Games Mafia Game 108 - Mob Psycho 100 (75%)

[Crescent Jinx]

This is on discord but will put here too.

 

[Baka Taichou]

# of blockers is not the point, and it‘s not a theory. I‘m asking if a team would assume another team would keep blocking a Det for example, or if they‘d add their Blocker to the mix randomly?
Nobody knew what Wojak was, so them continuing to block Baka after he stopped blocking her is far too bizarre.

Well, i assume they'd think what are the chances of the other blocker to keep blocking the same target. it would also depend on what other roles surfaces, if there was one more important than the necro out in the open, it also depends on said Baka, is she still sus, is she more trusted, is she more sus, if she's more sus then blocking her to get her misslynched would grow in priority, and assuming that previous night it was the town that blocked her, i'd assume they'd change targets since blocking her didn't prevent a kill. So yes I would target the Baka the next day. But seeing as I'm the one in question I can't impose that line of thought since y'all can just say I'm fabricating it for my own advantage. But that's my logic.

Also, there are no 2 teams, it's just one big mafia, janitor was a one time role and demon wasn't mafia det. Let's be real folks.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

• Also note the behavioural pattern of some people if there is a sudden change in case they got recruited last night

 

[GrySun]

Well mafia team should have killed her not bloecked her, her role allow her to spy, to investigate, to protect, she should be prio1 mafia kill and she stills is alive with a new excuse every day.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

Well I didnt want but i thought if I dont make it next day at least you know about eveil targets/action I shouldnt be mafia priority kill with a spy and necro around but well

Yeah basically either Baka is scum, Wojak is scum, or mafia is really odd in their decision making.
I‘m inclined to trust Wojak so either the 1st or 3rd.

 

[Baka Taichou]

Well mafia team should have killed her not bloecked her, her role allow her to spy, to investigate, to protect, she should be prio1 mafia kill and she stills is alive with a new excuse every day.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

Well I didnt want but i thought if I dont make it next day at least you know about eveil targets/action I shouldnt be mafia priority kill with a spy and necro around but well

yes lady mafia, this smoked method of blocking the first role claimer for the entire game to make them sus is not a new strategy, tell me more how I'm mafia please.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022 ---

• Also note the behavioural pattern of some people if there is a sudden change in case they got recruited last night

raven changed

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

• Also not bolding votes feels like a new mafia meta to trick people

 

[GrySun]

Well, i assume they'd think what are the chances of the other blocker to keep blocking the same target. it would also depend on what other roles surfaces, if there was one more important than the necro out in the open, it also depends on said Baka, is she still sus, is she more trusted, is she more sus, if she's more sus then blocking her to get her misslynched would grow in priority, and assuming that previous night it was the town that blocked her, i'd assume they'd change targets since blocking her didn't prevent a kill. So yes I would target the Baka the next day. But seeing as I'm the one in question I can't impose that line of thought since y'all can just say I'm fabricating it for my own advantage. But that's my logic.

Also, there are no 2 teams, it's just one big mafia, janitor was a one time role and demon wasn't mafia det. Let's be real folks.

I mean what you say is possible, just not the straightforward thinking I’d expect mafia to do with this if they don’t wanna overlap killers.

There being a 1-time use Investigator to counter a 1-time use Janitor makes no sense imo. Something‘s really fishy somewhere.

 

[Raven]

yes lady mafia, this smoked method of blocking the first role claimer for the entire game to make them sus is not a new strategy, tell me more how I'm mafia please.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022 ---

raven changed

How? because i said i doubt you? This how Mafia game works, You see something ain't right and you reconsider your initial thoughts.

 

[GrySun]

raven changed

Her teamwork squad did collapse somehow.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

If Erin was really faking it and is a mafia revealing Demon’s dead role for cred I‘d be amazed and put Erin on S-tier and vote her in best mafia award. I don‘t think anyone of us would come up with such a plan, not even Vandred.

So it has to be 2 mafia teams, or Cres really hates her SK + Janitor guy.

 

[digitaldude]

If not holt who is the mafia in your eyes?
@GrySun @Raven @wojak @Farfalla @GB @Erinyes @Brandish μ @Kat @Baka Taichou

We need to think some more, we can't repeat the shijima situation again.

 

[GrySun]

What was Samuel‘s Psychiatrist supposed to find for town?
1. PGO? No, that one is public knowledge.
2. Potato? No, that alone is too irrelevant to justify a Psychiatrist existing.
3. Traitor? We only had Naive Traitor from Wojak, so unless he lied a Naive Traitor is not something you put Psychiatrist in a game for.
4. Sickly secondary on Brandish? Very pointless, unless Brandish is mafia then it makes sense.
5. Lovers? With 2 mafia teams no way.

So what does this leave us with, Sam‘s role confirms either Brandish as mafia or someone hiding real Traitor like Baka(some older posts kinda sounded like being a Traitor).

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

Hm I guess some mafias would have secondaries like Farf and Erin and maybe you find those? Nvm.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Literally Brandish

 

[Farfalla]

I wish eren didn't reveal her main role so early in the phase though, this gives me flashbacks when DD stole my bomb role last day in chainsaw

But if she got Pirated then she's gonna stop getting results now.

If not holt who is the mafia in your eyes?
@GrySun @Raven @wojak @Farfalla @GB @Erinyes @Brandish μ @Kat @Baka Taichou

We need to think some more, we can't repeat the shijima situation again.

