Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump (2024) - News and Discussion!

Status
Not open for further replies.

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Honestly Psych House and Necromance shouldn't even be factored into ToC discussions at this point considering they've literally never left the bottom 2 spots, which is impressive in and of itself. I can't remember two series from the same batch ever doing this badly.
Are you saying that mainly due to them feeling good in terms of story writing? I know that is more of a question on your subjectivity but I was just curious.


Astro leaks are being posted and...damn, Wakui really took these lower rankings to the heart kkk

I guess that last chapter really showed he heard all of our complaints that he really held back in the beginning (along with other complaints I had). So now he is trying to step up in terms of matching our expectations and doing what we liked since Tokyo Revengers.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
So a series that has yet to stabilise somewhere between 1st and 4th in the last six issues, with volume sales that continue to rise each time (nearly 100k in 4 weeks - making it the 5th best selling per volume currently running in the magazine), which has higher views by comparison on the reading platforms, continues its colour page streak, and trends more still on Twitter while continually showing growth rather than stagnation or decline still needs more data to be determined a success?

But a series from one of the best-selling veterans of the past few years with a 'stable trajectory' (as you put it) of being in the double digits and bottom 5 for of the TOC most of its run so far, with its perfectly decent (but not a super impressive) 30k debut sales (in 4 weeks) considering the pedigree is an 'overwhelming success'?

That makes literally no sense and you know that.

I wish you'd stop playing this act and pretending you're in this fantasy version of reality whenever it's a series you care about but if it's something otherwise you reject the truth or just ignore it. Please, as someone who hated Nue's Exorcist and didn't get the appeal (and still doesn't enjoy it), just do what I did and either stop talking about it and accept that it's here to stay and there's enough people that it clearly does work for, and pray for its downfall in silence. I think as far as Kagurabachi is concerned you just need to accept your complete lack of understanding for its appeal because it doesn't subscribe to your specific taste and the fact it's only improved as a series and gained popularity despite the reason you would cite as negatives.

And also accept that by every metric Kagurabachi is more of a hit than Astro Royale, period. AR is fine, it's surviving. It's not a hit. It's not getting cancelled this coming round. But it will need to show improvement in performance if its going to live, and it might just do that based on the latest few chapters. There's hope still. But there's a difference in being hopeful for a new favourite series of yours to succeed vs twisting reality to make illogical and incorrect comparisons that you're trying to pass as objective when they're not.

(Shinuki, please don't delete my comment this time. I'm trying to word this as nicely as I can without starting another crusade.)
Very well constructed ItsSamu. I understand what you are saying. For me personally with the 3 mentioned series you discussed (Nue’s Exorcist, Kagurabachi, and Astro Royale), I do have a bit of a love hate relationship with them. I did not like them in their beginnings but for different reasons. But over time, they either became something I like and praise (but not in an obsessive fanboy way), to tolerable where I can start to see its merits but am not super crazy about it. But with Astro Royale, I didn’t like those early chapters as I felt it was a tone clash with the somewhat lighter tone writing when compared with the serious tone in the art. I’m glad that it is improving in the writing as that was what I wanted, but I am still having trouble with the direction. Also there is a massive abundance of characters and Wakui is trying to push it by saying everyone’s names when I am not invested to care.
 

Zest00

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2023
Messages
401
Reaction score
766
Country
Gotei 13
So....when is the next batch? September? October?
 

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
1,493
Country
Gotei 13
I guess that last chapter really showed he heard all of our complaints that he really held back in the beginning (along with other complaints I had). So now he is trying to step up in terms of matching our expectations and doing what we liked since Tokyo Revengers.
While I'm glad that Wakui finally is stepping up his game, I wonder what Wakui wants to do is the same to what he is good at.

He clearly wants to believe in hope and dream and justice and miracles, but he is at his best doing the opposite just because of the life he had before becoming a mangaka gave him both of those sides of his

Poor guy probably came to WSJ still thinking it's full of light, meanwhile at least half of the magazine is in literal blood bath, even Akane's dad is dead
 

Qukiqq

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2023
Messages
764
Reaction score
1,356
Country
England
So a series that has yet to stabilise somewhere between 1st and 4th in the last six issues, with volume sales that continue to rise each time (nearly 100k in 4 weeks - making it the 5th best selling per volume currently running in the magazine), which has higher views by comparison on the reading platforms, continues its colour page streak, and trends more still on Twitter while continually showing growth rather than stagnation or decline still needs more data to be determined a success?

But a series from one of the best-selling veterans of the past few years with a 'stable trajectory' (as you put it) of being in the double digits and bottom 5 of the TOC for most of its run so far, with its perfectly decent (but not a super impressive) 30k debut sales (in 4 weeks) considering the pedigree is an 'overwhelming success'?

That makes literally no sense and you know that.

