If we think about Chekhov's gun, if you presented an appeal in history, you need to use it.
If nezuko talk no justu Tanjuro, then what would even be the point of Tanjuro turning into a demon? Everything that Muzan said, would just get wiped away, then what would the point of Muzan final moment? About passing down memories and ideals just for it to get wiped away in a few chapters?? Also the Muzan fight was underwhelming. I can already imagine Tanjiro using breath of the sun has a demon. That would be crazy! I just don’t see situation being solve in a few chapters. I could easily be wrong, but you can also be easily wrong.
I would argue that that would be pretty much the point. Muzan as an enemy is fundamentally different from the upper moons. The upper moons had a speck of humanity and regrets which gave their fights emotional weight, specially when we saw them die. Muzan lacked that bit of humanity to the point that he didn't even have regrets about dying. He simply moved on and his last move was a middle finger to humanity. Even as the hashira fought him, muzan felt nothing, he is a dishonorable animal that simply killed because could and needed to be put down. Muzan didn't have the dignity of redemption or damnation as he died, he was less than the upper moons.... And ultimately, muzan fundamentally misunderstands the passing down of memories. They are about bonds, they are about the connections one makes with other people. That is why the hashira endured for 1000 years in the fight against muzan. Muzan injected a few cells into tanjiro but he doesn't actually have a bond with tanjiro, tanjiro isn't going to actually take anything from muzan to preserve it, at least not by choice.
well, first it doesn't make sense Tanjiro becomes the new villain in this story. The entire bond and bond that exists between these brothers would be weakened if Tanjiro escapes and starts a new war between humans and demons.
It would make sense, it would not be the first time. The main character turn into the antagonist. They can easily make it into a story about finding the blue spider lily, which is still unknown at the “moment” they can build Nezuko as a character, she’s always been a demon with no character development.
Yeah, I hear that argument in the blue arc in shokugeki no souma, he had to develop characters and in the end the arc was bad.
(Btw this is conversation hypothetical) but that’s your opinion, you can’t judge something without seeing it out. To me if it would have ended. It would have been the most unsatisfying final boss fight and a lot of ppl agree. It was terrible. But the same questions you ask, you can reverse it back. What if it backfires? But what if it turns out great? It’s always “what if’s” A lot of series end with talk no justu, but why would they? They are top in sells, so why should she/he stop? If the author believe she/he can continue and knows what exactly their doing. I believe in her/him. A lot of ppl agree, then it’s also a lot of ppl who disagree manly Because they want a good ending now, and they are stuck to believe this was the final arc. But it’s ppl like me, who’s more creative and see how amazing this could be, if done right which I believe he/she would do.
Better an unsatisfactory final fight, than an unsatisfactory arc.
And when did I say that I found the final fight unsatisfactory and that's the reason I want another arc? Actually, when did I ever say that I wanted another arc in the first place? Maybe the user you quoted above me said that, but I merely highlighted that the possibilities for another arc are there and depending on how Gotouge executes the plot, it wouldn't be forced at all to have another arc. Of course, if it ends here, I'm completely fine with it too. This is just my opinion too, btw.
Guys really want kimetsu no yaiba to become Nanatsu no taizai 2.0 with these claims that the doctor, the Blue spider lily, is missing and that they may have other stronger demons than Muzan.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Why so aggressive, though? I only expressed my opinion, pointing out that there are some things that have yet to be fully explored and could potentially serve for the start of a future arc. If you think this manga took a considerable nosedive in quality since the Red Light District arc and that a future arc would be a forced and a bad thing to do, then good, it's your opinion and I respect it, but please don't go forcing your opinion on others, because it's what it looks you're doing. For me, this manga so far has been pretty good (with some flaws, obviously, just like any fiction work, but still pretty good nonetheless) and I'm only pointing out that if Gotouge wants to go for a next arc, she could do it since the potential is there IMO. If she wants to end it though, I'm still fine with it, because like I said, I trust in Gotouge's writing since she hasn't given me a single reason yet to distrust it, unlike NNT and Fairy Tail, but that's just my opinion ofc.
Then I'm sorry if I said something I shouldn't have. Though, next time you should differentiate the quotes so there aren't any misunderstoods, since that user and I are saying fundamentally different things, and quoting me along with him gives an impression that we're saying the same when it clearly isn't the case. Just a recommendation though
No, it's clearly different, because I never said that I found Muzan's fight disappointing. The only thing I said is that it could potentially have been better for Gotouge's standards, but that doesn't mean that I found it disappointing either, far from it.
you didn't understand anything I said. I don't think the Red Light District is bad, quite the contrary, but it does have a repetition in the arc.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
You are defending the same point, aren't you? Of all that is good, kimetsu is the same that ends up getting bad.Then I'm sorry if I said something I shouldn't have. Though, next time you should differentiate the quotes so there aren't any misunderstoods, since that user and I are saying fundamentally different things, and quoting me along with him gives an impression that we're saying the same when it clearly isn't the case. Just a recommendation though
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Yeah, it can be solved in one chapter or it can be solved in an arc. It all depends on how Gotouge decides to execute it. The possibility of her not even explaining those points is there too even.
No, that user is saying that the last fight sucked and that that's the reason we should have another arc, for the ending to be more complete. That user is saying that Kimetsu should have another arc because if this is the ending it's terrible according to him. I'm just saying that this expansion could be a possibility that could happen. If it ends here, for me it was pretty good overall.
I haven't read Monster, so I can't say anything. But I don't agree with the notion that just because the villain was there since the start, if he were to disappear and be replaced by some other villain it would be incredibly bad. It depends on the execution, IMO. I have already expressed why I think this manga continuing could be a possibility and could make some sense, but like I said everyone has their own opinion.
If everyone has your opinion then why do you treat mine as if they are aggressive?
Ok, this will be my last reply to you. At no point I think I treated you arrogantly, but if I did and I didn't notice, then once again, I apologise. And no, obviously you didn't assault anybody, but it's the way you're saying things. I started with a comment saying that all of this was just a possibility that could or could not happen and that it would depend on what path Gotouge chose to do, as well as in the execution and how you perceived that execution, to which you quoted my post and basically said that this would be bad, that we people don't learn from the other mangas that have done this, and you also accused me of wanting this to turn into Nanatsu 2.0 and many more things. I found this reply quite aggressive, almost as if you were trying to put your opinion over mine, or you were trying to convince me to stop defending something when I wasn't even defending anything in the first place. Maybe it was just how I perceived it, but that's how I felt. Again, I apologise if I've said something I shouldn't have said.
This will also be the last time I speak. you have an opinion of expanding kimetsu can be a good thing, beauty.
Dude I’m gonna be honest, you keep bringing up other mangas. Which is extremely irrelevant. Every writer is different, every manga is different. Some can flourish, some can fall off. You think demon slayer will fall off if it continues, that’s your opinion. Just because it’s not ending the way you wanted to. No matter how good something can be there’s always ppl who have something negative to say, because it didn’t go there way. People will always be unsatisfied. If the manga ends soon with talk no justu, I would not be shock, I can easily see that coming. I would not be a big fan of it. Because what would Tanjiro turning into a demon in the first place? While they could have just skip that. And let him be with Nezuko. But I would quickly get over it. I’m not gonna hate on demon slayer for an underwhelming ending to me, I’m still gonna love it. But I’m looking at the bigger picture. I can see the potential in this, if done right. But you want closure, you want a happy ending now. Which is find, that’s your opinion.