Fantasy (Human) Selene vs Eileen

Who wins, and with what difficulty?


  • Total voters
    53

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Jacob was still oneshotted, and Neinhart's physical body wasn't overwhelmed by the power.

Again, where was this 'rule' stated?
that does not make it a straightforward win, and again “outstrips limits”, meaning his magic leaks out of his body, not contained within, so it doesn’t scale.

in Tenrou Island Arc during Ultear’s backstory.
 

grey matter

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Dec 4, 2019
Messages
6,580
Reaction score
10,155
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
India
Simple logic. Bro this Eileen/Erza fans give me headaches with their lack of reasoning. How does suzaku being stronger than human selene means that Eileen is to? Eileen never being compared to any form of dg
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

this doesn't look like a Dg level character to me
Simping fries dudes' brains and reasoning capabilities here. Just like IRL

There is a reason the most unreasonable fanbases in FT are those of Eileen, Erza and Mira.
 

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
that does not make it a straightforward win, and again “outstrips limits”, meaning his magic leaks out of his body, not contained within, so it doesn’t scale.

in Tenrou Island Arc during Ultear’s backstory.
It was a oneshot. Jacob still took that punch head-on and got K.O'd

That's not what "outstrips" mean.

"
as in to exceed
to be greater, better, or stronger thanbefore he had reached his teens, the child prodigy had outstripped his music teacher's abilities"


Neinharts magic basically just surpassed its limits i.e. he got stronger than before/his magic power is higher than it was before.

Even disregarding the enchancement, Ninehart's body should already have been strong enough to withstand Natsu's attack from his previous mp level, according to that 'rule'

Do you mind posting the scan where this was stated?
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
It was a oneshot. Jacob still took that punch head-on and got K.O'd

That's not what "outstrips" mean.

"
as in to exceed
to be greater, better, or stronger thanbefore he had reached his teens, the child prodigy had outstripped his music teacher's abilities"


Neinharts magic basically just surpassed its limits i.e. he got stronger than before/his magic power is higher than it was before.

Even disregarding the enchancement, Ninehart's body should already have been strong enough to withstand Natsu's attack from his previous mp level, according to that 'rule'

Do you mind posting the scan where this was stated?
That is not how scaling works, Jacob was not in a position to fight back, and when Natsu was in a similar power up form as before, he was overcome by another Spriggan of a similar level as Jacob.

The magic maybe stronger, but his body did not, outstrip is greater as in amount, not just in performance.
.
which his body still has limits, that is why his magic is pouring out of his body hence why we can see it literally leave his body. But that doesn’t matter as MPF shows that quantity is the same as quality with how much magic power determines strength of a wizard.

 
Last edited:

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
That is not how scaling works, Jacob was not in a position to fight back, and when Natsu was in a similar power up form as before, he was overcome by another Spriggan of a similar level as Jacob.

The magic maybe stronger, but his body did not, outstrip is greater as in amount, not in performance, which his body still has limits, that is why his magic is pouring out of his body hence why we can see it literally leave his body. But that doesn’t matter as MPF shows that quantity is the same as quality with how much magic power determines strength of a wizard.

Yes it is how it worked. Jacob wasn't caught off guard. He was fully aware that the attack was coming. He just wasn't strong enough to withstand the impact. Also, I'm not sure which spriggan your talking about, but it doesn't really matter since the debate is that similar mp levels =/= similar physicals

That magic aura was there to show his increase in mp and was only there in the one panel. If it was leaking out of him, that would've been indicated since that's not the usual case when someone has a "greater amount" of mp

Anyways it's not like the specifics of his enchantment matters or not, 'cause like I said, Nienhart's base mp was higher than Natsu's and he was still physically weak enough to be oneshotted.

Thanks for the scan. So it was when Ultear was still a little kid. Saying that all Wizards' physicals scale to their mp levels 1:1 (or even close to that ratio) because an infant was having issues handling too much mp is a stretch, especially when enchanted Nienhart (as well as base Nineheart) didn't have their physicals scaled to be higher than someone with less mp.
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Yes it is how it worked. Jacob wasn't caught off guard. He was fully aware that the attack was coming. He just wasn't strong enough to withstand the impact. Also, I'm not sure which spriggan your talking about, but it doesn't really matter since the debate is that similar mp levels =/= similar physicals


No it's not. Just look at its synonyms like "better" , "top", "excel", "outdo", "outshine" etc...

That magic aura was there to show his increase in mp and was only there in the one panel.

Anyways it's not like the specifics of his enchantment matters or not, 'cause like I said, Nienhart's base mp was higher than Natsu's and he was still physically weak enough to be oneshotted.