I wish you'd stop playing this act and pretending you're in this fantasy version of reality whenever it's a series you care about but if it's something otherwise you reject the truth or just ignore it. Please, as someone who hated Nue's Exorcist and didn't get the appeal (and still doesn't enjoy it), just do what I did and either stop talking about it and accept that it's here to stay and there's enough people that it clearly does work for, and pray for its downfall in silence. I think as far as Kagurabachi is concerned you just need to accept your complete lack of understanding for its appeal because it doesn't subscribe to your specific taste and the fact it's only improved as a series and gained popularity despite the reasons you would cite as negatives.

And also accept that by every metric Kagurabachi is more of a hit than Astro Royale, period. AR is fine, it's surviving. It's not a hit. It's not getting cancelled this coming round. But it will need to show improvement in performance if its going to live, and it might just do that based on the latest few chapters. There's hope still. But there's a difference in being hopeful for a new favourite series of yours to succeed vs twisting reality to make illogical and incorrect comparisons that you're trying to pass as objective when they're not.

(Shinuki, please don't delete my comment this time. I'm trying to word this as nicely as I can without starting another crusade.)
Why do you reply?

Everyone knows sharkbait is baiting for replies and your long reply only makes him make more bait.

Just ignore him.
 

ItsSamu

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2020
Messages
664
Reaction score
2,974
Gender
Male
Country
Scotland
Why do you reply?

Everyone knows sharkbait is baiting for replies and your long reply only makes him make more bait.

Just ignore him.
By that logic this thread is like if we’re all swimming in a public pool and there’s bits of occasional poo floating in the water. Are we meant to just ignore it and swim around it even though we know it’s there or should we highlight that someone is knowingly shitting in the pool and it would probably be better if that behaviour was pointed out and stopped?
 

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
1,493
Country
Gotei 13
Ignore is a beautiful function that exists to protect your mental health against baits. But at the same time using it means running away occasionally
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
By that logic this thread is like if we’re all swimming in a public pool and there’s bits of occasional poo floating in the water. Are we meant to just ignore it and swim around it even though we know it’s there or should we highlight that someone is knowingly shitting in the pool and it would probably be better if that behaviour was pointed out and stopped?
By that logic I haven’t seen that much of an outrage to make us go like this.

 

Qukiqq

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2023
Messages
764
Reaction score
1,356
Country
England
By that logic this thread is like if we’re all swimming in a public pool and there’s bits of occasional poo floating in the water. Are we meant to just ignore it and swim around it even though we know it’s there or should we highlight that someone is knowingly shitting in the pool and it would probably be better if that behaviour was pointed out and stopped?
But if you point out the poo , the person is just gonna start shitting twice as hard.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Ignore is a beautiful function that exists to protect your mental health against baits. But at the same time using it means running away occasionally
Amen to that. But when it is something that needs to be called out, it should. But unless it is with someone who is like a wall, let the wall fall by ignoring it.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

But if you point out the poo , the person is just gonna start shitting twice as hard.
:grinHahahahahahaha……..
 

Bulju

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2023
Messages
618
Reaction score
1,416
Age
29
Country
Argentina
Why do you reply?

Everyone knows sharkbait is baiting for replies and your long reply only makes him make more bait.

Just ignore him.
Ignoring something is easy in real life because you can just turn around and walk the other way. Ignoring something in a forum involves scrolling past it...then scrolling past all the replies to it...then ignoring the next post by that person...
Telling someone to just ignore a person's posts just because baiting and starting arguments are their main personality traits isn't so easy when you have to scroll past entire pages at a time to accomplish it.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
While I'm glad that Wakui finally is stepping up his game, I wonder what Wakui wants to do is the same to what he is good at.

He clearly wants to believe in hope and dream and justice and miracles, but he is at his best doing the opposite just because of the life he had before becoming a mangaka gave him both of those sides of his

Poor guy probably came to WSJ still thinking it's full of light, meanwhile at least half of the magazine is in literal blood bath, even Akane's dad is dead
That is a tough call. I guess this is a battle between what the author wants and the expectations of the reader. Though I find it funny how you say that Jump is a blood bath now and that Akane's Dad is Dead when he is still alive. I got that flack last year and galaxy-juice corrected me. It’s honestly hard when you want something bright and juxtapose it with a more dark world. I’d say the only ones that did it well were One Piece, Naruto, My Hero Academia, Black Clover, and Dragon Ball. Who have ever heard of a bright world with Yakuza’s when it is so dark. I challenge someone to me on that when you watch The Godfather movies and the vast lineup of Martin Scorsese movies.
 

SharkBait

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2013
Messages
14,180
Reaction score
6,982
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Please, as someone who hated Nue's Exorcist and didn't get the appeal (and still doesn't enjoy it), just do what I did and either stop talking about it and accept that it's here to stay and there's enough people that it clearly does work for, and pray for its downfall in silence. I think as far as Kagurabachi is concerned you just need to accept your complete lack of understanding for its appeal because it doesn't subscribe to your specific taste and the fact it's only improved as a series and gained popularity despite the reasons you would cite as negatives.

