Chapter Kimetsu no Yaiba Chapter 205 Spoiler/Discussion Thread

[n00bmaster69]

We didn't. We just saw a tidbit of their lives after the battle concluded. We never got to see Tanjiro fully complete his journey and we only get a faint idea of what happened afterwards. That is not a proper ending. Fan shouldn't have to interpret an ending as that means it is not a solid ending lol.

The point of a story is to show the main characters life tho lol. Imagine if we skip Asta becoming the WK and him being happy with a family and just skipped five generations just to see how their offsprings and reincarnations of dead characters are doing lol. That would be a joke. End Tanjiro's journey on Tanjiro not his lineage several generations down lol. We barely got to see him interact with Nezuko when she was not a demon.... The story could've ended with adult Nezuko and Tanjiro reflecting over their lives and how far they've come to obtain hapiness (their family). We could have also seen them talking about how the others are doing while they were reflecting over it as well. Not some weird carbon copy grandkids and reincarnated characters.

How isn't it reincarnations when we have carbon copies of old characters? Lol. Shinobu's lineage died out and now we have Shinobu and her sister clone? Obanai and Misturi clones married each other.... This is reincarnation and I don't think it's up to an interpretation when it's so blatant.

Yeah ngl i dont think this is the meaning of reincarnation getting their incarnation's carbon copy look

 

[Franz]

We never got to see Tanjiro fully complete his journey

But really yes, was Tanjiro's goal to heal Nezuko, once it was left to show?

The point of a story is to show the main characters life tho lol. I

No, the aim is to show the characters to achieve their goals, not vita mort and miracles.

Imagine if we skip Asta becoming the WK a

Senseless comparison, since Tanjiro has already achieved his goal and we have not skipped anything.

How isn't it reincarnations when we have carbon copies of old characters?

In fact, it is left to the reader's imagination. Simple similarity? Real reincarnation? Choose the version you like best.


I find it more poetic.

. End Tanjiro's journey on Tanjiro not his lineage several generations down lol. We barely got to see him interact with Nezuko when she was not a demon.... T

But you should also complain about the first chapter then.

Anyway, Tanjiro's journey ended last chapter (indeed even earlier), I would say in chapter 196, it is useless to stay here to complain

--- Double Post Merged, May 14, 2020, Original Post Date: May 14, 2020 ---

Yeah ngl i dont think this is the meaning of reincarnation getting their incarnation's carbon copy look

But aren't you too fussy? It's a manga, there is the suspension of disbelief

 

[aaannnnannan]

But really yes, was Tanjiro's goal to heal Nezuko, once it was left to show?

No, the aim is to show the characters to achieve their goals, not vita mort and miracles.





Senseless comparison, since Tanjiro has already achieved his goal and we have not skipped anything.



In fact, it is left to the reader's imagination. Simple similarity? Real reincarnation? Choose the version you like best.


I find it more poetic.




But you should also complain about the first chapter then.

Anyway, Tanjiro's journey ended last chapter (indeed even earlier), I would say in 1969, it is useless to stay here to complain

--- Double Post Merged, May 14, 2020, Original Post Date: May 14, 2020 ---

But aren't you too fussy? It's a manga, there is the suspension of disbelief

I completely agree with ya , the end was good and nearly perfect , I just hope that a novel will be written about how the ships happened and I have very few doubts that the novel won't be written

 

[levi12]

No I am hoping spin off and novel will explain how all those ships happens and what happen in all those years to Tanjiro and main guys.

Hope Gotouge do this

 

[aaannnnannan]

No I am hoping spin off and novel will explain how all those ships happens and what happen in all those years to Tanjiro and main guys.

Hope Gotouge do this

They will do it , money is always attractive

 

[levi12]

They will do it , money is always attractive

Depends on creator but I am hoping it happen

 

[Jko]

But really yes, was Tanjiro's goal to heal Nezuko, once it was left to show?

No, the aim is to show the characters to achieve their goals, not vita mort and miracles.





Senseless comparison, since Tanjiro has already achieved his goal and we have not skipped anything.



In fact, it is left to the reader's imagination. Simple similarity? Real reincarnation? Choose the version you like best.


I find it more poetic.




But you should also complain about the first chapter then.

Show him interact with his Sister for more than a couple pages. Show a happy ending for the sibling with their family not some future lineage.

Tanjiro's goal was reached but like the goal felt pointless since we barely saw them interact. Shed a few tears and go lived in their old house and that's the ending to their story? His goal should be a stepping stone to something greater and we should see that something greater not flashforward passed it. I guess a better example would be Ichigo from Bleach. It's like skipping seeing him at his happiest and fully living as an adult for a future lineage and reincarnated friends that we don't care for lol.

I mean it's pretty hard to not interpret that as reincarnation. I just don't like it.

Why?

But it didn't. We only saw a tidbit of his life after the war and skipped out on his ending.

i agree you have point

--- Double Post Merged, May 14, 2020, Original Post Date: May 14, 2020 ---

This is story about Tanjiro and main gangs not descendants and reincarnation.

