Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Doughboy]

Finally ended up watching the bleach live action. It was kinda boring until the fight at the end. Rukia’s actor was really good, outside the hair everything was 1:1. They changed a lot around from what I remember and the plot was different than I expected.

 

[iceemperor]

Oricon Chart for 10/29-11/4
161909 *161909 Neverland
*87702 **87702 Black Clover
*74425 **74425 Kimetsu
*66122 **66122 Harem
*34282 **34282 Harem: Fantasia
*24565 *863207 HxH
*20739 **20739 Act-age
*20139 **20139 Jigokuraku
*19182 *569510 Haikyuu
*17029 2045642 OP
-
*10573 **10573 Aharen-san
*10144 *667446 Heroaca
**9218 *206547 Boruto

Monthly chart from 10/01-11/04
863207 *863207 HxH
569510 *569510 Haikyuu
206547 *206547 Boruto
174752 *174752 Gintama
161909 *161909 Neverland
140602 2045642 OP
*95620 **95620 Darlifra
*88559 **88559 Yuragi
*87702 **87702 BC
*80317 *667446 Heroaca
*78382 *351446 Ruroken
*74425 **74425 Kimetsu

Act-age is the biggest change here as it doubled its sales from last volume which was:
11730 **11730 Act-age 3

Haikyuu's drop is quite staggerring right now as its 5th week last volume was:
│267683 (3)│486748│558891│592529│612377┃*,612,377 (*31)┃2018/08｜ハイキュー!! 33
│285688 (4)│455332│516573│550328│------┃*,550,328 (*25)┃2018/10｜ハイキュー!! 34

With an extra day, its still got a 50k gap. OF course, the fact that its been so consistent without an anime all this time is incredible though.

 

[Tamil]

Kimetsu got a pretty big growth. It never did 70k+ in the first 3 days before. It usually does ~65k in the first 3 days.

 

[SharkBait]

BLack Clover continues its reign of being in the top sellers on the charts, fending off KimetsuYaiba and other same genre contemporaries. Fantastic sales chart.

 

[Caiops]

Expected more of Black Clover sales, Kimetsu will be selling more than Black Clover after one episode of the anime.

 

[Tamil]

How many Kimetsu volumes in the top 500? I remember when it had like 5 or 6 volumes out, we usually saw all of them in the ranking.

 

[Franz]

Expected more of Black Clover sales, Kimetsu will be selling more than Black Clover after one episode of the anime.

It is not said that there will be an immediate boost.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 7, 2018, Original Post Date: Nov 7, 2018 ---

Neverland, considering how much it sells without anime, with this will make a bang, could also reach the levels of My Hero.

Kimetsu with the anime for me will arrive at the levels of BC, then in two or three years they will both be put aside for the next Jump hit, probably Jujutsu.

 

[TyVip]

Hoping for act age vol 1-4 stay in top 100 long enough to chart in the upcoming week. 40-50k is an ideal number.

 

[SharkBait]

Expected more of Black Clover sales, Kimetsu will be selling more than Black Clover after one episode of the anime.

Theres been no hype or fanfare regarding Kimetsu. Putting it in the season after Nevelard will cannabolize its potential, and secondly its content just doesnt seem that interesting to many of todays readers and viewers. Even here you rarely see anyone mention kimetsu, unlike heroaca or BLack Clover, etc.

 

[Franz]

This is 3 days worth of sales.. We'll have to see if/when they will go up again, but it's too early to make any predictions yet.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Theres been no hype or fanfare regarding Kimetsu. Putting it in the season after Nevelard will cannabolize its potential, and secondly its content just doesnt seem that interesting to many of todays readers and viewers. Even here you rarely see anyone mention kimetsu, unlike heroaca or BLack Clover, etc.

How? They're pretty different genre-wise and air in seperate seasons. That's like saying Sumo isn't doing we'll because it's airing the season after MHA S3 ended.

 

[SharkBait]

How? They're pretty different genre-wise and air in seperate seasons. That's like saying Sumo isn't doing we'll because it's airing the season after MHA S3 ended.

Catalog volumes of HeroAca, even v1, are still elevated and selling well after s3 ended, meanwhile Sumo seems to not be on anyones minds. It is clear that putting Sumo on after heroaca, has not done it any favors, as HeroAca is still making enough waves to drown out interest in Sumo.

 

[Franz]

Kimetsu is little mentioned because not having anime and not being particularly publicized as Neverland, is not very well known.

The same Black Clover is actually quite ignored .....

 

[Obitooooo]

December sales is :

- Bnha Vs Haikyu
- World Trigger Vs Shokugeki no Souma
- Dr Stone VS Jujutsu
- One Piece Vs Invade You

 

[Mammo]

Bozebeats v2 has incredibly strong reviews on AMZN further suggesting that it resonated well with readers.

it has 2 reviews on amazon..

 

[SharkBait]

- World Trigger Vs Shokugeki no Souma
- Dr Stone VS Jujutsu

Those are two interesting battles, Jujutsu should be triumphant.

Food Wars, has the resident chartmaker showed Food Wars performance over the past few volumes.

 

[Franz]

One Piece Vs Invade You

Do you like to win easy ? :P

 

[Obitooooo]

Those are two interesting battles, Jujutsu should be triumphant.

Food Wars, has the resident chartmaker showed Food Wars performance over the past few volumes.

And WT another Boost.

 

[101nemesis]

Theres been no hype or fanfare regarding Kimetsu. Putting it in the season after Nevelard will cannabolize its potential, and secondly its content just doesnt seem that interesting to many of todays readers and viewers. Even here you rarely see anyone mention kimetsu, unlike heroaca or BLack Clover, etc.

I mean, if discussions and mentions on this forum was a measure of popularity, BC should've been One Piece level by now. So.

Finally ended up watching the bleach live action. It was kinda boring until the fight at the end. Rukia’s actor was really good, outside the hair everything was 1:1. They changed a lot around from what I remember and the plot was different than I expected.

They basically merged two of the biggest moments of the arc into almost a single bit in the movie. But otherwise, it stayed mostly true.
It was a decent adaptation and a sequel would've been good since it'd have been the SS arc but unfortunately it bombed.

 

[SharkBait]

I mean, if discussions and mentions on this forum was a measure of popularity, BC should've been One Piece level by now. So.

BLack Clover is > One Piece/boruto/heroAca on [usa]CR so my suppositions arent invalid.