And also accept that by every metric Kagurabachi is more of a hit than Astro Royale, period. AR is fine, it's surviving. It's not a hit. It's not getting cancelled this coming round.
Generally, I genuinely enjoy reading Kagurabachi else I wouldn't be concerned about its performance or its aspects for success. Even with its flaws and general ways it could improve, its a decent series that adds a little bit of flavor to the magazine. I don't advocate for its downfall.

Assuming the author isnt the real name of an veteran/experience author who writes under a penname for other manga, I wouldn't directly compare Astro Royale and Kagurabachi, a veteran versus someone's first serialized series isnt fair...which is why I used two different benchmarks for identifying if they were successes or not.

There's nothing more pointless and depressing than being a Kagurabachi hater. First the sales, then the TOC rankings, they can't stop losing.
I dont think there are genuine Kagurabachi haters here, if anything people are only expressing genuine concern for Kagurabachi's performance, and that its performance has yet to stabilize. I think once it reaches the end of its second year or so and it continues to perform as it is, then everyone's concerns would be wiped away. The influence of memes and signal boosting from the non-voting public may be affecting its perception and performance, is all.
 
Last edited:

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,810
Reaction score
40,891
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Moderator Notice:
I think its enough already guys, y'all are derailing the thread into personal discussion about users and some unecessary analogies instead of talking about the magazine abd manga, so please move to a new topic!~ Shinuki
 

KrenKren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2024
Messages
1,492
Reaction score
3,901
Age
21
Country
United Kingdom
So....when is the next batch? September? October?
Unless anniversary covers delay the batch by by a week or two, it'd have to be in around early September, right? No chance Necromance lives to see another month.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
I dont think there are genuine Kagurabachi haters here, if anything people are only expressing genuine concern for Kagurabachi's performance, and that its performance has yet to stabilize. I think once it reaches the end of its second year or so and it continues to perform as it is, then everyone's concerns would be wiped away. The influence of memes and signal boosting from the non-voting public may be affecting its perception and performance, is all.
I agree on that. I remember when it started, and how annoying it was. I was genuinely not impressed by that influence from the beginning. But as time progressed I actually saw a lot of competence in the writing to actually make me a fan. Despite the memes I genuinely want it to stay.
 

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
1,493
Country
Gotei 13
That is a tough call. I guess this is a battle between what the author wants and the expectations of the reader. Though I find it funny how you say that Jump is a blood bath now and that Akane's Dad is Dead when he is still alive. I got that flack last year and galaxy-juice corrected me. It’s honestly hard when you want something bright and juxtapose it with a more dark world. I’d say the only ones that did it well were One Piece, Naruto, My Hero Academia, Black Clover, and Dragon Ball. Who have ever heard of a bright world with Yakuza’s when it is so dark. I challenge someone to me on that when you watch The Godfather movies and the vast lineup of Martin Scorsese movies.
Accidentally, Godfather is actually Wakui's most favorite movie. He is a movie geek

Anyway, before Astro, all of Wakui's released works (aside that one boxing manga that isnt available anywhere so I cant say anything about it) was about depicting light in a world choked in darkness. However, begining of Astro is almost the opposite of that. I think there is certain purpose behind it but it definitely threw off a lot of expectations

It's slowly reverting back anyway

oh and Akane's dad is certainly dead in the world of Rakugo. Poor guy couldn't even get a grave
 

SharkBait

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2013
Messages
14,180
Reaction score
6,982
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I agree on that. I remember when it started, and how annoying it was. I was genuinely not impressed by that influence from the beginning. But as time progressed I actually saw a lot of competence in the writing to actually make me a fan. Despite the memes I genuinely want it to stay.
The memes were a huge turn off and had people making a lot of bad jokes, or just get turned off, now people have to extra effort to convince people to check it out.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Accidentally, Godfather is actually Wakui's most favorite movie. He is a movie geek

Anyway, before Astro, all of Wakui's released works (aside that one boxing manga that isnt available anywhere so I cant say anything about it) was about depicting light in a world choked in darkness. However, begining of Astro is almost the opposite of that. I think there is certain purpose behind it but it definitely threw off a lot of expectations

It's slowly reverting back anyway

oh and Akane's dad is certainly dead in the world of Rakugo. Poor guy couldn't even get a grave
Oh, I didn’t know that. Cool that he is a movie buff.

And thank you for giving me more insight on Wakui and how he writes.

And yeah. Rakugo Akane’s father is dead, which is so sad. I can only imagine that that is how Akane feels as if it is a revenge story if done that way, but it didn’t.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

The memes were a huge turn off and had people making a lot of bad jokes, or just get turned off, now people have to extra effort to convince people to check it out.
Well for me I give it a chance for the sake of it. I want to treat the work fairly so that it can be judged by its merits. My worst case scenario is that it goes into what the DCEU was like with “those fans”. But since it can back it up, I can get behind it despite those memes. I agree that is a tough sell when you have a loud vocal group coming in and can act as a turn off just because of the over inflated hype.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top