They should have ended by seeing Tanjiro and rest Of his friends and survivors becoming adult and marry and have family

Not timeskip to characters we barely know and know nothing about.

Hence I give this series 7.8 or 7.9 out of 10

We follow this series for Tanjiro, Nezuko, Zenitsu, Inosuke and rests

Not carbon copies descendants and reincarnations

Exactly.

Yeah ngl i dont think this is the meaning of reincarnation getting their incarnation's carbon copy look

 

[aaannnnannan]

Depends on creator but I am hoping it happen

Ofc , but they have the chance to explain everything better and to make money in a way easier than drawing a manga , they are gonna do it

 

[n00bmaster69]

Show him interact with his Sister for more than a couple pages. Show a happy ending for the sibling with their family not some future lineage.

Tanjiro's goal was reached but like the goal felt pointless since we barely saw them interact. Shed a few tears and go lived in their old house and that's the ending to their story? His goal should be a stepping stone to something greater and we should see that something greater not flashforward passed it. I guess a better example would be Ichigo from Bleach. It's like skipping seeing him at his happiest and fully living as an adult for a future lineage and reincarnated friends that we don't care for lol.

I mean it's pretty hard to not interpret that as reincarnation. I just don't like it.

Why?

But it didn't. We only saw a tidbit of his life after the war and skipped out on his ending.


Exactly.

I said, I don't think Reincarnations are about carbon copies of the past characters. I'm sorry I'm kinda wack rn lmao

 

[Franz]

Show him interact with his Sister for more than a couple pages. Show a happy ending for the sibling with their family not some future lineage.

But the happy ending we saw in the last chapter, where they went to live with Inosuke and Zentisu in their old village.

The rest (families, life, death and miracles) is not important, it is a surplus.
Then as we said we talk about very young characters, the time for all these things will have had.

Tanjiro's goal was reached but like the goal felt pointless since we barely saw them interact.

Points of view, however the link between the two has always been one of the cornerstones of the work even when Nezuko was unable to speak.

--- Double Post Merged, May 14, 2020, Original Post Date: May 14, 2020 ---

This is story about Tanjiro and main gangs not descendants and reincarnation.

But in fact it is so, in fact we have seen their epilogues.

They should have ended by seeing Tanjiro and rest Of his friends and survivors becoming adult and marry and have family

Points of view.

We follow this series for Tanjiro, Nezuko, Zenitsu, Inosuke and rests

Not carbon copies descendants and reincarnations

But do you know that we are at the last chapter yes?


And that the space for the things you say is literally twenty pages?

 

[Zero14]

Wait so Nezuko 2.0 has a thing for Tanjiro and Kanao's (possible) descendant??

That's a little odd considering they're cousins technically

Dude why everybody keeps saying they are cousings. This happens like 4 generations after, they aren't even related anymore

 

[sterben.]

a spin off or the last or sequel can happen. and blue spiderlilly is here to stay. fans wont be satisfied. good move croc sensei. looking forward to NotZenitsu in an after story movie, telling everyone "i knew it!! great gramps book was not fiction at all!! see?! see?!" hahaha

 

[Franz]

What then in Japan (but also in Italy to whom interested) the marriage between cousins is legal.

A friend of my grandmother is married to her cousin.

 

[-Stray]

Jesus christ... I both love and a bit disappointed with this ending, I'd have preferred seeing Gonpachiro X Kanao with their kids, having a fun time even for a bit and then show us this future timeskip. Took a hell of a reincarnation jump, tho it is nice to have a wholesome ending after that grim battle with Muzan but... couldn't we have a wholesome ending WITH the cast we watched struggle instead of this? then again I kinda see the point.. cause reincarnation means dead characters can have their appearances in the last chapter, they wouldn't be able to do this if they didn't timeskip to... what 4-6 gens ahead? plus it seems Wani sensei's into school shinanigans since we do have a ver of Demon Slayer being students, she probably deep down wanted to do an SoL with them being highschool students in modern times.
That aside.. t'was a fun freaking ride! hope Getouge sensei returns with another fun series! wouldn't mind if its stories she would want to tell after the fight with Muzan or having this new gen SoL setting.

 

[levi12]

Okay did this chapter confirm Tanjiro and Kanao descendants are Kanata and Sumihiko or are we just speculating. How about Zenitsu and Nezuko descendants

Did this chapter confirm it? like literally confirm it

 

[Franz]

Well they are identical to Zenitsu and Nezuko .....

 

[aaannnnannan]

Well they are identical to Zenitsu and Nezuko .....

And they have both the Agatsuma surname

 

[Gladiolus]

So, did Zenitsu succeeded in boning Nezuko after all?

 

[aaannnnannan]

So, did Zenitsu succeeded in boning Nezuko after all?

So it would seem

 

[Gladiolus]

So it would seem

At the end, he was the one true winner of the manga lmao.