Games Mafia Game 127 - Neon Genesis Omongelion - End Game

[AwkwardMisha]

today for me is a bit busy, i will be mostly hopping from train to train

i will check in a bit, need to read through a bit

 

[Marmalade]

About to indulge in a bit of McDo to honor our hosts and for goodluck

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2024 ---

No one really stands out to me at the moment as a good lynch. I'm unsure as to whether Demon bidding in public is enough to lynch him, or if considering someone like Baka or Lawl for the lynch might be better.

What makes you feel that way about Lawl specifically? He hasn’t said all that much (personally have no clue how to read him yet this game)

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Implying you can read me in other games

 

[Marmalade]

I actually cant read

 

[Copy Panda]

tbh i also need mcdo

 

[SirSamuel016]

Why is it better?

??? What are you asking about?

What makes you feel that way about Lawl specifically? He hasn’t said all that much (personally have no clue how to read him yet this game)

Not passing my vibecheck atm

tbh i also need mcdo

You fkn live there bhai

 

[Baka Taichou]

But it does feel like bull

also Gry been directing ppl to lynch demon with subtle hints

so what if I believe it i'm automatically scum? It's an early game .... day 1 and we're all townies not like we'd lose too much if I'm wrong.

So you are voting me because of the public bid but you didn't even read the theories of the other player who did the same?

i've been busy, skimming through

Im townie, lol, how demons lynch makes you townie, can you elaborate ? I dont know what demon is, he could be mafia or townie but I find very easy/lazy to go for that wagon.

didn't say it m,akes me townie. you're all basically assuming (all as in the ones i mentioned on the list) i'm automatically mafia )) if i get a misslynch with my hunch. As if that's something never done before by townies. Even in the game i hosted last month.

Oh dear. Where to even start.
1) your fake news post edit isn't even quotable because you edited your own quote
2) i never said that? I have 7 post up until this one, go a level back and click on the 8 and double check
3) classical annoying baka defensiveness hat. who dares voice any claims of your susness about your strange posts and voting behaviors automatically gets on the list
4) you admitted yourself you didn't even see he had two votes, regardless, you voted because you didn't like his open approach, while not understanding the mechanics yourself, but meh, because you're baka everyone should be just OK with it and give you passes until you kill us all at night

I know your personal opinion about me is strong, but it's why you're always wrong. You're looking for reasoning to paint me in red without even considering the contrary, which i assume is either because you want me out of the game early for personal reasons or maybe getting misslynched on D1 with an all townie mechanic in 20 ppl game is really something so odd to happen, same for the getting a correct lynch on d1 on a hunch, who knows.

1. I quoted myself and added you to the original msg, and in my reply to the quote i mentioned "i added evil" the original post was not modified.
2. said what, that I'm sus? I'll check maybe I confused your avatar.
3. classical annoying baka indeed. How dare she voice out a hunch in the first place amirite. That list is not because you sus me it'd because you jumped to demon's defence on a D1 with no information to back you up and make you so certain he's not mafia, but you jump on me oh YOU'RE THE MAFIA. Make it make sense.
4. I said I didn't see DD voted for him. so? I at least understood that very clear line where it says you bid in private and only discuss about bids in public.

So my conclusion is, you're either trying to save him, or playing a 200 IQ move with reverse psychology by defending him, but accusing me, with you being the mafia and him and me town. That would be an insane move indeed.

That !

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2024 ---

Also



so i assume they can get same roles ?

@hosts even Jesus ?

that what? read my reply to him. or don't. I'm also skimming through and not reading properly so I can't force others to.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024 ---

I have 7 posts which feels low but relatively average thus far.

I'll votekill pompom

Low posts, vibe seems not dissimilar from last game. Weak but all I got rn

how do you jump at me and then vote pompom?