Maybe a better question is: who are the 4+ people you consider to be scum, as a group or not, including Holt or not? And minimal explanations.
I fiiinally got 30 mins to spare so I'll reread some stuff I left to check and gather my thoughts before replying.

 

[Baka Taichou]

I mean what you say is possible, just not the straightforward thinking I’d expect mafia to do with this if they don’t wanna overlap killers.

There being a 1-time use Investigator to counter a 1-time use Janitor makes no sense imo. Something‘s really fishy somewhere.

yes, there's no 1 time investigator.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

But if she got Pirated then she's gonna stop getting results now.


Maybe a better question is: who are the 4+ people you consider to be scum, as a group or not, including Holt or not? And minimal explanations.
I fiiinally got 30 mins to spare so I'll reread some stuff I left to check and gather my thoughts before replying.

who says she got pirated?

 

[Farfalla]

Hm I guess some mafias would have secondaries like Farf and Erin and maybe you find those? Nvm.

We basically still have 1/3 of the living players not revealing their role, imagine mentioning secondaries if they're mafia lol...

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

who says she got pirated?

He compared it to a game where that happened.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

But if she got Pirated then she's gonna stop getting results now.


Maybe a better question is: who are the 4+ people you consider to be scum, as a group or not, including Holt or not? And minimal explanations.
I fiiinally got 30 mins to spare so I'll reread some stuff I left to check and gather my thoughts before replying.

yes but DD posted after she said she is SM maybe i am overthinking

 

[Baka Taichou]

What was Samuel‘s Psychiatrist supposed to find for town?
1. PGO? No, that one is public knowledge.
2. Potato? No, that alone is too irrelevant to justify a Psychiatrist existing.
3. Traitor? We only had Naive Traitor from Wojak, so unless he lied a Naive Traitor is not something you put Psychiatrist in a game for.
4. Sickly secondary on Brandish? Very pointless, unless Brandish is mafia then it makes sense.
5. Lovers? With 2 mafia teams no way.

So what does this leave us with, Sam‘s role confirms either Brandish as mafia or someone hiding real Traitor like Baka(some older posts kinda sounded like being a Traitor).

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

Hm I guess some mafias would have secondaries like Farf and Erin and maybe you find those? Nvm.

you'd do anything to imply I'm sus huh, now I'm traitor? ))))))
ayayay gry

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022 ---

We basically still have 1/3 of the living players not revealing their role, imagine mentioning secondaries if they're mafia lol...

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

He compared it to a game where that happened.

well our publicly claimed pirate went for marm

 

[Shad]

my vote wasn't bold, shouldn't count

I'm 15 pages behind, but saw this.

I interprete the voting rules as the player intention to vote needs to be clear.

This will be the manner in which you vote. Make sure it is clearly displayed in your post though caps/coloured or bold font.

The rules mentions bolding and colouring as standard examples, in your case it was clear because it was in it own post.

Vote is casted, since you were aware that you needed to bold and didn't.

 

[Farfalla]

yes but DD posted after she said she is SM maybe i am overthinking

Ik, but that's still verifiable the next day.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

well our publicly claimed pirate went for marm

We had a Pirate claim?

 

[Baka Taichou]

yes but DD posted after she said she is SM maybe i am overthinking

no you're not overthinking

Scenario:

SM erin, claims 1 time role investigator target demon, demon mafia detective claim, sus of me since I claimed.

DD apprentice after her public reveal, to help confirm her. Occasionally posting random comments saying X and Y are mafia, including me.

Raven coming in suddenly switching sides, siding with erin in saying I'm sus. Flashbacks when she was santa and still had my back when I was sus to ppl. Flashback to Farf saying it can be an act to get on townie good side.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Some of y'all are trying rly hard to have the necro lynched, and that screams mafia to me. Too bad some of y'all townies are blind to that.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

Ik, but that's still verifiable the next day.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

We had a Pirate claim?

yes, brandish

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022 ---

Ik, but that's still verifiable the next day.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 15, 2022 ---

We had a Pirate claim?

a wait no I'm stupid, he claimed to have secondary sickly later on, and that's how he verified Marm

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 15, 2022 ---

Just so it.s clear I don.t agree with holt lynch.

 

[Farfalla]

Ok, checked wojak's timing: he blocked Sam on N1, Baka on N2, Sam died in N2, his reveal was in D3. Both were in his list so that bit seems consistent if he says he was trying to gain attention with uh... some weird hindrance tactics but traitors seem to be fond of those measures lately @.@ and ok he's new.

The block fest part I'll comment on once @Kat replies to my previous question.

Now the other thing I wanted to check, since Shijima was a Detective, what were the people he mentioned often other than Gry.

Spoiler

I already know perfectly well that Gry

People seriously, I don't think Baka is bad, I can be wrong but she doesn't pass me any of that

I was going to make my vote change to try to spice things up and on my list I had EVIL, GRY and even BAKA

I go to GRY because I think it's not on the side of the town, but on the side of evil.

@Baka Taichou, if anyone happens to me, good luck to you, evil, raven and farfalla.

I told Gry for me it's not from town.

@GB @Farfalla @Raven @Baka Taichou

Gry herself is a liar and you can't see that. But I'm the only one saying this, you don't believe me.

Perhaps my death turns on your alert to whom to look.

There is no way I can say concretely that you are a member of the mafia, but I have a feeling that you voted for Baka to protect GrySun.

Basically, it was almost always Gry and Baka. So food for thought that he could have gotten different results on those 2, with 2 nights to investigate in hands.