Games Mafia Game 87 - Baccano! - END GAME

[gnut]

I had my role before as well.

Why you so quiet xD

 

[GrySun]

I'm a roleless townie.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 17, 2020 ---

roleless like i can't make an action. I'm not a vanilla tho

Roleless means vanilla. Think what you mean is a „passive“ role, ie no action?

Can still do sacrifices at night.

 

[gnut]

Is using the mechanic worth it if you aren't using your role...what benefit is that in the end unless you are a scumbag looking for kills?

 

[desin24]

Lovely mechanic if ai understood it right, lovely avys. I'm really starting to appreciate mechanics that give people with boring/passive roles options to engage and make choices that can positively affect the game.

Will catch up tommorow after my exam. Will be here for the last couple hours of the day phase.

As for my hint: There is a reason I appreciate the mechanic

 

[Raven]

Roleless means vanilla. Think what you mean is a „passive“ role, ie no action?

Can still do sacrifices at night.

yup

 

[Farfalla]

Uh Greg cmon, some roles don't have actions, the rules say they can still perform rituals and people mentioned that repeatedly. Also some active roles, as you know, are circumstantial and won't act all the time anyway.

 

[Shad]

Is using the mechanic worth it if you aren't using your role...what benefit is that in the end unless you are a scumbag looking for kills?

If I understand the mechanic.

Anybody has a chance to get the elexir as long as they waste 3 night actions in a row from N1.

They can pass it to a confirmed townie (or take a risk on somebody that he trusts a bit) since this can let them confirm themselves as well, if the receiver get notified of who sent the Elixir to them tho.

The receiver can then either reveal that he received the elixir and confirm the sender (kind of), or keep it secret and bait a mafia kill to make them waste a night, which will confirm both the sender and the receiver of the elixir if the sender is still alive by then.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 17, 2020 ---

I think all townies should pass the elexir and not use it.

Passing the elexir is more valuable over all.

It will tie people claims together.

 

[SirSamuel016]

I don't have too much opinion on the super masons atm, I think it was @Shad who said it could be fitting for the theme to have that many but I'm not 100% sure either.

Their playstyle or not, I would like to see more activity out of those who have been quiet; @Seraph for one strikes me as just plain lurking with a thanks for the avatar and lets have fun post, and then a hint about having his role previously. Anything more you might want to contribute mate?

 

[Shad]

I don't have too much opinion on the super masons atm, I think it was @Shad who said it could be fitting for the theme to have that many but I'm not 100% sure either.

Their playstyle or not, I would like to see more activity out of those who have been quiet; @Seraph for one strikes me as just plain lurking with a thanks for the avatar and lets have fun post, and then a hint about having his role previously. Anything more you might want to contribute mate?

@Seraph intervention felt of to be as well, but it is still early, 15h left and timezones.

He may still participate later, let wait and see.

 

[SirSamuel016]

@Seraph intervention felt of to be as well, but it is still early, 15h left and timezones.

He may still participate later, let wait and see.

Aye, I would like to see more activity from him and others, but I also do unfortunately remember that their playstyle is to lurk until someone strikes the nail on the head/puts them under pressure.

 

[Gajeel]

Seraph has been playing this way ever since last year, there's nothing weird about it.

 

[gnut]

Uh Greg cmon, some roles don't have actions, the rules say they can still perform rituals and people mentioned that repeatedly. Also some active roles, as you know, are circumstantial and won't act all the time anyway.

I know....but you know I was talking about basics like det,doc,etc etc

 

[GrySun]

Is using the mechanic worth it if you aren't using your role...what benefit is that in the end unless you are a scumbag looking for kills?

If you got a role you can use every night to great effect like Doctor, prolly don't wanna touch the mechanic. If you're a 1-time use active it's a different story.

 

[gnut]

Lets not fall into the last game...not using my role because of mechanic shit

 

[GrySun]

I know....but you know I was talking about basics like det,doc,etc etc

Those imo have no need to ever bother with the mechanics yes.

 

[gnut]

If you got a role you can use every night to great effect like Doctor, prolly don't wanna touch the mechanic. If you're a 1-time use active it's a different story.

Yes this

 

[GrySun]

Lets not fall into the last game...not using my role because of mechanic shit

Like you "did"?

 

[gnut]

Like you "did"?

Heh...is what it is but this game Im not a cheat xD

 

[Shad]

@GrySun @gnut @SirSamuel016 @desin24 @Raven @Gajeel and Minaa!

Do you agree that the first 4 Elixirs should all be passed once before used?

Consider that the people with the highest chance to get them are passive / vanilla roles, while a detective woudn't be able to get it.
I think this is done on porpose to encourage them to pass it.

Passing it has the potential of confirming the sender or the receiver or both depending on what happens next.

There is a lot of scenarios as an example:
if somebody dies as Immortal but no one claims they gave them an elixir, they are probably mafia.
If somebody claims they gave them the Elixir, he will tie his claim with them and if one is exposed both will be exposed.

 

[GrySun]

@GrySun @gnut @SirSamuel016 @desin24 @Raven @Gajeel and Minaa!

Do you agree that the first 4 Elixirs should all be passed once before used?

Consider that the people with the highest chance to get them are passive / vanilla roles, while a detective woudn't be able to get it.
I think this is done on porpose to encourage them to pass it.

Passing it has the potential of confirming the sender or the receiver or both depending on what happens next.

There is a lot of scenarios as an example:
if somebody dies as Immortal but no one claims they gave them an elixir, they are probably mafia.
If somebody claims they gave them the Elixir, he will tie his claim with them and if one is exposed both will be exposed.

As Orgz once said, we‘ll burn that bridge when we get to it.