So after reading Guardian of the Witch, i can see the both sides, i kinda dig the couple of main characters, the art and you can see a potential to become something good, but man, the author could have used the battle shounen textbook a bit less, or at least make a better climax, because overall the first chapter was super cliche, totally by the book and the whole city was clearly inspired by AoT, it wasn't bad but even more typical than Zipman but at least the first chapter of Zipman had a better climax for a battle shounen with a big battle, here it was just 4 weird dudes with knifes being defeated like flies, the rest was Fafner with the typical mc speech about "i will protect you and become the number one of something".
Again, i didn't think was bad but the author better be working for the next chapters because it can quickly become something totally forgettable.
About Mashle, i liked the second chapter, not as much as the first but i laughed specially with him lifting the weights while the others were cleaning wands or looking at books kkkkk Also, as a big and longtime Harry Potter fan, just imagining the potential for parodies already make me want the manga to survive kkkk
Undead Unluck keeps being something really refreshing, it's not perfect by any means, but the author really knows how to not make it boring.