Thanks for the scan. So it was when Ultear was still a little kid. Saying that all Wizards' physicals scale to their mp levels 1:1 (or even close to that ratio) because an infant was having issues handling too much mp is a stretch, especially when enchanted Nienhart (as well as base Nineheart) didn't have their physicals scaled to be higher than someone with less mp.

Edit: this debate is getting pretty off topic, so I'll end it here on my part
but he was sent back flying with no way of protecting himself with Natsu taking advantage of that opportunity and striking when his composure was off. It is Invel who stopped Natsu before. There is also outweigh which is the be bigger in amount or outbalance which are synonyms to outstrip too. That doesn't change that is not normal magic power which is to indicate that his MP is greater than his limits. Nienhart's limits are that of any other Spriggan but his MP is greater but doesn't scale to his base stats, even before enchantment he managed to one-shot Jellal which would indicate his physical stats are weak too. It also carried over with Wendy who had Irene's persona with her MP which Selene said would be dangerous to Wendy's well being. Ultear was not an infant, she is a child yes but that does not mean much in the world of FT where children fight blood hungry enemies. And the same can be said for Natsu when overusing his magic causes damage to his body too.
 

Darklord#10

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 11, 2022
Messages
3,572
Reaction score
3,256
Age
22
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
Simping fries dudes' brains and reasoning capabilities here. Just like IRL

There is a reason the most unreasonable fanbases in FT are those of Eileen, Erza and Mira.
Lol it's even better for me to even simp for selene ngl. She's a certified god tier so I don't really care when people say she's stronger than igneel or acnologia or whatever. The point s with selene she has the feats and statements to back up why she's certified god tier in the verse. But people on here be trying to make reaches like brandish and gajeel fighting aldoron. They literally got one shot in under three minutes. They be saying stuff like she got acknowledge by two god tier? How does that mean she's stronger than suzaku. Or they say she's 400 year old enchantress? Yeah that's why Wendy was outdoing her right. Aldoron legit was fighting the whole ft guild plus jellal and brandish, Eileen got pushed by Wendy and Erza. She not surviving against selene. She's getting one tapped
Fuck selene tho. Eileen the better milf but she's fodder and she's getting folded
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
The point of Aldo is he is nerfed but even though defeating Giant Gajeel, he was still damaged enough to not move. Irene is stronger simply because she is above Wendy who defeated someone as strong as Suzaku. FT was fighting his seeds while the only one to truly fight Aldo’s main body was Giant Gajeel. Irene was not even going all out until she got enraged, and even then Erza had multiple power ups.
 

MyaHeart35

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2022
Messages
303
Reaction score
386
Age
25
Country
United States
When Selene flexed her power, it breached dimensions and was causing havoc in Earthland.

Suzaku being able to beat her human form doesn't auto-scale to Irene, since those 2 never had a direct comparison
Irene also breached dimensions when she pulled Gajeel out of hell using her universe one spell. They didn't have to get a comparison. Someone stronger than Suzaku was compared to someone far weaker than Irene.
August and Irene are the only ones in the original series to have stated or shown too much magic power. Even more so than Zeref.
August's power was stated to be like night and day by Natsu and a power not from this world,and more skilled than Zeref. Irene's power was stated to be obscene by Mavis. She wondered how someone could have that much power while August and Zeref were standing right beside her. If we were using Selene affecting different dimensions with her power that would make her stronger than Ignia and Acnologia since they weren't capable of doing that. Irene mid diffs
 

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
Irene also breached dimensions when she pulled Gajeel out of hell using her universe one spell. They didn't have to get a comparison. Someone stronger than Suzaku was compared to someone far weaker than Irene.
August and Irene are the only ones in the original series to have stated or shown too much magic power. Even more so than Zeref.
August's power was stated to be like night and day by Natsu and a power not from this world,and more skilled than Zeref. Irene's power was stated to be obscene by Mavis. She wondered how someone could have that much power while August and Zeref were standing right beside her. If we were using Selene affecting different dimensions with her power that would make her stronger than Ignia and Acnologia since they weren't capable of doing that. Irene mid diffs
Gajeel never went to hell. He got "saved" before he ever died:

Misaki has no evidence of being stronger than Suzaku. They're in the same tier of mp and in the same group, but that doesn’t mean that they're equal in stats (look at the Spriggans as an example)

August and Irene’s mp statements and their comparisons to Zeref don't matter, 'cause all 3 of them don't even remotely compare to Selene's feat lol.