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024 ---

a wait
I SAW EVIL FOR SOME REASON IGNORE THAT BRANDISH

 

[Farfalla]

About to indulge in a bit of McDo to honor our hosts and for goodluck

If you wanna honor me, do yourself a favor and grab a drink @.@b

 

[AnimePigeon]

AnimePigeon Day 1 Reads (Not Ordered)

Town Leans
Crescent Jinx - Feels like the Consensus Town Leader currently,

Evil3ye - Get the feeling Evil3ye is reading the game thread closer than most, so I'm taking that to mean they are likely Town currently. Enjoying there engagements in the thread.

James Rye - Generally enjoys reading and discussing Mech with them, seems to be Pro Town,

Vandred - Just generally like their posts so far. Keep up the good work fellow Townie!,

SirSamuel016 - I find myself reading Samuel's posts and being in agreement with most of there comments. I've only recently decided that I feel Tatsumaki would be a valid vote, but prior to that, I was thinking very similarly to Samuel. Hoping that you are infact a Townie!,

Brandish,

AwkwardMisha - Highly Likely to be Town if Tatsumaki Mafia but other than that generally a Null Seat,

Null Reads
Demonspeed,

Baka Taichou - Paired/Same Alignment w/ Desin24,

DigitalDude,

GrySun,

Marmalade,

Desin24 - Don't really see the point they tried to make about Demon Public Bidding, as I don't see that as being Alignment Indicative, Likely Paired/Same Alignment w/ Baka Taichou,

Holt,

Mafia Leans
Lawl Po Bia - Don't feel Lawl has been too helpful or Good so far this game, but I appreciate he might grew further into the game, so I might be a little rash to consider him a Mafia Lean,

Lady PomPom - Generally feel a little uneasy around this seat feels like a Wolf Siding Seat,

Tatsumaki - Just can't ever behind someone Voting someone for Low Posting and nothing else, when they had posted less at the time they made that observation of AwkwardMisha, feels incredibly wolfy from Tatsumaki,

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2024 ---

I've undoubtedly missed someone.

 

[Baka Taichou]

AnimePigeon Day 1 Reads (Not Ordered)

Town Leans
Crescent Jinx - Feels like the Consensus Town Leader currently,

Evil3ye - Get the feeling Evil3ye is reading the game thread closer than most, so I'm taking that to mean they are likely Town currently. Enjoying there engagements in the thread.

James Rye - Generally enjoys reading and discussing Mech with them, seems to be Pro Town,

Vandred - Just generally like their posts so far. Keep up the good work fellow Townie!,

SirSamuel016 - I find myself reading Samuel's posts and being in agreement with most of there comments. I've only recently decided that I feel Tatsumaki would be a valid vote, but prior to that, I was thinking very similarly to Samuel. Hoping that you are infact a Townie!,

Brandish,

AwkwardMisha - Highly Likely to be Town if Tatsumaki Mafia but other than that generally a Null Seat,

Null Reads
Demonspeed,

Baka Taichou - Paired/Same Alignment w/ Desin24,

DigitalDude,

GrySun,

Marmalade,

Desin24 - Don't really see the point they tried to make about Demon Public Bidding, as I don't see that as being Alignment Indicative, Likely Paired/Same Alignment w/ Baka Taichou,

Holt,

Mafia Leans
Lawl Po Bia - Don't feel Lawl has been too helpful or Good so far this game, but I appreciate he might grew further into the game, so I might be a little rash to consider him a Mafia Lean,

Lady PomPom - Generally feel a little uneasy around this seat feels like a Wolf Siding Seat,

Tatsumaki - Just can't ever behind someone Voting someone for Low Posting and nothing else, when they had posted less at the time they made that observation of AwkwardMisha, feels incredibly wolfy from Tatsumaki,

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2024 ---

I've undoubtedly missed someone.

same alignment with desin? you mean james? desin didn't vote for demon

 

[desin24]

Done with the bid. Was not so easy to choose since there can be many approaches. I wonder how many will go for the main roles, I went full support-ish here.

