Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[tirakai]

I assume this is based on new Manga+ IDs?

 

[Jovan]

I assume this is based on new Manga+ IDs?

Correct. Every series has 5 new entries, except Elusive Samurai with 4 (assuming a break is coming for this one as it's getting a CP next issue and selling very well, meaning no axe), Red Hood with 2 (1 filled this week already, meaning 1 chapter left) and Neru with 3 (1 filled this week already, meaning 2 chapters left)

 

[tirakai]

That means we're likely to see a new batch announced when the ToC leaks on tuesday, I'm excited to see what we get.

 

[Aeneas]

Nakama goes from an editor working on his first series to... an editor working on his first series. :P

 

[animeexpert]

He said it , he wanted to draw more monsters , Redhood end

AAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaa, shouldve just let him go on monster hunter expeditions. I can't take thisss!!! Plsss let him reboot his manga

 

[Newkerzy]

SxF anime confirmed.

Spy×Family Domestic Spy Comedy Manga Gets TV Anime in 2022

Takuya Eguchi to star as Loid Forger in anime by WIT Studio, Cloverworks

www.animenewsnetwork.com

I’ll just post it here too, since it was being discussed a while back.

 

[FireFantasyVI]

Undead was pretty good, interested to learn more about Unbreakable

Ayakashi was good, I'm enjoying the action

Magu was the usual, not particularly interested in the new character

Roboco was good, Roboco was pretty funny this chapter

HSF was good too, really liked the family dynamic here, though the pacing felt a little erratic

Sakamoto was great, both fights seem interesting, and the panel of Sakamoto in the elevator was hilarious and awesome

Elusive was great, looking forward to this war, and the joke of the chapter got a good laugh

Witch was great too, really cute stuff

Blue Box was pretty good, wasn't expecting the end of the chapter

Red Hood continues to go off the rails, between all the meta stuff and cramming a ton of plot points in, it's a beautiful trainwreck

Neru was pretty good, liked the end of the fights. Looks like it'll have a pretty open ending as opposed to Red Hood. It's a shame

P6 was alright, not a fan of the ending, though I guess it was inevitable

 

[Reyes]

Seems the MHA movie 3 is doing really amazing in USA

Halloween Scares Off Box Office: ‘Dune’ $15M+; ‘My Hero Academia’ $6M+, ‘Last Night In Soho’ & ‘Antlers’ Tie $4M

Sunday AM Writethru after Saturday AM update: The first full Halloween celebration in two years is taking its toll on the domestic box office, a grey cloud which many saw coming, with many trick-or-treating or attending parties last night. Essentially, whenever the holiday falls on a Sunday...

deadline.com

WHM is below those expectations, will come in around 6.4 million, a small increase over the weekend of the last move of 5.89 million despite the larger theater count this time around.

 

[SharkBait]

Halloween Scares Off Box Office: ‘Dune’ $15M+; ‘My Hero Academia’ $6M+, ‘Last Night In Soho’ & ‘Antlers’ Tie $4M

Sunday AM Writethru after Saturday AM update: The first full Halloween celebration in two years is taking its toll on the domestic box office, a grey cloud which many saw coming, with many trick-or-treating or attending parties last night. Essentially, whenever the holiday falls on a Sunday...

deadline.com

WHM is below those expectations, will come in around 6.4 million, a small increase over the weekend of the last move of 5.89 million despite the larger theater count this time around.

it was a mistake to put it in halloween weekend...but I guess it was the only choice, since next weekend is Eternals, and would probably have made my hero get smaller auditoriums...and last weekend was...Ron Goes Wrong...

should have got my hero a month earlier.

 

[Phantom RPG]

Snow Smile by KOJIRO. Not going to lie but i thought it would be a skiing one-shot not a full blown battle one shot. (Which i will say definitely is a contender against Vroom in my personal opinion, although the next is is the one am intrigued the most)


By the way, what have Nagoshi Ryousuke done before? Curious over what they have done prior.

 

[BX-02BLODIA]

SxF anime confirmed.

Spy×Family Domestic Spy Comedy Manga Gets TV Anime in 2022

Takuya Eguchi to star as Loid Forger in anime by WIT Studio, Cloverworks

www.animenewsnetwork.com

I’ll just post it here too, since it was being discussed a while back.

So what's the point of it being the Secret stage in Festa if everything they could unveil (KV, PV, cast) was already spilled?

 

[Aeneas]

Snow Smile by KOJIRO. Not going to lie but i thought it would be a skiing one-shot not a full blown battle one shot. (Which i will say definitely is a contender against Vroom in my personal opinion, although the next is is the one am intrigued the most)


By the way, what have Nagoshi Ryousuke done before? Curious over what they have done prior.

I think it's the first author in Jump I've seen list 3-gatsu as one of their favorite series (Mammo can probably find another one).

I'm wishing them luck based on that alone.

 

[Thehoennhippo]

Well Neru definitely introduced a pretty easy endgame thing this week.

 

[OtterBrigade]

So what's the point of it being the Secret stage in Festa if everything they could unveil (KV, PV, cast) was already spilled?

1 member of the cast. Anya is probably the one most want to hear, Yor is pretty important too.

 

[Mammo]

I think it's the first author in Jump I've seen list 3-gatsu as one of their favorite series (Mammo can probably find another one).

I'm wishing them luck based on that alone.

the guy that did Gekikou Kanzen Soccer-bu in June had 3-gatsu (& Double Art) as their favorite series

 

[Khurram]

So what's the point of it being the Secret stage in Festa if everything they could unveil (KV, PV, cast) was already spilled?