When Merc's girlfriend noted that Selene was in another world while her power was causing havoc, he wasn't surprised and went on to state that it was the power of an un-nerfed Dragon God, meaning that Ignia (and Acno due to scaling to them) are capable of this as well:


So yeah, Irene gets destroyed
 
Last edited:

Darklord#10

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 11, 2022
Messages
3,572
Reaction score
3,256
Age
22
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
Lol she legit getting one tapped. Selene is canonically stronger than Eileen doesn't matter human or dragon. She's a certified god tier in the verse. She got statement and feats to back it up. She way stronger than 50% merchphobia who while he was not going out no sold attacks from x793 team natsu Eileen not even comparable. She's also stronger than somewhat weakened aldoron who destroyed brandish+gajeel in less than three minutes

💀💀 how can this(Eileen) even damage dogramag not to talk of selene. Not even on igneel's level 💀
 

MyaHeart35

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2022
Messages
303
Reaction score
386
Age
25
Country
United States
Gajeel never went to hell. He got "saved" before he ever died:

Misaki has no evidence of being stronger than Suzaku. They're in the same tier of mp and in the same group, but that doesn’t mean that they're equal in stats (look at the Spriggans as an example)

August and Irene’s mp statements and their comparisons to Zeref don't matter, 'cause all 3 of them don't even remotely compare to Selene's feat lol.

When Merc's girlfriend noted that Selene was in another world while her power was causing havoc, he wasn't surprised and went on to state that it was the power of an un-nerfed Dragon God, meaning that Ignia (and Acno due to scaling to them) are capable of this as well:


So yeah, Irene gets destroyed
She does have evidence of being stronger than Suzaku people just don't wanna believe it because Suzaku has the better feats. Gajeel was already on his way to hell. Irene saved him. He was already in a different dimension since blood man died. Does that make human Selene stronger than their dragon forms because they weren't able to do so.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Lol she legit getting one tapped. Selene is canonically stronger than Eileen doesn't matter human or dragon. She's a certified god tier in the verse. She got statement and feats to back it up. She way stronger than 50% merchphobia who while he was not going out no sold attacks from x793 team natsu Eileen not even comparable. She's also stronger than somewhat weakened aldoron who destroyed brandish+gajeel in less than three minutes

💀💀 how can this(Eileen) even damage dogramag not to talk of selene. Not even on igneel's level 💀
We already know she is weaker than Selene but she isn't getting onetapped. Yeah because team Natsu were using they're strongest attacks. Gray's used a simple base ice cannon , Lucy used a simple star shot with Sagittarius, and Erza usual heaven wheel blumebatt. Of course he gone no sold some of their weakest attacks. And Irene is also way stronger than Brandish+ Gajeel.
Yeah use Erza POF moments at it finest as examples😒.
 
Last edited:

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
She does have evidence of being stronger than Suzaku people just don't wanna believe it because Suzaku has the better feats. Gajeel was already on his way to hell. Irene saved him. He was already in a different dimension since blood man died. Does that make human Selene stronger than their dragon forms because they weren't able to do so.
Then lets see it. Show me evidence that directly places Misaki above Suzaku

There's no evidence that he was already in a different dimension. Mashima's pretty clear in the afterword that death is permanent and that he'll never have a character be outright resurrected from the afterlife (dbz style).

This means that we have to assume that Universe 1 just somehow reconstructed and transported Gajeel before he died and went to the afterlife.

How do you know that they weren't able to do that, especially when Merc confirmed that it's not unusual for full-powered Dragon Gods?
 

Garmadooon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2023
Messages
691
Reaction score
1,235
Age
21
Country
France
I'm sure if I do a Human Ignia vs Irene thread, Erza/Irene stans will vote for her because the author said she's stronger than Natsu. :cookiearf
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Gajeel never went to hell. He got "saved" before he ever died:

Misaki has no evidence of being stronger than Suzaku. They're in the same tier of mp and in the same group, but that doesn’t mean that they're equal in stats (look at the Spriggans as an example)

August and Irene’s mp statements and their comparisons to Zeref don't matter, 'cause all 3 of them don't even remotely compare to Selene's feat lol.

When Merc's girlfriend noted that Selene was in another world while her power was causing havoc, he wasn't surprised and went on to state that it was the power of an un-nerfed Dragon God, meaning that Ignia (and Acno due to scaling to them) are capable of this as well:


So yeah, Irene gets destroyed
That afterwards does not really tell about what happened to Gajeel, and Gajeel was already gone from the living world and was just about to enter the afterlife so it would consider a distortion of space.

Misaki just like the other DDK are stated to be as strong as one another by multiple sources so that would sort itself out. It would equal in stats with their magic power (
as i gave more examples before
) and even with power, Brandish directly compared her feats to the strength of other spriggans so they would be as strong.
 

MyaHeart35

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2022
Messages
303
Reaction score
386
Age
25
Country
United States
Then lets see it. Show me evidence that directly places Misaki above Suzaku

There's no evidence that he was already in a different dimension. Mashima's pretty clear in the afterword that death is permanent and that he'll never have a character be outright resurrected from the afterlife (dbz style).