The ones arguing against sharing their spending/choice of EVA, also what do you guys think about sanities for the relevant roles?

 

[AnimePigeon]

Also waiting for GrySun (& Kakoha) to have there jaws drop to the floor with my posting.

 

[desin24]

same alignment with desin? you mean james? desin didn't vote for demon

He can feel our shared vampire-ness

 

[AnimePigeon]

same alignment with desin? you mean james? desin didn't vote for demon

I'm pairing you & Desin as likely being the same alignment for your similar thinking regarding Demon's Public Bid.

Others may have discussed Demons Public Bid too, but you and Desin have made more of a deal out of it.

I haven't really considered votes within this reads post, as I feel voted only become valuable for analysis on Day 2 once we have a reveal or two.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2024 ---

Done with the bid. Was not so easy to choose since there can be many approaches. I wonder how many will go for the main roles, I went full support-ish here.

The ones arguing against sharing their spending/choice of EVA, also what do you guys think about sanities for the relevant roles?

I'm fully expecting other players to see what I believe is the best EVA, and thus make the most optimal bet - given our remaining MHT results in the action we gain from said EVA we attain if we manage too win the bid.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024 ---

I actually cant read

Dyslexia is fun... especially when your trying to read and the words just start running away

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024 ---

VoteKill! Tatsumaki

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2024 ---

Sad times we live in when I'm not the lowest poster

 

[Tatsumaki]

@.@!! You both have the same post count

And people are free to take that into account when they vote me

You mean you don't carry an emergency croissant on you at all times?! °3°

I only ever carry chocolatines

 

[AwkwardMisha]

Alrighty lovelies, time to share some thoughts, as i am skimming through the posts~



I find it intriguing that Jinx is baiting a role from the start, much like Demon. In most of the games I’ve played with Jinx, she tended to stay quiet, offering more subtle hints.

Interestingly, in those games she was always mafia. So, I am pretty torn here.

unsure if she’s genuinely town this time or just baiting again



On the other hand, we have Demon, who James cornered pretty quickly

It’s been a while since I’ve played, so I’m not sure if this level of pressure is typical for James

While I appreciate a good deduction, the way Demon has been targeted for elimination feels a bit too aggressive for day one, especially given that the reasoning behind it was a public bid



James entire argument relies on how town should have a bidding strategy, but in the end the bidding is silent, making the forum discussions a bit moot

Sure, Demon is often mafia, and yes, I owe him one for letting me get lynched in a past game Still, going after him so aggressively this early seems like overkill



That said, I do agree with some of James’ logic, such as the idea that low bids on Evas allow mafia to hoard them, leaving town defenseless.

His strategy implies town bidding high for single use roles, ensuring that we can constantly rotate the roles

However, bidding high also means only a few roles will be distributed at a time, which could limit towns role options



What’s unclear to me is how James expects public discussions about bidding to work. Wouldn’t town openly sharing their bidding plans just make them easy targets for mafia? Plus, if two players bid the same on an Eva, it’s randomly assigned anyway

My gut tells me this entire debacle will end up intrinsically into a bidding war



Also, a clarification: if we run out of coins, do they replenish, or is that it, no more Evas?



If town bids high early on for singleuse roles, it could leave mafia free to secure Evas cheaply later on for longer term use.



Lastly, Tastu, I appreciated your reasoning behind your vote. If you were active yourself, it might have not come across as an opportunistic, low hanging fruit kind of vote~



I am still reading through fyi, these were my 2 cents until now

Aso i got in the wrong train reading through it
Need to find a way back now

 

[Evil3ye]

2. said what, that I'm sus? I'll check maybe I confused your avatar.

You put me on the list because accroding to you I said demon is town. Never in I'm life would I ever vouch for demon, 1) I can't ever read him, 2) he has the most sus avatar with horns and stuff. What happened here is you created a demon train (claiming unkowingly, but whatever is the difference anyway) and now throwing shade on everybody who put you in their sus list with last straw defenses like i don't like to play around you with zero self reflection on how you're not even really following the thread conversation, yet claim to be right about stuff on a "hunch". Well, good luck, babes.