Now I think , the secret stage might be for bastards remake .

 

[Discomusic]

1. The Elusive Samurai: The moment when the new general makes his confession is easily the moment of the week. It's stupid yet great because this secret turns him into a monster of war somehow. Very original "character estabilishment".
2. Sakamoto Days: First things first, glad the wife is ok, I was really worried. About the rest, it's your usual Sakamoto chapter, full of action and badassness.
3. Undead Unluck: As usual, there's Spring so high rank by default. Now that all Union members are finally introduced (am I missing someone?), let's play Squid Game but with traditional japanese games.
4. PPPPPP: Though still not particularly good, this manga is improving little by little. I like when the qualities of Lucky are recognized by only a selected few characters, like in the first chapter, and I like that the idea of him being a genius is morphed into something more sinster. Let's see how his brother will respond.
5. Ayakashi Triangle: The battle continues and it is still good. There is also a bit of strategy that is highly appreciated. Will this fight be a turning point for AT? (please let me dream)
6. Blue Box: Between this chapter and the last, it appears that Miura has mastered the art of cliffhangers. If next week is like this one, they will also have mastered the art of anticlimatic cliffhanger resolutions.
7. Witch Watch: Not as great as last week, but still a funny chapter overall, with Mini-Moi being the MVP of the week. It advances a bit the character development, of both Moi and the couple as a whole.
8. Highschool Family: Aah, culture festivals...always wanted to attend one just to see if they really are how they are depicted in mangas. But hold on! Kotaro already had a romantic interest! Is the class representative going to be the Hina of this scenario?
9. My Hero Academia: That solution may work, but it seems a little extreme to me. How very U.S.A. of them to try this. Someone will stop this plan anyway, whether it will be from the hero or the villain side.
10. Dr. Stone: This final arc is going really fast, like they are in a hurry to conclude the series. The chapter is important though, because Senku & co. achieved a result they were thriving for since so much time. Congrats, bros.
11. One Piece: A chapter that feels very transitional. The stakes rose even higher, but...isn't it the time to wrap up instead of adding new stakes?
12. Me & Roboco: If it is true that the main target of this series is elementary-middle school kids, this chapter is actually interesting because it can even be considered educational, warning about the dangers of social media abuse to boys and girls that are next-in-line to get their social accounts. Comedy wise, it was better than usual.
13. Neru: Way of the martial artist: A bit disappointed from how the fight ends, felt too sudden after all that build-up. The last minute new character is great, in a way: what if the series ends with her dragging Neru home because he still has to finish his non-martial arts school homework?
14. Black Clover: So, it's not over yet, huh? Not that I couldn't expect it, but still a bit of a letdown considering everything we've been through already. The gang coming for the rescue will be fun to watch.
15. Mission: Yozakura Family: As always, a few Yozakura fillers are a success but most are a failure. This one lies in the majority group without any doubt from my side.
16. Magu-chan: God of Destruction: When in need of shaking the status quo a bit, this series usually adds a new character to the cast...but this time, the new character doesn't shake anything at all. I think the real shake would be going from autoconclusive episodes to mini-arcs, that surely helped when it was attempted.
17. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood: They're throwing at us everything they've got, with such speed that it's impossible to process all of it. It became so bad it's good, and you can take this last place and put it in first and read the whole ranking again in an endless loop. As long as it entertains the Reader.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Obviously a landslide kkkk, thanks for your votes!

FAVORITE COLOR PAGE OF ISSUE #47 - VOTING RESULTS​

1. Blue Box Chapter 26 (35 Votes)

Spoiler

2. High School Family Chapter 59 (6 Votes)

Spoiler

3. Shitsuren Beginning GFC One Shot (4 Votes)

Spoiler

4. Mashle Chapter 83 (3 Votes)

Spoiler

Print Source:

Spoiler

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 1, 2021, Original Post Date: Nov 1, 2021 ---

FAVORITE COLOR PAGE OF ISSUE #48 - POLL VOTING​

You guys know the drill, vote in your favorite color page of this week issue, we have Sakamoto Days, Undead Unluck, Witch Watch and Snow Smile one shot.

Good Votes!

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 1, 2021 ---

Preview of Shonen Jump Issue #49 (HQ)

Obs: That's a pretty cool issue preview

 

[tirakai]

With Red Hood and Neru most likely both ending on ch 18, I wonder if they'll get 2 volumes or 3.

Series lasting until ch 19 always seem to get 3 volumes, but series only hitting ch 17 seem to go either way (Zipman got 2 volumes, while U19 got 3) and I can't see anything that ended on ch 18 from a quick check.

I guess it might depend on if they've got enough oneshots available or want to do lots of bonus stuff to fill up the pages?

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

With Red Hood and Neru most likely both ending on ch 18, I wonder if they'll get 2 volumes or 3.

Series lasting until ch 19 always seem to get 3 volumes, but series only hitting ch 17 seem to go either way (Zipman got 2 volumes, while U19 got 3) and I can't see anything that ended on ch 18 from a quick check.

I guess it might depend on if they've got enough oneshots available or want to do lots of bonus stuff to fill up the pages?

I think the first version of Neru with 4 chapters wasn't compiled in tankobon, and also some one shot, so they will maybe include, if not is hard to see getting more than 2 volumes, Kawaguchi has the original Red Hood and at least other 3 different cool one shot too.