This means that we have to assume that Universe 1 just somehow reconstructed and transported Gajeel before he died and went to the afterlife.

How do you know that they weren't able to do that, especially when Merc confirmed that it's not unusual for full-powered Dragon Gods?
Canonically Kirin is the strongest. Compared to Gildarts. Then not only was the only other person compared to the strongest, she said no one forced her to get serious except the strongest. All that points to Misaki as the second strongest, the dialogue is pretty clear.

The same could be said for the BDSK. I mean the only reason people want suzaku to be the strongest is because of his feats against Selene. Since the full powered DGs automatically scale to Selene feat, the BDSK automatically scale to Suzaku feats. But no... Suzaku has the best feats so Suzaku>>> BDSK.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

I'm sure if I do a Human Ignia vs Irene thread, Erza/Irene stans will vote for her because the author said she's stronger than Natsu. :cookiearf
I'm pretty sure if you do a Df Natsu vs the Guild thread some people would say df natsu oneshots.
 

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
Canonically Kirin is the strongest. Compared to Gildarts. Then not only was the only other person compared to the strongest, she said no one forced her to get serious except the strongest. All that points to Misaki as the second strongest, the dialogue is pretty clear.

The same could be said for the BDSK. I mean the only reason people want suzaku to be the strongest is because of his feats against Selene. Since the full powered DGs automatically scale to Selene feat, the BDSK automatically scale to Suzaku feats. But no... Suzaku has the best feats so Suzaku>>> BDSK.
I agree that Kirin could be > Suzaku because of Selene hyping him up, but that's it. Misaki sparred with Kirin. We don't know how those sparring sessions turned out other than Misaki getting serious, and there's also no evidence of Misaki sparring with Suzaku

There is, however, this:
Which suggests that human Selene (who lost to him) was the strongest opponent that he fought at that point

Edit:
The same could be said for the BDSK. I mean the only reason people want suzaku to be the strongest is because of his feats against Selene. Since the full powered DGs automatically scale to Selene feat, the BDSK automatically scale to Suzaku feats. But no... Suzaku has the best feats so Suzaku>>> BDSK.
They don't automatically scale just for being in the same tier/group. They scale because Merc confirmed that her feat wasn't unusual for a Dragon God, before explaining why him and Aldoron didn't have such an impressive power display.

Misaki and Haku, on the other hand, have given me reasons to not scale them to Suzaku. In Misaki's case, it's because she got defeated by someone who Suzaku destroyed

From what it looks like to me, the common consensus is that Kirin's likely the strongest due to Selene's statement
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,017
Reaction score
2,556
Country
Imperium of Mankind
I agree that Kirin could be > Suzaku because of Selene hyping him up, but that's it. Misaki sparred with Kirin. We don't know how those sparring sessions turned out other than Misaki getting serious, and there's also no evidence of Misaki sparring with Suzaku

There is, however, this:
Which suggests that human Selene (who lost to him) was the strongest opponent that he fought at that point
supposedly beat her, but with what she said would suggest that indeed Kirin is stronger than the rest with how she used power when she was serious, and Erza managed to fight Laxus to a extreme diff.
 

Darklord#10

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 11, 2022
Messages
3,572
Reaction score
3,256
Age
22
Gender
Male
Country
Nigeria
I'm sure if I do a Human Ignia vs Irene thread, Erza/Irene stans will vote for her because the author said she's stronger than Natsu. :cookiearf
Lol do it. Do Erza vs human ignia and ask what diff. You can also include a bonus round Misaki and Erza vs human ignia. It'll be fun to watch the thread 🤣🤣. I mean Erza fans already think that kyoka is stronger than mard geer. Eileen is stronger than zeref and stronger than human form acnologia. Minerva stronger than jura. I'm not gonna be surprised if they think Erza is on ignia's level. Lol I remember reading some comments when I was new here that Erza would fight all the five Dg together and still win. Another interesting thread would be Eileen and Erza vs igneel.
 
Last edited:

Lucy>Wendy&Elfman

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2021
Messages
1,929
Reaction score
1,138
Gender
Male
Country
France
Selene wins by hype. We don't know her abilities, so I will say he high-extreme diff.
Selene no diffs and makes Irene her slave

lol we dont know true powers of Selene.
Provided she behaves like she did against Suzaku, maybe mid diff win against human Eileen, loses maybe mid diff against dragon Eileen. again i have to stress this enough, she has to behave like she did against suzaku.

Unless we get any clear evidence of power creep in this time skip like we had in the others
Queen Irene wins
Selene wins if she's stronger than Suzaku, if not she loose.
Selene admitted she is weaker than Suzaku in her human form. Which clearly means that Irene is above her even more


Lol the denial at the time it's crazy
 
Top