cube with a simple punch one more time.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Mael with Sunshine MUST have been waaaay stronger than Escanor. I don't understand why you keep discussing over such things!
I dont see how what i do is any different to the people saying Mel is stronger than he has shown. The One>>>Prime Meliodas
Yeah the first one clearly does not address but you're going off with a tangent of "what ifs". So that argument of they could've used the coffin seal but you do realize everyone kept fighting despite all of that. The REASON why they were winning was all because of meliodas no1 from DC aside from DK or meliodas could oppose AAs. Omg "who was talking about grace, certainly not me" so if you look at my early premise I talked about mael and AAs not their grace equivalence to Commandments.[
No, you're clearly reading too much into that quote, no where is it said demons were winning. As for the tangent stuff, you're the one who keeps bringing up random stuff.
Him leaving THE CLAN had the impact on the goddess winninf. The fact that I brought up jelamets statement moots your argument here as she talks about their win. So you would have to prove me wrong using other sources that she isnt talking about their win when meliodas left.
Ok prove USING FACTUAL EVIDENCES that meliodas leaving was more on reputation. If you cant provide this is my win for your lack of evidence.
Prove you wrong? Why would i need to when the manga does that for me? The goddesses didnt win when Meliodas left, not even after he killed two commandments.
As for the reputation thing, its in the manga, its in the panels you gave, Estarossa, a 60k warrior, was a replacement for Meliodas, and countered the effects of Meliodas leaving. So unless Meliodas was only 60k, the effects of his defection had to be based on his reputation, not his PL.
Ok since u said "little more step" was implying a little increase provide that claim, prove escanors PL or gap is 100k higher than 142k. If you're in this debate with me provide your assumptions with factual evidences. When Merlin states this when it meant to stop him at that level of strength. So this does not indicate the power gap being ab overrated as you're exaggerating. Also if you're talking about him one shotting meliodas when he needed tp use divine sword so you clearly didnt address my points. Also translation from crunchyroll
Prove Escanor's gap is 100k or higher?
Granted i dont know the specifics like the exact number, but him oneshotting Meliodas makes the difference in strength pretty clear and obviously massive. Still waiting on you providing your "factual evidence" that shows that Mel's "little more" would make a difference in this fight.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
I dont see how what i do is any different to the people saying Mel is stronger than he has shown. The One>>>Prime Meliodas

No, you're clearly reading too much into that quote, no where is it said demons were winning. As for the tangent stuff, you're the one who keeps bringing up random stuff.
Prove you wrong? Why would i need to when the manga does that for me? The goddesses didnt win when Meliodas left, not even after he killed two commandments.
As for the reputation thing, its in the manga, its in the panels you gave, Estarossa, a 60k warrior, was a replacement for Meliodas, and countered the effects of Meliodas leaving. So unless Meliodas was only 60k, the effects of his defection had to be based on his reputation, not his PL.
Prove Escanor's gap is 100k or higher?
Granted i dont know the specifics like the exact number, but him oneshotting Meliodas makes the difference in strength pretty clear and obviously massive. Still waiting on you providing your "factual evidence" that shows that Mel's "little more" would make a difference in this fight.
Is it not possible to factor in mels ability to draw out even more darkness, indura, or his actual magic besides his “little more” status?
 

Tristan

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
2,725
Reaction score
2,376
Country
Germany
Is it not possible to factor in mels ability to draw out even more darkness, indura, or his actual magic besides his “little more” status?
Absolutely not! That ability puts Meliodas in the highest caliber of this series along with DK and SD! That's TOO MUCH for SunShine— a small fragment of SD' power— to handle.
 
Top