Others may have discussed Demons Public Bid too, but you and Desin have made more of a deal out of it.

Baka and James, not Baka and desin voted him, think that's what she was alluding to.

I'm sort of over the demon-baka-james discussion though. Don't quote me on that anymore, I won't engage. This is perfect ground for mafia to hide behind and slip through with low post counts and contributions.

 

[Tatsumaki]

@Crescent Jinx, I would argue that @Tatsumaki certainly comes across more Awkward than @AwkwardMisha given they are complaining & using the fact AwkwardMisha has "Low Posts" as the main reason for voting them, despite the fact Tatsumaki has less posts than AwkwardMisha until they posted there vote of AwkwardMisha.

So given that fact, it seems like a cop-out of a reason to vote someone, as there is very little substance to the read and it isn't a view I can get behind them being the only one to make. The argument of Low Poster = Mafia, could be applied to 5 players, but I don't feel that is a strong or valid enough an argument to vote someone other than to apply pressure to the target

Your reasoning is valid.

 

[SirSamuel016]

I find it intriguing that Jinx is baiting a role from the start, much like Demon. In most of the games I’ve played with Jinx, she tended to stay quiet, offering more subtle hints.

How is Jinx baiting a role when the opening post said everyone starts out as vanilla? That doesn't add up

 

[desin24]

Alrighty lovelies, time to share some thoughts, as i am skimming through the posts~



I find it intriguing that Jinx is baiting a role from the start, much like Demon. In most of the games I’ve played with Jinx, she tended to stay quiet, offering more subtle hints.

Interestingly, in those games she was always mafia. So, I am pretty torn here.

unsure if she’s genuinely town this time or just baiting again



On the other hand, we have Demon, who James cornered pretty quickly

It’s been a while since I’ve played, so I’m not sure if this level of pressure is typical for James

While I appreciate a good deduction, the way Demon has been targeted for elimination feels a bit too aggressive for day one, especially given that the reasoning behind it was a public bid



James entire argument relies on how town should have a bidding strategy, but in the end the bidding is silent, making the forum discussions a bit moot

Sure, Demon is often mafia, and yes, I owe him one for letting me get lynched in a past game Still, going after him so aggressively this early seems like overkill



That said, I do agree with some of James’ logic, such as the idea that low bids on Evas allow mafia to hoard them, leaving town defenseless.

His strategy implies town bidding high for single use roles, ensuring that we can constantly rotate the roles

However, bidding high also means only a few roles will be distributed at a time, which could limit towns role options



What’s unclear to me is how James expects public discussions about bidding to work. Wouldn’t town openly sharing their bidding plans just make them easy targets for mafia? Plus, if two players bid the same on an Eva, it’s randomly assigned anyway

My gut tells me this entire debacle will end up intrinsically into a bidding war



Also, a clarification: if we run out of coins, do they replenish, or is that it, no more Evas?



If town bids high early on for singleuse roles, it could leave mafia free to secure Evas cheaply later on for longer term use.



Lastly, Tastu, I appreciated your reasoning behind your vote. If you were active yourself, it might have not come across as an opportunistic, low hanging fruit kind of vote~



I am still reading through fyi, these were my 2 cents until now

Aso i got in the wrong train reading through it
Need to find a way back now

Pretty sure we can win MHT by lynching mafia same way they can earn MHT by killing us. Which is why I believe the "check MHT, give/steal MHT" might come in pretty clutch.
People being targeted for bidding on good EVAs is not really a problem since we can "Win" those valuable roles back. Usually Docs and Dets would need to stay on the downlow while this kind of depleting MHT forces much more and much earlier sharing.

At least these are my thoughts. The more is shared the easier it is catch people lying or being inconsistent. Specific roles are probably less of a prio.