Well, if it was the janitor the role of the dead person should appear as ?????, it shouldn´t reveal and Daws looked pretty much revealed to me.Maybe he'll jinx me instead
Should have gotten an innocent child stand, Host-sama, confirm me.
So you think that they used someone other then the janitor on the first night?
I'm not here trying to lynch you, but to get at least a "feel" for your role, something concrete xD It seems you missed the info I gave from the last dayphase: I said it's one of the classic roles that has always been around since I first joined mafia games. That already removes a huge chunk of possible roles I would say. Feeling like revealing at least a little bit now?As opposed to someone who only said his role is passive?You and I have revealed the exact same amount of info - everything about the Stand, almost nothing about the role. I'm in no rush to give anything else, so go ahead and vote me if you feel like it. I didn't hold the poisoning against you, won't be mad about this much either
Indeed it is. An no I'm not PGO, why? Wanted to know if its ok to target me at night?
Eh, I can only remember once instance where a Mafia team intentionally refused to use their Janitor, and only then it was because they were blocked on the first night, ironically back in Game 60 (Ace Attorney), so I wouldn't say its common.
?Lady pompom said:Yeah... On how you are trying to insist on no investigator role, I wonder if you^re not the janitor in person.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
really?Indeed it is. An no I'm not PGO, why? Wanted to know if its ok to target me at night?
Eh, I can only remember once instance where a Mafia team intentionally refused to use their Janitor, and only then it was because they were blocked on the first night, ironically back in Game 60 (Ace Attorney), so I wouldn't say its common.
I don't think you would either, which is where we differ, I think it's stand, you think its role.
?
Not really insisting, I even said there should be an Investigator last Day Phase.
Just today you already told twice on how it makes more sense it´s an investigator stand instead of a role, and I know my role, which makes me believe no way the roles was here just for a stand.ah it makes sense, but as a role? Assuming the Janitor kill was a stand you're going to have your role be something that could be useless because anything can happen to the Stand Wielder, what if they were lynched D1, got Assassin killed or something, now the Investigator's role in the game is null and void. Makes more sense having Investigator as a stand ability, but meh. Investigator and Mortician
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Yes.
Yes, like I just said, you think its a Janitor role so having Investigator role makes sense to you. To me, with the lack of Janitor kills, I feel its a stand so having a role dedicated to a stand whose usage is never guaranteed doesn't make sense to me, thus it would make more sense as a Stand. Not sure what the confusion is, already said that's where we disagree. It's not like I'm saying 100% I'm correct, so I say its a bit flimsy when you say I'm insisting.Lady pompom said:
Well, we do have a Mortician stand in the game apparently so...Lady pompom said:
This is a joke btw. Before someone takes it seriously.
I meant more as if you thought the janitor got blocked on the first night or if they aimed for Daws with the non-janitor killer?
In full metal alchemist, DD killed on N1. We didn’t use Belserion. Right @Belserion and @Vandred?
Fairly sure most passive roles have been around for ages, so that doesn't do much to distinguish them unless you mean the very first ones. Mine is similar in that case, a staple role that's been present since way back and appears in most games... more or less.I'm not here trying to lynch you, but to get at least a "feel" for your role, something concrete xD It seems you missed the info I gave from the last dayphase: I said it's one of the classic roles that has always been around since I first joined mafia games. That already removes a huge chunk of possible roles I would say. Feeling like revealing at least a little bit now?
Don't really get the "in no rush" part, if you're townie you should at least give a bit of info, if only so that we can sniff out mafia members more easily. It's Day 4 already.
It was a semi-rhetorical question about gnut's claim, mostly. Won't lie though, since shinobi's claimed the same combo I've been wondering what kind of roles would fit. Funnily enough there weren't any passive + passive pairs in the first JoJo game, but it definitely looks like Gry got creative this time around lolIndeed it is. An no I'm not PGO, why? Wanted to know if its ok to target me at night?
And I am telling my role is an investigator and gave my results. Just wait until janitor tries to kill me and hide my role with their ????
I am not quite sure which roles mafia team has... Because of the stands... But either Daws was targeted or he just hid badly behind a mafia (it also kills him if he hides behind someone from the killer´s team).
You got a better memory about this stuff than me, since I hardly remember anything that happened in that game
...I'd assume not?
Don't think you'd find it interesting, though it might be useful in figuring some things out.
If that happens, then you were right and I was wrong.And I am telling my role is an investigator and gave my results. Just wait until janitor tries to kill me and hide my role with their ????
Why does it have to be a BP stand? Can't it be BP passive role? Know something we don'tLady pompom said:
no, it could be a stand too, given how we do have some passive stands.Don't think you'd find it interesting, though it might be useful in figuring some things out.
If that happens, then you were right and I was wrong.
Why does it have to be a BP stand? Can't it be BP passive role? Know something we don't
Yeah I remember my epic fail. Didn't use my ability even once iirc. I don't remember why we didn't use it though.
I think that’s what we are all tying to figure out. The mortician stand result points at that a role didn’t kill him. But a stand is likely. But reading Panda’a question, he could have maybe been illusioned?
You think SS? I would think Santa would fit better in this game with the presents mixed in with Stands. If SS, they probably got me just like you did that last game when you were SS with my early reveal. So you think your results came because of an SS kill
Hmmm it says in OP that stands can’t be lost or changed, I was thinking this might be like the Santa present from Overlord. Where gnut got his role changed to freeman. Guess it wouldn’t apply to SS.
Think that time we were scared of losing that role early. That might have been the psychological issue this game as well. On D1, there was also talk of things like Daw’s Bomb Defuser saying there were bomb in the game and talk of a PGO. Pom’s reasoning could be legit.
Most people wait for those D3-4 Detective reveals in games. It’s why some hosts like vandred don’t even like putting detectives in games anymore.Inbefore gnut, Vandred and Gryffindor are the remaining mafia members
Also not sure what's the point in discussing past games now, guys...
I'm starting to wonder if we have any detectives at all (besides Lala potentially), because it still doesn't look like anyone has found out anything useful. We're still pretty much fumbling in the dark bc most people hardly talk =/
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
The situation with seraph was too obvious to ignore. Townie Seraph is much more involved so his absence and aggression just made him look uncomfortable in his own skin. It was mostly my gut but then you came in with the clutch so that was lucky. The only other person that I get a similar vibe from is Gryff which is why I poked him about the hint. He slides by way too easily with not sharing even the smallest detail about himself, yet uses the hints and reveals from other people to make his deductions. Not sharing means he can't get caught in a lie is the way I see it. Townie gryff is usually a Mafia hunter but this game he's all "eh" and "meh", maybe it's because the game is slow so he's bored, and I'm not knocking his activity because he's most likely posted more than I have, but it's the content. When you keep taking and taking but not giving, something's up. But then again this is a repetitive argument that's been happening with me and Gryff in most games we've played together so for now it's just a slight ringing for me.
