Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Witch Watch has consistently been doing bottom 5 or 6 in TOC for a while and yet the volume sales showed increase so i have no idea how to read into that

It's the current state of Jump, excluding Red Hood and Neru, nothing else on Jump is "axe fodder" at the moment, everybody has more or less a "role" in the overall line up, at most we could see HSF gone in the beginning of 2022 due to being the lowest selling, and even this one isn't 100% sure.

 

[Franz]

Break for Jujutsu next week.

 

[kardelcj]

Edit: So it is more or less 170k initial print for vol.2.

 

[Archaon]

I'm back.

So among the new Jump series, i'm interest the most in PPPPPP. I always prefer melodrama stories to the one that focus too much in the technical aspects (power system, world building,...). As for Red Hood, i find it kinda boring to be honest, like there something missing that make you want to engage with the characters.

 

[Pietro]

Wow Magu chan got 4th place with cp... it means it's doing great
I'm worried about Witch watch, it's always in the last 3, even if the manga is selling greatly

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Color pages for issue 45: Dr.STONE, Witch Watch, GFC entry 1 (GFC is back to produce more axebait).

Dr.STONE is also getting color pages on issue 46.

----
Cover and LCP of issue 43 for no reason.
Consecutive CPs on issue 45 and 46.

Why is Dr.Stone being so ultra-shilled?

 

[Franz]

More News about Jujutsu Kaisen 0 movie will be revealed in this week's issue.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

350k for 2 volumes of a romcom series, thats crazy, it must be higher than The Elusive Samurai for sure.

Color pages for issue 45: Dr.STONE, Witch Watch, GFC entry 1 (GFC is back to produce more axebait).

Dr.STONE is also getting color pages on issue 46.

----
Cover and LCP of issue 43 for no reason.
Consecutive CPs on issue 45 and 46.

Why is Dr.Stone being so ultra-shilled?

Ahhh i knew it that Golden Future Cup would return, this is why only PPPPPP started, but yeah, starting a new edition when you last winner is pratically dead in the magazine is quite awkward for everybody involved

Well, with the final arc officially announced, im not even surprieed anymore if it gets another cover this year kkkk

Nice to see WW breathung some fresh air

I'm back.

So among the new Jump series, i'm interest the most in PPPPPP. I always prefer melodrama stories to the one that focus too much in the technical aspects (power system, world building,...). As for Red Hood, i find it kinda boring to be honest, like there something missing that make you want to engage with the characters.

Welcome back

 

[tirakai]

Any info on how many GFC entries we'll see this year?

Not that I have much faith in them since all winners have flopped early since 2009 I think, but we might see one find success with their second series like Black Clover and Yozakura.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Any info on how many GFC entries we'll see this year?

Not that I have much faith in them since all winners have flopped early since 2009 I think, but we might see one find success with their second series like Black Clover and Yozakura.

Seems like 5, and the name of the authors:

町田麗弥
江ノ島だいすけ
一ノヘ
KOJIRO
名越良祐

By using google, most published one shots on GIGA before.

 

[Khurram]

I'm waiting for that dandadan cp

 

[CuriousReborn]

Wait, is this RH chapter the one that people praised a lot?

 

[Mammo]

Seems like 5, and the name of the authors:
町田麗弥

Reiya Machida seems like the obvious choice to win
having done multiple oneshots and having a miniseries on GIGA when that was a thing

江ノ島だいすけ

Daisuke is the guy that did the Super Mario meets Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann oneshot in the last GIGA issue right?
i liked that one, it was stupid, but fun as hell

一ノヘ

Ichinohe is from J+ and Jump Rookies all his work are weird and trippy


pretty interesting collection, I always enjoy the GFC, regardless of the outcome

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Wait, is this RH chapter the one that people praised a lot?

By the 8 chapters rule, the ranked chapter would be 6 that its when the praise for the series returned, next week would be Debonair introduction that jp twitter loved but at this point it would be a miracle if RH rises next week.

Btw, you have the website from the MHA data you posted before?

 

[Khurram]

GFC feels like axe bait

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Important to notice, the GFC list isnt "confirmed" yet, simply posted on 5ch, so take it with a grain of salt

 

[KagamiKuroko]

Color pages for issue 45: Dr.STONE, Witch Watch, GFC entry 1 (GFC is back to produce more axebait).

Dr.STONE is also getting color pages on issue 46.

----
Cover and LCP of issue 43 for no reason.
Consecutive CPs on issue 45 and 46.

Why is Dr.Stone being so ultra-shilled?

Boichi can handle all the color pages and covers while the other's can't

 

[Kushikime]

Break for Jujutsu next week.

I’m loving that in the past 5 weeks - OP, BC, MHA, JJK and Dr Stone will have ALL had breaks. Hopefully this means going forward Jump isn’t trying to run their veterans into the ground.

 

[KiMiTo]

Cover and LCP of issue 43 for no reason.
Consecutive CPs on issue 45 and 46.

Why is Dr.Stone being so ultra-shilled?

Why people are so butthurted when Dr. Stone gets Covers, LCPs or CPs?
And what is the meaning of "for no reason" lol. There is a couple of reasons.

 

[KagamiKuroko]